Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being irritated at "would of, could of....."

335 replies

DuchessOfDisaster · 08/08/2021 10:46

I cringe when I see this written down. Along with "defiantly" for definitely and other examples. I don't see there is ever any excuse. And the excuse that "language evolves" doesn't wash, because "to of" is not a verb and never will be no matter how language evolves. It's not the same as adopting words from other cultures, new words like selfies, or a different meaning for "sick", for example.

OK, when we say "would've", "could've" etc, it may SOUND similar, but that's no excuse either. It implies the writer has never seen "would have" etc written down, therefore doesn't read much. What did they do at school? Was this style of writing used then and never corrected?

Another cringeworthy example is the inability to differentiate between there/they're/their and your/you're.

Just why do people do it and worse, why is it excused?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
lazylinguist · 10/08/2021 10:17

It makes sense, whereas would of, could of don't make sense, because you cannot "of" anything. Of is not a verb.

Banging on about parts of speech is not helpful. Lots of people don't know what a verb is. Besides, it does make sense, in that there's not a single English speaker who wouldn't understand what you meant of you said 'I could of done that'.

Newmumatlast · 10/08/2021 09:02

[quote Sparklesocks]@DuchessOfDisaster well yes, no shit. Doesn’t mean we need to look down at them though does it.[/quote]
Agree with you

Though it irks me, I can't get particularly pressed about it. As long as you can understand someone, it hardly matters that much on a day to day basis. Yes on a job application or in professional work it doesnt look good but I do think we all need to be much more open minded about these things. People have different backgrounds and challenges.

WeatherwaxOn · 10/08/2021 08:57

And autocorrect decided "batin" was a valid word as I hit the post button. Blush

WeatherwaxOn · 10/08/2021 08:56

Picking up the "should of" batin again, many years ago I worked for a big, multinational bank and through my role, got too know a number of PA's. There was one occasion when one of them was typing from dictation and included the words "should of". They just did not know it was a contraction. They'd been to secretarial college, etc.

I wonder if part of the problem now is that some people consider their education finished the moment they leave school/college/university? My school was pretty poor. We didn't learn grammar, syntax or context unless we were studying A Level English Literature which had a poetry module. Teachers were more likely to throw something at you in frustration rather than help correct errors.

Whilst I do appreciate in spoken communication it isn't so important, in the written word, there is scope for misunderstanding and misrepresentation if things are not written clearly and correctly.
The "should of" I refer to would have just reflected badly on an organisation that had a good reputation. In other instances, the may be complications. I have a friend who cannot differentiate between 'accept' and 'except' despite the very different meanings.

youshallnotpass9 · 10/08/2021 05:56

@DuchessOfDisaster

You misunderstood you spelt okay wrong in your op

Witchlight · 09/08/2021 23:22

I’ve been working 121 with three adults during lockdown. They all fell through the gaps in the system for literacy. They have all been absolutely brilliant in how far they’ve come and I hope people like you don’t put them off.

This week, the it homework is to sign up to a board, such as Mumsnet and participate -read the posts and respond to threads that interest them, to use and develop their new skills. I do hope they don’t come across someone like you.

youvegottenminuteslynn · 09/08/2021 22:14

@Mushypeasandchipstogo

I’m totally with you OP. It’s just sheer laziness in many cases and absolutely nothing to do with dyslexia. ( I say that as a teacher with two dyslexic children. )
In that case it's extra disappointing you fail to acknowledge the many other reasons people may not have the same grammatical awareness or academic ability as you.

You've used two unnecessary spaces within the parentheses in your post. That's the sort of thing I wouldn't ever dream of bringing up normally (because I'm not a judgemental twit and would have no opinion on something that doesn't affect me) but since you're happy to judge others, I'm sure you are open to learning to improve your own writing skills.

You're welcome.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 09/08/2021 22:03

@pointythings

Ah! That’s the bit I missed. I thought the comment was in reference to Y8s in a British school. 🤦‍♀️

Pumperthepumper · 09/08/2021 21:48

@Mushypeasandchipstogo

I’m totally with you OP. It’s just sheer laziness in many cases and absolutely nothing to do with dyslexia. ( I say that as a teacher with two dyslexic children. )
There are so many ignorant people on this thread.
Mushypeasandchipstogo · 09/08/2021 21:29

I’m totally with you OP. It’s just sheer laziness in many cases and absolutely nothing to do with dyslexia. ( I say that as a teacher with two dyslexic children. )

pointythings · 09/08/2021 20:51

@BeingATwatItsABingThing

In Year 8, a student would be constructing simple sentences using a past, present or future tense, with perhaps a few adjectives and prepositions.

That’s depressing! I’d expect far more from a child Y2 standard and above. They would be able to add in conjunctions at least.

It's about building the fundamentals first. By Year 11, a Dutch student will be able to write a decent essay or story in English, read original English language YA novels and have a simple spontaneous conversation in English, so not the memorised regurgitation that passes for GCSE speaking in MFL. By Year 13 they're reading original major literary works and discussing them in English. The standard of MFL teaching in the Netherlands is still light years ahead of what happens in most UK schools. (I cannot speak for what happens in private schools.)
DuchessOfDisaster · 09/08/2021 19:08

@youshallnotpass9

I sent this thread to a friend, because she pulls me up (with permission) on my spelling and grammar and it took her a good 18 months before I got it. My facebook was full of her just going *could have

but OK, when we say "would've", "could've" etc

She says its okay @DuchessOfDisaster

Well it is, "would've", "could've" are perfectly correct contractions of would have or could have. It's correct to either say it or write it. It makes sense, whereas would of, could of don't make sense, because you cannot "of" anything. Of is not a verb.

We don't say (or write) that we are going to of a pizza tonight but some might write that they would of had a pizza if they'd thought about it.

OP posts:
Pumperthepumper · 09/08/2021 19:04

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

BeingATwatItsABingThing · 09/08/2021 18:54

In Year 8, a student would be constructing simple sentences using a past, present or future tense, with perhaps a few adjectives and prepositions.

That’s depressing! I’d expect far more from a child Y2 standard and above. They would be able to add in conjunctions at least.

pointythings · 09/08/2021 18:32

pumper, how au fait are you with the secondary school English curriculum in the Netherlands? Not very, I would guess. In Year 8, a student would be constructing simple sentences using a past, present or future tense, with perhaps a few adjectives and prepositions. Easy enough for someone of native speaker standard to correct. And when I say 'clueless about grammar, I do not mean 'unable to use or recognise it'. I mean that I was unaware of many of the technical terms used in grammar. I learned them soon enough, as I was learning French and German at the time; my ignorance did not last for long. Asking me to mark an exercise on the correct use of irregular verbs was really no big deal.

This did not mean that I could explain English grammar to my peers. I could show them correct and incorrect examples, but was unable to explain why one was wrong and one was right. That is what I mean by 'clueless '. Because these days, I can provide that explanation. Happy now?

youshallnotpass9 · 09/08/2021 18:25

I sent this thread to a friend, because she pulls me up (with permission) on my spelling and grammar and it took her a good 18 months before I got it. My facebook was full of her just going *could have

but OK, when we say "would've", "could've" etc

She says its okay @DuchessOfDisaster

Pumperthepumper · 09/08/2021 18:05

@igelkott2021

8You said you were clueless about grammar, why on earth would she - an actual teacher of English! - allow you to mark her students’ work? Clueless about grammar, yet perfectly capable of recognising incorrect grammar when you saw it? Nonsense*

It isn't - basic language exercises are very formulaic. If you speak the language you will know when something is wrong, even if you don't know why it's wrong.

It absolutely is nonsense, there’s no way a teacher would allow a novice learner to mark a student’s work.
igelkott2021 · 09/08/2021 18:03

8You said you were clueless about grammar, why on earth would she - an actual teacher of English! - allow you to mark her students’ work? Clueless about grammar, yet perfectly capable of recognising incorrect grammar when you saw it? Nonsense*

It isn't - basic language exercises are very formulaic. If you speak the language you will know when something is wrong, even if you don't know why it's wrong.

Pumperthepumper · 09/08/2021 17:55

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

pointythings · 09/08/2021 17:51

Pumper yes, because despite nog knowing the rules explicitly, I was perfectly capable of recognising incorrect grammar when I saw it. We are talking English as a foreign language for Years 7 through 9, so basic stuff. Besides, as someone who was already bilingual, it didn't take me long to pick up the rules. The essentials of 'rewrite this sentence using the passive voice' are not rocket science - I knew what passive voice was, just not the term. Stop trying to pick holes. I speak 4 languages fluently, one by birth, one by immersion, two through a combination of great teaching and immersion later on.

Pumperthepumper · 09/08/2021 17:33

@pointythings

CecilyP I did not learn my English in the classroom. I learned it by immersion when I was 10. I was clueless about English grammar until I started doing my mum's marking for her. (She taught English in a Dutch secondary school). I was older, but I learned English in the same way British people learn it, by hearing and speaking it.
Your mum taught English and let you - someone who was clueless about English grammar - mark her students’ work? Are you sure?
Hemingwaycat · 09/08/2021 16:52

It’s purely because in many accents people use should’ve and would’ve which is fine except many people take the abbreviation to actually be of rather than ‘ve.

Language naturally changes over time so I have a bad feeling that eventually ‘should of’ will take over because it will become so commonplace.

LaMadrilena · 09/08/2021 16:51

@BobVance

“Been” instead of “being” is one I see everywhere now and I really just don’t understand how people can’t realise it’s wrong. A good friend of mine uses it repeatedly so it isn’t one-off laziness, she thinks that’s the right word.
Yes! I'm suddenly seen seeing this a lot. "Would of" has been around for ever, but where on earth has this one come from?
youvegottenminuteslynn · 09/08/2021 16:45

@Eilatan2018

I work with a medical secretary who says ‘we was’ rather than we were and it infuriates me! Just sounds so thick!
You seem like a pleasant person.
FangsForTheMemory · 09/08/2021 16:33

For people who are saying this is new, when John Steinbeck wrote Cannery Row (published in 1945), he represented one of the main characters, Mack, as saying 'would of' not 'would have'.

It's not new.

Swipe left for the next trending thread