Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to be amazed at well behaved child?

164 replies

ThinWomansBrain · 08/08/2021 09:34

I went to the proms last night - just along the row from me (actually in my seat, but there were plenty spare) were a family with about 4 children, the youngest about six. I groaned inwardly as I sat down, but the small child was amazingly well behaved, appeared to sit quiet and attentively through two and a half hours of classical music.
Even I was feeling a bit fidgety towards the end!

By contrast older children in the cinema last week must have got up during the film for loo/drinks trips with parents at least three times.
And as for the 70+ y/o in front of me last night who played non stop on her phone, including playing the bloody radio with no headphones through the intervals... words fail me.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LemonRoses · 09/08/2021 20:36

[quote ActonSquirrel]@LemonRoses

How would you propose to sit between children on a train when there are maximum 2 seats next to each other

Your 4 year old remembered and followed the pre warnings did he? Didn't have to be told again? Confused[/quote]
I’d separate them diagonally if a seat area for four or with three sit beside one, opposite the other two but select carefully who was beside who. Usually we’d have my husband too, so easy to sit two beside us and one opposite. Saves squabbling.

By four they could certainly sit still and not disturb others for an hour or so . They didn’t really need pre warnings by then. If on a train, they’d have colouring, reading, workbooks, card games etc to keep them occupied.

DrCoconut · 09/08/2021 11:42

I famously sat through a performance of Handel's Messiah at the age of 3. My dad was an older parent and very strict, including corporal punishment, but even after he died when I was young I was still "well behaved". I was naturally quiet and compliant. Probably too much as I became a people pleaser as an adult and still struggle to assert myself.

Marmitemarinaded · 09/08/2021 10:29

And they won’t make an adjustments if it’s just naughtiness!

Marmitemarinaded · 09/08/2021 10:25

@Sleepyblueocean

"Yes and the ones that don’t meet school expectations are punished"

No a decent school works with the child using the expertise of the parents and makes necessary adjustments to meet need.

Exactly.
Sleepyblueocean · 09/08/2021 10:24

"Yes and the ones that don’t meet school expectations are punished"

No a decent school works with the child using the expertise of the parents and makes necessary adjustments to meet need.

Sleepyblueocean · 09/08/2021 10:21

"However, I do believe that all kids, except maybe those with very challenging learning disabilities have the ability to learn through practice, but practice they need to receive and many parents can't be bothered."

Well yes all children except those with the most profound learning disability will learn things through practice however my own children who isn't as severe as that, takes years to learn things that other children would be consistent at after a few telling. I don't think you understand how much effort some parents are putting in with a child who may appear to others to be badly behaved. And even when they do learn other things such as sensory issues can get in the way.

spongedod · 09/08/2021 10:19

I find it quite interesting that you feel you can make a judgement on how 'well behaved' a child is based on a couple of hours of observing then sat still. In exactly the same way it would be wrong to make an overall judgement of a child who didn't sit still.

Marmitemarinaded · 09/08/2021 10:19

@Lockeddownagain

Absolutely laughing at everyone slagging me for putting a bunch of old moans in their place. Of course my children didn't hear me and I was a bloody brilliant childminder. And they weren't saying oh they are so well behaved in a kind way they were implying 6kids can't be well behaved with one adult . And I didn't scream and shout they were told not to be so judgemental. And neither should you lot 🤣🤣
So a group of old ladies were impressed and complimented you at the behaviour of 6 toddlers with one adult (they didn’t know you were a childminder)

And had a go at them?

Marmitemarinaded · 09/08/2021 10:14

[quote Porcupineintherough]@Marmitemarinaded I think you'll find children behave differently regardless of expectation, even in schools. And the amount of effort required to reach the expected level of behaviour will vary greatly from child to child. Same as with maths, or reading.[/quote]
Yes and the ones that don’t meet school expectations are punished

ladygindiva · 09/08/2021 10:14

Yeah it does happen. Dc 1 was like that. No idea how or why, just super chilled and compliant and good at entertaining herself and reading quietly for hours etc. Dc2 and 3 ( twins) are the opposite. 4.5 years old and even the thought of taking them to a cafe or even the cinema fills me with dread 🤣

FawnFrenchieMum · 09/08/2021 10:07

@INeedNewShoes

Can I ask the parents here who mention having high expectations of their DC, do you verbalise your expectations to your children clearly before you go out somewhere?

DD is very good when we go to restaurants but I do make sure we having crayons/paper/books and that I chat to her while we're waiting.

I've wondered whether for events that we're not as used to whether it would be wise to talk to DD before we go about what the event will entail and how we need to behave or whether that's overkill.

Yes I do. On the way, I let them know what the plan is re snacks (ie whether I’ve brought some, plan to only buy before it begins or visit the shop at the interval). I let them know if I think there will be an interval etc and we will go to the loo at that time. Let them know they may whisper to me but only really if it’s important at that time otherwise to wait until the interval. Obviously all this has been built up, starting with short children friend films, to longer disney films, to dance shows to the theatre etc.
Lockeddownagain · 09/08/2021 10:07

Absolutely laughing at everyone slagging me for putting a bunch of old moans in their place. Of course my children didn't hear me and I was a bloody brilliant childminder. And they weren't saying oh they are so well behaved in a kind way they were implying 6kids can't be well behaved with one adult . And I didn't scream and shout they were told not to be so judgemental. And neither should you lot 🤣🤣

Porcupineintherough · 09/08/2021 09:58

@Marmitemarinaded I think you'll find children behave differently regardless of expectation, even in schools. And the amount of effort required to reach the expected level of behaviour will vary greatly from child to child. Same as with maths, or reading.

BecauseMyRingBurnsSheila · 09/08/2021 09:53

My DC love drawing, colouring and sketching so if they bring their paper and pens when we go out for a meal they can be completely engrossed whilst DH and I chat. They are 6 and 8.

However they can also be in a whiney, squabbling mood and only full on parent attention can avoid noisy tantrums.

Wonderful you saw these children on a good day and as a parent I am pleased when others compliment their good behaviour because I can remind them of it to encourage that behaviour in future.

Suggesting the children are cowed through threat of violence is a huge jump in logic. If anything my 2 would be bribed with a promise of ice cream at the interval rather than avoiding a beating when we get home.

Marmitemarinaded · 09/08/2021 09:45

I don’t get all the “there’s an element of genetics”

Yes of course children are different

But not like schools differentiate! They have an expectation of behaviour. And that’s final.

Same here

Marmitemarinaded · 09/08/2021 09:43

@INeedNewShoes

Can I ask the parents here who mention having high expectations of their DC, do you verbalise your expectations to your children clearly before you go out somewhere?

DD is very good when we go to restaurants but I do make sure we having crayons/paper/books and that I chat to her while we're waiting.

I've wondered whether for events that we're not as used to whether it would be wise to talk to DD before we go about what the event will entail and how we need to behave or whether that's overkill.

I do.

If we’re going to theatre - on the way I do a run through. If they have something to say, they whisper it to me but to try to save until interval. I say I don’t want to be badgered for snacks at interval - I have brought something and that’s it, and I say that as we squeeze past people - they are to excuse themselves and say thank you.

Bit of an aide memoire!

vivainsomnia · 09/08/2021 09:41

There is without a doubt an element of genetic and some kids are much more predisposed to be calm and patient than others. It is also totally true that personality traits need to be valued, and that some of the more disturbing kids will become the leaders of our society.

However, I do believe that all kids, except maybe those with very challenging learning disabilities have the ability to learn through practice, but practice they need to receive and many parents can't be bothered.

I had a very calm and one much less so, and yes, the second was much harder. Whereas it took only one reminder for the elder to behave, it took many more for the youngest, but they did learn, and their behaviour was as good as the eldest, it was just more work.

Neighbour has 3 kids, and two of them are so loud and annoying. She's asked me in the past whether they were disturbing us in the garden and I said yes, in fact they are, a lot. She was taken by surprise, but then said 'yes, I know, it's just the way they are, the eldest is an angel but the other two don't respond to what I tell them' and then had a little laugh expecting me to sympathise. I don't. She sends them in the garden and never ever tells them to cut the noise down. She does shout at them to come in for lunch, and sometimes will shout when they fight, but otherwise, she clearly can't be bothered to discipline and is just happy to send them away from her in the garden.

INeedNewShoes · 09/08/2021 09:35

Can I ask the parents here who mention having high expectations of their DC, do you verbalise your expectations to your children clearly before you go out somewhere?

DD is very good when we go to restaurants but I do make sure we having crayons/paper/books and that I chat to her while we're waiting.

I've wondered whether for events that we're not as used to whether it would be wise to talk to DD before we go about what the event will entail and how we need to behave or whether that's overkill.

SleepingStandingUp · 09/08/2021 09:28

They can over qt the end and said I can't believe how well the kids behaved and they got a mouthful. Kids learn by example so we need to teach them simple... So you taught the kids that even when people are being nice and conceding a point, it's ok to give them a "mouthful" . I'd move my kids from your care if i found out

ActonSquirrel · 09/08/2021 09:15

@LemonRoses

How would you propose to sit between children on a train when there are maximum 2 seats next to each other

Your 4 year old remembered and followed the pre warnings did he? Didn't have to be told again? Confused

brittleheadgirl · 09/08/2021 08:53

Both of my children were always impeccably behaved at the theatre, on trains, weddings etc I often had strangers commenting on how polite and sweet they were.
They were little turds behind closed doors though GrinGrin

LemonRoses · 09/08/2021 08:37

@ActonSquirrel

It isn't that hard. I saw a woman on the train with a very young child: about 4 and he had an older sister.

The mum was on him the whole time. Eg. Sit down. Put that down. Don't shout.

Constantly. He stood up again she told told to sit down again.

That's how you do it. You teach your children to behave in public from a young age. Most can't be arsed to be honest and let their kids run riot.

That’s exactly not how to do it in my book.

You set expectations at outset.
You make it easy for them to behave and not disturb others. You sit between them.
You engage and keep them occupied.
You are thoughtful about any food or drink and effect on others.
You only use music or games for brief periods to allow time for them to learn to sit quietly at other times and to protect their hearing.
You use headphones.
You role model.
You are courteous to others and insist children are also.

FawnFrenchieMum · 09/08/2021 08:34

I think it definitely depends on the child’s interests a lot of the time. We do expect our DC to behave wherever we go but some places are more challenging then others. I hate seeing kids running around restaurants for example and have insisted mine sit nicely since being toddlers.

I took DD to the ballet a couple of years ago so she will have been 7/8ish and I could feel the people around us inwardly groan as we sat down but at the end several of them congratulated DD on sitting so beautifully. She’s a dancer and dreams of going to ballet school. On the flip side she struggles to sit still for a whole film at the cinema. She gets restless and we have to keep the snacks flowing to stop her fidgeting.

WantStickyBean · 09/08/2021 08:30

Yep. Trauma survivor here. People would come over at restaurants and congratulate my parents on their beautifully behaved children Sad.

MsTSwift · 09/08/2021 08:26

Brings back memories of Dh brothers wedding they reluctantly invited our two (only children in both families) who were about 6 and 8 at the time both girls quiet extremely well behaved.

We arrived at the wedding and the brides father who we had never met stormed over didn’t say hello but hissed aggressively at the girls that they “must be quiet” etc. They were terrified too scared to even move throughout the (short) service. What a knob.