Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How strict are you with your kids?

256 replies

SheABitSpicyToday · 08/08/2021 09:24

I think I need to be stricter with my daughter, who is just turning seven. She’s become a brat and is becoming difficult to live with. I just feel like we’re constantly arguing and it’s making everyone in the house miserable.
We argue about food, chores, what we’re doing today, going to school, what she’s doing with her clothes and it’s exhausting. She literally wakes me up to start an argument and it just sets me I to a bad mood everyday and my partner too when he’s got to go to work.

She’s being so difficult and I don’t want her to feel miserable but at the same time we’re all miserable atm!

Aibu to ask how strict you are and how you manage things in the home between everyone?

OP posts:
Redwinestillfine · 08/08/2021 18:30

I agree with the above. Regular chats about expected behaviours, reminders before and after, praise when she behaves well and pull her up on it when she doesn't ( including in front of friends) but pick battles and concentrate on one or two at a time.

SimonJT · 08/08/2021 18:29

@SheABitSpicyToday

Why wouldn’t I? If I had a physical illness no one bat an eye to me explaining it to her. But a mental one? It’s important for kids to know about these things.
They would when its convinced them you’re going to die, especially when a six year old will think that their new sibling is harming their mum. You really have to try to put your brain in six year old mode.
mbosnz · 08/08/2021 18:28

Just something that worked for me, for the morning sickness - DH would get me an OJ and a banana for me to have before my feet hit the floor in the morning. It seemed to sort out my blood sugars, and really did seem to take the edge off. Yours might be worse, but I thought I'd suggest it.

With the one that I found a bit more challenging, I went through a phase when I was very down and negative on her, apt to latch on everything she did wrong. DH commented on this to me, and it really pulled me up short. I turned it around and worked very hard to catch her doing good, really making sure I praised what she did that was right, in a meaningful way. E.g, Honey, I really appreciate you not arguing over breakfast this morning, that was great, we had such a better morning as a result, didn't we?! Also getting little love treats, just cos - she's into science, what about a science magazine?

Also, there was no point expecting the poor kid to suddenly do everything the way I wanted it done at once. So, I tried to focus on one unacceptable behaviour at a time. And always remembering, just like you, your daughter is going through changes in life, and she's going to have days where she finds it easier, and days where she just doesn't have it in her. So try to get her into bed on a good note, every night, knowing that tomorrow is another day for both of you.

Being a Stay at Home Mum can be a God awful drag, especially if not your chosen path, but that's not your child's problem, and please don't make it so. It was still more your choice than hers, just as it was your choice to have another baby.

I hope your pregnancy gets easier, and remember, it's not forever, even though it feels it right now!

ObviousNameChage · 08/08/2021 18:28

@SheABitSpicyToday

Why wouldn’t I? If I had a physical illness no one bat an eye to me explaining it to her. But a mental one? It’s important for kids to know about these things.
It's not about keeping it a secret. But do you really not see how this is a bit too much for her? The house move, the new baby (no matter how much kids love and wish for one it's still a massive change), you being ill physically and mentally,the fact that you had to stop treatment for a while, the fact that she needs to understand when you go a bit wobbly because of your bipolar. It all adds up, and she's only 7 not an adult that can rationalise things and understand exactly what is happening and why.
Bumpsadaisie · 08/08/2021 18:27

@SheABitSpicyToday

I think her going from such a perfect text book child has been such a jarring experience too. She was abnormally obedient up until 6 months ago. I’m glad she’s got some fire in her but I’m just not in the right place to handle it atm but I’m trying my best.

We’ve always been very open about feelings with eachother. I’ve always made sure of it, because due to my bipolar I can be unpredictable and I’ve always made sure she knows it’s not her fault, nothing she’s done wrong and not to worry, mums ok just this is the nature of the illness.

She’s truly the best kid I could ask for and I know I’ve come accords as defensive because I am defensive. I’m doing the best I can and she’s turned out really great considering. There’s just these few issues that I want to get a handle on before the baby is born so life is easier for all of us.

Good for you, it is very difficult with bipolar. It also sheds a bit more light on the total situation that is going on here that wasn't quite so clear before.

You have got a LOT to manage, being pregnant with HG and bipolar that is non-medicated. No wonder you are at the end of your tether and your DD is acting out.

Are you under a CMHT/psych? Are you being supported? Can you be referred to the perinatal service?

I am not bipolar, but having HG and a toddler to look after made me extremely depressed myself. I could really have done with some proper support, looking back.

I just really think you need someone to resource and support you, so that you can have the resource with your DD in this time.

melj1213 · 08/08/2021 18:26

@Wingingit15

Sorry OP - hope you don’t mind me asking a question to others as have similar age kids and keep wondering how people actually do discipline them. Where people are saying don’t tolerate whinging about food or shouting etc - what do you actually do to stop it?
You can't physically stop them but you can adjust your reaction to make it less likely that they do it again in future.

DD is a preteen so we're getting to the awkward independent/hormone induced behaviour and she is starting to push back again but so far it has always about boundaries, expectations, routines and following through with consequences.

DD makes her own breakfast most mornings, usually just cereal or toast, and there is always yogurt and fruit available too. Some days I will offer to make a hot breakfast - pancakes, waffles, bacon sandwich, scrambled eggs etc - but it will be a straightforward yes/no choice of one option "Would you like a bacon sandwich this morning?" If yes then she will have that, if not then she can make her own as usual.

She doesn't whine about wanting sausages instead of bacon (for example) as she knows that the offer is X or Y and no amount of whining will change that. If she starts whining she gets one warning/request to stop and if she continued then there would be a consequence applied - no TV time before school, reduced tech time that evening etc - and I would totally ignore her until she spoke to me properly.

If she asks politely then I will happily switch the bacon sandwich for a sausage one (provided it is practical, so in this case that we actually have sausages and I haven't already started cooking the bacon) which reinforces that being polite and respectful will have more chance of getting her her own way whereas whining and complaining gets nothing.

The same goes when we are out of the house - ever since DD was a toddler I have always been strict about using manners and behaviour in public. To reinforce this any time we went anywhere new I would clarify expected behaviour either before we left home or immediately when we arrived before we started any activity. We worked on one or two specific things at a time so each time we were out they were the main focus (eg saying please and thank you; no shouting; waiting patiently; sharing; using cutlery instead of hands; no whining etc). Once she mastered each of the manners we would move to the next ... so if she had mastered please/thank you and we were working on not shouting, I would gently remind her if she forgot to use please/thank you but she would only get consequences for shouting. (I hope that makes sense, it's hard to explain written down)

With young kids you have to be explicit "Don't misbehave" is too general of a direction- they don't have the mental acuity to assess every behaviour in the moment to know if it is "good" or "bad" behaviour.

So, when we went out I would give her specific instructions "Remember that when we go inside we have to use our manners. What are good manners?" "Is it good manners to shout?... No, it isn't so we are going to try and remember to speak nicely and if you shout then we will have to go home as that is not good manners. OK?" Then when we went into the place I would reinforce that - if DD was getting loud I would give her a gentle reminder and if she continued then she would get a warning. If she was still shouting then I would follow through with taking her home.

SheABitSpicyToday · 08/08/2021 18:24

Why wouldn’t I? If I had a physical illness no one bat an eye to me explaining it to her. But a mental one? It’s important for kids to know about these things.

OP posts:
SimonJT · 08/08/2021 18:21

@SheABitSpicyToday

Yes I’m extremely depressed. I can’t take my meds until I’ve had the baby. Things will be better then and I’ve explained this to her.
Why on earth have you explained this to a six year old?
Dishwashersaurous · 08/08/2021 18:14

The single biggest parenting challenge is realising that life is never going to be static. That as soon as one issue or stage is complete it's onto the next one.

You can't resolve her. The issues will continually evolve

FoxgloveSummers · 08/08/2021 18:12

Ok so you’re worrying about being overwhelmed when the baby comes, so you feel you need to snap your daughter back into ultra goodness before then. The reality is, that may not happen. She’s changing, not deviating from perfection. She’ll change again you know this. If the real worry is that she’ll change for the worse and you won’t be able to cope, speak to your psych team (do you have pregnancy support from the NHS?) and try to work on those worries. If it feels like you’re biting off more than you can chew because you got pregnant on the understand ing that you’ll have a newborn and a good and self sufficient child I can understand your worries. But trying to sort the changed situation out by cracking down on your daughter so the situation is ok when the new baby arrives isn’t ok.

Dishwashersaurous · 08/08/2021 18:07

OK. You are ill. Mentally and physically.

She will know that.

She is too young to cope with it, so she acts up as a way of trying to explain that she's overwhelmed.

She's got loads of life changes to cope with.

You just need to focus on the day to day and doing what you can to make life better and not worrying too much about the overall .

  1. Stop reasoning and comprising. If you want something to happen she does it. Tough.
  1. Try and get as much of a rest as you can. Ask your partner, friends etc to help.
  1. Stick to a strict bedtime routine.
  1. Don't engage in arguments.
blah3000 · 08/08/2021 18:06

Focus slightly on the positives. She reads to the bump which is absolutely lovely. She is perfectly old enough to get her own breakfast.

Some things, such as cutting the bedding etc are impulsive behaviours probably for attention. Just don't react. "Oh well, now your bedding is cut. You have to live with that." My 6yo emptied the toothpaste into the toothbrush pot the other day. Sometimes it's just what children do. It made me furious, but I didn't even acknowledge it because part of it is him exploring and part is him wanting a drama.

If she tries to argue, just don't engage. I always fine a forced monotone voice bores them out of answering back and arguing. This is what's for tea. If you know she likes it but won't eat then fine, that's on her. You don't need to discuss it with her, she is old enough to realise. Maybe ask her at the start of the week if she has any requests for the week so then she has some choice and control but you are managing that? Same with her clothes, if she's cold then that's on her too. I would also ignore the shorts up her bum, that's probably just to get a raise out of you. Ignore.

Iggly · 08/08/2021 18:05

But what if things can’t be sorted before baby arrives? She’s constantly growing and changing - I wouldn’t expect constant behaviour. My 11 year old is very different to what he was a year ago, let alone 4-5 years ago!

SheABitSpicyToday · 08/08/2021 18:05

Yes there are a few things I’m going to try. And also discuss with my husband.

OP posts:
SheABitSpicyToday · 08/08/2021 18:04

I think her going from such a perfect text book child has been such a jarring experience too. She was abnormally obedient up until 6 months ago. I’m glad she’s got some fire in her but I’m just not in the right place to handle it atm but I’m trying my best.

We’ve always been very open about feelings with eachother. I’ve always made sure of it, because due to my bipolar I can be unpredictable and I’ve always made sure she knows it’s not her fault, nothing she’s done wrong and not to worry, mums ok just this is the nature of the illness.

She’s truly the best kid I could ask for and I know I’ve come accords as defensive because I am defensive. I’m doing the best I can and she’s turned out really great considering. There’s just these few issues that I want to get a handle on before the baby is born so life is easier for all of us.

OP posts:
FoxgloveSummers · 08/08/2021 18:03

I think given all that you’ve said then you probably just need to wait it out. Will you give anything suggested here a go?

SheABitSpicyToday · 08/08/2021 17:59

I’ve never done that to her. He’s been in her life since she was 3, he’s as much her dad as anyone else could ever be. She is still incredibly sweet, it’s just these random outbursts that I can’t cope with.

OP posts:
MayorGundersonsDogRufus · 08/08/2021 17:59

My daughter is almost 8. She is generally pretty good, with some normal kid boundary pushing. Things that I do:

  • I tell her what I expect from her in terms of behaviour. So if we're going out somewhere I tell her that I expect her not to run off, to say please and thank you, not to nag me to buy her tat, etc
  • I follow through on consequences for certain behaviours - having her Nintendo put away, trips being cancelled, etc. They have to know you mean it!
  • I acknowledge and praise good behaviour and tell her when I am proud of her, often
  • I get cross rarely but when I do she really knows she's done something wrong
  • the rest of the time, I try and connect with her when she is playing up - I will say to her in a gentle tone, "this isn't nice behaviour, is there something that you are worried or angry about that I can help with?" This often elicits information about her state of mind that I wouldn't have learned about otherwise
  • certain behaviours are off limits - stealing, hitting, bullying. There are serious consequences for those and she knows it

I'm not saying any of this would work for anyone else, but just sharing in case it is useful. I don't claim to be a child psychology expert but we have built a close, trusting relationship where generally she doesn't want to disappoint me. I can be quite stern but also very loving. It can be tempting to just introduce stricter and stricter punishments but I think often when a kid is playing up it is a cry for help. Clear boundaries and lots of love can do wonders.

Iggly · 08/08/2021 17:59

@SheABitSpicyToday

Yes I’m extremely depressed. I can’t take my meds until I’ve had the baby. Things will be better then and I’ve explained this to her.
I’m sorry to hear this. But be careful with the messaging.

All of these things explain why she’s behaving as she is.

My mum suffered from severe mental illness and I knew something was wrong. I couldn’t help internalise that, I didn’t know how to process it and kept trying to make it better but also played out for attention.

Remember, your daughter is not doing anything with the same sort of intent that an adult would.

FoxgloveSummers · 08/08/2021 17:57

Ok that makes sense and must make everything seem much harder. When did your partner appear on the scene? I’m wondering if for example you’ve become more aware of her behaviour because it now happens “in front of” someone else.

Can I also just say, as someone who spent decades with their mum complaining that I used to be such a sweet little girl and was now a nightmare etc (I wasn’t) - please don’t do this to her. Yes very small children are often sweet and then change but that’s development, not a fault.

Pebbledashery · 08/08/2021 17:55

I'm quite strict with my 3 year old but in the sense she knows right from wrong, what the dangers are, that she needs to eat her vegetables and that she only gets an hour of screen time a day.. I'm a lone parent and I regularly say to her I'm mummy and not best friend all the time.
When it comes to discipline, we just have calm down cushion in the corner of the living room. I got quite some assistance from my daughters health visitor about discipline and not to make it punitive.. She does respond quite well to it. However saying that, your daughter is older than mine. I would be giving your daughter just one option and if she doesn't follow that one option then there are consequences.

SheABitSpicyToday · 08/08/2021 17:53

Yes I’m extremely depressed. I can’t take my meds until I’ve had the baby. Things will be better then and I’ve explained this to her.

OP posts:
FoxgloveSummers · 08/08/2021 17:51

Just one more thought - one of my school friends had a similar dynamic with her mum. In retrospect her mum was depressed and thought having kids had ruined her life. Could you be depressed?

JoborPlay · 08/08/2021 17:50

@ObviousNameChage

She's only 6/7! Not a mini adult, not a pre teen, not going through puberty or hormonal.

I don't even think she's particularly naughty, more doing silly things and being annoying. If you think she won't pick up that you don't like her much at the moment, especially if you're arguing all day, you're kidding yourself.

Also your examples seem to change when you're challenged by others. Sleep becomes sickness, small shorts become pyjamas. Why would that be an issue and worry about who sees?

She apologised and tried being nice, and you couldn't just let it go, you had to remind her how "naughty " she was. Even behaving nicely and appropriately comes with an admonishment.

From the majority of your posts it seems that her independence is about what is convenient for you, as do the rules and discipline.

You need to break this toxic cycle, and it's not about being stricter, but listening, loving her, parenting her, being clear in your message/expectations/actions. Setting boundaries that are appropriate for her .. is she emotionally ready for harry potter, is she emotionally ready to make a project about what happens to the body when you die etc?

Actually having read the rest of your posts, I agree with this.
Bumpsadaisie · 08/08/2021 17:49

@Jellycatspyjamas

Again, her choice to have breakfast alone because she doesn’t want to wait for me to sort myself out.

She’s 6 years old, doesn’t have the capacity yet to think about waiting for you to sort yourself out. It’s for you to adjust to accommodate her needs, not the other way around. It’s for your partner to support you in your pregnancy and accommodate that, not her. She’s not a mini adult, she’s a child with a child’s understanding and a child’s capacity to process stuff, you really need to consider that when you say she’s making choices to get her own breakfast, put herself to bed, not go to sports camp - some of those decisions aren’t here to make just yet. No wonder she’s confused about what she can and can’t decide.

She might say she doesn't want a story, and this and that ... but she doesn't necessarily know the full picture of what she wants, and even if she didn't it wouldn't necessarily be right for her.

There are behaviour problems so something clearly is not working for her. She is trying to communicate with you - in the very immature way which is all she knows - and you are totally impervious to any curiosity about it. You're all wrapped up in your own misery about how unfair it all is and how little you like her.

I had HG myself and I remember how awful it is. I suspect you, or a child part of in you, very much would like someone to be a parent to you, to help you manage.

What your DD feels is probably mirrored by what YOU feel - upset and full of anxiety about having to manage something that feels overwhelming and that you are not in the least bit ready for (having to parent while being so sick and anxiety about whether you can manage a second child and all the rest of it). Having to be a parent while feeling so totally sh*t.

People on here are telling you to parent your child and that is right - that IS what is needed. It sounds like a "parent" is absent - you take your 7 year old at face value and treat her like she is able to make choices and decisions. She doesn't need strictness - she needs to be thought about by a parental figure. Which could well include firmness and boundaries. But strictness without containment will just lead to a very angry and very anxious child.

But people telling you this, in a strict way, are not going to help you. Just as you treating your DD strictly are not going to help her - unless it also comes with support and compassion. I think you and your DD are very much in the same sort of place.

Before you can properly think about and help your DD as her parent, you need some support for the part of you that feels that way too much is being expected of you. I had HG myself with both of mine and it truly is grim.

I wish you the best.