Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How strict are you with your kids?

256 replies

SheABitSpicyToday · 08/08/2021 09:24

I think I need to be stricter with my daughter, who is just turning seven. She’s become a brat and is becoming difficult to live with. I just feel like we’re constantly arguing and it’s making everyone in the house miserable.
We argue about food, chores, what we’re doing today, going to school, what she’s doing with her clothes and it’s exhausting. She literally wakes me up to start an argument and it just sets me I to a bad mood everyday and my partner too when he’s got to go to work.

She’s being so difficult and I don’t want her to feel miserable but at the same time we’re all miserable atm!

Aibu to ask how strict you are and how you manage things in the home between everyone?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Ainecollins · 09/08/2021 21:41

My daughter was 6 while I was pregnant with her little sister, her behaviour sounds exactly like your daughters. We had a really difficult time with her and it worsened as my pregnancy progressed. We tried everything and flipped between spending lots of time with her and giving her extra attention, to trying to be more strict and setting tighter boundaries. Nothing worked and we were both miserable and it upset the whole house. However once her little sister was born it was like a switch flipped and she went back to her normal self. She also loves her little sister (now 2) and there was no trace of jealousy when she was born. I think it was just the anxiety of not knowing what to expect when I was pregnant. Good luck!

YellowMonday · 09/08/2021 14:09

For your DD anxiety, have you tried meditation? It might be a good activity for you both to start and end the day. Lots of great free guided meditations on YouTube. 5 - 10 minute meditations to begin with.

I find it also helps in giving kids tools to self regulate and understand the emotions they are feeling.

Preech · 09/08/2021 10:48

Another thought, do you and your DP have some scope to get someone in to help you out temporarily? Could a family member drop by for a few hours every day in the afternoons while school is still out, and spend some time engaging with your DD?

Just thinking about how hard I find it with my kids when I'm unwell. My DH is able to do a lot and fill in the gaps when I'm down or ill because he works hours that let him do that. When DH's parents were healthier, they would take our kids and spend time with them so I could recover or rest.

If you don't have a parent or an auntie who could come by temporarily while you're sick and school's out, is there enough room in your budget that you could hire someone to come by and look after your DD while you're home and getting some rest? Even a trustworthy teenager who could use some babysitting money?

Preech · 09/08/2021 10:23

@OP my 4 year old is going through a defiant and highly emotional phase right now too. It's exhausting. I'm not pregnant and we haven't moved. But the posters mentioning anxiety helped a penny drop for me (thank you PPs).

It wasn't that long ago that our kids were taken out of school overnight, for months, with no idea of when things might return to a normal rhythm. And us adults were speaking about people dying and possibly worrying about dying ourselves, or at least getting badly sick. The pandemic has forced a huge upheaval and uncertainty on all of our children, and you've got additional (but totally normal) upheavals and uncertainties with a new house and a new baby on the way.

Is it possible she's worried your DH will love the new baby, his own baby, more than he loves her? Especially if she has a tentative relationship with her own dad? Is she weighing up his own happy reactions to a new baby and wondering about how her own dad was with her? I.e., "why did he go away? Was I not good enough to love? Is the new baby better than I am? If that's true, is Mummy going to go away from me too?" She may not be mature enough yet to express that kind of worry very well, but it might be worth addressing directly.

As far as "how strict":

If it's PJs and underpants that she's hoiking up, but it's only happening inside your house, I'd either let that slide and ignore it, or take the PJ shorts away. It's one thing if it's happening out in public. In the house, you and DP need to figure out together whether that's an argument you still want to feed into.

Meals are tough. DH and I don't want to cook five different meals, and I don't want to eat nothing but beige either. I've had the most success with meals that offer lots of choices for everyone at the table. Mexican, Greek, Italian, roast dinners. Sometimes, the best I can settle for with 4 year old DD is a few bites of rice, a tortilla wrap, and some cucumber slices at dinner time. But at least she's smelling what the rest of us will eat, and seeing our enthusiasm about the meals.

There is a lot of evidence now suggesting that junk foods and ultra-processed foods (most of the packaged stuff in the middle of the store) are highly addictive and can alter the way your body responds to food. You might be better off removing it entirely from the house (as far as your DD knows) and insisting on stuff like fresh fruit or a piece of toast for her snack. I have resorted to eating chocolate in my car alone before, when I've been desperate for it; otherwise, I'll get a meltdown from my girls about them wanting some.

I am a bit strict about TV and iPad content. More lax about the quantity of screen time than some of the mums I know, but I will log into our Netflix account through the PC, set age ratings on my DDs profiles, and blacklist entire TV programmes and films if I don't like the values they promote. If bad behavior escalates, I will cut off screen time completely for a while.

Iggly · 09/08/2021 08:39

I’m not getting up especially early to do it when she’s capable of doing it herself

But why not? That’s the deal with being a parent - and sometimes it’s nice to show someone you care.

liveforsummer · 09/08/2021 08:08

I missed the part about her not having the switch for a month - this is a situation I ended up in with dd2 as well. After about a week it loses all influence. It's such a long time til they get it or they've not had it it's not worth the effort anymore.

Re the holiday I agree with a pp that it will be a break for you and yes on the outside she is liking forward to it and excited, but given her anxieties re being away from you etc I'd expect an escalation of the behaviour, as I explained about the feelings about baby, 6 year olds have emotions they don't understand. All the chats about her feelings are great to let her know she's being listened to it if limited use in actually getting to the bottom of how she's feeling or why she's behaving that way as she likely doesn't know herself.

I do think you need to give her less choices, she may seem to want them and says she likes it but 6 year olds aren't developmentally mature enough to make them. Maybe let her make breakfast but make lunch and sit and eat it together. If you've booked a sports club then she gets told she's going, not allowed to stay home because she's had a tantrum on the first day. No need to feel stupid, people who run clubs for 6 year olds see it all the time. Let her choose her clothes/what to wear but only but clothes that you actually approve yourself. You've had lots of great advice here so hopefully you're able to take it on board and make things better for both of you. Finally, remember if you feel like you don't like her very much and you hate being a SAHM this will come across so you need to put extra work in to your acting game.

jellybe · 09/08/2021 08:02

She likes having her independence, so am reluctant to take it away. Plus she knows that if she gets up before I do, then she needs to make her own breakfast. I’m not getting up especially early to do it when she’s capable of doing it herself

From the way she is acting I'd say she doesn't actually like her independence but says she does because she see that this is something you really value. I think you need to dial it all back, which will be hard, and start doing more of these things for her.

You don't make her breakfast/ lunch but want to tell her what she can eat for these meals - why should she listen if she is the one who is making it? You have told her she is independent but then are telling her she isn't through your, what she will see as, irrational rules around what she can have when.

She may say she doesn't want you to put her to bed but start doing it anyway. Take it in turns reading bits of her current book to each other. It is fantastic that she is reading HP but there is a lot of parental lose in those books - this could be fuelling her anxiety about you leaving her.

Just because she is capable of doing things for herself doesn't mean she needs to always do it at that age. She is 7 treat her a bit more her age.

Plus you seem to have a bit of a focus on things being inconvenient for you, I.e. getting up to make her breakfast. Really that's just part of parenting and is a more stable consistent way of showing her you care rather than loads of treats, days out etc.

liveforsummer · 09/08/2021 07:28

I'm pretty relaxed in someways compared to DC's peers parents is they have quite a lot of independence and I'm not super strict on food or screens as it's something they both make good choices about. I am however strict on behaviour, manners and any whining and whinging. For your Dd is just remove the possibility of some of these things. Stop buying crisps, explain it's because she can't make good choices around them. Tbh if the dunkers are breadstick ones, cheeses and breadsticks are not a terrible breakfast. You could replace it with cheese triangles and a box of breadsticks. DD often has cheese, crackers and cucumber for breakfast or breadsticks, hummus and cucumber as she doesn't like cereal and toast. It's actually better than most breakfast cereals. It's a case of picking your battles here, you don't need to say no based on something not being a traditional breakfast thing if it's actually a nutritious option.

Re the clothes let her wear what she likes,, if she gets cold then that's a natural consequence. She's more than old enough to take responsibility for that. Buy longer shirts and get rid of any that can actually flash her bum cheeks (she can always have them back if she agrees to stop pulling them up, explain if it happens again once she's got them back then they go to the charity shop.

The bedroom is introduce punishments for cutting up bed covers - missing out on something happening soon or removal of screens or whatever she likes to do. That's something not to be tolerated. What motivates her? Does she like money to buy things or fidget toys? She can earn these by tidying her room even if it's not perfect, just giving it a go. With my dc I also don't let them have friends round if their room is messy so that's a motivation.

Finally she probably needs loads of love and reassurance. There is a new baby on the way and regardless of how she says feels about it she will be anxious and worried, she might not even realise it herself. Lots of 1:1 time and love, lots of praise. If she feels she's getting enough positive attention she might feel less inclined to seek it via negative (not saying she isn't getting enough but no harm to go over the top with it at times like these) by taking away the sources of conflict and again, picking your battles re clothes and sometimes food, it will be easier to do.

Phineyj · 08/08/2021 20:27

I think she is just really worried and it's understandable in the situation - you have a lot going on.

I have a challenging 8 year old (she's very anxious too) and the behaviours you describe would be pretty minor here! I think that rather than suddenly becoming 'naughty', she was unusually compliant before.

House moves are massive at that age. We moved twice when I was around your daughter's age and I remember it was very distressing, although I tried to keep that from my parents. Together with the pregnancy, your illness and the pandemic, I think it would be surprising if she wasn't feeling some effects.

Hopefully the return to school will help.

RobynRedhead · 08/08/2021 19:38

Haven't read the whole thread, but my dd was a handful at that age, could pick an argument over nothing and a complete contrary mary, would start the second she woke up and it felt relentless. Turns out she has asd (and I'm pretty sure some pda elements too as she's very controlling and demand avoidant). Even if this isn't the case with your dd, there's no harm in trying some pda techniques to see if they help at all, especially as you've mentioned anxiety.

www.pdasociety.org.uk/life-with-pda-menu/family-life-intro/helpful-approaches-children/

SheABitSpicyToday · 08/08/2021 19:36

She definitely would not appreciate me choosing her clothes Grin we have very opposite tastes!

We do have a lovely evening routine it’s just not in her bedroom because her bed is a single cabin and I can’t get up there! So she reads a story to the baby in my bed so I can lie down with her and we talk about her worries etc. then she goes off to her bed.

OP posts:
Dishwashersaurous · 08/08/2021 19:31

Poor kid, and you.

So much for you both to cope with, not surprising that she is playing up .

What external help do you have

Jellycatspyjamas · 08/08/2021 19:27

Yeah everything all happened at once. I found out I was pregnant the weekend we moved house.

That’s a huge amount for you to cope with, and a huge amount for her too - you’re all under a lot of stress. What supports can you draw on for her and for you so you’re able to be more emotionally and physically available to her. I know sickness is an issue but at the moment she gets herself up, chooses her clothes, sorts her own breakfast and lunch, does her own bath and puts herself to bed. These are all routine activities that provide nurture and stability - you might not manage them all but maybe pick ones that you or your DH can do with/for her, she needs adult involvement and support even if physically you think she can do them. Maybe leave a choice of clothes for her each day, pick her clothes together, make a packed lunch for her if you can’t face food when she’s eating, your DH could do a bedtime routine with her.

Once the baby comes your routines will all take another change so getting some landmarks in place for her now will give you something to work with. With so much change having the stability of adult care is important for her and you might see her behaviour change in and of itself.

It’s very hard, I’m sure you must be reeling a bit yourself too - do you have support with all you’ve got going on?

theworldhasgoneinsane · 08/08/2021 19:25

@SheABitSpicyToday

The other thing that’s causing issues is the interrupting when we’re talking. She will also ask us questions and then tell us we’re wrong when we answer her. She’s just very frustrating to be around atm and I’m not sure if it’s just an issue with this age or something else.
I've been reading through this thread and my daughter does some of these things especially THIS about asking questions! She doesn't do things like destroy her belongings but some of the behaviours you've mentioned are familiar. My DD is 8 so I'm reading with interest as you've had some really helpful suggestions
LuxOlente · 08/08/2021 19:13

@SheABitSpicyToday

We’ve tried Start charts but she seems a bit old for them now, she just thinks they’re stupid. She’s very independent and grown up for her age which I think doesn’t help. It’s very much like parenting a teenager. I’m 25 weeks pregnant and exhausted with it.
I'm gonna say this might be the issue; she isn't old for her age or 'like a teenager' or 'independent'. She's just a little kid of 6-7. You're projecting more mature behaviour on to her.

I'm just a boring old Supernanny-style mum - but it worked. State clearly the problem - "you don't hit. You don't shout." - and what will happen if it continues - "X minutes on the step/ loss of screen time or other privilege." - which gives them a chance to fix the behaviour. Mine almost always did, but if not, step or loss of privilege. When they know you'll follow through, they make good choices.

They haven't ever been 'naughty' since 5-6 years old, because they simply know what good behaviour is and feel no great urge to shout, be rude, argue or do any of those things. We all just talk normally and arrange stuff.

Dinner is placed on the table. You may eat some of it, or all of it, or none of it, but you will not ask for something different nor whine nor complain. Obviously I serve things they like. They just leave any veg or stuff that they don't. They're praised for being well-mannered. They're good eaters as they get no attention at all from being bad ones.

They do not know what a 'dunker' is so they never ask for one. Don't have crap food around the house, or ever introduce the notion one could eat them for breakfast, and they won't ask. And if they do, the answer is simply no with a reminder about the step/loss of privilege.

Embracelife · 08/08/2021 19:12

@SheABitSpicyToday

Yes I’m extremely depressed. I can’t take my meds until I’ve had the baby. Things will be better then and I’ve explained this to her.
CaN you ask about young carer support for her Family support It s a lot for 7 year old

it s hard for an adult
Navigating someone s mental health
(And same if you had physical illness she would need specific support someone to listen to her and suggest strategies)
Her behaviour reflects the situation so give her some slack
But ask for some support for her and you

Notdoingthis · 08/08/2021 19:08

I am not strict about things like food. We do make compromises. I can't be bothered making dinner last an hour. I am very strict on manners. So not tidying up, or answering back is not tolerated. They get a stern warning and it stops. I have hardly ever had to follow through on a warning (like being sent to their room or missing out on something).
I am fairly relaxed about clothes and things. Natural consequences like getting wet feet in the wrong shoes is fine by me.
But there are some non negotiables, like brushing teeth and suncream.

SheABitSpicyToday · 08/08/2021 19:06

Yeah everything all happened at once. I found out I was pregnant the weekend we moved house.

OP posts:
Jellycatspyjamas · 08/08/2021 18:49

Yes I’m extremely depressed. I can’t take my meds until I’ve had the baby. Things will be better then and I’ve explained this to her.

So her deteriorating behaviour coincided with your pregnancy and being off your meds? Which makes a lot of sense in line with the other changes that have happened in her life and in yours.

I honestly think you’re giving her too much information - she’ll have no way to process that you’re ill and can’t take medication while you’re pregnant, and she sees how physically unwell you are - and how that stops you spending time with her - to hold in mind that things will improve when the baby gets here is a lot to ask from a 6 year old. And the baby will bring sleepless nights and stress too so things might not necessarily feel better for her for a long time.

You have a lot on your plate, but so does she with much fewer resources available to her to deal with it all. Going gently with her, picking your battles and recognising she’s expressing herself in the way she knows how (and in ways you can’t ignore) might reduce some of your dislike of her - she’s trying to have her needs met, as are you.

Iggly · 08/08/2021 18:44

@SheABitSpicyToday

Her wondering what’s going on with me would be much worse than her having a 7 year old friendly discussion on mental health. They discuss mental health at school, it’s no different to that.
Mental health discussions at school tend to focus around less complex issues like bipolar. Plus physical illnesses in parents will also generate anxiety in a child regardless of explanations!
justaweeone · 08/08/2021 18:40

Mine are now 18 and 23!
They've turned out as fab young people, not quite sure if it was nurture or nature.
I think I winged it a bitGrinand certainly not the perfect parent!
Have a look at the book in the photo attached, he also wrote a book about toddlers.

How strict are you with your kids?
delilahbucket · 08/08/2021 18:39

Actions equal consequences for her and pick your battles. Do you need to argue every point? If you're arguing with her, she's copying and arguing with you. Don't engage with her. She does as she is asked or there is either a natural consequence or say if she doesn't do a job, she isn't allowed to do anything else until that job is done, even if it means sitting on the sofa in silence.

SheABitSpicyToday · 08/08/2021 18:35

Her wondering what’s going on with me would be much worse than her having a 7 year old friendly discussion on mental health. They discuss mental health at school, it’s no different to that.

OP posts:
icedcoffees · 08/08/2021 18:34

@SheABitSpicyToday

Why wouldn’t I? If I had a physical illness no one bat an eye to me explaining it to her. But a mental one? It’s important for kids to know about these things.
Yes, but she's six.

She shouldn't be expected to have to deal with all of this. It's too much for her, hence her behaviour.

Bumpsadaisie · 08/08/2021 18:30

I get too that it is disconcerting that her behaviour has changed. But a compliant perfect child is I think more cause for concern than one who is acting out!
A perfectly behaved child is a child who doesn't experience themselves as a child.
This "bad" behaviour ironically could be a good sign that things are getting reorganised for the better between you in the proper way - so that she can be a child and you the parent.

Swipe left for the next trending thread