Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Employer asked staff not to work from abroad

259 replies

Cosmos123 · 08/08/2021 08:24

A memo came out with new wfh strategy.
Basically they have informed staff that the hybrid model will be used where staff do not need to meet with clients.
Also staff can be requested to return at short notice to the office.
Not sure that is great news for those who have relocated hundreds of miles away.
Also a brief note at the end that working permanently from abroad will not be allowed due to tax implications or summat.

Wonder who even moved abroad during the pandemic?
Anyways seems that Wfh remotely forever for those who wanted it won't be happening.

OP posts:
SpeakingFranglais · 08/08/2021 10:13

You have never been able to work from home in a different country to the one you are employed in just because you fancy it.

My company has had a WFH policy since 1999. The guidance then, as now, is that you can can only work from your registered home address (although "Agile Working" has made this more flexible in recent years) and if you wish to move house you need your employers permission to continue any WFH arrangement. Working from overseas is banned because, as other have said, there are tax implications and your company would need an tax agreement with the other country, and every other country your colleagues may have a holiday pad in) and there are also H&S, insurance and travel expense and travel time considerations.

For our company WFH from a new address may also have implications on London Weighting allowances (or whatever it is known as now).

You would be amazed (or probably not) how many people thought they were being penalised for not being able to WFH from their Spanish villa for the entire school holidays or who thought they should retain their inner or outer London Weighting allowances even if they moved 300 miles north of the M25.

overthethamesfromyou · 08/08/2021 10:09

Our IT department spent the summer shutting down access from workers who logged in from abroad without permission. For us it's GDPR, regulatory implications and tax.

PizzaCrust · 08/08/2021 10:07

Are you someone who doesn’t get to WFH so think no-one else should either, or are you one of those people who wants everyone forced into the office to keep you company?

Neither, I work p/t so it makes no difference to me whether I’m at home or not. I simply thing there are a proportion of workers out there who seem to think the world revolves around them and their wants. See: moving across the world without asking permission as an example.

I also think people tend to big up how successful WFH actually is for them. Honestly, I would be willing to say it isn’t is half as productive as a lot of people let on. It takes a particular type of person to maintain motivation in a home setting and honestly, most of us aren’t that type of person.

You can have your opinion, as will I. I do think it’s disgusting though how so many workers with disabilities have been told for years “no you can’t WFH” yet now you have some moron who moved to France complaining that they no longer can due to their own moronic decisions. Isn’t in the same ball pack and these people need to face the reality of their quite frankly stupid decisions.

Nocutenamesleft · 08/08/2021 10:06

@Cosmos123

A memo came out with new wfh strategy. Basically they have informed staff that the hybrid model will be used where staff do not need to meet with clients. Also staff can be requested to return at short notice to the office. Not sure that is great news for those who have relocated hundreds of miles away. Also a brief note at the end that working permanently from abroad will not be allowed due to tax implications or summat.

Wonder who even moved abroad during the pandemic?
Anyways seems that Wfh remotely forever for those who wanted it won't be happening.

I’m trying to get my husband to work from abroad

He can’t sadly. But he can change jobs and go work there. Which is an option

My husband works completely remotely. He always has. If he needed to come back at short notice. His boss said he’s more than able to go and work from abroad

I hated how this was handled and want to move as soon as. We have no ties to England.

SmokeyDevil · 08/08/2021 10:04

Honestly, I have sympathy for people who just chose a slightly longer commute to get some more outdoor space, but there's definitely a limit!

I don't feel sorry for them either to be honest. They have a brain, they could have thought 'what will I do in future if my company wants me back in the office full time or even part time? Can I afford my new, possibly increased mortgage, plus the travel expenses?'. They have brains, they can use calculators, it's all on them that they were stupid.

I might be getting to wfh permanently, which will be great, I love it. But I am not buying a bigger house with more space for a proper office unless that is certain. There is no point in us paying for a bigger mortgage for a house we won't get to use more.

Marlboroandmalbec34 · 08/08/2021 09:57

Long term you cannot work in different country to your employee compliantly. You need a local employment contract following the legislation of that country and to be paying taxes and social contributions in the country of residence. The term you can stay in a country without been considered a tax resident differs between country.

I work for a company that offers solutions to this exact problem. It’s crazy how many people moved country in the pandemic and they are leaving their employers in a really difficult position of been non compliant.

junebirthdaygirl · 08/08/2021 09:52

Very common among young people in lreland . They are known as tech nomads. Ones l know have permission from their companies to go for 3 months so avoid tax issues. My ds's company didn't allow it due to possible issues with the system they use. He was fine with that. Read that the Canaries are making up for lost tourism with the amount of young people who are going there for the 3 months. Others are in Barcelona/ Lisbon etc.
All be moving back soon hopefully as office's open up.
I can't complain about it as l am sure l would have been very tempted as a young person to go after months working at the kitchen table. It probably kept some of the young people sane during the various lockdowns.

ThunderCrow · 08/08/2021 09:48

WFH to some degree (perm or hybrid) was coming anyway. Over the last 20 years it's just grown and grown. The pandemic has given it a massive shove in the same direction. I doubt the genie is going all the way back into the bottle now.

I can see companies now having to respond to put in terms about working from abroad. From an IT pov (my profession) it makes little difference to the security or ability to fix an issue, assuming you already have a corporate approach to both. But from a legal, tax and identity pov I could imagine most companies not allowing it.

ThinWomansBrain · 08/08/2021 09:45

as someone has pointed out above, there are tax issues regarding staff not lining in the UK.
Additionally, isn't there something in GDPR about processing information in a third country outside of the EU?

WillYouDoTheFandango · 08/08/2021 09:43

[quote MyriadeOfThings]@WillYouDoTheFandango would you be as jealous if it was a small mining village in the NE though?

They are just working and staying with family after all.[/quote]
If their remote mining village in the NE was basking in 30 degree sunshine and they had a pool I would be yes!

I know she’s working but she has the evenings and weekends by the pool and her parents are doing a lot of childcare as they’ve missed their grandchild. I don’t begrudge her btw. It’s been 2 years since she’s seen her family and I’m really happy for her.

onelittlefrog · 08/08/2021 09:41

@TeenMinusTests

Anyone who relocated hundreds of miles away without having permanent right to work from home was being somewhat daft.
This!

But I don't agree with them saying it's a hybrid model but also saying people can be required to return to the office at any time with short notice.

It's one or the other and they should be clear and up front about it - you can't start a new employee saying it's hybrid/ flexible, and then a couple of months in say you want them in the office.

I think any approach is fine but they just need to be clear on it.

Dreamstate · 08/08/2021 09:41

Same in my company plenty of silly people who moved up north are bow complaining about travelling hours and cost to come into the office. We're also moving to a 2 or 3 day per week model but let's be honest its based on collaborative working so in reality it could be more some weeks and less on others. Its not a fixed 2 or 3 days either but a guideline.

Then you also have those who got pets like dogs now worrying about dog walking costs, someone even asked if they could bring them to work. Wtf!

FunMcCool · 08/08/2021 09:40

It gives company’s tax issues if employees work from abroad. That’s probably why they don’t want people doing it.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 08/08/2021 09:39

I’m surprised so many people want exclusive wfh arrangements as it won’t be long before companies think actually it’s cheaper to employ people in India, Poland etc.

There are a lot of reasons why that’s unlikely to happen. Tax implications is one, but cultural differences/not understanding British culture, lack of team cohesion, unpopularity with customers (overseas call centres being something most people don’t like, to the point that UK only call centres are a selling point).

I worked for a company that outsourced staff to India and it was an absolute disaster. Cost them a fortune to shift everything, then a bigger fortune to move things back AND fix the fuck ups.

Cheaper doesn’t mean better, and some companies want to provide a good service rather than a cheap one.

TheWayTheLightFalls · 08/08/2021 09:39

I read today that Premier Inns, Novotels etc in central London are reporting a lot of interest for mid-week one/two night stays from businesspeople who now simply live too far away to commute conveniently. Shock, horror.

The working abroad thing... yes, it's nonsensical and people employed on British contracts for British companies who unilaterally decide to fuck off to Italy/Bali/wherever don't get any sympathy from me. But at the same time I can imagine individuals working for small organisations and doing this discreetly getting away with it for ages and ages. If you keep a home (address) in the UK and don't open an Italian bank account, register with an Italian GP etc, what are the chances of the Italian tax authorities cottoning on?

LIZS · 08/08/2021 09:37

Many companies have IT helpdesks based somewhere different to their offices or outsourced. Many IT issues can be resolved remotely or equipment couriered.

Hekatestorch · 08/08/2021 09:36

I’m surprised so many people want exclusive wfh arrangements as it won’t be long before companies think actually it’s cheaper to employ people in India, Poland etc. Than it is in the UK. Can’t understand why people aren’t worried about this more.

I wouldnt want permanent wfh. However, not for this reason. A huge amount of jobs can't be just shipped abroad.

I have set up remote offices abroad, it's really not that simple. And actually, in the long run, doesn't really impact revenue. Ots very costly to set, and ends up with not much gain.

That's why alot of call centres (which are jobs that could go abroad) tend to go, then come back, then go again and then come back.

Because they often end up starting to lose money when customers decide to leave, due to the fact that they don't like call centres abroad. This one thing can really impact a customers decision on wether to stay or leave a company.

But I agree, people really need to think about wether their jobs are the ones that could go.

PizzaPiePizzaPie · 08/08/2021 09:35

What happens if you have an IT problem and you work nowhere near work? DH had to take his laptop in last week to fix something and then stayed in work for the day whilst they were working on it.

girlmom21 · 08/08/2021 09:32

How can you have any sympathy for people who chose to move 100s of miles away based on them being temporarily required to work from home due a global pandemic?

These people are idiots.

C8H10N4O2 · 08/08/2021 09:31

I’m surprised so many people want exclusive wfh arrangements as it won’t be long before companies think actually it’s cheaper to employ people in India, Poland etc. Than it is in the UK. Can’t understand why people aren’t worried about this more

Because that already happened 20 yrs ago and the pattern is already in place. Nearshoring, offshoring and farshoring work already have their place in many industries. Most large companies in London either have their own offices in the regions or outsource work to companies in the regions. Perhaps the difference is more small companies opting for virtual offices, however some will come a cropper as it takes good management to make it work.

NothingIsWrong · 08/08/2021 09:29

We are not allowed to work abroad at all, but apart from the tax implications, our IT equipment is not allowed out of the country for security reasons.

Disclaimer I am no IT bod, so I have no idea if this is a thing or not! But it's what my boss told me

BlueSurfer · 08/08/2021 09:28

@Cosmos123

We have been wfh in a hybrid model since 2010.

The 2 days in the office if you live more than 1.5hr commute each way takes it toll still as.many have found in the organisation.

So those who have moved further a field may not realise how exhausting that commute for 2 days a week can be. The cost also.

That was a fairly standard commute for many of my colleagues in the city pre-pandemic though.

Many of us are now in the opposite situation that we haven’t moved but the company has closed several offices so they are now much further away from us. As a result we largely can wfh and in certain other countries as well if we prefer.

HelenHywater · 08/08/2021 09:28

I think there are tax implications for the employer if it's a permanent move abroad. We have people now working abroad who are (finally) visiting elderly parents - but they're just there for a couple of weeks.

TheGenealogist · 08/08/2021 09:26

Oh and in DH's case, employees cannot work from home. Similar to something like manning the points on a railway or monitoring a power station. You have to physically be in work to do it.

Eatingsoupwithafork · 08/08/2021 09:26

Yep it will be tax implications - you even need different contracts for people working 100% from home vs hybrid. We’re already seeing people in the North taking remote roles for companies in London… recruiting in the North is nearly impossible at the moment as people are being offered roles so fast for companies they normally wouldn’t have bothered to apply to as it’s not in their region. It will be much cheaper paying for someone in the North vs London.

I’m surprised so many people want exclusive wfh arrangements as it won’t be long before companies think actually it’s cheaper to employ people in India, Poland etc. Than it is in the UK. Can’t understand why people aren’t worried about this more.