Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Employer asked staff not to work from abroad

259 replies

Cosmos123 · 08/08/2021 08:24

A memo came out with new wfh strategy.
Basically they have informed staff that the hybrid model will be used where staff do not need to meet with clients.
Also staff can be requested to return at short notice to the office.
Not sure that is great news for those who have relocated hundreds of miles away.
Also a brief note at the end that working permanently from abroad will not be allowed due to tax implications or summat.

Wonder who even moved abroad during the pandemic?
Anyways seems that Wfh remotely forever for those who wanted it won't be happening.

OP posts:
alltheemptyfields · 08/08/2021 11:36

I don't know why people fail to see the link between companies allowing totally flexible re: country and taking the risk on corporation tax etc., and outsourcing those jobs to cheaper labour pools abroad.

because companies who have tried that in the past have already moved back, before the pandemic. that's why.

SOME staff can be used abroad, some really really cannot.

Some companies even had trouble with staff IN THE UK because of accent that was unacceptable to the client and had to impose a quota of native English speakers. (and not only UK, the companies I am talking about are in England, Greater London...)

Because you can still need to organise a week training once a year or so in this country, have people coming to meet once a month.

Working from home doesn't mean being in a cave and not seeing anyone ever again.

icedcoffees · 08/08/2021 11:29

To every person who says that their job is too specialised for that to happen to them, I urge them to think what the company would do if they resigned/went on mat leave/got sick. A company that is truly that dependent on named individuals is a high risk one.

Exactly. Nobody is irreplaceable.

Savoury · 08/08/2021 11:27

I don't know why people fail to see the link between companies allowing totally flexible re: country and taking the risk on corporation tax etc., and outsourcing those jobs to cheaper labour pools abroad.

To every person who says that their job is too specialised for that to happen to them, I urge them to think what the company would do if they resigned/went on mat leave/got sick. A company that is truly that dependent on named individuals is a high risk one.

On a personal note, I find that people are now questioning moves that on paper seemed to make sense during lockdown. Even doing a 4 hour round trip (if you count wait times, journey on each side) twice a week is a headache.

LBOCS2 · 08/08/2021 11:23

We have moved to agile working, with our company having closed our City office (we have smaller hub offices in other areas of London). It's fine, it works well and does allow us a lot of flexibility. We're also able to allow some of my team to go to see their families in Europe, and spend the time they need to quarantine there working - so they don't lose holiday over it.

I do question people who have moved a long way away though as they limit their choices in terms of moving jobs as well - the industry we work in is small (and almost exclusively based in large cities) so if they stop being happy at our company they're going to find it extremely hard to leave.

alltheemptyfields · 08/08/2021 11:12

Those who don't embrace WFH and Hybrid working are going to lose a hell of a lot of staff to companies who do.

I agree

At the very least, people now expect flexibility, even if it's only to be allowed to WFH when they expect a delivery (instead of taking a day off), wfh when the kids have some school thing and work later, stay home when they come back from holiday or plan to go on holiday that evening...

There are very few people who genuinely expect to be in the office and that's it, never work elsewhere ever.

We are talking about businesses where it's possible, no one is discussion virtual surgeries or remote plane flying...

BootsScootsAndToots · 08/08/2021 11:12

We were looking to move closer in to the city to cut dh commute just before the pandemic.

He works for a global company and does 6 am calls and 7 pm calls, travelling in / out in between these times on a not- massively-reliable train route.

We are waiting to see what the working pattern settles into for him, but if he gets 3 days or more WFH I'd personally like to move further out.

So glad we didn't move in as it would have meant going from mortgage free with a big enough house to a whopping mortgage for a teeny tiny place.

Thewinterofdiscontent · 08/08/2021 11:03

@MrsOvertonsWindow

I do wonder if there's a connection between wfh and the awful levels of customer service we're getting? Every organisation I speak to you there's endless layers of "do you really need to speak to us? Covid... " messages, repeated endlessly. Understandable in the middle of the pandemic but why have businesses not resolved this by now? Ages to get through to First Direct followed by inexplicable errors at their end - a bank with normally impeccable customer service. It seems routine that what would have been a 5 minute max phone call now turns into half an hour of listening to voicemail messages about they would rather you don't phone.
This is absolutely my experience. Noticeably down hill from banks, credit cards and insurance services.

I do have online and apps but they can take ages to log into and find basic information.

icedcoffees · 08/08/2021 11:03

@MadameOvary81 then you're very fortunate, but most people won't be in that kind of situation.

Those who don't embrace WFH and Hybrid working are going to lose a hell of a lot of staff to companies who do.

However I don't necessarily agree with this. Not everyone likes WFH and not everyone can sustain that lifestyle. WFH massively favours the wealthy as they're the ones who have study space, garden offices and who can't afford to build annexes and buy nice office equipment.

Many people have been working from their beds or crammed into a corner of the kitchen for 18+ months now. There have been numerous threads on here from people who are desperate for things to go back to normal and who can't wait to get back into the office.

I would also say that the people who love WFH and who rave about how good it is are the people above - who live in nice, spacious houses and who've saved thousands on season tickets each year as a result. But there have also been numerous threads on the other side - from managers who struggle to engage their team, from customers who are sick of dealing with workers who are working from home with screaming babies/barking dogs in the background etc.

WFH undoubtedly has it's benefits but I don't think it's always as amazing as some people try and make it out to be.

MadameOvary81 · 08/08/2021 10:57

@icedcoffees I completely understand. We are lucky that my partner is a director, albeit down the food chain as it's a multinational conglomerate. Also very specialised. If she was fired they would lose a whole department. It would take them years to find a replacement for her. She could also solo tomorrow if she wanted to. But her company have been amazing so far. They have started hybrid working and they are allowing all employee's to apply for WFH full-time come September. So, there shouldn't be a problem for us. But I do agree a lot of people we far too hasty in moving. Employers are going to have to a have a huge re-evaluation of how things work from here on in. Those who don't embrace WFH and Hybrid working are going to lose a hell of a lot of staff to companies who do.

lannistunut · 08/08/2021 10:57

In my work, wfh has been shown to be more productive. It hasn't always been as much fun Sad but workwise it has been absolutely full on and we have delivered more than the previous year.

alltheemptyfields · 08/08/2021 10:46

I also think people tend to big up how successful WFH actually is for them. Honestly, I would be willing to say it isn’t is half as productive as a lot of people let on.

I assure you that businesses would have had everyone back in the office weeks ago if it was the case. Businesses are not charities.

The pretence of "being productive in the office" just by showing your face but distraction from colleagues, inane meetings, bloody tea rounds, chats, office politics, signing of cards, organising presents, people interrupting every 3 minutes because you are "there"...

Even people who want to go back to the office expect to stay home Fridays and so on.

icedcoffees · 08/08/2021 10:46

@MadameOvary81 I appreciate you had difficult circumstances, but what you would do if his boss said "I need you back in the office full-time from September?"

As a former manager myself, if someone said to me "I can't come back to work because I've moved to the other end of the country" they'd be fired for breaking their contract (not being able to access their workplace).

EBearhug · 08/08/2021 10:41

I work for an international company and most of us are now officially hybrid workers. In practice, in my department, most of us were already. Few of us were in every day of the week. In EMEA, we've been working like that for the best part of two decades anyway, so there's been a lot of eye-rolling about the return to office training which points out you might now have colleagues in different locations, even different timezones (though if this means people in the USA remember not everyone works there, so a meeting at 5pm EST won't get much attendance from those of us on this side of the Atlantic, it will be a good thing.) The people I'm working closest with at the moment are in Ireland and the Netherlands, so being back in the office makes no difference to how we work.

Some roles do have to remain in the office. Certain contracts can only be worked on by staff in a particular country. There are some restrictions about taking kit (laptops, phones) to certain countries, though most we have offices in are okay. Some workers were already on homeworking contracts - others are moving to homeworking contracts. We already had some people living a few hundred miles away and coming in just once or twice a week, which was their choice.

In the past, some people have moved countries, but if it's for more than the odd week here or there, you will get asked to change your contract. Different countries across Europe have very different rights when it comes to things like redundancy and pensions and health care, so however much you like the location, it's worth checking if it's really going to work in your favour.

For the rest of us, it's very much dependent on their team. Some have been told they must be in the office first Tuesday of the month. (HR are apparently getting a bit twitchy about the chance of there being too many in on one day, as we're not at full capacity in the office currently, with useable desks being separated.) Some are every Wednesday. Some have been told, don't come in for work alone, only if you have sociable reasons too.

My manager doesn't really care, as long as he can contact us, wherever we are. Our team is already spread three different UK offices, Netherlands, Belgium, Germany and Ireland, so online meetings are normal. I think he's going to try and sort out one day a month where most of us can be in to go to lunch together, but I don't think he'll be insisting on any particular day otherwise. I suspect that once the schools are back, some of us will settle in to one or two days back in on days that others will be around. Certainly most of us agree that if you're going to be sat in the office on your own, you might as well be sat at home on your own (unless you have technical issues like Internet problems, or really need a break from the family.)

Aprilx · 08/08/2021 10:41

@junebirthdaygirl

Very common among young people in lreland . They are known as tech nomads. Ones l know have permission from their companies to go for 3 months so avoid tax issues. My ds's company didn't allow it due to possible issues with the system they use. He was fine with that. Read that the Canaries are making up for lost tourism with the amount of young people who are going there for the 3 months. Others are in Barcelona/ Lisbon etc. All be moving back soon hopefully as office's open up. I can't complain about it as l am sure l would have been very tempted as a young person to go after months working at the kitchen table. It probably kept some of the young people sane during the various lockdowns.
Permission from an employer isn’t generally enough to avoid tax issues. In fact I can’t think of any tax or employment law that can be superseded by employers permission.
lking679 · 08/08/2021 10:40

I’ve done a formal flexible working request to change my working pattern permanently to only coming into the office one day a week so we can move further away. If they accept it your employment t&c’s are updated. I’d never do it without that agreed first you could end up unemployed!
Employer fine with it as they’ve closed office space and not a desk for me anyway! 🙈

alltheemptyfields · 08/08/2021 10:40

Unless you are stuck with school-aged children, you would have been mad to stay put for more than a year if you had the opportunity to go elsewhere.

Selling your property being a step too far, but I don't know anyone who didn't make the most of the pandemic and went to holiday houses, with family, abroad. I don't think we have more than 2 people working from London this month.

What's the point of being a martyr and staying local?

SOME companies have sold their offices, for many, it IS permanent.

MadameOvary81 · 08/08/2021 10:37

@icedcoffees

Anyone who moved several hundreds of miles away due to a temporary WFH rule is an idiot.
We moved from the South East to the North West because we had no choice. Our landlord saw the mass exodus from London coming and when our contract needed renewed, he tried to up it from £1800 a month to £2400. The house re let the day after it went up on Rightmove!

Also, we have a house abroad that we used to live in. It was let but our tenant decided to stop paying at the beginning of the pandemic. We only just got him out this month and it's because we sold the house. We would have been bankrupt if we had stayed in the SE.

My partner is still attached to the office in the SE but we won't be going back...no matter the consequences.

lannistunut · 08/08/2021 10:34

I'm moving nearer to work due to wfh, because I want to be able to go in flexibly and not have to worry about any form of commute. That way I can go in for a morning meeting and then wfh for the afternoon if I choose to.

I do have colleagues who have made the opposite decision, some have moved quite a distance.

We are lucky to have a very flexible employer and a workforce where individuals can not be easily replaced due to the knowledge/experience they have being very specific.

sst1234 · 08/08/2021 10:32

@EileenGC

I know people who moved back home/to where their partner was living.

I know a couple of idiots who went on an ‘around the world’ trip, specifically to countries that didn’t have many restrictions in place and allowed them to escape this brainwashed society of sheep. Their words Grin First ones to come back and start moaning about masks, isolations and whatnot. ‘We’ve done none of that in a year’. Well, congratulations.

I have a friend who had to move back home to help care for her parents who got very ill last year.

Tax and online security-wise, you wouldn’t normally be able to work in another country for months on end. Obviously companies were more lenient due to the circumstances, but now if you want to keep your job you need to get back pronto. Which seems fair enough to me - unless your initial job agreement allowed for working abroad.

You sneer but they came back alive and well after having a great time and with better mental health than many at home so who’s the idiot?
SD1978 · 08/08/2021 10:32

I'm afraid I have little sympathy to people who without consultation with their employer, have assumed an ongoing WFH scenario and moved to a location which it is no longer tenable to attend the office/ the office that employs them. Tax would be the overseas issue as others have said.

MadameOvary81 · 08/08/2021 10:31

There are several people in my partner's company working abroad...two in Greece, and one in Italy, France and Spain. The two in Greece are actually Greek but the others are Brits in the their holiday homes. Hmm

I can't blame them though, the lockdowns have been miserable...i'd rather do them in the sun, too.

icedcoffees · 08/08/2021 10:30

Anyone who moved several hundreds of miles away due to a temporary WFH rule is an idiot.

MrsOvertonsWindow · 08/08/2021 10:25

I do wonder if there's a connection between wfh and the awful levels of customer service we're getting?
Every organisation I speak to you there's endless layers of "do you really need to speak to us? Covid... " messages, repeated endlessly. Understandable in the middle of the pandemic but why have businesses not resolved this by now? Ages to get through to First Direct followed by inexplicable errors at their end - a bank with normally impeccable customer service.
It seems routine that what would have been a 5 minute max phone call now turns into half an hour of listening to voicemail messages about they would rather you don't phone.

SmokeyDevil · 08/08/2021 10:15

I also think people tend to big up how successful WFH actually is for them. Honestly, I would be willing to say it isn’t is half as productive as a lot of people let on. It takes a particular type of person to maintain motivation in a home setting and honestly, most of us aren’t that type of person.

You are right, it's not for everyone. I love it, but some of my colleagues don't like it so much. I think people should get to decide where they work really. If you want to wfh from home, do so. If you want to work from the office, do so. But you can't just decide these things, you have to get permission from your employer.

AlfonsoTheMango · 08/08/2021 10:14

Another one with no sympathy.

We are returning to work on a hybrid basis starting next month. Some people who moved hours away from the hours during the pandemic are now asking what special provision will be made for them as they are no longer able to commute.