Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Employer asked staff not to work from abroad

259 replies

Cosmos123 · 08/08/2021 08:24

A memo came out with new wfh strategy.
Basically they have informed staff that the hybrid model will be used where staff do not need to meet with clients.
Also staff can be requested to return at short notice to the office.
Not sure that is great news for those who have relocated hundreds of miles away.
Also a brief note at the end that working permanently from abroad will not be allowed due to tax implications or summat.

Wonder who even moved abroad during the pandemic?
Anyways seems that Wfh remotely forever for those who wanted it won't be happening.

OP posts:
icedcoffees · 08/08/2021 12:54

This is quite lazy thinking. No one would be organising 50 people's amazon delivery and school things. People just declare they are wfh those days.

And that might work in your industry, but in many others it won't, which is why people are saying some people have unrealistic expectations.

What if everyone in one department "declares they're WFH" when the set-up requires a certain number of people to be in the office to deal with clients who come in to the business place, for example?

Hekatestorch · 08/08/2021 12:52

Good luck to a company having to organise meetings and other work needs around 50 people's Amazon deliveries, holiday plans and 'school things'.

This is quite lazy thinking. No one would be organising 50 people's amazon delivery and school things. People just declare they are wfh those days. Or in a lot of jobs, just mention they will be off line while at school. Because lots of us have jobs, where we have done this for years. In alot of jobs its possible.

IF and employer can offer flexible working, the main point being if

dreamingbohemian · 08/08/2021 12:51

@LIZS

Many companies have IT helpdesks based somewhere different to their offices or outsourced. Many IT issues can be resolved remotely or equipment couriered.
I work for a London uni that has outsourced most of IT to Cornwall. They're now thinking of doing the same with HR.

If it saves money while bringing good jobs to a region that needs them, I say why not.

Hekatestorch · 08/08/2021 12:49

@icedcoffees

Bit if they can, why not? Especially the school thing. Where possible if employers could accommodate people's lives more, not completely, but understand they have kids and lives outside work. Then give them a better balance, why not?

Because businesses are about making money, not accommodating school plays, Amazon deliveries and letting the builders in.

I mean, of course it would be nice if they could do those things, but they're under no obligation to and I do think some people have unrealistic expectations about those things.

I don't anyone is saying there is an obligation. As I said, if they can why not?
notimagain · 08/08/2021 12:48

I don't know why people fail to see the link between companies allowing totally flexible re: country and taking the risk on corporation tax etc., and outsourcing those jobs to cheaper labour pools abroad.

Agreed….

Yes, Some companies in the UK have tried this and found it didn’t work (I see usual reasons have been proffered such as accents, familiarity with the culture) but it sure as heck has been found to work for many non-contact roles in some very big companies and sometimes whole departments have been outsourced overseas in the search of employees with specific skills who will work for less than UK rates.

icedcoffees · 08/08/2021 12:47

Good luck to a company having to organise meetings and other work needs around 50 people's Amazon deliveries, holiday plans and 'school things'.

Exactly. It's all very well saying that companies should be flexible but accommodating the needs of everyone who wants to WFH on different days and at different times for different reasons is almost impossible.

IcedPurple · 08/08/2021 12:44

@Hekatestorch

I think if people expect the type of 'flexibility' that means employers have to accommodate everyone's Amazon deliveries, weekend breaks in Amsterdam, and little Johnny's 'school thing', they're going to be disappointed.

Bit if they can, why not? Especially the school thing. Where possible if employers could accommodate people's lives more, not completely, but understand they have kids and lives outside work. Then give them a better balance, why not?

You'd wonder how people ever survived a working day.

Good luck to a company having to organise meetings and other work needs around 50 people's Amazon deliveries, holiday plans and 'school things'.

icedcoffees · 08/08/2021 12:42

Bit if they can, why not? Especially the school thing. Where possible if employers could accommodate people's lives more, not completely, but understand they have kids and lives outside work. Then give them a better balance, why not?

Because businesses are about making money, not accommodating school plays, Amazon deliveries and letting the builders in.

I mean, of course it would be nice if they could do those things, but they're under no obligation to and I do think some people have unrealistic expectations about those things.

IcedPurple · 08/08/2021 12:41

[quote BrightYellowDaffodil]@IcedPurple Why? Flexible working means I can start early/finish early or vice versa. Or take a chunk out of the middle of the day and finish work off in the evening. Or can stop work for 10 minutes for a delivery and carry on working around it, rather than having to take off the entire day. Our managers have made it clear that they don’t mind when work gets done, as long as it does. And it clearly does because it would be obvious after 18 months if it wasn’t.

Good employers trust their staff and allow a degree of autonomy and flexibility.[/quote]
Well yes. But if say, a meething - whether in person or virtual - is scheduled for 4 on Tuesday, then the rest of the staff shouldn't have to work around someone's 'school thing'. And if your employer needs you to be in the office on Wednesday, then you shouldn't deman to WFH just because you're expecting your new shoes to be delivered that day.

There's flexibility, and then there is taking the piss.

Hekatestorch · 08/08/2021 12:37

I think if people expect the type of 'flexibility' that means employers have to accommodate everyone's Amazon deliveries, weekend breaks in Amsterdam, and little Johnny's 'school thing', they're going to be disappointed.

Bit if they can, why not? Especially the school thing. Where possible if employers could accommodate people's lives more, not completely, but understand they have kids and lives outside work. Then give them a better balance, why not?

HalzTangz · 08/08/2021 12:35

@Cosmos123

A memo came out with new wfh strategy. Basically they have informed staff that the hybrid model will be used where staff do not need to meet with clients. Also staff can be requested to return at short notice to the office. Not sure that is great news for those who have relocated hundreds of miles away. Also a brief note at the end that working permanently from abroad will not be allowed due to tax implications or summat.

Wonder who even moved abroad during the pandemic?
Anyways seems that Wfh remotely forever for those who wanted it won't be happening.

I think people that relocated miles away from the workplace are stupid. WFH was temporary guidance during a pandemic, not the green light to WFH on a permanent basis. Why did they think a temporary guidance was the green to WFH long-term/forever.

People were always going to have to go back to work, whether that be full time or hybrid. It's good that many companies have now embraced hybrid working.

Your company is correct re overseas working,their are tax complications with this.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 08/08/2021 12:35

@IcedPurple Why? Flexible working means I can start early/finish early or vice versa. Or take a chunk out of the middle of the day and finish work off in the evening. Or can stop work for 10 minutes for a delivery and carry on working around it, rather than having to take off the entire day. Our managers have made it clear that they don’t mind when work gets done, as long as it does. And it clearly does because it would be obvious after 18 months if it wasn’t.

Good employers trust their staff and allow a degree of autonomy and flexibility.

icedcoffees · 08/08/2021 12:33

People ahould be allowed office or hybrid working, inflexibility will cost companies good candidates whichever way they go.

All ways of working have their downsides. I don't think there are many industries where a culture of 100% WFH is a good idea, likewise where 100% office work is a good idea.

I do think most industries will go down the hybrid route, but moving 200+ miles away from your workplace when you don't have a contract that allows permanent WFH is daft whatever way you look at it.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 08/08/2021 12:31

People ahould be allowed office or hybrid working, inflexibility will cost companies good candidates whichever way they go.

Absolutely. I’ve known of several people now who have rejected jobs because there’s no WFH/hybrid/flexible working. It’s been a long time coming - the “home working revolution” has been touted since the 90s but never quite happened - but now the companies that can offer it but choose not to will not be the ones people generally want to work for.

In addition, flexible working opens up the pool of potential employees for the employer - we are in the south and one of our new people is up north. In the fullness of time I believe they’re going to do a set number of days a month, which presumably means they’ll stay in a hotel or something (which has got to be good for hotels, since general business travel has reduced and will probably remain so). We’d only have had relatively local candidates previously.

IcedPurple · 08/08/2021 12:31

At the very least, people now expect flexibility, even if it's only to be allowed to WFH when they expect a delivery (instead of taking a day off), wfh when the kids have some school thing and work later, stay home when they come back from holiday or plan to go on holiday that evening...

I think if people expect the type of 'flexibility' that means employers have to accommodate everyone's Amazon deliveries, weekend breaks in Amsterdam, and little Johnny's 'school thing', they're going to be disappointed.

icedcoffees · 08/08/2021 12:29

@alltheemptyfields

Exactly. Nobody is irreplaceable not even the ones who refuse to move with the time 🤷
WFH isn't necessarily "moving with the times" though. I see lots of people say that but they don't necessarily explain why it's such a forward way of doing things?

Yes, it's a great benefit to some people, but certainly not to everyone.

lannistunut · 08/08/2021 12:20

In my field interestingly one employer has opted for more office time. A lot of staff are now looking for alternatives, as they want the wfh model most are going with. This will be a factor.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 08/08/2021 12:10

[quote icedcoffees]@MadameOvary81 then you're very fortunate, but most people won't be in that kind of situation.

Those who don't embrace WFH and Hybrid working are going to lose a hell of a lot of staff to companies who do.

However I don't necessarily agree with this. Not everyone likes WFH and not everyone can sustain that lifestyle. WFH massively favours the wealthy as they're the ones who have study space, garden offices and who can't afford to build annexes and buy nice office equipment.

Many people have been working from their beds or crammed into a corner of the kitchen for 18+ months now. There have been numerous threads on here from people who are desperate for things to go back to normal and who can't wait to get back into the office.

I would also say that the people who love WFH and who rave about how good it is are the people above - who live in nice, spacious houses and who've saved thousands on season tickets each year as a result. But there have also been numerous threads on the other side - from managers who struggle to engage their team, from customers who are sick of dealing with workers who are working from home with screaming babies/barking dogs in the background etc.

WFH undoubtedly has it's benefits but I don't think it's always as amazing as some people try and make it out to be.[/quote]
I am aware of people refusing job offers after they found out company isn't sure about hybrid or olft office.

Ai agree with the previous statement. Many, many people welome hybri and it may become one of the reasons to pick particular company. People ahould be allowed office or hybrid working, inflexibility will cost companies good candidates whichever way they go.

lannistunut · 08/08/2021 12:06

@icedcoffees

To every person who says that their job is too specialised for that to happen to them, I urge them to think what the company would do if they resigned/went on mat leave/got sick. A company that is truly that dependent on named individuals is a high risk one.

Exactly. Nobody is irreplaceable.

Actors, journalists, academics, musicians, consultants, artists, trainers, health practitioners, some sales (requiring contacts) are all types of role where individuals can not be easily replaced as they are the only ones who have that particular portfolio of talent/knowledge/experience/certification.

Not everyone works in a standard company or a standard role.

Of course if someone leaves they get replaced, but that doesn't mean it makes good business sense for key staff to leave as the disruption is not good for business. In some sectors, if you lose your one person who does x, it can be months before you can offer that specific service again.

GertrudePerkinsPaperyThing · 08/08/2021 12:04

I’m a civil servant and no one is allowed to work from abroad. Which is fair enough!

I agree people who relocated because “oh we can work from home now” were stupid and short sighted. This was never intended to be forever - it’s a short term solution to a pandemic. Yes, maybe places will allow a few days from home - and a few may be permanently home working - but unless you were told taht specifically, no you don’t get to work your London / Birmingham/ Manchester job from Cornwall or the north of Scotland. And you want to keep your London weighting too, do you?

Our place of work put certain procedures in place to allow for wfh but they cost money. They’re not going to be in place forever just to allow wfh.

IcedPurple · 08/08/2021 12:03

Not sure that is great news for those who have relocated hundreds of miles away.

Relocating 'hundreds of miles away' due to an emergency situation is a pretty dumb move in fairness.

Unless their employer guaranteed them that they would never have to come back into the office again - and even then it's risky as companies go bust and people get made redunant and have to seek new jobs - then assuming they could WFH indefinitely was very presumptuous.

alltheemptyfields · 08/08/2021 11:57

Exactly. Nobody is irreplaceable
not even the ones who refuse to move with the time 🤷

alltheemptyfields · 08/08/2021 11:56

a lot of people actually don't want to work from home

there are actually very few jobs where you can WFH anyway.
It's hardly going to be a revolution. It's only a handful of office workers who are resistant to change and the modern world. People reacted the same way with computers, with internet... Grin

If I want to take my kids to something or need to stay home for some necessary, unreschedulable thing, I would book time off. If you're not working, it's not work time.
that's the point of FLEXIBLE time. If I had to go to the office, I'd have to book a day off. If I can just take the break I need and work around it, it's a normal day.

It's a stupid system if you have to treat staff like children and demand they are doing 9 to 6 on the dot (on roles where it's not needed, no one is expecting a teacher or store staff to turn up a 11am and work until 7pm instead...)
when it's a lot more productive and give a better quality of life to be treated like professional adults and give them flexibility.

NavigatingAdolescence · 08/08/2021 11:52

@MissyB1

One of our friends owns a second home in Italy and since the pandemic has been wfh there for about half the year. I wonder if that affects his tax or his employer’s.
Both.
Jourdain11 · 08/08/2021 11:43

On the flip side, a lot of people actually don't want to work from home.

If I want to take my kids to something or need to stay home for some necessary, unreschedulable thing, I would book time off. If you're not working, it's not work time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread