Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Employer asked staff not to work from abroad

259 replies

Cosmos123 · 08/08/2021 08:24

A memo came out with new wfh strategy.
Basically they have informed staff that the hybrid model will be used where staff do not need to meet with clients.
Also staff can be requested to return at short notice to the office.
Not sure that is great news for those who have relocated hundreds of miles away.
Also a brief note at the end that working permanently from abroad will not be allowed due to tax implications or summat.

Wonder who even moved abroad during the pandemic?
Anyways seems that Wfh remotely forever for those who wanted it won't be happening.

OP posts:
SchrodingersImmigrant · 08/08/2021 18:30

[quote BrightYellowDaffodil]@alltheemptyfields

I agree. I’ll admit to only reading the first article but I never understand why these articles are written as if women are passive and entirely without agency. Women have a choice to go to the office as much as men do, or to be as engaged as a man when working from home, or speak up in a meeting as a man would. It’s a choice. I’m a woman, and I’ve never encountered any of the issues the article references.[/quote]
Agreed!

NothingIsWrong · 08/08/2021 18:25

@Brainwave89

Yes, some people moved to family boltholes in France Tuscany and other locations and have been working quite happily (with great broadband) from there ever since. From a tax perspective this could get quite difficult. If you are working from say Italy, technically you should be paying Italian tax, and this is not only a problem for the individual, but also there employer. That being said, with a quick use of VPN, no one would really know [or in practice care that much?], so good luck to them all... and if I had the foresight I might have joined in.
It would be gross misconduct with immediate dismissal if I was found to be working abroad, and pretty easy to find out if someone called me on the phone. The ring tones are distinctive.
Lockdownbear · 08/08/2021 18:17

The other issue is people tax dodging in other countries. Effectively working without having a visa.

Think about it if it was the other way round, say French people working for a French company in the UK, using a French bank account, UK doesn't know what they are up to, what happens if they take ill, holiday insurance isnt going to cover the bills, NHS shouldn't foot it either, how are they getting back to France?

IcedPurple · 08/08/2021 17:57

@Brainwave89

Yes, some people moved to family boltholes in France Tuscany and other locations and have been working quite happily (with great broadband) from there ever since. From a tax perspective this could get quite difficult. If you are working from say Italy, technically you should be paying Italian tax, and this is not only a problem for the individual, but also there employer. That being said, with a quick use of VPN, no one would really know [or in practice care that much?], so good luck to them all... and if I had the foresight I might have joined in.
I think it's very risky to suggest someone use a VPN to deceive their employers - and by implication, HMRC and the authorities of the country you are resident in.

And I doubt that your employers wouldn't 'care that much'. I would say actively taking steps to work under false pretences could potentially be a sackable offence.

Brainwave89 · 08/08/2021 17:50

Yes, some people moved to family boltholes in France Tuscany and other locations and have been working quite happily (with great broadband) from there ever since. From a tax perspective this could get quite difficult. If you are working from say Italy, technically you should be paying Italian tax, and this is not only a problem for the individual, but also there employer. That being said, with a quick use of VPN, no one would really know [or in practice care that much?], so good luck to them all... and if I had the foresight I might have joined in.

furstivetreats · 08/08/2021 17:35

It's completely fair to disagree with me and the articles but I shared my opinion and backed it up. I hope I'm wrong, I've no desire to see women do any worse in the workplace (and I kind of feel like I need to underline this; what I think might happen and what I want to happen are most certainly not the same thing) but I'm interested to know why women have so much free choice and agency when it comes to wfh - do they have the same free choice and agency when not wfh?

BrightYellowDaffodil · 08/08/2021 17:05

@alltheemptyfields

I agree. I’ll admit to only reading the first article but I never understand why these articles are written as if women are passive and entirely without agency. Women have a choice to go to the office as much as men do, or to be as engaged as a man when working from home, or speak up in a meeting as a man would. It’s a choice. I’m a woman, and I’ve never encountered any of the issues the article references.

GCAcademic · 08/08/2021 16:32

I would argue that it's much easier for women to speak up in virtual meetings. Everyone puts their virtual hand up and waits their turn till the Chair gets to them. No more talking over people. Anyone who tries this can be muted. I prefer it.

alltheemptyfields · 08/08/2021 16:29

sorry but I find these articles so patronising and infuriating:

difficult for women to speak up in virtual meetings
Hmm

First, it’s crucial to avoid eclipsing women’s perspective by speaking on their behalf.
ahem, thanks?! Confused but that's speaking on women's behalf and treating us like children or second class citizens?

The whole thing would be funny if it wasn't hurting my teeth so much.

furstivetreats · 08/08/2021 15:56

@alltheemptyfields

I do worry about the long term impact on women. I think there will still be schmoozing in the office, after hours drinks etc and those who can't do it because of commitments requiring them to wfh will suffer.

again.. what difference does wfh makes? Presumably in your example the "women" rush home to deal with childcare, the after hours drink don't involve them anyway.

There are numerous articles about the issue, it's not something I came up with by myself.

hbr.org/2020/07/why-wfh-isnt-necessarily-good-for-women

www.businessbecause.com/news/insights/7539/working-from-home-impact-women

ShortBacknSides · 08/08/2021 15:53

Not sure that is great news for those who have relocated hundreds of miles away.

YABU

Anyone who did this in the light of the last 18 months only is daft. Of course working from home for many will eventually end. There are many advantages to having people present in-person in a workplace.

Even if there is a hybrid form - a mix of remote and in-person working, people need to take responsibility for making decisions about where they live and where they work.

Also a brief note at the end that working permanently from abroad will not be allowed due to tax implications or summat.

Yes that is so. It’s to do with “domicile “ for taxation purposes. Employers are very much within their rights to require employees to be domiciled in the UK. I think that there’s a maximum of 3 months abroad allowed each tax year.

furstivetreats · 08/08/2021 15:47

@alltheemptyfields

We haven't been able to contact payroll or other back office functions by phone since March 2020 which is unacceptable.

of course it's unacceptable.

Businesses (and my own employer) have been operating as normal since last .. April!

People have been on full pay, working as normal since the first lockdown. (many working a hell of a lot more efficiently, for various reasons).

Yes, we both agree it's unacceptable. I'm not really sure what the point of the post is, sorry. I've been in work throughout myself as I'm not in a back office function.
alltheemptyfields · 08/08/2021 15:31

We haven't been able to contact payroll or other back office functions by phone since March 2020 which is unacceptable.

of course it's unacceptable.

Businesses (and my own employer) have been operating as normal since last .. April!

People have been on full pay, working as normal since the first lockdown. (many working a hell of a lot more efficiently, for various reasons).

Bubbletiers · 08/08/2021 15:31

Sorry don’t know how to reply direct to “dream state”

Nietzschethehiker · 08/08/2021 15:30

It's certainly relevant in my industry I've had in the past several colleagues working in other countries. Many of whom were British trained (as the role requires UK specific qualifications) then relocated. Prior to Brexit this was fine. Our job has roles that can be delivered entirely online as long as there are some uk based staff to offset one or two tasks (which noone really minds and usually there are multitudes of uk based staff so in fairness it is a once or twice a year job for us) and actually the people that deliver well are hard to come by so its reasonable to assume your skillset is worth any inconvenience. I had heard of a few people who then moved to do this at varying points over the last year and a half but didn't consider Brexit.

I'm not in the know as to why this is an issue but I do know they have now been told similar. I am surprised people didn't check this before moving. Any I've heard of have moved to European countries so it seems a reasonable research bit to be done.

I find it slightly insane you wouldn't have this conversation with your employer well before moving and if they did surely this issue was discussed ? The only person I know who kept their job without having moved back was someone who has lived in Spain for about 5 years and is pretty much indispensable. Professionally she is definitely worth any form of change they need to make to accommodate her residency and in fairness they employed her on that basis.

Bubbletiers · 08/08/2021 15:29

Ah well I’m actually leaving London full stop. I don’t think I’m “one of those”. A mere observation that perhaps I should’ve made the move a while back and how it’s impacted me.

alltheemptyfields · 08/08/2021 15:27

I do worry about the long term impact on women. I think there will still be schmoozing in the office, after hours drinks etc and those who can't do it because of commitments requiring them to wfh will suffer.

again.. what difference does wfh makes? Presumably in your example the "women" rush home to deal with childcare, the after hours drink don't involve them anyway.

lannistunut · 08/08/2021 15:25

@icedcoffees

Bit if they can, why not? Especially the school thing. Where possible if employers could accommodate people's lives more, not completely, but understand they have kids and lives outside work. Then give them a better balance, why not?

Because businesses are about making money, not accommodating school plays, Amazon deliveries and letting the builders in.

I mean, of course it would be nice if they could do those things, but they're under no obligation to and I do think some people have unrealistic expectations about those things.

Not all work is in 'businesses'. Many people work in services or institutions.

Also, many businesses work effectively - and make more money - by operating flexibly.

We are not all employed in Manchester mills any more!

furstivetreats · 08/08/2021 15:18

@cinammonbuns

I’m most worried about the implications this will have on women with children who insist one flexibility to the point of disrupting business function. I cannot see many men declaring they will wfh because of a school thing and worry this will discourage hiring of women of child bearing age even more,
@cinammonbuns I agree with this. I do worry about the long term impact on women. I think there will still be schmoozing in the office, after hours drinks etc and those who can't do it because of commitments requiring them to wfh will suffer.

I don't, can't and wouldn't wfh but would absolutely add my voice to those saying part of the issue is the not knowing. We haven't been able to contact payroll or other back office functions by phone since March 2020 which is unacceptable. Yes, it's because of my company rather than wfh per se, but the end result is the same. If some long term decisions are made then hopefully either it will be a rota for people to be in the office so there is always someone on the phones, everyone back in the office all the time, or at least proper systems put in place to ensure we can actually get a prompt answer rather than waiting 4 or 5 days for an email.

YellowMonday · 08/08/2021 15:15

@ElephantOfRisk

Data protection laws are also involved and in financial services, regulators permission is required to process customer data off shore so would depend on what work is being done.
This is very significant. Pre-COVID, when managers received requests to live and work overseas, we could not approve as our IP and our/customer data could not go offshore full-time.

Work trips were ok as there was an approval and cyber review process. Only hard exclusion was China, big no to work/personal computer/phone going - temp versions required.

FinallyHere · 08/08/2021 15:12

Global corporate technology company, recruitment is now officially location blind.

Really good technical resources are very difficult to find, so the right people are welcome to be based wherever suits them.

It might not suit everyone, but it is entirely possible with the right will, with available resources and infrastructure.

101spacehoppers · 08/08/2021 15:00

In my line of work (I'm public sector at the moment but in the general area of my work) it's incredibly common to merge all sorts of working models- people are often based all over the place and with very niche skills that can't be replicated. Pre covid in my team we had 2x people on compressed with one wfh day (including the head of team), one commuting to London from Yorkshire and staying over 2 nights, one based fully at home overseas and one 4 days from home. Others mostly in but ad hoc home days. It's so easy to sort it out. Just agree a day when most people are generally around for all the team stuff, use a Teams invite as standard and behave like grown ups and show a bit of flexibility for big meetings and away days etc.

Totally understand that some jobs are much more difficult but if you don't trust your team to behave like adults you've got bigger problems.

BrightYellowDaffodil · 08/08/2021 15:00

Would you be happy if you had scheduled a meeting in the office with Darren, only to be told the day before that he'd got a great 50% off deal on Bosch wireless headphones, so would have to be at home when the delivery man knocked?

I cannot even begin to countenance a time when anyone would actually do that. If I want to be in for a delivery I would expect - and be expected - to arrange it around my existing diary commitments. To change something for personal reasons would be the exception rather than the rule.

Yes, there will always be people who take the piss, but it is up to good managers to manage and educate them in terms of what is acceptable.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 08/08/2021 14:51

It's not just londoners making house prices jump. Where I am rent and prices of apartments stagnated or even dropped, but houses risen as fast as Dracula woul out of his cofin if he smelled blood.
It's because people are looking for more space. While before they were happy in a city centre flat, after the lokdowns, many decided it's better to have won outside space. Also maybe a home office.

It's overal people move and change of priorities which made house prices jump, not just londoners moving, that's unfair on them.

Dreamstate · 08/08/2021 14:47

@Bubbletiers

I too selfishly hope people won’t all work long term from home. I’m hopelessly out priced and unable to rent or buy outside of London now because nothing is available. Lots of Londoners rented second homes or bought.

It means I’m struggling to even get a home even with funds in my account and a stable local job.

I get it was nice and a novelty for a while but it sucks for some of us. Rewind pre pandemic I could’ve had my handpick of country cottage rentals (long term) & could’ve bought a doer upper.

I have to say there have been plenty of threads where people outside of London always complain that noone cares about them, thst their property prices dont go up and there is little investment. That everything is London centric.

Now its shifting and prices are going up the complaining hasn't stopped its now switched to csnt wait for londonderry to go back so I can afford to buy, those londonders coming here pushing up prices

Cant win can they. Make your mind up what you want

Swipe left for the next trending thread