Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Employer asked staff not to work from abroad

259 replies

Cosmos123 · 08/08/2021 08:24

A memo came out with new wfh strategy.
Basically they have informed staff that the hybrid model will be used where staff do not need to meet with clients.
Also staff can be requested to return at short notice to the office.
Not sure that is great news for those who have relocated hundreds of miles away.
Also a brief note at the end that working permanently from abroad will not be allowed due to tax implications or summat.

Wonder who even moved abroad during the pandemic?
Anyways seems that Wfh remotely forever for those who wanted it won't be happening.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Northernlass99 · 11/08/2021 13:45

My whole organisation has been WFH for 18 months now and I have never worked so hard! They have an ethos of being 'unbossed' so everyone takes responsibility for their work and just gets it done. Doesn't really matter if you start at 6am and finish early, or take a break in the middle of the day for kids and then work to midnight. However if there is an important online meeting at midday we will all be there, if you need to meet a deadline we will meet it, and take some Flexi another day when it is less pressured. It works brilliantly because everyone trusts each other and we are part of a team so don't want to let anyone else down.

However we will need to come into the office periodically from September for a mixed model, so anyone who moved away was silly and will need to move back. We are not allowed to work from abroad either, and if someone has London weighting they will be expected to be in the office 2 or 3 days per week going forward. But that will work fine too. Just mark in your diary the days you are wfh and those you are in the office. If there is a team meeting that's your office day and you rearrange personal affairs. All our phones divert to mobiles or VOIP anyway so no problem. Its all to do with trust. If you have good managers and good relationships, with people who are kept keen and motivated there is no problem. But I work in healthcare and everyone is pretty motivated to do a good job.

Justanotherlurker · 10/08/2021 21:55

@Devondonkey

I'm in Devon (yes, my name) and I've met a few people who moved down here to wfh and are now being told by their employer that they have to be in office at short notice whenever they need them. Which completely shafts them (which I suspect is employer's aim) as having to bomb to London randomly when you have small children is a nightmare. I suspect they'll have sold up within a year. Or been sacked and be embracing the West Country's job market which is going to be rather a painful moment for them.
My multi national employer has done the same, there was a mass exodus of people out to the countryside across its offices thinking that WFH would become the norm or that they had some special inate quality that thier job was not replacable.

In my team I know I can already recruit in their new local area for a lot cheaper than they are currently on, with just as much technical knowledge and aren't trying to dictate what days they can come into the office already.

There has been a lot of people who jumped feet first into a situation where they thought they held the cards, it is going to be washed out slowly but the restructure of WFH is not going to be as rosey as some predict it will.

Devondonkey · 10/08/2021 21:36

@icedpurple No, I agree with you re moving hundreds of miles and expecting it all to be dandy. I just mean that telling people they need to come into the office when required is quite an effective way of managing the situation without confrontation. Because you can't really insist on not coming to the office, but they can then turn the screws as and when they want to.

IcedPurple · 10/08/2021 15:18

@Devondonkey

I'm in Devon (yes, my name) and I've met a few people who moved down here to wfh and are now being told by their employer that they have to be in office at short notice whenever they need them. Which completely shafts them (which I suspect is employer's aim) as having to bomb to London randomly when you have small children is a nightmare. I suspect they'll have sold up within a year. Or been sacked and be embracing the West Country's job market which is going to be rather a painful moment for them.
Why do you think it's the employer's aim to 'shaft' them?

They chose to move hundreds of miles away from their place of employment, didn't they? The childcare issues brought about by this choice are hardly their employer's concern.

Devondonkey · 10/08/2021 14:16

I'm in Devon (yes, my name) and I've met a few people who moved down here to wfh and are now being told by their employer that they have to be in office at short notice whenever they need them. Which completely shafts them (which I suspect is employer's aim) as having to bomb to London randomly when you have small children is a nightmare. I suspect they'll have sold up within a year. Or been sacked and be embracing the West Country's job market which is going to be rather a painful moment for them.

timeisnotaline · 10/08/2021 13:36

[quote igelkott2021]Legislation around taxation, GDPR, health & safety and more besides, has little to do with how much you 'value' your employee

Well clearly it does, because some employers make it work, and the same laws apply to everyone (other than a bit of sectoral regulation). For example, Ocado: www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-58143560[/quote]
You can hardly relocate to another country if you are only allowed to work overseas for a max of one month per year.
My company has introduced the same 30 day rule.

furstivetreats · 10/08/2021 08:21

I don't have my gander up, I was merely responding in kind.

C8H10N4O2 · 10/08/2021 07:31

since I was posting specifically about my experience, in my company, in my industry, I didn't think it was necessary to discuss other experiences in other companies who are not in my industry.

No need to get your gander up. It wasn't clear from that post that you were continuing to speak specifically about your company.

Do you really think that everyone can work from home?

Feel free to point to where I said this was the case.

IcedPurple · 09/08/2021 16:07

[quote igelkott2021]Legislation around taxation, GDPR, health & safety and more besides, has little to do with how much you 'value' your employee

Well clearly it does, because some employers make it work, and the same laws apply to everyone (other than a bit of sectoral regulation). For example, Ocado: www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-58143560[/quote]
For one whole month a year.

KatherineJaneway · 09/08/2021 15:39

Well clearly it does, because some employers make it work, and the same laws apply to everyone (other than a bit of sectoral regulation). For example, Ocado: www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-58143560

That's for a maximum of one month per year though.

furstivetreats · 09/08/2021 11:56

@C8H10N4O2

Yes, we both agree it's unacceptable. I'm not really sure what the point of the post is, sorry. I've been in work throughout myself as I'm not in a back office function

What does back office have to do with it? Do you really think its only back office functions who have been working remotely?

What I've found fascinating over the past year or so as our clients have jumped or been dragged into more digital working is that it does expose poor managers. I don't see that as a bad thing frankly.

@C8H10N4O2 yes, I can confidently tell you that in my company, the company I was posting about, which was abundantly clear in my original post, it is only back office functions working from home since it is utterly impossible for those of us on the front line to work from home. I'm not stupid enough to think that this is the same in all companies/industries but since I was posting specifically about my experience, in my company, in my industry, I didn't think it was necessary to discuss other experiences in other companies who are not in my industry. Do you really think that everyone can work from home?
igelkott2021 · 09/08/2021 11:27

Legislation around taxation, GDPR, health & safety and more besides, has little to do with how much you 'value' your employee

Well clearly it does, because some employers make it work, and the same laws apply to everyone (other than a bit of sectoral regulation). For example, Ocado: www.bbc.co.uk/news/business-58143560

C8H10N4O2 · 09/08/2021 09:22

So, to answer your question- plenty of us are more than capable of doing what you’ve suggested. Unfortunately the workplace is full of people who couldn’t give a fuck how their selfishness impacts others and so why would they care about important meetings and the like? They only care for themselves. Without any rules they’d do less than they do right now

If the workplace is full of lazy Pauls in a country where employment protection is bare minimum then your problem is either:

  • lousy management skills
  • low pay
  • both of the above.

Yes every workforce might have the odd lead swinger but I've never been to a client where this is genuinely true of the majority of the staff.

C8H10N4O2 · 09/08/2021 09:20

@EBearhug

I would argue that it's much easier for women to speak up in virtual meetings. Everyone puts their virtual hand up and waits their turn till the Chair gets to them. No more talking over people. Anyone who tries this can be muted

I think this is very dependent on how could the meeting chair is. Some of them are nothing like this competent at managing whichever video conferencing platform is in use.

Completely agree with this and tbh its not even about technical competence (can assign someone to manage that within the meeting).

Its core meeting management skills and the fact that so few people don't know the difference between running a meeting and having a group chat.

IcedPurple · 09/08/2021 09:19

Any single employer is clearly free to make whatever rules they choose.

Only within the laws of Britain and the country of the employee's residence, which can be very complex. They can't just make up 'rules' to suit themselves.

C8H10N4O2 · 09/08/2021 09:18

Yes, we both agree it's unacceptable. I'm not really sure what the point of the post is, sorry. I've been in work throughout myself as I'm not in a back office function

What does back office have to do with it? Do you really think its only back office functions who have been working remotely?

What I've found fascinating over the past year or so as our clients have jumped or been dragged into more digital working is that it does expose poor managers. I don't see that as a bad thing frankly.

FinallyHere · 09/08/2021 08:47

It's idiotic to move abroad without proper research.

It's also true that many people can and do now work across borders, perfectly legally and fulfilling their obligations in each territory. Pretty much each case can be different, so that finding out the specifics in order to make sure they are addressed is the way forward.

Any single employer is clearly free to make whatever rules they choose.

Those already having trouble recruiting specialist staff have found cross border working to be a useful way to attract and keep good people.

SchrodingersImmigrant · 09/08/2021 07:36

You would think it's early days to police it, but since uk has already made news with detaining eu citizens, the countries might well just get on woth it.

It's idiotic to move abroad without proper research.

notimagain · 09/08/2021 07:29

What amazes me about people working in Spain and Italy in their holiday homes is that if they are a British passport holder since Brexit they have no legal right to do that without a visa, and the can only stay for 90/180 days.

It’s early days in the policing of the 90/180 requirement and Covid has complicated matters but there are signs that it is now being more actively monitored..

As DerAlteMann says the tax and social charges can be eye watering in places like France, any income at all earned whilst in country, even if “just” working at a keyboard in your holiday home for a UK company should be declared to the local authorities and the penalties for non-declaration can be stiff to say the least.

Anyone planning on such an arrangement really needs to take professional advice.

DerAlteMann · 09/08/2021 03:35

The tax, and more particularly social security contribution positions (esp. in France), if UK employees are working overseas can be horrifically complex (& expensive).

Newyorkhereicome · 09/08/2021 00:46

What amazes me about people working in Spain and Italy in their holiday homes is that if they are a British passport holder since Brexit they have no legal right to do that without a visa, and the can only stay for 90/180 days. I work for an investment bank in the city with a lot of European employees so they have agreed that people can work up to 20 days in a European country a year BUT you have to inform HR and also prove you have the legal right to work there. A lot of these people will have more than tax issues to worry about if the overstay in the Schengen Area are the can be fined and banned when they do exit.

notimagain · 09/08/2021 00:10

But that's splitting your work between countries and France was your place of prime residence and probably as part of the EU and freedom to work anywhere. I'd assume it would be more difficult to do that now as the UK is no longer part of the EU.

I suspect you are right - splitting your work legitimately between the UK and an EU country would certainly be more difficult for those who haven’t already established residency in the EU.

Lockdownbear · 08/08/2021 23:59

FWIW for many years I was legally working in the UK, living in France, paying French tax …andUK tax, and UK NI…but FWIW no NHS care whilst in the UK whilst working ( because of residency).

But that's splitting your work between countries and France was your place of prime residence and probably as part of the EU and freedom to work anywhere.

I'd assume it would be more difficult to do that now as the UK is no longer part of the EU.

It certainly seems like something that needs to be thought through before people do it.

notimagain · 08/08/2021 23:19

But would they be legally working and living in the UK if they were employed as living in France and paying Franch tax.
Rather than paying UK tax and national insurance tax.

Stranger things can happen and can be legit…

FWIW for many years I was legally working in the UK, living in France, paying French tax …and UK tax, and UK NI…but FWIW no NHS care whilst in the UK whilst working ( because of residency).

Foolsrule · 08/08/2021 23:02

And before anyone jumps on and talks about money saved on commuting etc, what about those of us who are not saving on commuting (walked/cycled to work) but now have a permanent office space in half of the living room? Yes, actually now living at work. I do resent the fact that I work to pay a mortgage, that then offers my employers so many square feet of real estate…