Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask why you haven't/won't have the covid vaccine?

338 replies

shuz1980 · 07/08/2021 22:21

Is it because your an anti vaxxer? Concerned about long term side effects?

OP posts:
Thewinterofdiscontent · 08/08/2021 16:18

I know of a few who won’t get the vaccination.
One because she’s in a low risk area ( very rural) and didn’t see the need. I have a few extended family members who have had it and think anti bodies suffice.
I also have some family that just refuse because anything “the herd” is doing is probably the wrong thing.

I think it’s personal choice and the whole for the greater good thing gets on my nerves. The vaccine clearly doesn’t stop people catching it, there’s new variations all the time and people up to 40 barely know they have it anyway.
I’ve been jabbed for my sins but not bothered about those that haven’t.

DoubleTweenQueen · 08/08/2021 16:15

@Dayofpeace The paper you've cited does contain a great deal of interesting hypothesis, but light on specific evidence that any of the issues suggested may, or have been, of issue.

There is a great deal of real data out there which does counter suggested issues, already taking into account the following:

Development of vaccines and supporting models

Study of the natural disease and any evidence of ADE within patients and/or patients who have been treated with antibodies naturally produced in covid-survivors

Titre of vaccine material
Site of administration
Half-life of material and systemic distribution (regarding spike protein)

Physiological and immunological contraindications

No-one is suggesting that study and caution should not be exercised, but the area is extremely well placed for scrutiny.

Any caution should be balanced, as should any argument for or against.

We are all likely to be exposed to Sars-2 as time goes on. If it doesn’t kill us, we will have elicited an immune response to viral proteins expressed through infection. I would prefer my body to have a head start.

The necessity and/or ethics of immunising the young is another issue.

It is arrogance to perpetuate the contents of that paper as anything other than hypothesis, and some conjecture. That’s not science and medicine on the ground, IMO.

Dayofpeace · 08/08/2021 16:05

@mummyford

I think all discoveries have been based on speculative hypotheses. That is the nature of scientific enquiry. But there are reasons to investigate further. It is not wild speculation.

I don’t see the need to argue against a call for more research before rolling out a new biotechnology to populations of young people and children.

I believe in the principle of informed consent. Consent cannot be informed if the questions are stifled and the data is not present.

Dayofpeace · 08/08/2021 15:58

@mummyford

I’m aware of the Reuters article. It means nothing that potential risks are dismissed by vested interests even in the absence of long term safety data.

In fact, it rather reinforces the point that we should investigate any and all potential issues, not suppress them out of hand.

We should be led by the data, not by pre-formed opinion in the absence of specific research.

jackstini · 08/08/2021 15:54

I am double vaccinated as are most people I know

The 2 reasons 2 friends have given for not having it were:

1 - It's too new - they had not realised it was based on a SARS vaccine that is years old and are now considering it

2 - they had Covid very early on and believe that they now have antibodies that offer the same protection as the vaccine. They don't - the antibodies will be greatly reduced after 18 months and won't protect against new variants. It's their decision but seems flawed and I & the rest of our friendship group won't be spending time with them now we know this - freedom of choice works both ways

Dayofpeace · 08/08/2021 15:45

[quote Incywincyspiderspleasegoaway]@Dayofpeace it's not spin but their titles on the article, albeit I'm sure they do have wider qualifications. The body of works that they cite aren't specifically about what they are hypothesising, of course, so the qualifier others doesn't add a huge amount of credence in that respect albeit they are basing various things on some facts.[/quote]
@Incywincyspiderspleasegoaway

I think it is your spin. You thought it would undermine credibility of the article to just use those two descriptors with no acknowledgement of their qualifications and experience or the work they draw on. Otherwise why mention it?

The fact is that the authors point to risks with the mRNA vaccines that have not yet been confirmed one way or another.
They call for more research into those risks.
Who can possibly suggest that is the wrong thing to do?

RampantIvy · 08/08/2021 15:34

@SupermanWithTheGreyHair

I don’t agree with it being tested on animals so haven’t had it. When they create a vaccine that’s cruelty free, I’ll be first in the queue.
I think you will find that most if not all vaccines and medication will have been developed using animal products/testing at some point in their development.

What will you do if you become insulin dependent diabetic? When insulin was first developed they used insulin from pigs and dogs. The vaccines made by Pfizer/BioNTech, Oxford/AstraZeneca and Moderna do not contain any animal-derived ingredients, nor does modern insulin, but animal-derived materials may have been used in the production processes for the covid vaccine, and definitely for insulin.

Incywincyspiderspleasegoaway · 08/08/2021 15:32

@Dayofpeace it's not spin but their titles on the article, albeit I'm sure they do have wider qualifications. The body of works that they cite aren't specifically about what they are hypothesising, of course, so the qualifier others doesn't add a huge amount of credence in that respect albeit they are basing various things on some facts.

rakali · 08/08/2021 15:28

@iloveicelollies
The vaccine issue is so divisive. Hate it.
I agree, I do too. Whenever I see discussion shut down or people choosing not to get one vaccine being labelled antivaxxers, it just makes me more anxious about ever getting it.

RampantIvy · 08/08/2021 15:27

I know 4 people who have had the vaccine and still got covid and i thought the whole point of the vaccine was that you couldn't get it after the vaccine so im struggling to see the point

The whole point of getting the vaccine is to reduce the risk, not eliminate it entirely. Information about the vaccine not being 100% effective has always been available. The majority of patients in ICU are unvaccinated.

the NHS does not do "annual bloods" though does it?

They do regular “MOT’s” though @Xenia. I think it is every 5 years, although I am happy to be corrected. They check bloods, blood pressure BMI, ask how much alcohol you drink and how much exercise you do, etc and then tell you what your stroke/heart attack/diabetes risk is. We get contacted by our GP about every 5 years. This happens once you reach 50 (I think)

WFU = work from home @SaharaFlower. Apologies for using an acronym.

No guideline anywhere says the unvaccinated have to take extra measures over people who are vaccinated

I know that, but these are general guidelines for everyone. A PP said that they know some vaccinated people who seem to think they are bullet proof, so I wondered if unvaccinated people were throwing caution to the wind or still being careful.

Where are these mysterious GPs?

Mine’s in South Yorkshire @Tinpotspectator. It is a large rural practice. They have probably suspended these health checks during the pandemic though.

Dayofpeace · 08/08/2021 15:26

[quote Incywincyspiderspleasegoaway]@Dayofpeace I agree with you there should be no censorship and plenty of discussion, although it is critical that it is factually accurate. The names you mention though (including the naturopath and computer scientist who wrote the article you linked to) have all been received critically though in respect of misinformation. I'm not sure how strong that case is for Dr Robert Malone, although I don't think he invented the mRNA vaccine as such. He and his wife have had the Moderna vaccination but he raises questions about benefit v risk in children and very young adults.[/quote]
@Incywincyspiderspleasegoaway

I agree it is critical that information is factual & accurate. Certainty in this regard can only be reached through research, analysis, and time.

If potential risks are “received critically” instead of properly investigated, I think that is a bias and censorship issue.

Robert Malone is indeed vaccinated. The risk / reward for him seemed appropriate. This will be true for many. For others it is likely not to be. However, these sensible, cautious views are being suppressed.

I understand that since Robert Malone made his views clear, there were subsequent attempts to discredit him and try to minimise his role in mRNA invention.

Re: the author of the linked article being “a naturopath & computer scientist”, this is your spin. Their experience and quals are much broader than your description would suggest, plus they reference a wide body of works by qualified others.
I did already say when I provided the link that it was generalist overview. There are many more specific pieces of work but to start to reference them all is too much here.

rakali · 08/08/2021 15:19

@XenoBitch

Are the unvaccinated still following other guidelines to reduce the risks - WFH, shopping online, avoiding crowded places etc?

No guideline anywhere says the unvaccinated have to take extra measures over people who are vaccinated, so no, I am not (although WFH is irrelevant to me and I avoid crowds due to anxiety not Covid).

Same. Hate crowds and I can't WFH, I've gone out to work throughout.
MarchSurprise · 08/08/2021 15:07

I don't feel there has been enough research into the vaccine to know it is safe, or that there won't be side effects in years to come. People act like this is a ridiculous belief, but why don't they know how long it lasts for and when boosters will be needed, if they've done enough research? I will have the vaccine if still needed once I am confident they have enough info.

I also feel that vaccinated have a potential to become the superspreaders if they can pass it on still but not have symptoms. If they are less likely to have symptoms, and can get into places without a test, then they have a good chance of having it and passing it on. Atleast unvaccinated will likely have a recent clear test, and are more conscious of their symptoms.

Thirdly, I think the reason a lot of people are so awful towards the unvaccinated is because they are worried about their choice to have the vaccine and would rather we all sunk together if it turns out there are long term effects to the vaccine.

It may sound far fetched, but that's my current take on it. I am not an antivaxxer, I have confidence in all other vaccines given, but I will not be pushed into something I am not sure about. I am taking more precautions than most, for example, I am not going out to pubs/restaurants/shops and for the rare time I do need to pop into the supermarket, I wear a mask and still social distance.

iloveicelollies · 08/08/2021 15:02

Also, he mistrusts the quickest vaccine. Wholeheartedly believes that this won't be the best one we will get against covid and that it will be a learning curve. Hence why he thinks more patience was required in terms of vaccinating absolutely everyone. He does think it's done wonders for elderly and vulnerable but is now worried immunity for likes of his father and mine is waning when we are coming up to the season when it all kicks off again. He is very careful and respectful of rules and hygiene.

iloveicelollies · 08/08/2021 15:00

My husband is not getting it yet as he has a lot of worries about mRNA and long term side effects. He's not anti vacc and was very pro the elderly and vulnerable having the vaccines as said benefits outweigh risks for them. Where he doubts it is younger healthier people being made to have it and has suspicions about the coercion tactics that have started to get younger people to take it. He also doesn't trust the governments of Uk, America and Europe who are pushing it the most. He also thinks after vaccinating the vulnerable and elderly here we should be pausing our programme to vaccinate those groups in rest of world. He doesn't feel at risk for covid. Healthy, 30s, non smoker, barely drinks, does lot of sport. I think it's a lottery and wish he would get vaccinated to protect himself. But can't push him on it. He's agreed to get novavax if it's ever approved as he's read a lot of good stuff about it. He's from Ireland and it's likely to be approved there before here so he'd probably drive over there to get it instead of remaining unvaccinated. I'm vaccinated by the way and he didn't try to talk me out of it at all. I think if we have choice of vaccinating our 9 and 7 year olds we will have a big row though. Unless it's Novavax. I think you're reasonable to ask as long as not rude about what you hear back. The vaccine issue is so divisive. Hate it.

Tinpotspectator · 08/08/2021 14:57

Where are these mysterious GPs?

Incywincyspiderspleasegoaway · 08/08/2021 14:56

@Dayofpeace I agree with you there should be no censorship and plenty of discussion, although it is critical that it is factually accurate. The names you mention though (including the naturopath and computer scientist who wrote the article you linked to) have all been received critically though in respect of misinformation. I'm not sure how strong that case is for Dr Robert Malone, although I don't think he invented the mRNA vaccine as such. He and his wife have had the Moderna vaccination but he raises questions about benefit v risk in children and very young adults.

Chippingbird23 · 08/08/2021 14:54

@CityCommuter

We know of a GP who decided not to get the jab. His explanation is 'personal choice'... he's not actually vaccinating anyone at his practice so his patients have to go elsewhere. He maintains that he's 'not going to inject a patient with something that he wouldn't inject in himself'! Can't believe he still has his job tbh with that attitude but he would be described as very eccentric even Pre-Covid...
Actually he is right isn’t he?! We don’t know what’s in it and it’s the quickest vaccine made in history and time will tell what it really does for long term effects. Unvaccinated from covid and proud here.

Yes that’s right I’ve had other vaccines and not anti vaccine and no amount of propaganda ooh an anti vaccier died and he had covid and hiding the fact people are dying from the vaccine itself and the nasty effects on many. Yes some GP are speaking out against this absurd medically tyranny and a vaccine that no one really knows what will happen long term to anyone.

XenoBitch · 08/08/2021 14:47

Are the unvaccinated still following other guidelines to reduce the risks - WFH, shopping online, avoiding crowded places etc?

No guideline anywhere says the unvaccinated have to take extra measures over people who are vaccinated, so no, I am not (although WFH is irrelevant to me and I avoid crowds due to anxiety not Covid).

rakali · 08/08/2021 14:46

I haven't had it due to anxiety. I am not an antivaxxer. I have had every other vaccine offered to me, as has my child.

SaharaFlower · 08/08/2021 14:43

"Are the unvaccinated still following other guidelines to reduce the risks - WFH, shopping online, avoiding crowded places etc?"

When I need something, I go to the shop. I don't know what WFH is. No crowded places, unless there isn't a choice.

Parker231 · 08/08/2021 14:40

@topwings @Xenia. My GP does five year check ups including bloods and then a follow up to discuss any medication needed or changes to diet. The nurse at the GP’s also do the three yearly smears

GalesThisMorning · 08/08/2021 14:39

Apologies @Nightgardenisodd, if I did read it I dont remember your circumstances. I hope that enough people will get vaccinated so that the world becomes safer for people like you who are medically unable to do so. I'm sure you are aware that you can travel to the UK whilst unvaccinated, and quarantine after arrival. Personally I wouldn't have wanted to travel unvaccinated however so I can understand not wanting to do so

Nightgardenisodd · 08/08/2021 14:25

@GalesThisMorning Did you read my previous post on this thread? There are medical reasons and I would love nothing more for them not to be. If they only allow vaccinated people, I’ll never be able to return to my home country again, is that fair?

Xenia · 08/08/2021 14:25

topwings, one reason our NHS is cheap and we do not overly medicate is because of lack of money and we do not over medicalise. People do not get an annual health check of any kind at all. There is no need for one anyway for most people.

Swipe left for the next trending thread