Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think one adult should be able to support a family with a full time job?

265 replies

Kendodd · 07/08/2021 22:04

Talking about a normal size family, two/three children. Not talking about riches either, just an ordinary place to live and everyone well fed and clothed, all needs covered without state benefits. Any full time job as well, not just some fancy high paid thing.
I know for lots of people working really hard in full time jobs supporting their family just isn't possible on the money.

YANBU - they should be able to support a family.
YABU - they shouldn't be able to have a home and children on an unskilled job.

OP posts:
mrsm43s · 07/08/2021 23:26

I think that minimum wage is exactly that, the minimum.

I think that every able adult should expect to work full time, and take responsibility to support themselves, and pay towards their dependants.

I think that if you want more than the minimum of food/clothes/roof over your head, then you should work up from earning minimum wage.

I think two people, both hard working, 5+ years into their careers, with the associated payrises that come from 5 years of hard graft and promotions/taking on additional responsibilities should be able to afford to support a family. In my experience, they can, often with one able to go part time for a few years.

ancientgran · 07/08/2021 23:20

@Howshouldibehave

In the 1970s maybe but not any more!

It’s pointless saying that ‘should’ happen when for the majority it doesn’t and won’t ever.

I was a young mum in the 70s with a mortgage on 15% I think and we couldn't live on one wage. We had two wages and still didn't have a car or a phone, if we were lucky we had a holiday for a week in a relatives caravan.
AngeloMysterioso · 07/08/2021 23:20

Should- yeah, sure. In an ideal world.

Can- ha! Nope. DH earns over £50k and all we could afford with him as the sole earner in the south east was a small 2 bedroom flat. I’m now re-training for a career change because we’re soon to be a family of 4 and there’s no way we’ll be able to afford a decent sized home with me as a SAHM.

TheHateIsNotGood · 07/08/2021 23:20

Also very much agree with stanley - let's say 2 people working 25hrs each = a F/T job with a bit of overtime and 2 happier, less stressed people.

And I say that as a long-term single parent - it might not apply to me but I'm happy to support the idea for 2-arent families, which is the norm after all.

DespairingHomeowner · 07/08/2021 23:17

@SapphosRock

YANBU but unfortunately YANB realistic.

If the family lives in the south rent for a 3 bed house will be at least £1,500 per month + bills. Food, clothes etc for a family of four at least another £500. Then there are holidays, school trips, birthday presents, petrol, MOTs, fixing broken washing machines etc etc.

The single adult would have to earn at least £40k for the family to scrape by, more like £60k+ for the family to live comfortably.

In London, add 20k to that at least to not be stressed about money - and that’s without childcare costs, private schools etc

Family I know on 60k in a modest area are ALWAYS stressed about money despite managing it well: 1 car, camping holidays, no debt, v few frills

I think people underestimate how expensive housing in London is, and how salaries for most really don’t cover the gap. In my field, salaries have stayed the same for last ten years or so, while cost of living & housing esp relentlessly move up!

atlastifoundit · 07/08/2021 23:14

@Kendodd

Talking about a normal size family, two/three children. Not talking about riches either, just an ordinary place to live and everyone well fed and clothed, all needs covered without state benefits. Any full time job as well, not just some fancy high paid thing. I know for lots of people working really hard in full time jobs supporting their family just isn't possible on the money.

YANBU - they should be able to support a family.
YABU - they shouldn't be able to have a home and children on an unskilled job.

It used to be perfectly possible a few decades ago when there were millions of council houses, and most people rented at a reasonable price.

Can't think what went wrong there...

TheHateIsNotGood · 07/08/2021 23:14

I agree with you OP - as a lifelong female 'rights' protagonist who spent many, possibly wasted, decades doing equality rather than theorizing or running to HR with my latest 'grief'.

It used to be the norm for years that a 'man' could support his family as long as he stayed 'in work'; if the lady of the house earned a bit of'pin money' that was good too.

Whilst not ideal if you're a woman, seems that scenario is virtually non-existent now, so either both mother and father run themselves ragged paying the household bills or the father might still have the mindset that all things domestic are woman's responsibility, so she's run even more ragged than ever....progress eh...

Monkeybusinesss · 07/08/2021 23:13

@19lottie82
You do realise that so few poor people actually do that don’t you?

XenoBitch · 07/08/2021 23:13

@Stanleyville

Rather than one person work and one person not why don't we aspire to all people working fewer hours? That's potentially good for all of society.

I don't think a sahp dynamic is particularly healthy when compared to an alternative of both parents caring and earning.

Not everyone is capable of working. Some couples consist of one partner working full time because the other has an illness/disability.
Fizbosshoes · 07/08/2021 23:11

My DPs bought their house in the 1980s.my Dad had a v average wage, they had 1 car and my mum was a SAHM. Today semi detached houses in the same road (london suburbia - not particularly exclusive or sought after area) are £600k +
That's 20 x the average wage - no amount of skimping on tech, cutting out coffees or giving up smashed avocado is going to change that.

LolaSmiles · 07/08/2021 23:10

Rather than one person work and one person not why don't we aspire to all people working fewer hours? That's potentially good for all of society.

I don't think a sahp dynamic is particularly healthy when compared to an alternative of both parents caring and earning.
Good point. Women would keep more financial independence and it would also elevate the status of domestic and family duties because for some reason when men do something it's valuable.

Anxietyandwine · 07/08/2021 23:09

We live in an okay part of a larger - niceish area. 2 adults and 2 kids. DH works FT as a general manager for a well known electrical store on an ok wage (28k ish).

I resigned after my mat leave when baby 2 was turning 1.

We currently receive around £600-900 a month in universal credit and would not be able to feed our kids without it. (If I went back to work I’d be working to pay nursery fees as were not entitled to any free hours!)

Our rent is £950 a month for a normal sized 3 bed semi and we need 2 cars as school is 20 min drive away.

System is broken. We’ll never afford to buy and I can’t afford to work til we get some nursery funding.

Stanleyville · 07/08/2021 23:05

Rather than one person work and one person not why don't we aspire to all people working fewer hours? That's potentially good for all of society.

I don't think a sahp dynamic is particularly healthy when compared to an alternative of both parents caring and earning.

19lottie82 · 07/08/2021 23:05

You can’t buy an old car now, the huge associated costs/green taxes make it nigh on impossible

Nonsense 😂

You think a phone and a car isn’t essential for most people?

No, but a £75 a month contract phone and a £400 pm PCP deal are not, and plenty of people have these despite not being able to afford them.

entropynow · 07/08/2021 23:04

@MauveMagnolia

My house cost £6000 in 1970. It was bought by a male teacher and his housewife, wife. A male teacher earned about £1600 (women earned less)

It was sold in 2006 for £570,000. A teacher earned £29,500

Today it is a million. A teacher earns £35,000

One of the by products of most families having 2 working adults is house price inflation.

Only partly is it due to dual income households. House price inflation is VERY area-dependent, the same money buys a lot more in cheaper areas and prices have risen less steeply (and in some areas not at all - friends' flat in Nottingham scarcely rose in price at all in ten years and some prices in that area actually fell for a few years running).
godmum56 · 07/08/2021 23:02

@Jellycatspyjamas

I think it depends on how you define needs too. When we got married (nearly 30 years ago) we were both on average salaries, we bought a one bedroom flat in an ok area, nearly all our furniture was second hand from family and friends, we didn’t run a car, didn’t go abroad on holiday and really cut our cloth to suit our purse. New clothes were bought as birthday and Christmas gifts, I wasn’t getting hair, nails, brows done etc and didn’t have expensive tech etc.

You just need to look at some of the threads here to see what people consider “needs” can stretch to include two cars, expensive tech, subscriptions to streaming services, foreign holidays, meals out, nails done, brows waxed, baby classes of all types, extra curricular stuff for kids etc etc. With the best will in the world one salary would need to be pretty good to cover all of that.

Housing is a huge issue but so is the standard of living people want for their money.

This definitely. There is much more unnecessary stuff to "need" than when I was young and dinosaurs roamed the earth. I am not saying that is the whole reason but its definitely a part of it.
MurielSpriggs · 07/08/2021 23:02

Personally I think it does have to be "they shouldn't be able".

The only way to normalise financially comfortable households with only one adult working is to make two-worker households the exception. And almost certainly that means a return to the expectation that the woman's place is in the home. No thanks.

Monkeybusinesss · 07/08/2021 22:59

Since when did taking your kid to Thorpe park and buying a mobile phone mean that you needed an entire other humans wage to make up for it,
All these people working a full time job 40 hours a week just to go on holiday and buy a washing machine and phone - weird of them.

Rewis · 07/08/2021 22:59

I think we should start with an adult with a full time job being able to support themselves. Since that's not really happening at the moment.

LolaSmiles · 07/08/2021 22:58

I think it should be possible to buy a house on one salary and that it should be possible to have a comfortable but simple standard of living on one non-professional / non-managerial salary.

I don't think NMW should be enough to support two adults and 3 children though.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 07/08/2021 22:57

@Shelddd

I like how many people are still saying its lifestyle when I literally post a chart showing housing is 2x compared to income what it was when your parents and grandparents bought their house.

It's not lifestyle!!! housing is twice as expensive compared to income now. That's why you need 2 incomes...

Yep. It’s absolutely the house prices that skew the balance.
AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 07/08/2021 22:56

@NailsNeedDoing

You think ANY full time job should be enough to fully support two adults and up to three children? No, that’s ridiculous.

A full time minimum wage job should be enough to support one adult.

So people on minimum wage shouldn’t be able to have children?
Monkeybusinesss · 07/08/2021 22:55

Anyway the point is people on this thread as per usual say things like
I didn’t have a washing machine in the 70s
Well guess what, very few people did because they were fucking expensive. Even in the 80s my well off parents rented one.

They are not expensive now, you can buy one for £100 and spread the cost. It’s hardly comparable to buying a washing machine in the 70s which was the equivalent cost now of around 4K

If washing machines cost 4K now I can guarantee very few people would have them. And if they did they would rent them.

Jellycatspyjamas · 07/08/2021 22:53

And I don’t fall in the “boomer” age group, don’t have a nice pension, didn’t get free uni education, bought my first flat with a 16% interest rate. I’m very aware that poverty is real, but this discussion is about whether it should be possible to live comfortably on one salary, which very much depends on your definition of “comfortable” or essential.

Shelddd · 07/08/2021 22:52

I like how many people are still saying its lifestyle when I literally post a chart showing housing is 2x compared to income what it was when your parents and grandparents bought their house.

It's not lifestyle!!! housing is twice as expensive compared to income now. That's why you need 2 incomes...

Swipe left for the next trending thread