Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think one adult should be able to support a family with a full time job?

265 replies

Kendodd · 07/08/2021 22:04

Talking about a normal size family, two/three children. Not talking about riches either, just an ordinary place to live and everyone well fed and clothed, all needs covered without state benefits. Any full time job as well, not just some fancy high paid thing.
I know for lots of people working really hard in full time jobs supporting their family just isn't possible on the money.

YANBU - they should be able to support a family.
YABU - they shouldn't be able to have a home and children on an unskilled job.

OP posts:
giggly · 08/08/2021 03:08

I think yabvu to suggest that a “ normal” family consists of two adults. I support two dc with one wage and we are a very normal family thank you.
To answer your question you have to cut your cloth accordingly. I’d love a bigger house but my mortgage is currently £740 a month and I can’t afford any more so a big standard 3 bed it is.

nancybotwinbloom · 08/08/2021 02:21

@PastMyBestBeforeDate
Depends where you live.

£70k "northwest is a 3 bed semi. With a garden.

£70k down south ie london area. Well. It's a studio if your lucky.

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 08/08/2021 01:32

Sorry. 10% deposit not 5%

PastMyBestBeforeDate · 08/08/2021 01:26

People my age (50+) need to stop banging on about PCP, phones and avocados.
I bought a house 30 years ago for 3 times my graduate salary. The same house today is 20 times my graduate salary. I saved a 5% deposit while paying a car loan and rent. It was 3 months salary.
Assuming you could still get 3 times salary as a mortgage now, even if salaries have doubled, you'd need 5 years of salary as a deposit.
It really isn't a case of cutting your cloth.

PurpleOkapi · 08/08/2021 01:06

I don't think anyone has a God-given right to a salary sufficient to support five people plus a mortgage.

rottd · 08/08/2021 01:05

In terms of multiples, and in terms of buying somewhere cheap first, things are the same now as they were when I bought my first flat. I'm not saying this is the case everywhere, I know it isn't, but it is definitely the case where I live.

Surely the op is talking statistically though?

rottd · 08/08/2021 01:03

Champagne was only for weddings and even then it was often a cheaper alternative.

I don't think most people today quaff champagne regularly?

Weddings were nothing like weddings now. Most people could not have afforded a modern wedding.

I'm also unsure why wedding costs are relevant?

rottd · 08/08/2021 01:01

I don't think drinking at home could have been the norm because there was thousands more pubs in the past.

No cocktails, no wine, no Prosecco!

I'm not sure why the type of alcohol available is relevant but surely cocktails were bigger in the past too.

HeddaGarbled · 08/08/2021 00:53

Was lifestyle much cheaper then? more people smoke & drank alcohol & went to pubs none of which is cheap

My experience was that drinking at home was occasional rather than regular. Pub-going was only at weekends and then only for drinking, not for meals.

Pub opening hours were restricted (closing time was 10.30pm except Saturdays when it was 11.00pm and they weren’t open during the day except a couple of hours over lunchtime) so less time to spend a lot. No cocktails, no wine, no Prosecco!

Champagne was only for weddings and even then it was often a cheaper alternative. Weddings were nothing like weddings now. Most people could not have afforded a modern wedding.

Kite22 · 08/08/2021 00:47

Your emotive, or goady language in your OP isn't exactly looking for an open debate though is it ?

I agree with Jellycatspyjamas's point. Yes, you can argue about specifics, but the point is right.

I don't live in the SE. I live within a couple of miles of all the homes I have lived in. I can track property prices and I can track the earning of my profession. I am also constantly on Rightmove / Zoopla / local estate agents websites mainly because I love looking at houses but also because I have two nephews and one dc all looking to buy at the moment. In terms of multiples, and in terms of buying somewhere cheap first, things are the same now as they were when I bought my first flat. I'm not saying this is the case everywhere, I know it isn't, but it is definitely the case where I live. (The flat my sister first bought was up for sale recently). My dc's attitude towards working towards getting that first foot on the ladder is very different from mine all those years ago. In terms of the combination of trying to earn extra, (a bar shift or some babysitting on top of your day job) and in terms of trying to not spend, (literally, on so many things) and in terms of accepting you aren't going to be able to start off with a nice 3 bed semi in an area you want to live in.

I think YABU to think that only one adult should WOTH. If that is a choice that any family wants to make, then fine, but obviously part of that decision is a financial sacrifice, long term.

rottd · 08/08/2021 00:29

Was lifestyle much cheaper then? more people smoke & drank alcohol & went to pubs none of which is cheap.

rottd · 08/08/2021 00:24

The solution is to build lots of housing in order to increase supply and bring down prices.

But look at the shite that does get built.

rottd · 08/08/2021 00:23

wage stagnation has been a thing for at least a decade & probably for another one since covid.

Interest rates are too low to make anything on savings but the gov can't raise them.

MurielSpriggs · 08/08/2021 00:23

Just about everywhere where there's full employment there's competition for housing. Obviously two-income households are going to outbid single-income ones. Single income households will be left with the smallest and worst accommodation. Probably only big enough for single people.

The solution is to build lots of housing in order to increase supply and bring down prices. That's still a long way from being a vote winner.

rottd · 08/08/2021 00:20

That it is normal to have to borrow hundreds of thousands/ mortgage lengths are increasing. The standard used to be 25 years now you can get mortgages for over 35 years.

yep it's become a pyramid scheme

MaverickDanger · 08/08/2021 00:19

YABU.

The assumption that until recently most women stayed at home is quite frankly incorrect for a lot of women. For generations, my female ancestors have worked out of necessity - be it in nursing, factories or on farms.

The first generation of my family who had the choice to work or not was my mum who is 60. For many working class families, this has always been the reality.

rottd · 08/08/2021 00:19

Today it is a million. A teacher earns £35,000

One of the by products of most families having 2 working adults is house price inflation.

It's not just that though because 2 working adults struggle to afford property

rottd · 08/08/2021 00:17

Nice idea, but as well as house prices making this difficult or impossible, you're comparing with a time where lifestyles were very basic compared with today.

Few children had their own bedroom, most families had no car or possibly one old car, eating out was very rare, far fewer treats and expensive days out like theme parks, no technology, almost no-one went abroad on holiday, far fewer clothes etc etc.

When was this? I was born in the 80s in London & loads of my peers had one parent working, holidays abroad became accessible with cheap airlines, things like mcdonald's & pizza hut were popular etc

MiddlesexGirl · 08/08/2021 00:11

I don’t think that women should expect to opt out of income-generating work when they have children.

And almost certainly that means a return to the expectation that the woman's place is in the home. No thanks.

Who said it had to be the woman "opting out"? There's nothing to say it can't be a man staying at home and looking after the kids.

stayathomer · 07/08/2021 23:52

Someone upthread was talking about phone costs etc and I always find these threads drop to that, trying to find way to cut entertainment or food, when it's actually rent/mortgage, health insurance, cost of electricity, heating, going to the doctor, getting a plumber in ... these are the things that break you. When we were bottom of the barrel everyone was suggesting switching providers etc. We were pay as you go on phone (twenty euro each a month) and had netflix and then you got the inevitable 'do you shop in aldi?' Um, yes! Because dh was on a decent wage they assumed we were pumping hundreds into something we just hadn't copped onto but most people nowadays are savvy, the problem is the actual cost of living, the fact that (in Ireland anyway) if you don't have things like health insurance your family is effed and the cost to heat your home. You can totally live on one wage but no frills, no savings, saying that, look, you do what you have to, we couldn't afford for me to work with childcare and the commute. I always recommend to my friends to try to cling onto their jobs!

transformandriseup · 07/08/2021 23:41

I think two people, both hard working, 5+ years into their careers, with the associated payrises that come from 5 years of hard graft and promotions/taking on additional responsibilities should be able to afford to support a family. In my experience, they can, often with one able to go part time for a few years.

Some jobs offer very little progression even if you have worked hard in them for years.

HeddaGarbled · 07/08/2021 23:39

It was the Thatcher government in the 1980s who started the house buying expectation. The rationale was that home owners were more likely to vote Conservative, I think.

Up until then people like me didn’t expect to become property owners. Rentals could be shit and I certainly lived in some bad places (grotty shared bathrooms, damp, gas and electricity on meters that needed perpetual feeding with coins, landlords who were extremely dodgy and would send the ‘boys’ round to collect the rent in cash).

I suppose the difference between now and then is that, then, council and housing association properties were more plentiful, and at least with those, the rent was controlled.

Marcee · 07/08/2021 23:32

It used to happen in the past.

Unfortunately living standards have fallen significantly. Houses that could be bought with one basic salary, now aren't affordable despite two good salaries.
We've just been brainwashed with the idea that we just aren't working hard enough. That it is normal to have to borrow hundreds of thousands/ mortgage lengths are increasing. The standard used to be 25 years now you can get mortgages for over 35 years.

Every year inflation is stealing money from your pockets, the banks are printing money- willy-nilly. Of course they dont want to pay you any interest on your cash- they can just print as much as they need.

The money you have becomes more worthless every year- yet people vote for more of the same, I really dont understand it.

chaosrabbitland · 07/08/2021 23:30

@Kendodd

I don't think it's possible anymore.

I know it's not possible.
The question is whether it should be possible or whether we are ok with it not being possible.

it should be possible , it once was and should be again , , there are a lot of mums who are forced to work ,but would really like to stay at home with their children when they are little ,but cant , our goverment wants mothers to work . theres no incentive for them to stay at home currently so until enough parents feel strongly enough to lobby for change things will stay as they are
ancientgran · 07/08/2021 23:29

@Shelddd

I like how many people are still saying its lifestyle when I literally post a chart showing housing is 2x compared to income what it was when your parents and grandparents bought their house.

It's not lifestyle!!! housing is twice as expensive compared to income now. That's why you need 2 incomes...

What about mortgage repayments? It isn't just the price of the house, which obviously varies tremendously round the country, it is also interest rates. Back in the 70s and 80s we couldn't imagine the sort of rates you can get on a mortgage now.

Then there is pay and take home pay. Income tax was higher back then so the headline pay might be x times higher now but due to lower tax it will actually be more.

It is very complicated to compare.

Swipe left for the next trending thread