Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think one adult should be able to support a family with a full time job?

265 replies

Kendodd · 07/08/2021 22:04

Talking about a normal size family, two/three children. Not talking about riches either, just an ordinary place to live and everyone well fed and clothed, all needs covered without state benefits. Any full time job as well, not just some fancy high paid thing.
I know for lots of people working really hard in full time jobs supporting their family just isn't possible on the money.

YANBU - they should be able to support a family.
YABU - they shouldn't be able to have a home and children on an unskilled job.

OP posts:
timeisnotaline · 08/08/2021 08:33

I’ve just used the pmt function on excel for a quick and dirty and number of periods = 20 hence annual cost for those wanting to look into the numbers.

vickibee · 08/08/2021 08:32

I have just become a single parent becuase my dh passes suddenly a month ago
I am worrying about money on top of everything else, he was the main wage earner so we are over 2k per month down. I work very part time and earn about £1100 per month. I am excluded from benefits because I am getting a death in service payout. Which clears most debts and leaves me with a small capital sum.
I am going to have to get a full time job but that is hard becuase my son has a learning disability, it is so shit. We do live in the north which is cheaper but the wages are also poor.

timeisnotaline · 08/08/2021 08:31

17% interest on 100K is 17K a year. 2% interest on 500K is 10k a year. We are borrowing more and more to buy, but the cost gap is nowhere near as large as the house price gap. Annual cost on a 20 year loan for that 100k at 17% is 18k, annual cost on a 20 year loan for that 500k on 2% is 31k, or less than twice as much. House prices is the single biggest factor but there is a lot more to it than that. Once you have narrowed the cost gap down to the actual payments you make, the living expenses becomes a bigger factor, and life style expectations have changed a lot. (Obviously, if interest rates rise, many many people are screwed.)

user1487194234 · 08/08/2021 08:26

We could have managed on one wage but would not have had quite so many nice things
No way would I have given up my career to live off my husband
We both went part time
Has been brilliant

Musication · 08/08/2021 08:04

It should be but I don't think it's ever going back to that, not anytime soon anyway.
I grew up in an ordinary household with 3 kids supported by one professional working adult, although my mum worked part time when we got to school age as she was bored. My DH family the same. But it just isn't a thing now with the inflated cost of housing

Bluntness100 · 08/08/2021 08:03

Min wage or there abouts is not supposed to support four or five people.

KingdomScrolls · 08/08/2021 08:01

There are also a lot of women without pensions of their own from that generation

KingdomScrolls · 08/08/2021 07:59

The thing is when only one income is needed, it's so often women who give up work and that causes all kinds of other imbalances. You could live on one salary in the seventies but people would also turn a blind eye to a man giving his wife a slap, consent within marriage was assumed, women were expected to run around after their husbands and there was little financial independence if you wanted to leave.

Antsinyourpanta · 08/08/2021 07:42

£70k down south ie london area. Well. It's a studio if your lucky.

Confused really?

rottd · 08/08/2021 05:51

There’s been a major sea change since 2008 with a withdrawal of easy mortgage credit and much reduced earnings growth

One reason wages have fallen is because our levels of productivity is so low. There is a serious lack of investment into the economy, the only real investment has been stimulus to prop up & inflate the housing market. What's so ridiculous is that for most ever increasing house prices aren't a good thing because it makes it harder to move up that ladder but the public tend to find security in seeing their property go up & it encourages them to spend.

KentuckyCriedFricken · 08/08/2021 05:20

Wfat do you mean by “no state benefits”? Education? Healthcare? Social services?

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/08/2021 05:16

That is why there is a housing crisis because young people can't afford to buy a house on a single wage any more

Yes, and in large parts of the UK, young people can't afford to buy a house with two 'good' wages coming in.

AuntieJoyce · 08/08/2021 05:14

@Nat6999

For a family to manage on one wage then salaries would have had to keep up with house prices. When I bought my house my mortgage was for £38500, my salary was £18500, now that house is worth £110000 yet the salary for the job I did now is only £20700, the house price has nearly trebled in 20 years. While ever there are less than 1% pay increases wages will not catch up. When I first started work we often got 5 or 6% pay increases but the mortgage rate was 15%, the mortgage rate now is around 2%. That is why there is a housing crisis because young people can't afford to buy a house on a single wage any more.
This is an interesting post because effectively the purchase is unaffordable but servicing it wouldn’t be due to low interest rates

There’s been a major sea change since 2008 with a withdrawal of easy mortgage credit and much reduced earnings growth

Nat6999 · 08/08/2021 05:02

For a family to manage on one wage then salaries would have had to keep up with house prices. When I bought my house my mortgage was for £38500, my salary was £18500, now that house is worth £110000 yet the salary for the job I did now is only £20700, the house price has nearly trebled in 20 years. While ever there are less than 1% pay increases wages will not catch up. When I first started work we often got 5 or 6% pay increases but the mortgage rate was 15%, the mortgage rate now is around 2%. That is why there is a housing crisis because young people can't afford to buy a house on a single wage any more.

rottd · 08/08/2021 04:54

i know what the thread is about but I was replying to your post which was a reply to another post which specifically referenced that point.

PurpleOkapi · 08/08/2021 04:50

@rottd

The human race is in no danger of extinction. Or if it is, that threat comes from the consequences of continued overpopulation, not from people foregoing parenthood because they can't afford it. Society doesn't benefit from encouraging a population explosion among minimum-wage workers or anyone else.

I think you are getting ahead of yourself. That poster made a valid point about whether only "rich" people have dc. For one if they did who would do all the minimum wage jobs? I don't think having a discussion around living costs & wages encourages a population explosion & the UKs population is expanding because there are more older people living longer, birth rates are already very low.

The thread isn't about whether those making minimum wage should be allowed or practically able to have children. It's about whether minimum wage should pay enough to support a partner, multiple children, and a house on just that one salary. It currently doesn't, at least not without government assistance, so everyone who currently does minimum wage jobs would still do them.
ShippingNews · 08/08/2021 04:35

@sayanythingelse

It SHOULD be but it isn't.

My mum never worked after having children and we lived comfortably on my dad's salary working in a factory. We had a nice house, holidays abroad and never wanted for anything.

DH works 60 hours a week and I've just cut down to 20 to make childcare easier. We lived in a rented house because even though we have a deposit, we don't earn enough between us to get a big enough mortgage for a 3 bed semi.
We live comfortably but we don't have money for extras now I'm part time. We could never live a life on one salary like my parents did.

I agree. My parents were married in the 40's and Mum never worked from the day she got married . We had a very comfortable life on Dad's wage as an electrician, holidays, nice home etc.

I got married in the 80's and I always worked full time as a nurse, DH as an army clerk. I only had the minimum time off when the DCs were little. We had the basic house, very few holidays, state education for the kids. Bought our first house when we were both 40.

"Should" is a good word but it doesn't really mean much. And your suggestion of mass social housing wouldn't suit many people.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 08/08/2021 04:25

It should be possible, in theory, but in reality it's become increasingly difficult over the past 40 years in the UK.

Prior to 1979 wages grew hand-in-hand with prosperity. After 1979 that stops, and despite prosperity still climbing, the growth in wages tails off. It's almost as if something significant happens at that point in time.

The UK is still prosperous post 1979, but the profits are not going into the hands of normal, working class people to the extent they were previously. 'Trickle down' is a complete and utter myth.

So people can afford 'mod cons' now. People in the 70's couldn't buy 'mod cons' because by and large there were far less of them invented and on the market available to buy. Great, you have an iPhone, the kids have xboxes, and so on, but you can easily function without all that stuff. Can you afford to buy your 3 or 4 bedroom home on a single salary?

By the way, we are the only country in Europe that has experienced economic expansion since 2008, and absolutely no increase whatsoever in salaries. We are being utterly conned by the charlatans we elect to run the UK.

rottd · 08/08/2021 04:03

The human race is in no danger of extinction. Or if it is, that threat comes from the consequences of continued overpopulation, not from people foregoing parenthood because they can't afford it. Society doesn't benefit from encouraging a population explosion among minimum-wage workers or anyone else.

I think you are getting ahead of yourself. That poster made a valid point about whether only "rich" people have dc. For one if they did who would do all the minimum wage jobs? I don't think having a discussion around living costs & wages encourages a population explosion & the UKs population is expanding because there are more older people living longer, birth rates are already very low.

Mintjulia · 08/08/2021 03:59

As a single mum, I manage it. I never married so no divorce settlement, no family support. I'm on standard rate tax, in the south east but pay mortgage, bills, DS' costs, car.
DS has his own room, plenty of clothes, two sport hobbies, good home cooked food. We are lucky

BUT that doesn't include expensive foreign holidays, pay TV, alcohol, gym membership, eating out every week etc. Outside of London I'm not sure housing is always the problem, lifestyle is.

My finances only feel tight when I have a partner and he wants a bottle of wine every night or when DS was little, £50 an evening for a baby sitter.

rottd · 08/08/2021 03:58

£70k down south ie london area. Well. It's a studio if your lucky.

err maybe a parking space

£70k "northwest is a 3 bed semi. With a garden.

which areas? that surely can't be the average.

PurpleOkapi · 08/08/2021 03:44

But by this argument anyone who is in a low paid job should not expect to be able to have children or a family. So families become the preserve of the well paid do they? Those on minimum wage aren’t working for themselves , you know. They are working for someone else who is benefiting from their labour and no doubt enjoying a good standard of living

How many children is "enough" to satisfy this right that you believe everyone has? One? Two? Five? Ten? Why that number? And since the creation of children generally requires the participation of two adults, why shouldn't the general expectation be that both adults participate in paying for them?

The human race is in no danger of extinction. Or if it is, that threat comes from the consequences of continued overpopulation, not from people foregoing parenthood because they can't afford it. Society doesn't benefit from encouraging a population explosion among minimum-wage workers or anyone else.

twinningatlife · 08/08/2021 03:43

@Kendodd

I don't think it's possible anymore.

I know it's not possible.
The question is whether it should be possible or whether we are ok with it not being possible.

Why. Should it? So that someone can be a STAHP?
Themeparklover · 08/08/2021 03:40

Unless they are receiving credits and are in a council house or housing association small property on a general role such as unskilled job they absolutely wouldn't afford to securely provide for their family. It takes a simple google search of credits indeed search of basic salaries and search of housing prices on right move to realise this...

PinkyDozza · 08/08/2021 03:34

@NailsNeedDoing

You think ANY full time job should be enough to fully support two adults and up to three children? No, that’s ridiculous.

A full time minimum wage job should be enough to support one adult.

But by this argument anyone who is in a low paid job should not expect to be able to have children or a family. So families become the preserve of the well paid do they? Those on minimum wage aren’t working for themselves , you know. They are working for someone else who is benefiting from their labour and no doubt enjoying a good standard of living
Swipe left for the next trending thread