Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think one adult should be able to support a family with a full time job?

265 replies

Kendodd · 07/08/2021 22:04

Talking about a normal size family, two/three children. Not talking about riches either, just an ordinary place to live and everyone well fed and clothed, all needs covered without state benefits. Any full time job as well, not just some fancy high paid thing.
I know for lots of people working really hard in full time jobs supporting their family just isn't possible on the money.

YANBU - they should be able to support a family.
YABU - they shouldn't be able to have a home and children on an unskilled job.

OP posts:
BananaMilkshakeWithCream · 08/08/2021 10:23

If it’s an unskilled job then how much is the person you’re talking about going to be on? If it’s minimum wage then I think it would be hard to support a family of two/three kids plus run a house. We sometimes find it hard and we have a joint income of £73k.

timeisnotaline · 08/08/2021 10:15

@CheddarToldMeTo I don’t get it. Don’t your numbers say with you not working your dh brings in £500 a month spare after your outgoings. Then if you worked, 3 days so approx 1700 a month, and paid 700 childcare, you’d clear another 1k a month after childcare so you’d have 1500 to play with/save/holidays. That sounds like you can easily afford a child??

PumpkinPie2016 · 08/08/2021 10:07

My Nan (born in 1932) and my grandma (born in 1926) both worked in various forms over the years. My grandma was nurse trained and worked as a nurse throughout her life, despite having 5 children. Her husband (my grandad) worked for David Brown's tractors.
My other Grandad was a HGV driver and my Nan did a few different jobs over the years.

I don't think it's necessarily correct that all families used to survive on one wage.

A big part of the issue now is that wages simply haven't kept up with house prices/cost of living generally, so unless a person earns a very good salary, it would be difficult to support a family on one wage.

I think lifestyle is a factor, although not the sole reason for not being able to have a family on one wage. Tech is cheaper and more readily available now that it would have been in the 70s/80s and even early 90s. There is massive variation though. If you want the latest phone on an expensive contract, it will be costly. A more modest phone/contract will be less.

Me and DH both have Samsung Galaxy phones. Both have data/messaging etc. We pay £12 a month for both (not each!). They are not the latest phones but both do what we need.

We don't have loans on cars. Each was saved for and paid outright. We put money away each month so that eventually, when needed, they can be replaced. Both decent cars that are reliable and run well. Not top of the range things though.

We have one child so he has his own room anyway.

We are quite frugal generally. We could spend more than we do but are happy as we are. Obviously, others may not be happy to be that frugal. Each to their own.

Soontobe60 · 08/08/2021 09:59

When we bought our first house in 1982, the building society would only take my dhs income into account! The mortgage was 3x his income, over 20 years, and we paid a 5% deposit. The interest rate was about 7%.
Now people have combined incomes taken into account, interest rates are very low, and younger people can get mortgages over 30+ years. My DD is paying the same monthly that I paid 10 years ago for a house worth 50% less than hers.

Monkeybusinesss · 08/08/2021 09:57

I can’t believe people are still banging on about washing machines.
You know washing machines are cheap these days.
You know that going to the laundrette costs around £30 per week in London.
No poor person could afford to go to a laundrette in this day and age, having a washing machine isn’t luxurious.

Howshouldibehave · 08/08/2021 09:55

I was trying to fit my family into one of the 4 groups posted by @vivainsomnia but couldn’t really.

I was born in the late 70s with two older brothers. My dad worked, but it wasn’t a highly paid job-we didn’t ever go abroad or to restaurants, but had a week away on holiday each year-usually somewhere in the middle of nowhere! We had a decent house and a bedroom each, but it wasn’t fancy. We had a telly, no cheap clothes, my parents decorated nicely themselves and had a lovely garden. My dad had a company car and late in the 80s when my mum got a part time job, had another crappy car for her and then us to practise learning in.

Hankunamatata · 08/08/2021 09:51

With 3 children, no. Perhaps with 1 child

ancientgran · 08/08/2021 09:46

@rottd

Nice idea, but as well as house prices making this difficult or impossible, you're comparing with a time where lifestyles were very basic compared with today.

Few children had their own bedroom, most families had no car or possibly one old car, eating out was very rare, far fewer treats and expensive days out like theme parks, no technology, almost no-one went abroad on holiday, far fewer clothes etc etc.

When was this? I was born in the 80s in London & loads of my peers had one parent working, holidays abroad became accessible with cheap airlines, things like mcdonald's & pizza hut were popular etc

I was born in the 50s, my mother worked, all the mothers I knew worked. I had my first child in the 70s, I worked, all the mothers I knew worked. My grandmother worked in the 20s and 30s when she had children, her mother worked in the 1890 and 1900s.

Obviously some people lived on one wage, but that's true now.

vivainsomnia · 08/08/2021 09:44

I think that many couples who claim they can't would if they made different choices in regards to their lifestyle. People expectations of what is normal were luxuries for many in the 70s and 80s. When I was growing up, families fell under 4 categories. Those whose dad earn a lot, mum at home and very nice life. Those wit dad working only, very low income and at least 5 siblings. They were the ones with old,dirty clothes etc... Then you had the ones who had a very nice lifestyle, holidays abroad, nice home, activities etc... and had both parents working. Then you had those with mum at home, dad earning okish, 1 or 2 siblings, and they lived in smaller homes, not as nice neighbourhood, shared bedrooms, houses needed renovation and decoration. Some didn't have a TV or only black and white, some mums had to go to wash clothes at the automaton because they didn't have a washing machine. Food was cheap and not very exciting. They didn't do much activities, never went out, and holidays were once every few years camping trips. They were happy with that life, they didn't consider the alternative because they believed that having a sahp was essential.

Nowadays, families expect so much more. A nice new home, large enough for all kids to have their bedroom, nice area, at least one car, often two, even where there is public transport. Kids in very nice clothes, house very nicely decorated with a lot of nice furnishings. New appliances, annual holidays, if possible abroad.

These were all luxuries for one working family in the past. Should it be now be a due? I personally don't think so. I still consider these luxuries.

AngelsWithSilverWings · 08/08/2021 09:39

I was born in the 1970s. Both of my parents had to work to pay the bills and we had to be very frugal. If we had a holiday it was camping.

At one point my Dad did a weekend window cleaning round to supplement his wages from London Transport and my mum had three jobs at one point. She had a school hours job and then worked evenings in the bingo hall and weekends in a pub. They had to to do the childcare in shifts and pay a teenager to babysit during the hour or so of crossover when they were both at work.

This wasn't an unusual way of life on the council estate/working class town I lived in. Everyone worked and there weren't many SAHPs.

I think my childhood experience had a lot to do with me becoming a SAHM - I didn't want the constant stress and worry that my parents had. I always saw work as something you had to do to pay the bills and nothing else.

CheddarToldMeTo · 08/08/2021 09:33

I wish we could, as we are hoping to start a family soon and the cost of childcare is terrifying me!! I'm a planner, but sometimes maybe it would benefit me more to stop planning and just jump in 😂 anyway, I digress.

We wouldn't be able to live at home with one child on one salary. Our basics of:

Mortgage
C tax
House insurance
Internet
Water
Gas and Electric
Pet insurance
Basic TV subscription
Loan for Carpets (nearly paid)
Loan for Sofa (nearly paid)
Loan for Car (paying back a family member)
Combined credit card costs

All come to £1,200.

Then add in our respective life insurances (my husband's is expensive as he does a dangerous job), cheap phone bills and separate car insurance, plus other work insurances my husband has to have that would then increase to:

£1,500.

We budget £280 a month for food

£1,780.

We individually at the moment budget £140 each for petrol, if I wasn't commuting 40 miles a day, five days a week I could probably knock that down to £60 a month.

£1980.

Then we'd have to factor in the ridiculous estate maintenance charges that our new build estate attracts, about £100 a year.

My husband brings home approximately £2,500 a month.

Childcare where we are could be up to £700 based on a 3day week working 8-5.

We'd already be in debt 😭😭😭

I bring home approximately £2,100 a month working full time so for us it wouldn't be feasible until kiddo gets their free childcare hours.

CrazyHorse · 08/08/2021 09:30

@AlexaShutUp - by your logic a single parent on an average wouldn't be able to raise children with out the help of benefits.

I most certainly want my DDs partner to be able to support her should she chose not to work, I also would like her to be able to support her partner should they chose not to work.
In an ideal world quality child care would be easily available and house prices so low that one person could provide for a couple of children without support, or one of a couple should be able not to work or work part time.

I think it's somewhat of a myth that women didn't work at all in the 50s/60s/70s/80s, but it was financially possible for the family to survive with only one parent working for a few years. Funnily enough they would have accepted they couldn't afford a holiday or other luxuries, but it was doable.

notanothertakeaway · 08/08/2021 09:27

I don't agree with tax credits subsidising low wages. I think employers should pay a living wage

But I wouldn't expect one modest earner to be able to support four dependants

Kendodd · 08/08/2021 09:19

I would point out that I made no mention of a partner in my op.

OP posts:
IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 08/08/2021 09:15

@topwings

Why is putting women (let's face it, it would be the woman) back into the kitchen and not being able to earn their own money being presented as an ideal life?
I have no idea. Education staff inspire children to study hard and that they can achieve anything in life so we certainly don’t want the message to be men work and women don’t. Whilst some families may model that, many others won’t want it to be the normal message sent out,
Kendodd · 08/08/2021 09:09

The UK is still prosperous post 1979, but the profits are not going into the hands of normal, working class people to the extent they were previously. 'Trickle down' is a complete and utter myth.

Completely agree. The super rich have sucked up every penny of profits. We have people working 50 hours+ in Amazon warehouses and still needing to be subsidised by the tax payer to feed their family while Geoff Bezos is going to fucking space. Its so wrong.

OP posts:
TempleofZoom · 08/08/2021 09:09

@TheHateIsNotGood

I agree with you OP - as a lifelong female 'rights' protagonist who spent many, possibly wasted, decades doing equality rather than theorizing or running to HR with my latest 'grief'.

It used to be the norm for years that a 'man' could support his family as long as he stayed 'in work'; if the lady of the house earned a bit of'pin money' that was good too.

Whilst not ideal if you're a woman, seems that scenario is virtually non-existent now, so either both mother and father run themselves ragged paying the household bills or the father might still have the mindset that all things domestic are woman's responsibility, so she's run even more ragged than ever....progress eh...

Every woman in my family worked. However it wasn't recognised as such or called "pin money" so as not to offend the men who couldn't cope with the shame of having a wife who WOH Hmm Women's contributions in or out of the home were not recognised.
AlexaShutUp · 08/08/2021 09:02

It's actually quite depressing that so many people want to go back to a life where only one parent works. We know it would be the woman who ended up staying at home in most cases. I honestly don't understand why people aspire to this as some kind of ideal.

My mother's salary wasn't even taken into account when she and my dad applied for their first mortgage. It was considered irrelevant. She did give up work when we were born, because it was considered the done thing, and she was bored and miserable as a SAHP. Her mental health has never recovered. Her biggest regret now is that she wasted her talent and potential.

I really don't want to go back to those times. I don't want my dd's future spouse to earn enough to support her. I want her to be independent and in an equal relationship.

It takes two parents to create a child. Why should only one pay for that child?

DazzlePaintedBattlePants · 08/08/2021 08:55

Mortgages need to be regulated again - it’s cheap credit that has caused the house price expansion. Once house prices are more suistainable, the pressure on social housing eases. Social housing should be for the minimum wage earning families - not for those on normal salaries who can only not buy their own house because house prices are insane.

And I wish people would give it a rest about mobile phones, holidays and cars being the reason people can’t buy a family house. 3 bed semis round here start at £450k and whilst it wouldn’t be unusual to find couples earning £120k between them, once you start taking in nursery fees etc they won’t exactly be living the life of Riley. Some Normal living costs (food, mobiles, entertainment) have fallen massively in real terms since the 1980’s, so it’s entirely possible to eat better/have newer clothes for the same cost as 30 years ago. But you can’t say the same for house prices, where the change is almost an order of magnitude.

I’d also point out that round here, Facebook marketplace/eBay/freecycle do a roaring trade in secondhand furnishings. I would say that the majority of people are not furnishing their first house new.

WRT new cars - you can either pay £350 a month servicing a loan on a £10k second hand car, or the same on a brand new PCP car. Or go without for a few years whilst you save up. So just because you see someone cruising around in a brand new car doesn’t necessarily mean that they have made crappy financial decisions.

In short, I don’t se much evidence behind the argument that no one can afford a house because they buy too much crap/eat out too much.

Willwebebuyingnumber11 · 08/08/2021 08:52

@TheRebelle you’re assuming all SAHMs only have the basic necessities. My children don’t go without any extras. Infact they have more than a lot of children I know in families where both parents work.

Willwebebuyingnumber11 · 08/08/2021 08:51

My family and our group of friends have this life.
We’re all mortgage free or have small mortgages and all aged between 29-32.
We all bought our homes young, between 20-22 and where we live they were cheap. Between £60k-80k.
Husbands all work very hard; all trade / run businesses and we’re all SAHMs.
All have at least 1 holiday abroad per year, days out and very nice lifestyles.
All have at least 2 children, some of us have 3. One family has 4.

TheRebelle · 08/08/2021 08:46

I don’t think you should be able to support a family on one wage because that means, more often than not, that it’s the woman who gives up work to look after children and even if it meant only having the very basic necessities then it would mean many children growing up without any of the extra things that are available now that enrich their lives.

gogohm · 08/08/2021 08:45

@MauveMagnolia

But that's area dependant because you can buy a flat where my house is for £120k

gogohm · 08/08/2021 08:43

Years ago, when my parents were small, many families had one breadwinner but my maternal grandparents never owned their modest house, never had a car, never had a colour tv, my grandmother washed their school shirts when then got in from school by hand (she never owned a washer) and ironed them dry because they only had one each and mum remembers that they had to wait for their dad to get home on a Thursday with his wages sometimes so Nanna could buy bread for tea which was often bread and jam. Contrast to my paternal grandparents where grandad was a skilled worker and Nanna always worked at least part time, they owned their house, a car, and went abroad for holidays in late 50's.

Life has never been easy on one income unless it's a professional salary, we lived on one growing up but my dad owned a business and mum had worked to get the house deposit together before I was born. I stayed home with my kids for a few years but my ex was, well is a pretty high earner, with a doctorate.

topwings · 08/08/2021 08:43

Why is putting women (let's face it, it would be the woman) back into the kitchen and not being able to earn their own money being presented as an ideal life?