Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think one adult should be able to support a family with a full time job?

265 replies

Kendodd · 07/08/2021 22:04

Talking about a normal size family, two/three children. Not talking about riches either, just an ordinary place to live and everyone well fed and clothed, all needs covered without state benefits. Any full time job as well, not just some fancy high paid thing.
I know for lots of people working really hard in full time jobs supporting their family just isn't possible on the money.

YANBU - they should be able to support a family.
YABU - they shouldn't be able to have a home and children on an unskilled job.

OP posts:
LakieLady · 08/08/2021 14:32

@KingdomScrolls

The thing is when only one income is needed, it's so often women who give up work and that causes all kinds of other imbalances. You could live on one salary in the seventies but people would also turn a blind eye to a man giving his wife a slap, consent within marriage was assumed, women were expected to run around after their husbands and there was little financial independence if you wanted to leave.
It used to be that way because the woman's salary was generally lower than the man's, so for them to give up work had less impact on household income.

One would have hoped that, 50 years after the Equal Pay Act, that would no longer be the case, but average pay for women is still less than for men.

MotionActivatedDog · 08/08/2021 14:20

Minimum wage only came into existence in 1999 so 22 years ago.

I agree one full time minimum wage shouldn’t really be expected to support a family of 4 or 5.

Antsinyourpanta · 08/08/2021 14:12

The reality is that lots of peoplewillspend their entire working life earning minimum wage for various reasons. Minimum wage should be enough to maintain your own life, for life. Housing, food, heat, clothing, toiletries, travel to work or to see your mum, and the odd night out, day out, trip to the cinema is really not an unreasonable expectation to have for a very basic life.*

I think that's reasonable,but its different to supporting yourself, a partner and 2 or 3 children. (Has Minimum wage been enough for this in previous generations? Or did it not exist?)

LakieLady · 08/08/2021 14:11

@Antsinyourpanta

£70k down south ie london area. Well. It's a studio if your lucky.

Confused really?

South-east, but 50 miles from London, and the cheapest property on Rightmove here (apart from retirement flats) is £150k for a one-bed former council flat on a fairly rough estate.

Studio flats to rent? A gobsmacking £895 a month.

It would probably be cheaper to buy the first flat than rent the second.

MotionActivatedDog · 08/08/2021 13:41

@MotionActivatedDog

The reality is that lots of people will spend their entire working life earning minimum wage for various reasons. Minimum wage should be enough to maintain your own life, for life. Housing, food, heat, clothing, toiletries, travel to work or to see your mum, and the odd night out, day out, trip to the cinema is really not an unreasonable expectation to have for a very basic life.
I’ll add to that list: savings. People on minimum wage should be able to stick a bit away for a rainy day. Washing machines break down, house moves need to be paid for etc
NeverTalkToStrangers · 08/08/2021 13:37

I agree with MotionActivatedDog. Minimum wage should be enough for a single adult to live a reasonable life on, including a week at Butlins and an occasional meal out at the local curry house or whatever. But I think it’s reasonable for the state to kick in for a few years in order to help minimum wage earners bring up children.

LakieLady · 08/08/2021 13:35

If washing machines cost 4K now I can guarantee very few people would have them. And if they did they would rent them

Like they used to with tv's!

I left home in 1975, and got my first washing machine in 1988. And it was £12, secondhand, several years old and lasted me 6 years before it gave up the ghost. Things have got cheaper, relative to wages, but they don't last as long.

I didn't have a single piece of new furniture until 1991. And most of my furniture is secondhand, from junk shops or auctions. Only my sofas and bed were bought new.

MotionActivatedDog · 08/08/2021 13:18

The reality is that lots of people will spend their entire working life earning minimum wage for various reasons. Minimum wage should be enough to maintain your own life, for life. Housing, food, heat, clothing, toiletries, travel to work or to see your mum, and the odd night out, day out, trip to the cinema is really not an unreasonable expectation to have for a very basic life.

transformandriseup · 08/08/2021 13:11

People should not expect to live a full life on minimum wage because people shouldn't be on minimum wage their whole life - and I don't mean everybody should go into high earning careers but that minimum wage should be for people just starting out or in very low end work, once they have experience they should be paid more

I agree with this. It doesn't help a lot companies are getting rid of middle management roles so it's becoming more difficult to gradually step up. My child would probably need to be in secondary school before I can commit to my managers work schedule even if I already have the skills to do her job.

nosyupnorth · 08/08/2021 13:02

Having thought about it more, I think this approach is coming at it backwards.

People should not expect to live a full life on minimum wage because people shouldn't be on minimum wage their whole life - and I don't mean everybody should go into high earning careers but that minimum wage should be for people just starting out or in very low end work, once they have experience they should be paid more. Companies are taking advantage by making millions of jobs minium wage that should be entitled to more.

AuntieJoyce · 08/08/2021 12:49

@NeverTalkToStrangers

Family Income Supplement was introduced in 1970 to support the working poor. I’m not sure it’s ever been possible for a family of four to live comfortably but frugally on a single unskilled labour/minimum wage income although the current levels of housing cost have definitely made it far more difficult.

I blame Thatcher. Thirty five years on we’re still seeing the impact of right to buy.

There’s a lot of blame for Thatcher on MN but this was a hugely popular policy decision at the time and had those individuals been unable to buy they would have remained blocking social housing indefinitely

If we want to put the blame on any government my vote’s for Blair’s tax credits and immigration policy with the resulting long reaching dampening of wage inflation

MauveMagnolia · 08/08/2021 12:49

@Monkeybusinesss

I can’t believe people are still banging on about washing machines. You know washing machines are cheap these days. You know that going to the laundrette costs around £30 per week in London. No poor person could afford to go to a laundrette in this day and age, having a washing machine isn’t luxurious.
Lots of people have £20 but not £200

Bright house showed that

MauveMagnolia · 08/08/2021 12:47

@rottd

Today it is a million. A teacher earns £35,000

One of the by products of most families having 2 working adults is house price inflation.

It's not just that though because 2 working adults struggle to afford property

I agree but if all families had stayed on 1 income house prices would not have risen as they would have been unaffordable. From the 1930s to 1970s house price inflation was much lower
AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 08/08/2021 12:38

We cannot progress to equality if women want to be supported and as a result, fully dependant on someone else.

If it takes two people’s wages to keep a household ticking over, you’re reliant on the other person anyway.
The solution isn’t to make it so that both parents have to work full time. We should respect the role and input of the SAHP equally to the final input of the other parent. That’s the only way we will achieve equality.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 08/08/2021 12:25

@notanothertakeaway

I don't agree with tax credits subsidising low wages. I think employers should pay a living wage

But I wouldn't expect one modest earner to be able to support four dependants

I disagree with wage top ups too and would like to see them gone but I don’t think it’s an on employer to pay a living wage as such. Jobs vary in needing none or a lot of skill so salary should be based on that. You can’t base a wage on living costs as some people want to live in an expensive area, work a few hours, have multiple children, a non working partner, two cars etc.
Ariela · 08/08/2021 12:21

I think there has been a major shift towards having it all: nice holidays, nice car, new furnishings and white goods, definitely not secondhand, eating out and takeaways - when I was small there were perhaps 3-4 chippies locally, and that was it. 4-5 restaurants one was Italian, 1 Chinese 1 new one was Indian - you had a birthday meal in one of those, pubs didn't do food. Crisps and pork scratchings were a new thing.
I worked 3-4 jobs a week to earn/save a 10% deposit. Sat on the floor , ate on my lap, no TV for months after moving in. Carpeted the bedroom first then the lounge.

it's all so very very different now.

Iamthewombat · 08/08/2021 11:59

I think YABU to think that only one adult should WOTH. If that is a choice that any family wants to make, then fine, but obviously part of that decision is a financial sacrifice, long term.

Why is putting women (let's face it, it would be the woman) back into the kitchen and not being able to earn their own money being presented as an ideal life?

We cannot progress to equality if women want to be supported and as a result, fully dependant on someone else.

I didn’t get this from the OP. I don’t think that she is advocating for a return to the stay at home wife model.

I took it to mean, if you have a household of two adults and two children, and both of the adults are working in minimum wage jobs, and the children are small, and childcare is unaffordable, should that family expect to be able to cope on one of the adults’ wages for a time?

To which the answer should be yes. It only works if you have social housing available, and targeted benefits though. Both of those things identify and deal with need, which I’m not sure that you could achieve through salary.

For example, you couldn’t expect employers to pay person A more than person B for the same job because A had a non-working partner and small children and B had only one or neither of those things. Although that is pretty much what used to happen before wage equality was legislated, with the B group being women!

GoodForTheSoul · 08/08/2021 11:34

@AlexaShutUp

It's actually quite depressing that so many people want to go back to a life where only one parent works. We know it would be the woman who ended up staying at home in most cases. I honestly don't understand why people aspire to this as some kind of ideal.

My mother's salary wasn't even taken into account when she and my dad applied for their first mortgage. It was considered irrelevant. She did give up work when we were born, because it was considered the done thing, and she was bored and miserable as a SAHP. Her mental health has never recovered. Her biggest regret now is that she wasted her talent and potential.

I really don't want to go back to those times. I don't want my dd's future spouse to earn enough to support her. I want her to be independent and in an equal relationship.

It takes two parents to create a child. Why should only one pay for that child?

This.

We cannot progress to equality if women want to be supported and as a result, fully dependant on someone else.

NeverTalkToStrangers · 08/08/2021 11:25

Yes I think you’re right Namenic. It’s not really viable to set up a capitalist society for one full time wage earner to support three or more dependents when only a small minority of households will fall into that structure by necessity, normally due to childcare requirements or disability.

I’m not sufficiently qualified to judge whether it’s “better” to support that minority through state aid and leave the rest to the free market (within the constraints of the minimum wage and other employment legislation) but that’s definitely the choice our society has made.

Namenic · 08/08/2021 11:01

I’m not sure being able to support 3 dependents (1 spouse plus 2 children) on 1 salary is totally necessary for the duration of working life - eg age 21-68. I think that we have a gap in provision of childcare between 0-3 (assuming some people do not get maternity leave due to zero hours contracts) and special needs care and elderly care. I think we also need a better CMS service as well and support for single parents.

We also have huge housing costs due to lack of supply and higher expectations re:space. I think probably it is more practical for more 3 bed low rise flats to be built with shared communal facilities rather than more houses which take up more land. Building at an adequate rate to keep house/flat prices reasonable would be a good start.

sst1234 · 08/08/2021 10:54

@Kendodd

I don't think it's possible anymore.

I know it's not possible.
The question is whether it should be possible or whether we are ok with it not being possible.

Your question is essentially a piece of string concept. How many children before it becomes reasonable that the second parent should work? Also, of course it is reasonable to expect to have only one parent work with 3 children - like in the 50s. But then you have to expect the same living conditions - outside toilet to most houses, no car, maybe no tv, no fridge, no eating out, absolutely no holidays abroad, most people didn’t go to university. So the question is totally irrelevant to today’s society.
sst1234 · 08/08/2021 10:45

It’s unreasonable to expect that 50% of the adult population could economically inactive and the economy still function the way we want it to. We can’t have it k no it’s ways, half the economic activity means half the lifestyle.

C8H10N4O2 · 08/08/2021 10:30

[quote Jellycatspyjamas]@Monkeybusinesss I’m not sure why you’re getting stroppy with me, I’m not the only person who cites lifestyle as being part of the issue. The point I was making is that lifestyle was much simpler, with way fewer expectations on what would be considered essential. So if you’re saying should one salary be enough to cover housing, food and essentials you really need to be able define what’s essential, and those goalposts have shifted immeasurably in the last 30 years (when it would be much more usual to have one salary cover a families living costs).[/quote]
Ah yes.
Millennials just need to stop with the avocado on toast to be able to buy a mansion in Notting Hill.

Or we could acknowledge that basic housing costs have inflated massively more than salaries in the last 30-40 yrs, social housing and good quality professional private rental stocks have been denuded and stop pretending that young people's lifestyles are the cause of inflated house prices.

NeverTalkToStrangers · 08/08/2021 10:27

Family Income Supplement was introduced in 1970 to support the working poor. I’m not sure it’s ever been possible for a family of four to live comfortably but frugally on a single unskilled labour/minimum wage income although the current levels of housing cost have definitely made it far more difficult.

I blame Thatcher. Thirty five years on we’re still seeing the impact of right to buy.

C8H10N4O2 · 08/08/2021 10:24

@MauveMagnolia

My house cost £6000 in 1970. It was bought by a male teacher and his housewife, wife. A male teacher earned about £1600 (women earned less)

It was sold in 2006 for £570,000. A teacher earned £29,500

Today it is a million. A teacher earns £35,000

One of the by products of most families having 2 working adults is house price inflation.

Yes housing costs are behind a great deal of the financial struggles for young people.

As a graduate first year employee in the public sector I was (just) able to get a mortgage and afford a decent two bedroom flat in a mansion block with gardens, in a decent area of zone 3 in London.

That same job starting salary has gone up approx 3. The price of the flat has gone up 18

Interest rates were higher in the 80s but we had MIRAS to offset interest (double if you were not married at one point).

More social housing is desperately needed. Selling off all the good quality social housing created a cottage industry of hobby landlords and profiteering from first time buyer type properties. The lack of decent social housing combined with lack of security in private rental market results in people feeling pressured to buy when in most of Europe they would live in rented more securely.

All of this is independent of the single earner argument. I don't think women should drop out of the job market and take a massive risk when they do. However when I look at colleagues in Scandinavia and Benelux countries then both parents downsizing jobs to 3 or 4 days a week when children are young I wish it was an affordable option in the UK.