Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think one adult should be able to support a family with a full time job?

265 replies

Kendodd · 07/08/2021 22:04

Talking about a normal size family, two/three children. Not talking about riches either, just an ordinary place to live and everyone well fed and clothed, all needs covered without state benefits. Any full time job as well, not just some fancy high paid thing.
I know for lots of people working really hard in full time jobs supporting their family just isn't possible on the money.

YANBU - they should be able to support a family.
YABU - they shouldn't be able to have a home and children on an unskilled job.

OP posts:
vivainsomnia · 09/08/2021 09:51

Or we could acknowledge that basic housing costs have inflated massively more than salaries in the last 30-40 yrs, social housing and good quality professional private rental stocks have been denuded and stop pretending that young people's lifestyles are the cause of inflated house prices
Nobody is saying that they struggle only because of their lifestyle, we are saying that if they didn't expect the lifestyle they feel they deserve, they might find that they do ok despite the inflated house prices. After all, many do manage.

You can't control the house market, not directly, but you certainly can control how many luxuries you get.

TempleofZoom · 09/08/2021 09:40

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken

It’s not about “I want”. It’s about basic human rights.

If you are in low paid unskilled work

So people in low paid unskilled work should not bother working at all? Or not have children?

What about people in low paid unskilled work who find themselves as the only adult in the home?

The reality is that one low wage is unlikely to support a family of 4 -its always been thus. Its not a new concept. The myth of the man working and the woman as SAHM. All the women I know have WOH and in some cases in it, to provide for their families. Its simply a case of womens work being unrecognised. The vast majority of families need 2 wages unless there is one high earner. I didnt say low paid workers shouldnt work but in a family then both will need to WOH. As I said previously single parents need support but actually child support laws need tightening.
AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 09/08/2021 09:23

It’s not about “I want”. It’s about basic human rights.

If you are in low paid unskilled work

So people in low paid unskilled work should not bother working at all? Or not have children?

What about people in low paid unskilled work who find themselves as the only adult in the home?

TempleofZoom · 09/08/2021 09:18

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken

How is it a strange mindset to believe that if an adult works full time hours, they should be able to expect that that wage should support their family?
Because life just doesnt work like that! "I want" Erm no thats not how it works. If you are in low paid unskilled work or starting out in a career then you just wont earn enough for one person to support a family of 4 on your own. Every woman in my family for generations has worked, its a myth that women didnt work, it just wasnt recognised.

Totally agree that single/ disabled parents should get help but actually that both parents are responsible and laws on supporting DC adequately should be tightened.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 09/08/2021 09:09

How is it a strange mindset to believe that if an adult works full time hours, they should be able to expect that that wage should support their family?

TempleofZoom · 09/08/2021 09:02

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken

If they can afford to make a lifestyle choice to have one parent at home, and both partners want that set-up, then that's totally fair enough, but I don't think it's a right to live like that.

Why not? Why shouldn’t people have the right to support their family financially if they’re working full time?

What a strange mindset Confused It comes down to you either earn enough or you dont.
AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 09/08/2021 08:38

If they can afford to make a lifestyle choice to have one parent at home, and both partners want that set-up, then that's totally fair enough, but I don't think it's a right to live like that.

Why not? Why shouldn’t people have the right to support their family financially if they’re working full time?

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 09/08/2021 08:37

I don't understand the comment about working away. My DH spent large chunks of the year away pre-pandemic. That didn't stop me from pursuing my own career. True, it would be difficult - perhaps impossible - to sustain two roles where a lot of travelling is required, but it is still perfectly possible for the other partner to work, just as many single parents manage to hold down a job without a partner around.

The question isn’t whether the partner left at home should be able to work, it’s whether they should HAVE to work.

AlexaShutUp · 09/08/2021 08:07

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken

What about families where one parent works away? Oil rigs Long distance lorry drivers The army Laggers

Are these families given a pass in your judgement to have one parent not work? Or should these families also find a way to have both parents work 30 hpw?

Some of these comments are so ego centric. There are other families and situations outside of your bubbles where the parents can’t just work harder to get a promotion and more money. Families where both parents working isn’t a viable option. Families where there is only one parent so a two adult wage is not viable.

It should be possible to raise a family and have a good quality of life on one wage. It’s insane that we’ve conditioned to believe otherwise.

I don't understand the comment about working away. My DH spent large chunks of the year away pre-pandemic. That didn't stop me from pursuing my own career. True, it would be difficult - perhaps impossible - to sustain two roles where a lot of travelling is required, but it is still perfectly possible for the other partner to work, just as many single parents manage to hold down a job without a partner around.

I would like to see a much better benefits system in place to support parents who cannot work due to disability - either their own or that of a child. Better support for parents who are widowed. And better enforcement to ensure that absent parents pay a fair share for their children. However, the reality is that most children have two parents, so it seems reasonable to expect that both parents will share financial responsibility for them. If they can afford to make a lifestyle choice to have one parent at home, and both partners want that set-up, then that's totally fair enough, but I don't think it's a right to live like that.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 09/08/2021 07:56

What about families where one parent works away?
Oil rigs
Long distance lorry drivers
The army
Laggers

Are these families given a pass in your judgement to have one parent not work? Or should these families also find a way to have both parents work 30 hpw?

Some of these comments are so ego centric. There are other families and situations outside of your bubbles where the parents can’t just work harder to get a promotion and more money. Families where both parents working isn’t a viable option. Families where there is only one parent so a two adult wage is not viable.

It should be possible to raise a family and have a good quality of life on one wage. It’s insane that we’ve conditioned to believe otherwise.

nancydroo · 09/08/2021 07:51

My DH works full time and we have two kids. I worked until last year full time but became burnt out and left. It has been an adjustment and budgeting is tight. It would be easier if all four of us stopped having ideas of more things to spend money on e.g. clubs, furniture, decorating. Then we might be able to continue to muddle along.

Namenic · 09/08/2021 07:40

Why not aspire to flexible contracts? Some people want/need to work longer hours (eg saving for a deposit or teenage children) whereas some need shorter hours (eg young kids, or children with special needs).

But the main problem is one of supply. Council should mandate time limits for developers, so they must get the houses built by a certain date, or the land is repossessed (to prevent building companies trickling houses in to keep profits high).

toconclude · 08/08/2021 21:24

@Stanleyville

Rather than one person work and one person not why don't we aspire to all people working fewer hours? That's potentially good for all of society.

I don't think a sahp dynamic is particularly healthy when compared to an alternative of both parents caring and earning.

100pc agree. Problem is, employers don't want this.
Whycangirlsbesonasty · 08/08/2021 20:36

If a couple of teachers/ nurses / police can’t afford to buy a 3 bed house in an ok area in which to bring up their kids then capable people will look to other careers, at a cost to all of society. We shouldn’t underestimate the damage high house prices do to our country.

Snog · 08/08/2021 19:17

I'm an advocate of the four day week as a standard for everyone, so both parents would typically work 30 hours a week which should cover childcare costs and a basic standard of living even at minimum wage.

We also need to build a lot more houses with secure tenancies.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 08/08/2021 18:05

[quote Monkeybusinesss]@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken
Yeah ain’t that the truth.
If Someone said you might have to sleep on a coat (likely…) charity shops sells sheets, but that’s by the by. I would JUMP at the chance to have a mortgage.[/quote]
I’ve already got sheets and a full house of furniture. A mortgage 2x my wage (or my husband’s) would be a fucking dream!

Monkeybusinesss · 08/08/2021 17:54

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken
Yeah ain’t that the truth.
If Someone said you might have to sleep on a coat (likely…) charity shops sells sheets, but that’s by the by. I would JUMP at the chance to have a mortgage.

MotionActivatedDog · 08/08/2021 17:46

it is nice to dream of a world of work where one income could support a family BUT no-one would give up their holidays and fancy cars /houses to just get by

What are you talking about?? Plenty of people don’t have holidays or fancy cars or houses on two incomes!

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 08/08/2021 16:25

OP - it is nice to dream of a world of work where one income could support a family BUT no-one would give up their holidays and fancy cars /houses to just get by (which is what that life would be like)
People's expectations are now way too high

This has made me quite angry. Most people I know don’t have nice holidays abroad or fancy cars. They’re all teachers, nurses, police officers, council workers, call centre workers whose rent is so high they can’t afford these luxuries and don’t even have the choice to give them up in order to save a house deposit.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 08/08/2021 16:20

@bunnybuggs

I bought my first house (terraced for £7,500) in 1978 - as a single parent with a 3 year old. I borrowed twice my salary (computer programming ) of £3500 and paid a deposit from my savings In those days - there were high interest rates, high tax rates and no help in the way of tax credits, subsidised childcare etc. As I single parent I did get a bit extra family allowance/child benefit and a slightly increased tax personal allowance. I moved in with second hand castoffs for furniture and used coats on the bed. I could not afford a holiday and my income was equal to my outgoings (including childminder) so no fancy car either, It did get better but it was tough for a good few years. I cannot see anyone tolerating that kind of life these days and quite rightly too. I had no choice and my life was not that differant or harder than anyone else trying to get by at that time - no thought of unfairness or envy.

OP - it is nice to dream of a world of work where one income could support a family BUT no-one would give up their holidays and fancy cars /houses to just get by (which is what that life would be like)
People's expectations are now way too high

I would happily, happily live this way for a few years to have a mortgage that was two times my annual salary. I don’t know anyone who wouldn’t!
bunnybuggs · 08/08/2021 16:01

I bought my first house (terraced for £7,500) in 1978 - as a single parent with a 3 year old. I borrowed twice my salary (computer programming ) of £3500 and paid a deposit from my savings
In those days - there were high interest rates, high tax rates and no help in the way of tax credits, subsidised childcare etc. As I single parent I did get a bit extra family allowance/child benefit and a slightly increased tax personal allowance.
I moved in with second hand castoffs for furniture and used coats on the bed. I could not afford a holiday and my income was equal to my outgoings (including childminder) so no fancy car either,
It did get better but it was tough for a good few years.

I cannot see anyone tolerating that kind of life these days and quite rightly too. I had no choice and my life was not that differant or harder than anyone else trying to get by at that time - no thought of unfairness or envy.

OP - it is nice to dream of a world of work where one income could support a family BUT no-one would give up their holidays and fancy cars /houses to just get by (which is what that life would be like)
People's expectations are now way too high

MurielSpriggs · 08/08/2021 15:45

For minimum wage to cover the cost of housing, it would have to be massive in the SE and other high-rent areas.

Which would just put house prices up!

AllTheSingleLadiess · 08/08/2021 14:43

A full time minimum wage job should be able to support one adult without top ups.

RickJames · 08/08/2021 14:39

I was working with a Works Council manager in a big German firm, a couple of years ago. We were looking at payslips and I was translating them into English for her.

It was very surprising. The heavily unionised manual workers were subsidised for everything from having to change clothes before and after a shift, free canteen food to unsociable hours. In effect they paid no tax because it was made up by the subsidies, 3000€ was pretty much 3000€ take home. The white collar workers were taxed to the bone with no subsidies. Despite earning technically, a lot less, the manual labourers were coming out with a good wage that you easily run a family on plus they would be paying low wage rates for child care etc.

So that's my observation. In the 1970's in the UK unionisation protected the wages that manual workers did earn and therefore, with a bit of budgeting, you could run a family on one wage. Nowadays, employment is a bit of a free for all with 0 hours contracts and stuff. Although, there are top-ups and tax credits...

But ultimately, rent and house prices are ridiculous now and not in step with wages so I think even the most amazing union wouldn't achieve much.

YANBU but I think its just the way things are now.

LakieLady · 08/08/2021 14:34

@Antsinyourpanta

* The reality is that lots of peoplewillspend their entire working life earning minimum wage for various reasons. Minimum wage should be enough to maintain your own life, for life. Housing, food, heat, clothing, toiletries, travel to work or to see your mum, and the odd night out, day out, trip to the cinema is really not an unreasonable expectation to have for a very basic life.*

I think that's reasonable,but its different to supporting yourself, a partner and 2 or 3 children. (Has Minimum wage been enough for this in previous generations? Or did it not exist?)

For minimum wage to cover the cost of housing, it would have to be massive in the SE and other high-rent areas.