Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIBU to think one adult should be able to support a family with a full time job?

265 replies

Kendodd · 07/08/2021 22:04

Talking about a normal size family, two/three children. Not talking about riches either, just an ordinary place to live and everyone well fed and clothed, all needs covered without state benefits. Any full time job as well, not just some fancy high paid thing.
I know for lots of people working really hard in full time jobs supporting their family just isn't possible on the money.

YANBU - they should be able to support a family.
YABU - they shouldn't be able to have a home and children on an unskilled job.

OP posts:
Antsinyourpanta · 12/08/2021 09:23

But FWIW I do think that paying every single worker enough to comfortably support a family of four or five would unbalance the economy in favour of single people incalculably, and probably also have negative effects on the women incentivised to stay home. I don’t think it’s ever been the case in the UK.

If everyone was paid enough to support a family of 4 or 5 the costs of goods and services would probably go up dramatically.

AlexaShutUp · 12/08/2021 09:22

[quote AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken]@AlexaShutUp
But why shouldn’t one person be able to support a small family? That is what you’re arguing for. That they should struggle. That they should have to rely on benefits after working a full week.[/quote]
No, I'm not arguing that anyone should struggle. I just think it's really odd to expect that minimum wage should be enough to support not only the person who earns that salary and a fair contribution towards the cost of their children, but another non-working adult as well.

It takes two to start a family, so why wouldn't both parents expect to work to support that family? I have already said that there we need better systems in place to pursue non-resident parents for child maintenance, and I would like to see much better state support for those who are widowed or where one parent is unable to work due to disability etc.

I just don't understand why anyone would expect to be able to afford a SAHP with one parent on minimum wage.

sst1234 · 12/08/2021 09:18

[quote AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken]@AlexaShutUp
But why shouldn’t one person be able to support a small family? That is what you’re arguing for. That they should struggle. That they should have to rely on benefits after working a full week.[/quote]
Because it’s not the 1950s anymore when only 50% of the population was working outside the home. Things have moved on. It is ok for to expect both parents to earn and parent.

Heliachi · 12/08/2021 09:10

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk guidelines.

NeverTalkToStrangers · 12/08/2021 09:07

Saying that it’s acceptable for single earner lower waged parents to rely on (humanely administered) state top ups for a short period of time is not the same as saying that they “shouldn’t” be paid more.

But FWIW I do think that paying every single worker enough to comfortably support a family of four or five would unbalance the economy in favour of single people incalculably, and probably also have negative effects on the women incentivised to stay home. I don’t think it’s ever been the case in the UK.

Disneycharacter · 12/08/2021 09:00

We did when first married. We couldn't afford nice holidays, I had to scrimp around charity shops, couldn't buy the nicest food and so on. Only 1 old rickety car. Got a job and our standard of living soared. Nicer house with mortgage, kids had better lifestyles, less financial stress etc.

Like all things in life it's a compromise and the 'government' has more important priorities than supporting family life and the choices people make. If you choose to have 5 children you work to support them, not rely on social housing and handouts.

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 12/08/2021 08:52

@AlexaShutUp
But why shouldn’t one person be able to support a small family? That is what you’re arguing for. That they should struggle. That they should have to rely on benefits after working a full week.

AlexaShutUp · 12/08/2021 08:34

[quote AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken]@sst1234

Not at all. People are basically saying, it’s tough shit that people in low wages can’t afford to pay for cheaper housing, basic healthy food, cheaper clothes, a little uk holiday once a year, because they should work harder for promotion or live in shared accommodation without families.
It’s a disgusting attitude.

I strongly believe that it should be possible for an adult who works full time, to earn enough to provide a basic but decent standard of living for a small family of three or four.

If you believe that low paid, unskilled workers should have to be reliant on state top ups, or that they should live in bedsits or in shared accommodation alone until they have pulled themselves up by their bootstraps, I can only assume that you think they are not worth the same standard of living as the rest of us or that their jobs don’t matter enough to get paid an actual living wage. When in actual fact, they’re doing some of the most important work.[/quote]
I don't think any of those things at all. I just think that, if there are two capable adults, both of them should work to support their families unless they can afford the luxury of one person opting out. It has nothing to do with them not being "worth" the same standard of living as the rest of us, whatever that means, because the default for many of "the rest of us" is also that both parents should work.

To be clear I absolutely believe that two parents earning full time minimum wage should be able to enjoy a decent standard of living... healthy food, a safe and comfortable home, opportunities to have fun with their children etc. I just think it's reasonable to expect both partners to work for that. For families where it isn't possible to have two incomes for whatever reason, then the state should step in to ensure that they too can still enjoy that decent standard of living.

notanothertakeaway · 12/08/2021 08:09

If I were in charge, I wouldn't allow people to own a second home that sits empty for large periods of time

If these houses were sold, then there would be greater supply, therefore house prices would fall, therefore more affordable housing

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 12/08/2021 07:24

The question is “should” they be able to. Not “do you think there’ll ever be a time when…”

If you think they shouldn’t be able to, and it’s not because you think they’re worthless, why on earth would you not want that?

AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken · 12/08/2021 07:01

@sst1234

Not at all. People are basically saying, it’s tough shit that people in low wages can’t afford to pay for cheaper housing, basic healthy food, cheaper clothes, a little uk holiday once a year, because they should work harder for promotion or live in shared accommodation without families.
It’s a disgusting attitude.

I strongly believe that it should be possible for an adult who works full time, to earn enough to provide a basic but decent standard of living for a small family of three or four.

If you believe that low paid, unskilled workers should have to be reliant on state top ups, or that they should live in bedsits or in shared accommodation alone until they have pulled themselves up by their bootstraps, I can only assume that you think they are not worth the same standard of living as the rest of us or that their jobs don’t matter enough to get paid an actual living wage. When in actual fact, they’re doing some of the most important work.

sst1234 · 12/08/2021 01:34

@Kendodd

Men get away with providing paltry CS and just walk away. There should be a massive overhaul of the system and they should be held responsible. Completely agree but think this is a separate issue. Two incomes should provide a better financial lifestyle. Bigger house, meals out, holidays etc. I don't think it's right that it should take two incomes to get by, that should be doable on one income imo.
What a bizarre argument. It takes two to create a family. Why should it take only one income to get the standard of living you expect in 21st century. Like others have said again and again, one income can support a family but you would need to dial back the clock to 1960s standard of living.
sst1234 · 12/08/2021 01:29

@AllTheUsernamesAreAlreadyTaken

It’s so sad how worthless so many posters deem low paid workers as well as the jobs they do
Are you just shoe horning this statement in for dramatic effect or did anyone actually say this.
abstractprojection · 11/08/2021 20:00

Of course it should be though personally I think it would be ideal if both parents could work but less so a balanced mix of nursery, time with each parent and time together as a family. This is what my OH and myself are aiming for

ancientgran · 11/08/2021 16:10

@Kendodd

They totally and completely deserve tax credits to be able to indeed support their family. Why should the tax payer fund low pay? I read once that the amount Philip Green spent on his third superyacht was equivalent to the amount of tax credits paid to BHS staff so they could feed their children. And the increase in Geoff Bazo's wealth, just during the pandemic would have been enough to give 900,000+ Amazon employees a bonus of over $100,000 each. Those figures might not be completely accurate, but they're close enough and you get the just.
People seem to think the low paid and benefits is something new. My husband joined the police force in the late 60s. For the next ten years it was common for officers with children to be claiming supplementary benefit and that was on top of family allowance (child benefit) and double rent allowance for a married officer.

It was also common for officers to have 2nd jobs.

onlychildhamster · 09/08/2021 14:47

Also the basis of comparison can be completely different. My MIL bought a 3 bed terrace in zone 3 north london in 1997 on a single salary, the neighbours were druggies. My Dh remembers a little girl in torn clothes gnawing on a chicken bone in the neighbour's garden and when the house was sold, cocaine was found in the boiler. Today, the same house is worth in excess of 750k and while it isn't naice in the conventional sense, the people who buy homes on that street tend to be professionals and its actually considered a fairly decent area. There are a lot of anecdotes on Mumsnet of single income families who managed to buy houses in Hackney and other areas of zone 2 london. The thing is, those areas were considered bad areas in the past but now that they are all gentrified, it does attract people from wealthier backgrounds as compared to 20 years ago.

So when you say' my mum was a nurse but could afford to raise 2 kids and managed to buy a house in South London', south london is quite a different place these days!

strivingtosucceed · 09/08/2021 14:30

I'm not sure how realistic it is to expect to raise a family of four on one minimum wage even if you get UC. I grew up in the 90s tbf but I don't remember anyone with a SAHP living in super nice houses or having foreign holidays. Both my parents worked in decent jobs and I still had to share a bedroom with my sister.

I think a lot depends on what you consider a minimum lifestyle, is owning your own home a right? Separate beds for the kids? Frequent trips/meals out (adds up with 4 people)? Tesco v aldi shops? Middle of a bustling city? Would it make sense for a single person to earn enough for all of this as the absolute minimum?

TempleofZoom · 09/08/2021 13:33

Agree Jax
Both my DP WOH, although Mums job wasnt really ever mentioned and we had a standard 3 bed in the 70s.
Drove an old car( one) holidays camping or staying with relatives.
Second hand everything, everything cooked from scratch.
Fish and chips once a month.
I dont recall eating out.
Flasks , egg sarnies and a wagon wheel on a day out.
That was fun on a warm day Grin

cultkid · 09/08/2021 13:17

It should be like this I whole heartedly agree

vivainsomnia · 09/08/2021 13:14

But the OP is specifically excluding state benefits viv. She’s saying that society should be arranged so that a single low skilled job should be sufficient to support a family of four or five without any UC/tax credits at all, and is lamenting that this is currently not the case
Fair enough, but ultimately, it doesn't make that much difference because if you do work 40h at NMW and stick to the 2 children rule, unless you live somewhere very expensive, you are probably not getting much in UC anyway.

The issue is when people work less than 40 hours, with many considering 30h to be FT, and those who think they are entitled to 4 or 5 children. Inevitably, the more children, the less able is the second partner to work and make it worthwhile financially, and 5 children obviously cost much more than 2.

But as already stated, you can't really administer a NMW for those with families but single get to earn less for the same job, so it does make sense to have a system in place that looks at individual cases and provide additional income to allow them to support the family.

I'm pleased though that they raised the criteria as being entitled to only 16h or even 24h was utterly ridiculous. I still feel it's ridiculous to base it on NMW, so that someone earning more can still work less than FT and claim UC. This is wrong.

AlexaShutUp · 09/08/2021 12:58

The OP has raised a more interesting debate about what should happen where that is not the case, where one parent is required to care for young or disabled children because their salaries won’t cover professional childcare. Or where one parent can’t work due to disability, mental illness, addiction, imprisonment or death, or has skipped the country. That’s a lot of families.

Personally, I think that's where state support should kick in.

If employers had to pay all of their staff enough to cover these eventualities, just in case, the reality is that there would be fewer jobs all round.

AlexaShutUp · 09/08/2021 12:55

Personally, I think that minimum wage should be enough to support half the costs of providing for an average sized family, eg one adult and one child. I don't think it's reasonable to expect to be able to support the relative luxury of having one partner at home on minimum wage. I really don't see that as a fundamental right.

onlychildhamster · 09/08/2021 12:48

I don't have that view because my mum/dh's mum always worked. And it was hard for dh's mum to support a family on her single wage in the 1990s even if her house cost £100k.

I also think that women should work even if it's to increase tax revenues. We have an ageing population and unless we want the retirement age to be 85, we should encourage most people to work. What I would say is we should make part time childcare hours more affordable so that if parents want to go part time to spend more time with kids, they can afford to. This would also help full time working mothers too. Also now that pensions are so much lower in real terms than they used to be, no one can depend on their spouse's pension so accumulating more working years is probably better.

Do you also mean that the single working person's pension has to support an elderly couple into their 90s. That's a quite tall order!

NeverTalkToStrangers · 09/08/2021 12:32

@TempleofZoom

Why is it a separate issue? Pp was insisting that a single parent in a low paid job should magically be able to provide for her DC alone. Why when there is another parent who is equally responsible for those children ? It perpetuates this shitty system of feckless men breeding and walking away.
I don’t think you’re going to get any disagreement on here that if there are two biological parents who are able to earn and support their child then they should both do that, and the UK government does a very poor job of enforcing that principle.

The OP has raised a more interesting debate about what should happen where that is not the case, where one parent is required to care for young or disabled children because their salaries won’t cover professional childcare. Or where one parent can’t work due to disability, mental illness, addiction, imprisonment or death, or has skipped the country. That’s a lot of families.

Also what should happen where the father is “unknown”? What pressure should the state exert to discover their identity?

Jaxhog · 09/08/2021 12:19

@sayanythingelse

It SHOULD be but it isn't.

My mum never worked after having children and we lived comfortably on my dad's salary working in a factory. We had a nice house, holidays abroad and never wanted for anything.

DH works 60 hours a week and I've just cut down to 20 to make childcare easier. We lived in a rented house because even though we have a deposit, we don't earn enough between us to get a big enough mortgage for a 3 bed semi.
We live comfortably but we don't have money for extras now I'm part time. We could never live a life on one salary like my parents did.

I'm intrigued by this. My Dad was a senior academic and my mum a nurse. We were 4 kids living in a nice but falling down house in the NW and had only ONE foreign holiday in all the years I was growing up. (Others were camping in the UK) No way could we have survived if my Mum hadn't worked.