Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If it’s that bad, why aren’t we panicking more??

911 replies

Nightgardenisodd · 07/08/2021 20:59

Climate change.
I keep reading posts about it and it’s scaring the crap out of me for my DD’s future.
How bad is it? Anyone have any positivity about it?

OP posts:
worriedatthemoment · 12/08/2021 12:11

@jasjas1973 how was it caused by people in the 50 and 60's they had much less than we do now and lived much greener life's as such ?

worriedatthemoment · 12/08/2021 12:09

Also were people not greener years ago
Drinks came in glass bottles that people returned , gas heating didn't really exsist, cars were owned by a few, people mostly walked and worked / shopped locally bought meat from butchers , veg from greengrocers in quantity they needed and wasted very little , a joint of meat was all used up and often several meals, hardly anyone flew
These are just a few I can think of.
Yet people are saying what happening now is due to people in 50/60's etc , how when they had less and lived much simpler life's

worriedatthemoment · 12/08/2021 12:04

Ironic that all those posting are on an unnecessary laptop or iphone even of for work use , being on mn using up battery and needing to charge later is all not needed
If we are going to change as people on here say that means everything cut back not just well I am a vegan so I am doing my bit
Im not an eco warrior and science always contradicts , one scientist says one thing another something else
Many of us switched to diesel due to scientists telling us it was better for the environment , now they say different

worriedatthemoment · 12/08/2021 11:57

@Cam77 where is your proof with this ?

randomlyLostInWales · 12/08/2021 11:50

Environmental collapse has already started and we were too busy inventing smart phones and new single use plastics.

The world population looks like it will peak sooner than previous predictions:World population likely to shrink after mid-century

Share of renewable energy more than doubled between 2004 and 2019 been there have been massive technolgical improvement in solar pannels , we're increasingly switching to electric cars and the infrasture is slowly catching up, there's thought and investment going on around greening flying or reducing it there's new ideas out there like Fungus packaging, household appliances are increasingly energy efficient and overall energy consuption has dropped over decades in uk there's increasing awareness around clothes
and fabic production - there's lot of technolgical and social change going on.

I do think it serious - history is littered with cilvizations that collapsed due to factors all exacerbated or caused by climate change but over pessimistic assements are as bad as someone else should make changes not me it's seeking justification to individual inertia - it's another reason why governments need to step in not only with big overviews and longterm aims but also with incentives, laws and trying to remove barries people may face that ensure green changes over the whole population are made where it will have an effect though they have a tough job balancing short term prioties and effects with long term ones.

I do agree with less cars and more public transport investment and more joined up servcies.

Though there's a "green journalist" who lives in London and writes he can't manage without a car partly due to grown children needing lifts and cats needing to be taken to vets - I don't get this I've lived all over UK small towns, cities yet we manage with pets that need to get to vets and children who need to get various locations and job that require us in at some point all without any kind of car or anyone to give us lifts.

Ibelieveinghosts · 12/08/2021 11:12

[quote jasjas1973]@Ibelieveinghosts

Possibly i did but the climate changes we are experiencing now are the results of what previous generations have done.

The changes ocean current because of ice melt were apparent in the 80s, caused by things we did in the 50s and 60s if not before :(

But of course i agree we need to use tech to reduce GH gasses.

I wonder what the CO2 emissions are of millions of UK holiday makers travelling around the UK, stuck in hours of queues, heating on max drying out clothing, compared to 1000s of flights to Spain etc.[/quote]
Absolutely, but unfortunately we can’t change the past. What we need to do now is change the present to have a better effect on tomorrow.

The amount of cars on the road is ridiculous, we need to be making better use of public transport. Subsidising the rail network so going by train is as cheap as currently going by car. It should be really expensive to go anywhere by car. People used to go on holiday on the train all the time.people used to walk miles each day, but the speed of life now doesn’t permit it.

We need to alter how we live our lives entirely so they are no longer predicated on speed and having stuff. We just fill our lives with shit.

Lockdown was an absolute blessing in this respect, I’m horrified how quickly people are back to how they were. It’s like they’ve been programmed to live a certain way by a nasty computer virus and even on a total reboot that virus has just reappeared.

Doomscrolling · 12/08/2021 10:40

In all honesty I think civilisation will collapse in the coming decades. We had the chance in the 80s to address it and didn’t; 40 more years of polluting the planet. We’re past the tipping point now.

Environmental collapse has already started and we were too busy inventing smart phones and new single use plastics.

woodhill · 12/08/2021 10:31

@MercyBooth

Heat networks are now in developments across the UK as a key part of the sector's zero carbon drive. But residents living with these systems are facing huge bills and often weeks/months without hot water.
Sounds awful.
jasjas1973 · 12/08/2021 10:28

@Ibelieveinghosts

Possibly i did but the climate changes we are experiencing now are the results of what previous generations have done.

The changes ocean current because of ice melt were apparent in the 80s, caused by things we did in the 50s and 60s if not before :(

But of course i agree we need to use tech to reduce GH gasses.

I wonder what the CO2 emissions are of millions of UK holiday makers travelling around the UK, stuck in hours of queues, heating on max drying out clothing, compared to 1000s of flights to Spain etc.

Ibelieveinghosts · 12/08/2021 10:02

@jasjas1973

The thing is it’s not want people want anymore. Growing up my bedroom had no heating, the single paned window was cracked and you could see your breath in the air, my uncle went to Spain and it was like he had visited the moon, I first went abroad aged 22. It was summer when strawberries hit the shops (PYO was a massive treat of a day out). Clothes were generally hand me downs

All of this was fine because it’s how people lived. All of this is fucking brilliant compared to the alternative

Might have seemed Green but everything made had huge environmental cost, fossil fuels used were partially burnt at low temps, waste was dumps in rivers etc and all your 'lecky came from filthy coal again poorly burnt.

Even that flight was in a plane that was hugely inefficient and he stayed in a hotel with AC powered by.... see above!

All the local growers here in the Tamar valley burnt wood then oil to heat green houses, the place stank of unburnt fuel :( sewage sprayed on the land and/or pumped into the Tamar..

Thats before we get onto lead and family cars that did 30 to the gallon.

I think you missed the point of my post though. It wasn’t that we were more environmentally friendly back then it’s what the accepted norms were back then. Imagine if we could put up with those temperatures with more environmentally friendly fuel rather than using it up to sit at 25 degrees in a t shirt. All power puts some drain on the planet. Imagine if people didn’t fly so often but the flights they did take were on very environmentally transport.

We should be using technology to improve things not as an excuse to carry on and do even more of the damaging things!

Mousetown · 12/08/2021 08:57

@Sloth66

Look at some of the threads on mumsnet this week. Posters planning on having three, four children or more, and being cheered on. It’s clear they couldn’t care less about what is happening to the planet, and are in denial. they will continue to do what they want.
Absolutely. I am so done with being polite about it. Having so many children should be socially unacceptable. People should be made to feel uncomfortable about their choices. It’s nothing to celebrate.
Sloth66 · 12/08/2021 08:43

Look at some of the threads on mumsnet this week. Posters planning on having three, four children or more, and being cheered on.
It’s clear they couldn’t care less about what is happening to the planet, and are in denial. they will continue to do what they want.

Walkaround · 12/08/2021 08:41

The only reason the UK produces 1% of the carbon emissions is because we are no longer a manufacturing nation - we import stuff. It’s a lie that we are responsible for only 1%, as that would only be true if we didn’t buy almost all our manufactured goods from other countries. China is only such a big emitter because it makes stuff the rest of the world is buying from it - and not just stuff we “don’t need.” It’s bloody hypocritical to point the finger at China when a huge proportion of the stuff we are using was manufactured, at the very least in part, in China. We have also been drowning poorer countries in our plastic waste. We import goods and manufactured parts we claim to be green, because the polluting bit was largely done elsewhere, then export as much of the pollution we do create here as possible.

Ibelieveinghosts · 12/08/2021 08:12

@DGRossetti and this materialistic ever “improving” technology driven empire is due to fall but people would rather turn a blind eye than accept the inevitable cycles of history.

Ibelieveinghosts · 12/08/2021 08:08

@Mousetown

There is a woman in my mumsnet birth group who, less than a year after giving birth, is pregnant with her 8th. People are falling over themselves telling her she is some kind of Wonder Woman. I think she is a selfish, ignorant idiot. I don’t even care if she reads this. Attitudes need to change.
Absolutely, this really gets my goat, it’s just reflective of the fact that deep down women are seen as successful of they produce lots of offspring and men are seen as successful if they manage to impregnate a woman multiple times. On the flip side it’s why single children are seen as negatively -we should be growing the tribe as much as possible.

Procreation is the single worst thing you can do for the environment-obviously it needs to happen to a level to continue the species but one child or (multiples) should be seen as the norm/ideal.

All these “whoops” baby number 7 on its way should be viewed alone the lines of “whoops just emptied 800 gallons of oil in the river”.

Nothing you ever do for the environment will compensate for the additional person you put on the planet.

DGRossetti · 12/08/2021 07:39

[quote Sarahlou63]@Justanotherlurker - precisely. Politicians of any hue are fucked; explain what's really coming down the line...lose votes/lose their seats = no influence.[/quote]
That's how empires fall ...

lannistunut · 12/08/2021 07:00

@Tumbleweed101 I thought covid showed the opposite Sad especially with not vaccinating poorer nations even though it will benefit us.

Tumbleweed101 · 12/08/2021 06:52

I think Covid has shown that globally we could all work together if we chose to. The response to that, especially during the early stage was quite globally dramatic and I wondered then if a similar global response could be made to climate.

Mousetown · 12/08/2021 06:43

There is a woman in my mumsnet birth group who, less than a year after giving birth, is pregnant with her 8th. People are falling over themselves telling her she is some kind of Wonder Woman. I think she is a selfish, ignorant idiot. I don’t even care if she reads this. Attitudes need to change.

wherearemychickens · 12/08/2021 06:27

And we are only a plague because of how we choose to live. We can choose differently!

wherearemychickens · 12/08/2021 06:26

I really don't get the 'at best we only make 1%' difference argument. I mean, all that says is it's a global problem and we are a tiny fraction of the globe. Um, yes. Even if it is 1% it's still a fuckton of carbon that we shouldn't be putting up there and we should be owning our shit. It's a moral problem not an 'I'll do it if you do it' economic one. It's looking your grandchildren in the eye and saying 'we did what we could' not 'sorry for the burnt and flooded planet you now live in, covered in plastic shit, with no wildlife left, we were waiting for everyone else to act and no one did'

Suzi888 · 12/08/2021 02:47

@Sarahlou63

Science is telling us loud and clear that the current level of pollution/warming/population is unsustainable. Humanity, in some form, will survive but in vastly reduced numbers. It's too late now to stop it.
^ this There are too many of us, we’re a plague.
emilylily · 12/08/2021 00:13

@Balgoresboy

''Agree with others who said there's not much point in me buying a bamboo toothbrush and walking to work, when places like China and Russia are producing more and more plastic and pollution and nobody is doing anything about it.''

yes but if everybody did little things,even a million people, it makes a difference.

At best the whole of the UK could make less than 1% difference.

BP popularised the phrase 'Carbon footprint' as a way of shifting public attention away from limiting the activities of fossil fuel companies and onto individual responsibility. They were very successful so now we all think that switching off the lights will save the world; it won't.

Balgoresboy · 11/08/2021 23:44

''Agree with others who said there's not much point in me buying a bamboo toothbrush and walking to work, when places like China and Russia are producing more and more plastic and pollution and nobody is doing anything about it.''

yes but if everybody did little things,even a million people, it makes a difference.

PickUpAPepper · 11/08/2021 23:37

"Make it so" Smile

Swipe left for the next trending thread