Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If it’s that bad, why aren’t we panicking more??

911 replies

Nightgardenisodd · 07/08/2021 20:59

Climate change.
I keep reading posts about it and it’s scaring the crap out of me for my DD’s future.
How bad is it? Anyone have any positivity about it?

OP posts:
ChardonnaysPetDragon · 13/08/2021 09:02

As i said, IF people really care, they won't be voting Tory or Labour, they'll intend to vote Green.

That’s not going to happen, their policies are utterly unhinged and unworkable.

We need the mainstream parties to have a sound environment policy, but that’s not a vote winner.,

jasjas1973 · 13/08/2021 08:48

@ChardonnaysPetDragon

A general election won't change anything for the better.

Both parties will be wary of the green agenda, it's expensive. It's not a vote winner, there is already moaning that it will cost too much for the Red/Blue wall and the traditional conservative middle class voters won't be happy to shoulder the whole cost.

It will be worse.

As i said, IF people really care, they won't be voting Tory or Labour, they'll intend to vote Green.

What would both parties do if the Greens were at 45% in the polls and all 3 main parties at 10 or 15% ?

You can bet your last vegan burger that policies would very quickly change.

But of course this won't happen, which is why i said earlier "people dont care" if they did, they wouldn't support the main parties because without political change (and not just in the UK) we wont begin to address this issue until it is far too late.

jasjas1973 · 13/08/2021 08:43

@Bluebellsinparadise

Most people don't give a fuck about Climate destruction, they are looking forward to hols, opening up hospitality etc

What a lovely attitude! How dismissive you are of the many people who live in the U.K. who probably have a lot of financial pressures and day to day worries that eclipse climate change. It’s a privilege to have the luxury of worrying about things other than how you’re going to pay the bills and put food on the table.

Also a lot of people can’t afford a holiday abroad or to eat out.

Most people don't live in penury in the UK, 40 million foreign trips were made by British people pre CV (many multiple trips)

Rich or poor, the vast majority people do not care about climate destruction or rather they are not willing to change any aspect of their lives.

You may not like that but that doesn't make it any less true.

wherearemychickens · 13/08/2021 07:58

An interesting facet to Brexit earlier this year for me was finding out how much of our waters were class 2 or whatever - basically unclean. Like the previous poster saying about the sewage flows into our rivers and seas. That should be unacceptable.

wherearemychickens · 13/08/2021 07:56

Doesn't a really really large proportion of the plastic waste in the sea come from the fishing industry? That's another reason not to support it.

wherearemychickens · 13/08/2021 07:55

That's a really impressive list. We do a lot of that but not as thoroughly or as well - have taken notes!

There's a difference between pasture fed and grain fed cows - my understanding is when cows eat the grass the roots underneath die off a little bit in response so you actually build up soil. That's where the really thick good soil on the plains of America - that we are now exhausting through industrialised agriculture and monocroppimg - came from. I would eat beef from cows raised in a regenerative farming pasture fed long rotation kind of system. I completely agree we shouldn't be eating grain or soy fed cows from industrial feedlots. I don't think we should be eating fish at all, unless it's things like mussels grown on ropes.

Bryonyshcmyony · 13/08/2021 07:53

@GreatAuntEmily

50% of all global co2 emissions are due to intensive animal farming *@afriusaenghather* Do you have a link for this?
This has been disproven very recently. I read something about it (something valid as well not a farmer's Facebook page)

Can't for the life of me think where though sorry

Bluebellsinparadise · 13/08/2021 07:49

@Fimofriend what an awesome list - and great ideas- thanks for sharing

Fimofriend · 13/08/2021 07:34

@afriusaenghather Here we go again. We talk about climate and immediately someone is aggressive. But since you demand to know what I do:

  • We still eat some fish and meat but have cut down a lot and have exchanged some of the red meat for chicken as it is better for the environment.
  • Eat leftovers. (This we have always done. We have always wasted very little food)
  • Have swapped 2/3 of our use of rice for pearl barley instead.
  • Grow a large portion of our own vegetables ourselves and make jam, cordial, and cider from our own produce. We have an allotment.
  • Buy more organic and local produce. Much of it from a shop which does not use plastic.
  • In general, going after food in containers made of cardboard or paper instead of plastic.
  • When we cook a ragout, we boil it for an hour and then cover the pot with towels for the remaining two hours instead of keeping it on low heat on the stove.
  • Turn off the oven a little before time and let the food finish on the remaining heat.
  • Stopped buying things that contain palm oil.
  • Primarily buying tea in one bigger bag instead of individual tea bags as a lot of them contain plastic.
  • Use shopping bags made out of textile instead of plastic. Most of them made with scraps we had. Most more than 20 years old.
  • Use bamboo toothbrushes and in general swap plastic for wood when we buy new things.
  • Always looking for the documented most environmentally friendly solutions whenever we buy something.
  • Environmentally friendly scrunges, and hardly any use of bleach.
  • Use scraps from old t-shirts for cleaning the house.
  • Kitchen cloths mainly knitted from second-hand cotton yarn. (Thanks mum)
  • Reuseable food wrapping such as lunch boxes and bee wax wrappings.
  • Compostable bin bags and we reuse the plastic bags from toilet paper as bin bags as well.
  • Composting
  • Sorting garbage. When something can be recycled but is not collected at our house we find a place to recycle it.
  • Have a low consumption and buy many items second-hand.
  • Donate unwanted items to charity shops.
  • Reuse and mend clothing and household items.
  • Keep clothes for many years.
  • Use washing nuts instead of washing powder. This is also good for your wallet as we are still on the one kilo of washing nuts we bought more than 3 years ago and that kilo cost the same as one kilo of washing powder.
  • Make my own dishwashing tablets from washing soda, baking soda, distilled vinegar, and Epsom salt to save the environment from the borax that is in almost all dishwashing tablets you can buy.
  • Dry the hanging outside whenever possible instead of using the dryer.
  • One of our cars is a hybrid. We only put fuel in that a couple of times a year. The other car we don't have to pay road tax on as it doesn't pollute much either.
  • Work from home when possible.
  • Walk to the shops instead of using a car when possible.
  • Choosing trains instead of cars whenever possible,
  • Turn off the lights in rooms we do not use.
  • Live in a well-insulated house, so less waste of power.
  • Put on a sweater instead of turning up the heat.
  • I have written to Aldi and Tesco to ask them to please sell items such as beans, rice, and oats in paper instead of plastic.
  • My husband has influenced his company to implement more heating-efficient solutions and I have influenced my company to change some of the things we buy to be more environmentally friendly.
  • Have influenced others to be more environmentally friendly. Two of our neighbours have now bought hybrid cars because they saw how well it worked for us and my inlaws have bought an electric car and have also clearly stated that we inspired them to do so. Two families we are friends with have switched over to washing nuts after seeing how well it worked for us.

It is now at a point where it is getting exceedingly more difficult to find more environmental solutions. Never the less we try. Shampoo bars didn't work for us. Our daughter and I just have too thick hair, I guess.

GreatAuntEmily · 13/08/2021 06:35

50% of all global co2 emissions are due to intensive animal farming
@afriusaenghather
Do you have a link for this?

Fimofriend · 13/08/2021 06:33

@Bluebellsinparadise I totally agree. However, I don't know how to engage everybody either. It did seem, though, as if David Attenborourgh's "Blue Planet" did get a larger group's attention.

HasaDigaEebowai · 13/08/2021 06:32

Wondering how vegans would deal with more competition for their food sources from billions of other humans? How would they farm sustainably on such a massive scale and what would they do with land that currently has cows and sheep on it?

It doesn’t work like that thankfully. Cows and sheep are the biggest problem. They are fed by farmers. The food we give to them contains protein. That protein is reduced over 20 times to convert it to meat protein. That food is edible for humans (soya). So for every kg of protein provided by beef you could get 20 times the amount by humans consuming the food directly.

Same space, masses more food.

BeachDrifting · 13/08/2021 05:57

I live in a pretty coastal town and I’m constantly getting alerts that it’s not safe to swim in the water. The water company pump sewage into the sea near the bathing area. That’s just one example of why this is bad. You wouldn’t expect that this would be a thing in the UK but it is. That’s just one example of why we have to be worried about all of this stuff because we can’t trust the people running things (like water companies) to do the right/best thing. In a river near here there are almost 30!! points where sewage goes in. It’s known about and kids get sick if they swim but nothing actually gets done. If they can’t sort/stop sewage going into our water then how the heck is something more complicated like climate change going to get sorted?

Walkaround · 13/08/2021 04:48

Wondering how vegans would deal with more competition for their food sources from billions of other humans? How would they farm sustainably on such a massive scale and what would they do with land that currently has cows and sheep on it?

PickUpAPepper · 13/08/2021 04:43

I don't eat meat.

Transportation is a major source of greenhouse gas emissions. That fact should not be ignored either. Much of the issue with transportation is optional to some degree or other - either due to optional travel, or optional choices about more or less efficient vehicles, or the choices made at a societal level to prioritise private over public transport for ideological reasons. Food is not optional to the same degree. Veganism is not as simple a matter environmentally as is sometimes claimed: while it would be more efficient to eat lower down the food chain, the physical land of Britain cannot produce all of the nutrition requirements that way. Vegan diets cause more food miles, and therefore involves more transportation.

afriusaenghather · 13/08/2021 04:36

50% of all global co2 emissions are due to intensive animal farming

All those on this thread being high and mighty about others car choices etc should ensure they are aware of this if they consume meat or dairy products.

Fishing - bottom trawling causes huge levels of co2, further over fishing our seas has removed important organisms that absorb massive co2 volumes.

I’m sick of idiots not realising that half our world issues are due to animal farming and abuse.

Very little benefit will be gained by driving a Tesla in comparison to worldwide vegan or vegetarianism.

It’s a fact. That most people choose to ignore.

PickUpAPepper · 13/08/2021 04:28

Electric cars are a huge efficiency improvement on petrol, a technology we have available now, and a far better stopgap than nuclear power for instance. Electricity can be produced through renewables: even without support the industry is beginning to prove itself economically superior.

afriusaenghather · 13/08/2021 04:25

I read someone on this thread saying as people don’t wear masks, what hope do we have. What an idiot! Your mask is adding to the waste cycle we have in all likelihood and your likely moaning about it whilst heading to the supermarket to buy steak or mince in plastic packaging that used so much water and emitted so much co2. Blind as fuck to the real issues!

Seriously. If you really really give a shit about climate change, go have a little look at the general vile responses that people get when they suggest to others not to eat meat.

Farming and fishing are overnight game changers in addressing not only co2 production but also absorption

The sea has the ability to suck up all our poisonous co2, but due to industrialised fishing we as humans have completely removed this benefit. The co2 produced from cows is off the scale.

If you really care, go vegetarian. You can still drive your petrol or diesel car, you can still use your heating. It would literally remove all the co2 excess production.

Have a research.

Electric cars will be the new diesel. We need hydrogen tech, not a pretend stop gap.

PickUpAPepper · 13/08/2021 04:16

The "failure" of "middle class" groups to "engage" lower classes is complex and difficult. I am from a working class background, followed the education route, have always been interested in environmental issues, and this question of how what becomes a marker of class identity frustrates me no end.

Lower class people are excluded by lack of wealth and a culture which simultaneously worships only wealth, power and greed. They also actively reject education as the preserve of wealth and having no inherent value. A culture that valued information and science more would not be in this position.

afriusaenghather · 13/08/2021 04:13

@Fimofriend

First of all there is plenty we can do as individuals. The mighty river is created by many small streams. People who says it doesn't matter if we buy bamboo toothbrushes i stead of plastic are just looking for an excuse to be lazy and ignore the problems. Second, China is improving. their policies. They are creating more environmentally friendly power plants, they are no longer accepting plastic waste from the western world, they have put incentives in place for people to have fewer children and have put a large plan of green financing in effect.
There is nothing impactful we can do as individuals except to stop eating fish and meat and stop buying anything we can in packaging.

The climate issue is top down, but money driven politics cover their arses by pushing it to consumers.

If we didn’t fish the seas, we’d have the biggest co2 absorber going.

I don’t eat fish or meat. Do you?

MondayYogurt · 12/08/2021 21:35

[quote Bluebellsinparadise]@MondayYogurt I’m not in a bubble thanks and I’m well educated. But people who live around me aren’t and they are not on Twitter! Of course I can find people who are in the environmental movement who represent minority groups, but I’m talking about the failure of big environmental groups to engage with ALL groups living in modern Britain. Not just Guardian readers![/quote]
Then join one and make changes.

Skinnytailedsquirrel · 12/08/2021 20:21

I'm glad I don't have children is all I can say. Yet...the women in their 4x4s picking up their darlings from school half a mile away don't give a shit.
Not enough people give a shit. The world needs to stand together - but they can't/wont.

woodhill · 12/08/2021 20:11

@Dreamstate

We can't even keep our own beaches clean! The way people litter. Maybe start from the basics first
Yes the littering is disgusting

Trivial. - Witnessed a woman chucking a used tissue out of her car yesterday - who does she think will pick it up.

Dreamstate · 12/08/2021 19:44

We can't even keep our own beaches clean! The way people litter. Maybe start from the basics first

SchadenfreudePersonified · 12/08/2021 19:11

I am really wondering why so many people on this thread are blaming poorer nations. Have you looked at the carbon footprint of an average Indian as compared to an average British person? Even if an Indian woman has 6 children, their carbon footprint is tiny compared to Boris's 7 or 8 children.

It's absolutely tiny compared to Johnson alone!

98% of the world's wealth is concentrated in the pockets of less than 2% of the world's population - and their carbon footprint is HUGE! Not only in comparative terms, but in actual terms

Conspicuous greed - huge consumption and worse, incredible WASTE. But the entitlement of the rich is overwhelming.

And far too few of us seem to want to do anything about it.

Me saving my shower water to put on the garden is (almost literally) a drop in the ocean when it's offset against my three neighbours who use power sprays to clean the weed seedlings out of their block paving drives each week: 000's of gallons - straight down the drain.