Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If it’s that bad, why aren’t we panicking more??

911 replies

Nightgardenisodd · 07/08/2021 20:59

Climate change.
I keep reading posts about it and it’s scaring the crap out of me for my DD’s future.
How bad is it? Anyone have any positivity about it?

OP posts:
afriusaenghather · 14/08/2021 17:14

@Tealightsandd

The issue is replicated around the world. China was condemned when it tried to tackle it - their (now abandoned) one child policy. It's not a completely lost idea however. Certain parts of India are looking at incentising smaller families. It's only (some parts) of one country, but it's a start.
This is really true and your posts above about globalisation. China moved from 1 child policy to 2, they moved to a 3 child policy in May this year.

The loss of local country manufacturing puts the UK at risk too.

Have a look up how avacado became popular, it was a big crop year and clever marketing. A huge global industry of one product, which causes mass co2 by transportation, which lots of people would not want to give up.

Tealightsandd · 14/08/2021 17:07

From what I understand, bitcoin - crytocurrency is very unenvironmentally friendly. Consumes huge amounts of energy. Perhaps something we might need to bear in mind.

Tealightsandd · 14/08/2021 17:04

The issue is replicated around the world.
China was condemned when it tried to tackle it - their (now abandoned) one child policy. It's not a completely lost idea however. Certain parts of India are looking at incentising smaller families. It's only (some parts) of one country, but it's a start.

Tealightsandd · 14/08/2021 16:59

At the start of the 19th century, the total UK population was around 10 million. Just two hundred years(ish) later, that's pretty much the population of London alone. Today the total UK population is around 68 million. Add in modern consumption - and that's a drastically increased demand for limited natural resources (and land etc).

Tealightsandd · 14/08/2021 16:54

Industrialisation in the 1950’s has caused this mess, and it now all run on big global businesses making it very hard to understand the truth, as they pay to retain their ‘cash cows’

Yes. Although really the problem (industrialisation) started in the 19th century (to a smaller extent in the late 18th). People known as luddites - the ones smashing the machines. They were trying to save their livelihoods and avoid destitution for themselves and their families. That was their motivation but if you think about it, they were also (unwittingly) fighting against the start of human worsened climate change.

Basically industrialisation, human overpopulation, and globalisation don't fit in with environmentally friendly.

afriusaenghather · 14/08/2021 16:48

Typos above (eg Tesla fire required 40 times the water)

afriusaenghather · 14/08/2021 16:43

[quote Daftasabroom]@afriusaenghather I'm afraid meat production does not account for 50% of emissions, if that were the case the whole thing would be blindingly simple to solve - posting such obvious rubbish does nothing to further your (our) cause and detracts massively from the issues we face. I posted upthread a link to ourworlindata, this is a very well respected organisation translating huge volumes of peer reviewed papers into bite meal sized chunks. The pie chart is my favorite infographic at the moment.

Top level emissions data:

Energy (electricity, heat and transport): 73.2%
Direct Industrial Processes: 5.2%
Waste: 3.2%
Agriculture, Forestry and Land Use: 18.4%

A great list @Fimofriend

So, some positivity. The UK Government is one of very few in the world to have set legally binding targets for emissions reduction. This is managed through the Climate Change Committee www.theccc.org.uk/ and one of the key intruments is the carbon budget. The Gov (I'm not generally a fan of this lot) are investing billions in sustainability, and they are really useless at advertising this. Equally I get truly exasperated by well meaning organisations demanding net zero within a decade - this is naive in the extreme, if we could we would, we can't. 2050 is challenging.

FWIW - ALL big businesses are building sustainability road maps, I work in this field and they are generally bricking themselves.

I also get fed up with people saying "its up to gov" "its up to big business". NO do not devolve your personal responsibility, it is up to all of us, every individual, every club, every parish, county, organisation and country.

A last thought, the first step on the road to sustainability is to understand and measure our impact, bearing in mind the graph I posted upthread which clearly shows energy use in domestic buildings is a huge factor: we are a family of four, our domestic heat and energy use is 10600kWhr.pa or 59kWhr/m2.

If anyone wants help measuring their energy use, im only too happy to help.[/quote]
There isn’t a purely accurate way to tell the true percentage. The charity providing the info graphic and data are primarily funded by the Bill and Melinda gates foundation. Whilst I’m not suggesting that this study and data presentation, was influenced, I am suggesting that there is huge evidence to show many eco charities are actually a front for big business messages.

There are many many studies including one by Oxford that put global industrial farming as one of the largest cause of greenhouse gases.

I also referenced industrial fishing in my posts. There’s huge evidence to show that the ocean charity messages that are pumped to consumers are based on big business capitalist funding.

Have a look at the dolphin friendly label you see on tuna. It’s all a falicy - it’s a label paid for by big business in reality.

The pie chart doesn’t even take into account half possible things I’ve read about - recent evidence suggests that phytoplankton (tiny organisms within the sea that photosynthesise) create 80% of the worlds oxygen, and absorbs 4 x co2 of the Amazon rain forest. 45% of the plastic in the sea (which breaks down to micro plastic) killing the sea life we need to retain this co2 absorbing oxygen creation, is actually from industrial fishing nets, yet we are told a very different thing indeed.

The fuel industry is another thing indeed. Not one I discount. Have a look at the Exxon video here showing how big oil companies dispute and delay climate change action by various methods. m.youtube.com/watch?v=5v1Yg6XejyE

Eating animals and fish is a major contributor to climate change. It’s easier to change my diet than it is to cycle to the shops for my weekly food.

Industrialisation in the 1950’s has caused this mess, and it now all run on big global businesses making it very hard to understand the truth, as they pay to retain their ‘cash cows’

Electric cars are not without major issues - the scene of a Tesla on fire last week which took ten times the water to extinguish is shocking. When we all have electric black outs due to plugging in our cars at night, that’ll be pretty scary. www.google.com/amp/s/www.independent.co.uk/climate-change/tesla-crash-driver-arrested-fire-b1901603.html%3famp

Personally I think we need to fine (anti trust) and tax (closing loopholes) big businesses and give a leg up to local small business that promote more localised industry.

We’re too late to reverse things without really drastic action frankly

Daftasabroom · 14/08/2021 15:15

@afriusaenghather I'm afraid meat production does not account for 50% of emissions, if that were the case the whole thing would be blindingly simple to solve - posting such obvious rubbish does nothing to further your (our) cause and detracts massively from the issues we face. I posted upthread a link to ourworlindata, this is a very well respected organisation translating huge volumes of peer reviewed papers into bite meal sized chunks. The pie chart is my favorite infographic at the moment.

Top level emissions data:

Energy (electricity, heat and transport): 73.2%
Direct Industrial Processes: 5.2%
Waste: 3.2%
Agriculture, Forestry and Land Use: 18.4%

A great list @Fimofriend

So, some positivity. The UK Government is one of very few in the world to have set legally binding targets for emissions reduction. This is managed through the Climate Change Committee www.theccc.org.uk/ and one of the key intruments is the carbon budget. The Gov (I'm not generally a fan of this lot) are investing billions in sustainability, and they are really useless at advertising this. Equally I get truly exasperated by well meaning organisations demanding net zero within a decade - this is naive in the extreme, if we could we would, we can't. 2050 is challenging.

FWIW - ALL big businesses are building sustainability road maps, I work in this field and they are generally bricking themselves.

I also get fed up with people saying "its up to gov" "its up to big business". NO do not devolve your personal responsibility, it is up to all of us, every individual, every club, every parish, county, organisation and country.

A last thought, the first step on the road to sustainability is to understand and measure our impact, bearing in mind the graph I posted upthread which clearly shows energy use in domestic buildings is a huge factor: we are a family of four, our domestic heat and energy use is 10600kWhr.pa or 59kWhr/m2.

If anyone wants help measuring their energy use, im only too happy to help.

iseeu · 14/08/2021 12:55

@Lavender24

People don't want to acknowledge how bad it is because they don't want to take any personal responsibility for it and change their ways ie not eating animal products. Sadly people would literally rather ruin the planet for their kids than change their habits.
I don't think it is as simple as that. I think it is the options available to people which need to change and that has to be led by governments.

For example - I replaced my WellKnownBrandVacuum 3 years ago - first one lasted 10 years suction amazing, second lasted 3 years suction pants (not accusing WellKnownBrand of limiting lifespans, I don't know, but it seems to be a logical possibility). There are no longer options locally to have my WellKnownBrandVacuum remediated. I don't want to buy an expensive brand which lasts only 3 years. I could buy a basics brand for peanuts but reviews say no spare parts are available and it will only last a year. I think to myself - well, it costs peanuts, i could buy another in a year. But that would mean several machines to the landfill and right now there isn't a decent alternative. Landfill = pollution= damage to environment and climate change

This is just one example.

If you have a contract with a well known comms company, you get offered regular "upgrades" of expensive phones for no extra cost. Huge piles of rubbish pollute and have knock on effects on environment and climate.

Travel - as I said upthread lorry and airline manufacturers are now offering electric or renewable fuel replacements - the technology has been able to be developed for years - why hasn't it happened before?

Huge problems are caused by resources from under ground - oil, coal - getting it out of the ground, refining it, using it, disposing of it - again different technologies could and should have been developed

Daftasabroom · 14/08/2021 12:17

Some of the misinformation here is staggering. The most important thing anyone can is educate themselves. I'd urge you to start here:

ourworldindata.org/emissions-by-sector
skepticalscience.com/

If it’s that bad, why aren’t we panicking more??
HasaDigaEebowai · 14/08/2021 10:56

Also I can't quite see that growing fields of animal fodder is BAD but doing away with animals and growing fields of human fodder (all the ploughing, seeding, harvesting,_ is necessarily wholly Good for the environment

Very little is black and white but the Amazon is being cut down to grow soy to feed cattle. That crop is the same crop used to feed humans but in its own right can provide 20 times as much protein as when it comes to us in the form of beef

GreatAuntEmily · 14/08/2021 10:27

Also I can't quite see that growing fields of animal fodder is BAD but doing away with animals and growing fields of human fodder (all the ploughing, seeding, harvesting,_ is necessarily wholly Good for the environment.

GreatAuntEmily · 14/08/2021 10:25

@afriusaenghather
Sorry I missed your previous links.
Worldwatch Institute found that the FAO underestimate and overlooked some direct and indirect livestock emissions including CO2 emissions from livestock respiration,
I do think that alot of farmed animals do NOW, contribute to global warning with the clearing of forest in S America etc but that comment above might lead to the reducing of say, elephant herds inAfrica, or the owning of cats and dogs (of which there are millions) so I would say there are unforeseen consequences of reducing respiration from animals.
The links for the Independent are dated 2009 - I think views have changed since then.
The time.com 'How Industrial Fishing Creates More CO2 Emissions Than Air Travel' is no doubt true but the benefits of fishing are that millions are fed. The benefits of air travel are little imv, so you have to keep in mind the benefits of fishing.

afriusaenghather · 14/08/2021 09:34

@GreatAuntEmily

Intense animal farming has only been a thing since, say, WW2. We were burning coal long before that so I think the comments about animal farming are wrong.
Scientific studies showing you large causes of climate change, but you think they’re wrong?

Sometimes the truth is uncomfortable.

jasjas1973 · 14/08/2021 08:08

@stillcrazyafterall

What would me (or even the whole of the UK) panicking achieve? It needs EVERY SINGLE country to sign up to action, because as soon as one country says 'we can do that because...' others will join in. It isn't going to happen. I will be long dead by the time the earth dies as will my children. Perhaps by then technology will have come up with a way to slow it down.
Don't need every country, just the major players, trade with these other countries will then have to become "Greener"

Temp in parts of europe yesterday was 48.5'C, these could become the norm very quickly and no reason to suggest that wont happen here, little grows in these temperatures, add in flooding and sea level rises and our food supply chain stops.

So don't be so sure you want see very large (and damaging) changes in climate.

stillcrazyafterall · 14/08/2021 07:14

What would me (or even the whole of the UK) panicking achieve? It needs EVERY SINGLE country to sign up to action, because as soon as one country says 'we can do that because...' others will join in. It isn't going to happen. I will be long dead by the time the earth dies as will my children. Perhaps by then technology will have come up with a way to slow it down.

HasaDigaEebowai · 14/08/2021 06:58

It isn’t just the methane, it’s the carbon along the whole production cycle

GreatAuntEmily · 14/08/2021 06:54

Surely if humans stop eating meat they will therefore eat more veg and pulses and they will then produce more methane themselves.

GreatAuntEmily · 13/08/2021 22:44

Intense animal farming has only been a thing since, say, WW2. We were burning coal long before that so I think the comments about animal farming are wrong.

SchadenfreudePersonified · 13/08/2021 22:30

@LaurieFairyCake

ANYTHING CAN BE DONE WITH PURPOSE AND WILL

I hugely agree with this.

  1. Tell people they're not flying anymore - allocate them one flight a year
  1. Force people to only buy electric cars by not allowing manufacturers and dealers to sell them - they're all allowed to sell off pre-2021 stock. And hopefully all older cars (and classics) will be kept on the road longer.
  1. Force people to only buy eco-boilers - if you own your property give them an interest free/very low interest loan to pay for it, if they can't afford it put a charge on their house for it to be paid for when they die (so they're not stressed by it)
  1. Force councils to wildflower any redundant space (and keep beehives). And turn over suitable land for community gardens to grow vegetables. EVERY fucking space that's not used - we dug up Britain in the war (not to great effect actually, it was more of a PR thing) so let's do it again.
Yes to the above.

Unless govt, takes control NOTHING will get done.

SchadenfreudePersonified · 13/08/2021 22:26

@afriusaenghather

50% of all global co2 emissions are due to intensive animal farming

All those on this thread being high and mighty about others car choices etc should ensure they are aware of this if they consume meat or dairy products.

Fishing - bottom trawling causes huge levels of co2, further over fishing our seas has removed important organisms that absorb massive co2 volumes.

I’m sick of idiots not realising that half our world issues are due to animal farming and abuse.

Very little benefit will be gained by driving a Tesla in comparison to worldwide vegan or vegetarianism.

It’s a fact. That most people choose to ignore.

THIS ^
Walkaround · 13/08/2021 17:29

@Lavender24

People don't want to acknowledge how bad it is because they don't want to take any personal responsibility for it and change their ways ie not eating animal products. Sadly people would literally rather ruin the planet for their kids than change their habits.
As each individual knows their actions cannot single handedly ruin the planet, it’s more a question of people not wanting to change their actions if they perceive that few people around them are doing likewise and that nobody is in full agreement on what everyone should be doing, anyway. Massive, fast and co-ordinated change requires strong and decisive leadership - something China is more likely to achieve than the likes of the UK and the US, if it’s that way inclined, as it doesn’t have to listen to opposing political voices, nor let the people hear opposing points of view.
Sarahlou63 · 13/08/2021 17:01

@Lavender24

People don't want to acknowledge how bad it is because they don't want to take any personal responsibility for it and change their ways ie not eating animal products. Sadly people would literally rather ruin the planet for their kids than change their habits.
Nail. Head.

It won't be until the rise in food prices - due to crop failures - becomes a reality that most people will take notice.

wherearemychickens · 13/08/2021 16:24

My point really was that it was something previously thought impossible, until suddenly it was something happening.

Going the other way, the same is probably true of wet bulb temperatures in this country. Who knows, depending on how much we muck this up.