Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If it’s that bad, why aren’t we panicking more??

911 replies

Nightgardenisodd · 07/08/2021 20:59

Climate change.
I keep reading posts about it and it’s scaring the crap out of me for my DD’s future.
How bad is it? Anyone have any positivity about it?

OP posts:
MsTSwift · 07/08/2021 23:10

Maybe being optimistic but the majority accepted curtailment of what they wanted to do due to clear and present danger of Covid. Sadly we need a similar hard line to deal with climate change. Problem is humans adapt and we love our warm houses steak and 3 foreign holidays a year. Some companies were testing flying like getting a bus. We can’t all carry on living like that though. Blaming “big corporations” and “government” is pathetic- who are the consumers and the voters? You can’t abdicate responsibility like that.

phishy · 07/08/2021 23:08

its

phishy · 07/08/2021 23:08

@OnlyFoolsnMothers

I like many feel reluctant to change our personal lifestyles when you see India, China and Russia do what suits them- we’re fucked anyway
It’s hypocritical to have a go at those countries when the UK is also set to fail it’s climate goals.

www.carbonbrief.org/ccc-uk-will-miss-climate-goals-by-huge-margin-without-new-policies

PTW1234 · 07/08/2021 23:07

I feel so guilty, the floods in Germany, wildfires in Greece and Turkey. This isn’t normal and I feel so sad for all who have lost their lives, homes and family members.

Snow in May and June in England! It’s bizarre and happening at such a pace, there is not even a choice for the most to be more socially conscious. I would love to shop sound and buy organic, less packaging etc, but I am in a rat race - we all need to do better

Lapsidasicle · 07/08/2021 23:05

My goodness this thread is depressing! Way to make probably a lot of people with poor mental health even worse.

I also follow many of the individual level actions listed here. Hardly ever buy new clothes, cycle everywhere, use the car once a week, recycle etc.

But none of that will make a spot of difference. So why worry? What’s going to be, is going to be. People considering not having kids due to this are crazy... refugees and populations at war still have children- and they’re in far more precarious situations. In history, human kind have faced worse threats at an individual level. They just got on with it.

Seems to me we’ve been really spoilt in the last 50 years. Work on your resilience and ‘make do and mend’ skills. But don’t waste any time worrying about this or freaking your poor children out.

The reality is you have no power in changing the course we are on, unless you’re one of the very few in a position to do anything that will make a difference.

Jeff Bezos is one of those people. And he’s pissing off into space Hmm

Skysblue · 07/08/2021 23:05

We aren’t panicking because the responses that humans have evolved to danger are flight / fight / if you can’t do either, ignore and hope for the best.

Most people can’t fight or run from climate change, so we’re ignoring it. This instinct is normal but is a massive part of the problem. That said panic is rarely a helpful emotion.

I’d like to see stronger government on this. Less “what do the people want us to do” more “by the way you can’t have X anymore because it’s bad for the planet sorry it is now banned.” Unfortunately we don’t elect competents though.

Also, the government that most needs to lead on this is China and they’re too focused on their economy to lead on climate :(

wherearemychickens · 07/08/2021 23:03

And a lot of the solutions would mean a genuinely better quality of life for us all - e.g. pedestrianised town centres with lots of cycling and less air pollution (how much nicer does Paris look now following Hidalgo's changes?) - but again, we seem stuck.

MMMarmite · 07/08/2021 23:03

If panicking could stop climate change I would keep panicking. Sometimes I do. I go through periods of campaigning on the issue as much as I can. But I can't solve it alone, and I can't stand to live my life focusing on constant fear, so other times I try to avoid thinking about it and just carry on with life. Even though I know intellectually how bad climate change is.

I wish there was a better solution. Sad

SpaceshiptoMars · 07/08/2021 23:01

Some positivity and ideas here:

www.drawdown.org/

wherearemychickens · 07/08/2021 23:01

The thing I find most depressing is that a lot of the solutions are out there in terms of land use/agriculture, transport, heating, building requirements, but our politics is just not stepping up to the challenge. In construction for instance we had a target for zero carbon houses by 2016 - subsequently dropped by the Conservatives as a target - so of course it's only a tiny fraction of the houses built today, whereas if it had been kept as a mandatory requirement, by now it would be all new builds.

UnsolicitedDickPic · 07/08/2021 22:59

[quote SlipperyDippery]@adeleh there’s an app called Klima where you pay a direct debit to invest in tree planting or solar power and stuff to offset your personal carbon footprint. I pay about £5 a month.[/quote]
I've just signed up to this, thank you for the suggestion.

Confrontayshunme · 07/08/2021 22:58

We have cut plastic out of our lives almost completely and basically only have plastic medicine packaging, but in the time it took me to type that, CocaCola made 100,000 plastic bottles.
Soooo, it is all worthless while we enjoy capitalism and a constant need for GDP and stocks to be ever increasing.

cherryadeisyummy · 07/08/2021 22:56

@Beecham

I try to be hopeful - what's the alternative? It's no help to anyone if we all freak out. Firstly, it's in most countries interests to move away from fossil fuels and towards a greener economy. China is still quite bad at using coal but they are moving towards a lower carbon economy and are good at inventing new green technologies. In the next few years things like electric cars will be completely mainstream.

Things to me seem to be moving in the right direction - governments DO care. But it's just not happening fast enough. So we need to apply pressure to politicians

And I do think everything we can do as individuals can genuinely make a difference. Eg pressure to get rid of plastic bags and straws started off as a niche thing, now it's everywhere. Loads of countries have banned them completely. Consumers have power!!

But governments can and do change and not always for the better. Look at all the backwards steps Trump took. The US are horrendous polluters that a real leader could have tried to stem. But he just saw it all as a hoax and a laugh and just pushed things back further than they needed to be.

All while whipping up his divided America to still see it all as a big laugh and a joke too.

MakeMeCleanTheHouse · 07/08/2021 22:55

@Carboholic

xkcd.com/1732/

Take one look at this graph and then please blush at ever having said “natural phenomena”.

OP:
Have fewer children
Fly less
Drive less
Vote!
Don’t buy shit just because an ad tells you you should or because the Joneses have it
Eat less meat

The big ones are probably flying less, voting better and having fewer children (though this is a hard one and very personal). Just because other people are doing something pr not doing something doesn’t mean you have to. Eg, if China and the US are pissing in the swimming pool doesn’t mean we should, and if MN tells you never to date a man who doesn’t drive doesn’t mean you need to own 3 SUVs. Doing something lessens anxiety. But there is a good reason to take this very, very seriously.

Thanks for this link. It was really excellent at showing previous climate changes compared to now
Unfashionable · 07/08/2021 22:53

Climate change is real, that’s obvious to anyone, but it is part of the natural cycles of our planet.

The Romans grew grapes in the North of England, which is just about feasible today. Between the 17th & 19th centuries, during a period called the ‘little ice age’, people skated on the frozen Thames, which is completely unthinkable today, because we are currently in a warm spell. History teaches us that the cycle will change again, because that’s what it does.

Confrontayshunme · 07/08/2021 22:53

There is a great book about this mental block called Don't Even Think About It by George Marshal about the neurology around climate change. The more it affects people, the LESS they do about it weirdly. If you own a bechfront hurricane prone property in the US that has been flooded, you are actually LESS likely to believe in climate change. Same with flood prone areas of the UK. Essentially, we can't begin to fathom the devastation happening in front of us because our brains only asses immediate, life threatening risk and not slowing boiling alive.

Dreamstate · 07/08/2021 22:51

@Sarahlou63

If you really want to make a difference then you should teach your children how to survive with only a basic infrastructure. How to produce their own food, how to repair clothes, how to maintain their vehicles and homes, how to adapt to mental and physical challenges. Even if your children don't need these skills, their children probably will.
They can't even teach their children to not litter lol good luck trying to teach them anything more than something so basic and simple as dont throw litter on the floor
entropynow · 07/08/2021 22:50

@PlanDeRaccordement

How was it worse in 1921?
  • Raw sewage in most of worlds water sources...yum yum
  • No waste removal for rubbish...just heaps rotting outside every town
-coal fired power plants causing acid rain killing entire lakes and rivers
  • polluted air killed millions more than now such that even London still had killer fogs on a regular basis.
  • deforestation was at its peak world wide
  • world starvation and poverty was much higher than now
-infant/child mortality far worse
Of course there was waste removal for rubbish. Child poverty and mortality have little to do with climate change. You are not arguing to the point.
MareofBeasttown · 07/08/2021 22:48

@Sarahlou63

If you really want to make a difference then you should teach your children how to survive with only a basic infrastructure. How to produce their own food, how to repair clothes, how to maintain their vehicles and homes, how to adapt to mental and physical challenges. Even if your children don't need these skills, their children probably will.
Wow this is grim. I don't know how to do most of this. I am telling my children not to have children, though I don't know if they will listen to me. Probably not.
Sarahlou63 · 07/08/2021 22:46

If you really want to make a difference then you should teach your children how to survive with only a basic infrastructure. How to produce their own food, how to repair clothes, how to maintain their vehicles and homes, how to adapt to mental and physical challenges. Even if your children don't need these skills, their children probably will.

RubyGoat · 07/08/2021 22:40

Yes I know mica mining isn't about climate change. It's just another example of how many people don't care about things. This problem has been known about for many years & it's still a really common ingredient in cosmetics.

Beecham · 07/08/2021 22:40

I try to be hopeful - what's the alternative? It's no help to anyone if we all freak out.
Firstly, it's in most countries interests to move away from fossil fuels and towards a greener economy. China is still quite bad at using coal but they are moving towards a lower carbon economy and are good at inventing new green technologies. In the next few years things like electric cars will be completely mainstream.

Things to me seem to be moving in the right direction - governments DO care. But it's just not happening fast enough. So we need to apply pressure to politicians

And I do think everything we can do as individuals can genuinely make a difference. Eg pressure to get rid of plastic bags and straws started off as a niche thing, now it's everywhere. Loads of countries have banned them completely. Consumers have power!!

Hyperion100 · 07/08/2021 22:39

Problem is...we wont do what is required to fix the problem.

No cars, no air travel, no central heating, no more "stuff", limit on children, stop thinking about perpetual growth...a complete move away from capitalist model.

MareofBeasttown · 07/08/2021 22:39

[quote Cam77]@OnlyFoolsnMothers
It's not tit for tat though - it's... don't expect people in far away places to be willing to make sacrifices that you and your compatriots are unwilling to make.[/quote]
Well, exactly. This is at least the second time I have noticed this "India and China should stop building airports and roads! They are ruining the world." Maybe the West can do without its airports and roads instead.

icedcoffees · 07/08/2021 22:37

[quote MareofBeasttown]@Sarahlou63 The ultra rich will survive anyway, just as they have survived covid. I can;t really stomach this sort of eco-fascism.[/quote]
But it's nothing new.

During the plague, the rich fled London and left the poor to die.

Money buys choice. 'Twas ever thus.

Swipe left for the next trending thread