Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If it’s that bad, why aren’t we panicking more??

911 replies

Nightgardenisodd · 07/08/2021 20:59

Climate change.
I keep reading posts about it and it’s scaring the crap out of me for my DD’s future.
How bad is it? Anyone have any positivity about it?

OP posts:
lannistunut · 08/08/2021 06:48

@Amima

Let me give an example. I used to buy earbuds with plastic sticks. They were awful for the environment but I needed to clean my ears so what could I do? Then the government banned plastic sticks and the earbud manufacturers started making paper sticks instead. I happily buy the paper earbuds and use them to clean my ears. But until they were manufactured and put on the shelves I couldn’t buy them. Extrapolate that to everything that’s wrong with the world. The government and the big corporations need to make the changes in order for the rest of us to be able to adopt them.
You could just not buy them, you have free will Confused
CalamityJaneDoe · 08/08/2021 04:16

The thing is, we can’t sustain the kind of terror we would need to actually change it RIGHT NOW, which is when we need to do it. We just can’t. As in, we are not capable of keeping it at the forefront of our minds and making it our driving force.

We experience the terror in short horrible bursts but there’s so many distractions. The planet is on fire but what is immediately noticeable are the things happening to us, personally. So you read about wildfires and lasting damage and you feel the horror and the panic and the toddler needs a nappy change and did you hear about the new season of stranger things? Oh the simpsons is on and I must get to those dishes before tea time.

It’s just not sustainable, mentally. If we could cut through the distractions, maybe people would listen. If we had a solid plan that everyday people could follow (and not just turning lights off) then maybe.

I sometimes think about media blackouts. Dead air on all radio stations. WiFi and data turned off. Every tv channel just showing the same screen, possibly with a plan on, or just the affects of climate change in pictures and video. It’s so easy to turn away when we get scared, flick the channel, go on Facebook, never fully facing the truth for fear that it will blind us with fear.

It’ll never happen though. Climate change can’t be stopped by the likes of you and I, and the richest people, the ones who can stop it, won’t. There’s no profit line, is there? And they won’t suffer because they’re old enough to die before things get bad enough and arrogant enough to think they’re more important.

The closest thing we have is boycott. All we can do is stop driving cars powered by petrol and diesel, stop buying from amazon, stop giving money to the ones who won’t stop causing the problem. But, when petrol cars are all some people can afford, they won’t stop. When you work half an hour away and don’t have a bus route nearby how can you?

tara66 · 08/08/2021 04:14

I don't understand why there is still so much plastic and why it was allowed in the first place. Not so very long ago people had only paper bags or used their baskets when they shopped for food for example. Now everything just about is made of the stuff.

Onfire · 08/08/2021 03:42

A big issue is people believing in the green washing that goes on
This is often at a lower level that doesn’t cause major impact but at a higher level people have been encouraged to give up cars that go to scrap to then buy a new electric car

The energy it takes to construct the plant to build that car, the materials that are beeddd to build that car, the energy and resource it’s taken to build those massive batteries and then the fact that’s those batteries are then a major future waste issue is hugely concerning

If people had continued to drive the car that didn’t need to be disposed of than buying a new car be it electric, or hybrid that would save a huge amount of carbon use.

It’s not been massively reported in the news but a major fire broke out at the largest Tesla battery plant recently , it burned so hard it needed over 100 firefighters

Stop thinking that buy driving an electric car is saving the planet, it really isn’t

bluetongue · 08/08/2021 02:49

@Ijustknowitstimetogo

I agree it will be bad eventually. But the worst of it is still probably over a hundred or more years away so it just doesn’t feel real or urgent to most people yet.
Do you not read the news? Disappearing permafrost in the Arctic, record temperature in Canada and a whole town destroyed by fire, catastrophic bushfires in Australia and unprecedented deadly floods in Germany.

Not to mention Covid that was made much more likely due to environmental degradation.

Ijustknowitstimetogo · 08/08/2021 02:42

I agree it will be bad eventually. But the worst of it is still probably over a hundred or more years away so it just doesn’t feel real or urgent to most people yet.

Guineapigbridge · 08/08/2021 02:10

Listen, chickens, the sky's not falling okay. We've got another few hundred years of pain first. We will be well dead.

Lucycantdance · 08/08/2021 02:08

I can’t express how frustrating it is reading this thread and seeing some people say “iF We aLL dO oUr BiT” like that would have any meaningful impact on this unfolding disaster.

This is down to capitalism. Corporations and the powerful are the only ones who can actually mitigate this because they are responsible. That means pressuring them. Educate yourselves.

ArcheryAnnie · 08/08/2021 01:00

Amima I don't have a pension, either, so understand.

I will tell you this though...I have serious doubts that my granddaughter will live to see old age. I am not sure that my sons, in their early 40s now, will.

Mamanyt my DS is the light of my life, but I do wonder if I have been terribly selfish in having him at all. I feel like I am imposing on him a terrible personal future, and fear he won't even get to be the age I am now.

pollyglot · 08/08/2021 01:00

It's only a generation or two ago (my childhood in the 50s and 60s, actually) that people did live a far simpler life in terms of the disposable lifestyle that's one of the drivers of pollution. Most housewives rode a bike to pick up the groceries in their fabric or wicker shopping baskets. Children walked or rode bikes to school. Meat, eggs, veggies all were sold in brown paper wrappers, and other things in cardboard boxes. Almost no plastic at all. Cars were gas-guzzlers, but not every family had even one vehicle. Water came from the tap, and often from the roof in the form of rain water. Many people still had longdrop toilets, soap, not detergent-based stuff was used for washing, sheets were turned, towels recycled as sanitary towels or cleaning cloths after being used till threadbare. I had one pair each of sandals, shoes and gumboots. One good dress, two for school. Clothes were hand-me-downs or home made by my granny. Windows were cleaned with cold tea and newspapers, all vegetables and fruit were home-grown and bottled for out-of-season. Children learned to grow food and make compost and keep chickens. Many people raised a killer if they had a little space, and lacking freezers, they were shared among friends and family. Knitwear was made by loving grannies and aunties and carefully washed by hand. Wool was recycled when a jumper became thin. Holidays were spent with family who were lucky enough to live on farms or by the sea. Otherwise, almost everyone went camping in a sea-side campground.

I know this sounds a bit Waltonesque, or like life in the Great Depression, but everyone I know lived like this. It wasn't just because you were poor - Dad was a very well-paid professional, and mother had money. Our less-well-off neighbours lived exactly the same. It wasn't until the late 60s that the hunger for consumerism really took hold. Our carbon footprint back then was miniscule in comparison to what it is now. For a child, it was paradise, not so much for the women who had to carry the majority of the hard work. I guess no-one wants to return to those simple, "primitive" days. But there has to be a quid pro quo.

Mamanyt · 08/08/2021 00:49

It is that bad. We may have reached the Point of No Return, far earlier than we thought. That said, the only thing to do is to remain calm, and do what you can to reduce your own ill-effects on the planet. Act locally, think globally, as the saying goes. We may yet survive this.

I will tell you this though...I have serious doubts that my granddaughter will live to see old age. I am not sure that my sons, in their early 40s now, will.

This is the price of putting commerce above science.

HarebrightCedarmoon · 08/08/2021 00:41

I'm 45 and it feels like we have known about it all my life yet governments have not done enough. I just feel like individual efforts are pissing on a massive fire and governments need to take drastic actions to prevent the worst effects. But ultimately all the plutocrats in the world don't give a shit - look how much money those on the rich lists have made in the last year. There is just too much money to be made out of it by disaster capitalists.

Amima · 08/08/2021 00:36

Also as I said, it requires widespread systemic change. I’m equally fucked if I spend my money on the veg box but other people can’t afford to so we still end up in the same situation. We all live on the same planet - if even 10% of us fail to participate we are ALL doomed.

Amima · 08/08/2021 00:32

if you can't afford the veg scheme, then you are going to get an even nastier shock when there's societal collapse and worldwide food shortages
I’ll deal with that when it happens. Same as I don’t have a pension and I know I’m screwed when I retire, but I don’t have the money to pay into a pension for tomorrow because I have to prioritise keeping a roof over my head today. Lots of people literally live hand to mouth, they barely survive and don’t have money to invest in their future.

ArcheryAnnie · 08/08/2021 00:28

@Amima

But that only works when the veg scheme is available and affordable at the same price as the supermarket. I can afford supermarket veg but I can’t afford the veg scheme.
I'm on a very small (substantially lower than average) income, so I hear you on this - but I promise, if you can't afford the veg scheme, then you are going to get an even nastier shock when there's societal collapse and worldwide food shortages.
ArcheryAnnie · 08/08/2021 00:25

I'm absolutely terrified about the latest gulf stream stuff.

I get why there's been a softly-softly approach to environmental campaigning in recent years (encourage everyone to take just one step, etc etc) but I think we are at the point where high-carbon stuff needs shaming, on a worldwide scale, the way things like drunk-driving fell out of use because they became widely socially unacceptable.

Cukku · 08/08/2021 00:23

I've been encouraging my daughters not to have children. I hope the advice will stick. I'm going through a cancer scare at the moment and Global Warming definitely makes me feel less attached to life.

Guineapigbridge · 08/08/2021 00:18

The best thing we can do for our survival is invest in R&D for artificial environments on Earth and on Mars. I'm with Elon on this. I disagree with him that population collapse is a bad thing.

Amima · 08/08/2021 00:13

Amima - no, you didn’t need to clean your ears
Oh god no, I can’t stand having wet ears. If I’ve had a shower I need to dry them out with a cotton bud. And I need to use deodorant and brush my teeth and a number of other things that are technically not essential for survival. If we’re going to stop doing everything non essential then we basically revert to being animals.

adeleh · 08/08/2021 00:07

Thank you slippery - have signed up!

Freedomprogramme · 08/08/2021 00:06

I campaigned on the streets to get the climate change act passed - that was satisfying.
I ran a friends of the Earth group too-that was frustrating - it was a bit like this thread.

Now I’m involved with big business (automotive and aerospace) as they decarbonise, and deal with China. It’s positive and exciting. I move them along.

I think if we had more mothers in engineering and CEO roles we’d progress faster.

XenoBitch · 07/08/2021 23:57

[quote Sarahlou63]@Amima - no, you didn’t need to clean your ears. People have lived for thousands of years without sticking twigs into their ears. Marketing companies working for personal hygiene companies told you it was the done thing to clean your ears and you - along with all of us - believed them. Repeat for 99% of products we believe we need to make our lives happy and complete.[/quote]
This. Is like the countries (US?) who think vaginal douches are a thing you need to do to keep clean. Our bodily orifices are self cleaning.
That said, I do use cotton buds but for crafts, not shoving in my ears.

bluetongue · 07/08/2021 23:56

@Susannahmoody

India, China and soon Africa are going through the equivalent of the industrial revolution. We have no chance.
Not to mention the huge population explosion in Africa.
beigebrownblue · 07/08/2021 23:55

Who is 'we;?

Some of us knew this fourty years ago and were acting accordingly.

What are YOU doing OP?

Sarahlou63 · 07/08/2021 23:54

@Amima - no, you didn’t need to clean your ears. People have lived for thousands of years without sticking twigs into their ears. Marketing companies working for personal hygiene companies told you it was the done thing to clean your ears and you - along with all of us - believed them. Repeat for 99% of products we believe we need to make our lives happy and complete.

Swipe left for the next trending thread