Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If it’s that bad, why aren’t we panicking more??

911 replies

Nightgardenisodd · 07/08/2021 20:59

Climate change.
I keep reading posts about it and it’s scaring the crap out of me for my DD’s future.
How bad is it? Anyone have any positivity about it?

OP posts:
MsTSwift · 08/08/2021 09:02

I agree with Scotdoc except the last paragraph. No one should have more than 2 children it’s utterly unjustifiable at the current time.

Simpleisntit · 08/08/2021 09:02

It’s the height of arrogance to say that humans have the power to change nature eh @chainjane? Are you serious? Have you actually looked at any of the science? There is a reason it’s called man made climate change. Wheeling out the ‘oh but the temperature has always changed’ argument is incredibly stupid. What makes you think you know better than pretty much the entire global scientific community?

ThirdElephant · 08/08/2021 08:58

Have less children is also wrong IMO large families in current climate irresponsible but birth rate in Britain is already below replacement and if people can’t have much wanted children who are we saving the planet for?

The one or two kids you do have plus everyone else's? The impact of a British kid will be far more than that of a kid living in a subsistence farming community in a developing country, so we need to have fewer kids to compensate for that.

I think you've summed up the problem here really well. We know what needs to be done, but no one wants to stop doing the things they see as necessary for their lifestyle to continue. So, you are all for climate change action, but not if it stops you having your four or five kids. Barbara down the road is also all for climate change action, but not if it stops her having her three or four long-haul holidays a year.

And so on it goes. No one cares enough about the future to make sufficient compromises in the present.

whenwillthemadnessend · 08/08/2021 08:57

Scottie

Totally agree

bluelemming · 08/08/2021 08:51

@ChainJane

Don't worry about it. Humans always predict the worst. 60 years ago people were genuinely scared that there might be an atomic war at any moment. 40 years ago we were told that AIDS would kill off huge numbers of people. 25 years ago I remember BBC news telling us that mad cow disease might decimate the population within a decade. Then it was terrorism, now it's climate change.

Humans need something to worry about, it is in our nature. It's also convenient for the powers that be because they can use whatever fear people have as an excuse to raise taxes and cut services.

The world is hotter than a century ago, certainly. But before industrialisation temperatures were already rising, ever since the peak of the "mini ice age" where the Thames regularly froze solid to the point they held fairs on the ice. Go back a thousand years and temperatures were about the same as they are now.

The point is temperatures have always fluctuated and the world has adapted to the new conditions. Yes, people die off and populations rise and fall. We are due a correction in population figures because there are too many people for the planet to support. Natural disasters such as floods and famine will help bring about the necessary reduction (because obviously politicians can't actively promote sterilisation or genocide). But that's always been the case, that's how we evolve - the people who adapt best to the prevailing conditions are the ones who survive.

The problem with those who shout that we need to stop climate change are misguided. It's the height of arrogance to think humans have the power to change nature.

Excellent post. We all need to do our bit but perspective is important. We will all die at some point. The Earth will survive as it already has for billions of years.
Simpleisntit · 08/08/2021 08:45

Yes communal living would solve a lot of societal problems!

burritofan · 08/08/2021 08:44

Tbh @pollyglot that lifestyle sounds bloody idyllic the way you describe it, please write some cosy fiction and I’m all yours (aware I’m viewing it through rose-tinted cottagecore spectacles), but it would be hard to go back to just on housing costs alone – most houses with a garden for all that home-grown food now need two adult wages to maintain, which leaves less time for all the cold-tea window washing and knitting.

More and more I’m wondering if the future lies in communal living.

Porcupineintherough · 08/08/2021 08:42

@Itsprobablynotcominghome that was wise. I e had kids nowso feel forced to worry.

Scotdoc123 · 08/08/2021 08:36

It’s terrifying but all the posts making it about personal responsibility are wrong. What we need is to make it clear to the government there is significant support for drastic action. Similar to the emergency measures for the pandemic. So banning flying for business reasons, forcing companies to take responsibility for product lifecycle, frequent flyer tax, meat rationing, massive investment in active travel and rewilding, financial incentives to discourage driving and encourage use of public transport, massive investment in renewables for energy, universal basic income.

The idea that this is pointless because of Russia and China is nonsense. Look at how lockdowns spread through the world. Britain still has a lot of cultural influence. If we get on a war footing with climate change, others will follow. Politicians are cowards though and I don’t know if they will have the guts to do it and I think the British population is still not supportive of this. It is very telling that we took unthinkable measures for covid but we won’t do this for our children. Have less children is also wrong IMO large families in current climate irresponsible but birth rate in Britain is already below replacement and if people can’t have much wanted children who are we saving the planet for? I

Elephantsparade · 08/08/2021 08:31

Governments need to see the votes and the potential tax revenues to change. Im not sure how you counter all those big 'donations' from particular industries
Business need to see the profit

Simpleisntit · 08/08/2021 08:25

While you’re all here, I’ve been asked to design a campaign to give the clear message from businesses the world over that countries need to increase the ambition of their climate change commitments ahead of the big conference in November (cop26). I have a plan already but if you have any ideas for clever influencing tactics or stunts etc let me know, I’m sure there are lots of great ideas out there and I really want this one to go with a bang… (it’s a business audience so can’t go too wacky probably)

Itsprobablynotcominghome · 08/08/2021 08:19

I gave up worrying a while ago.

Decided to not have children. Will live my life as conscientiously as I want, which is probably miles more than most in this country.

I dread to think what the next 50-100 years has in store for this planet.

HasaDigaEebowai · 08/08/2021 08:16

So for example I've only recently become aware of just how appalling cut flowers are for the environment. Many are flown in from kenya and have a massive CO2e impact.

I might not yet be able to influence my friends to skip their overseas holiday but I can certainly persuade them that its so much nicer to have flowers from the garden or to buy dried flowers that last for months (and are very trendy).

Having said that, I give up with my parents. They are flying off abroad every other month and I struggle t even get them to sort their recycling.

HasaDigaEebowai · 08/08/2021 08:06

Yes but I can influence those people. They’re my circle and tbh most people are sheep like in their behaviours.

SmokeyDevil · 08/08/2021 08:03

@HasaDigaEebowai

But it’s so depressing seeing goverment do nothing and then people around us using their big cars to go to the shop down the road or putting the heating on in august coz they’re a bit chilly or buy new clothes every day or eating meat at every dinner… Sorry i ramble but i find it terrifying! What can we do

You have to be prepared to mess your unpopular views known. I was at a lunch with friends last week. A group of six middle aged and fairly affluent women all talking about holidays. When it came to my turn I said we weren’t going away and that was because I was too concerned about the environmental impact of flying. They looked at me like I had two heads and then started talking about how they absolutely must go away because they needed it so much. But I’m determined to make the point every time. Travel in planes needs to go back to being an occasional luxury.

See? That's what I mean. People are too selfish and they will continue to be until it personally affects them. Even then, it will escape the notice of most and they'll blame something else.
HasaDigaEebowai · 08/08/2021 07:55

But it’s so depressing seeing goverment do nothing and then people around us using their big cars to go to the shop down the road or putting the heating on in august coz they’re a bit chilly or buy new clothes every day or eating meat at every dinner…
Sorry i ramble but i find it terrifying! What can we do

You have to be prepared to mess your unpopular views known. I was at a lunch with friends last week. A group of six middle aged and fairly affluent women all talking about holidays. When it came to my turn I said we weren’t going away and that was because I was too concerned about the environmental impact of flying. They looked at me like I had two heads and then started talking about how they absolutely must go away because they needed it so much. But I’m determined to make the point every time. Travel in planes needs to go back to being an occasional luxury.

SmokeyDevil · 08/08/2021 07:54

It is bad, but it won't change. Here's why.

You'd have to get everyone to agree to only have one child. Won't happen.
You'd have to get everyone to agree to no more international travel unless you are moving countries for work. Won't happen.
You'd have to get everyone to agree to stop using cars unless they are electric now and only use public transport, cycling or walking. Won't happen.
You'd have to stop production of plastic. Won't happen.
You'd have to stop building homes and get people to accept the ones we have are it. Won't happen.
We would have to stop importing so much food from other countries, so our variety of food would decrease. So that won't happen either.

You need drastic changes like these at this point. Little steps, like waiting until 2030 to cease production of non electric cars, is pointless. Drastic is what is needed. But when you see threads of here of people saying they need a holiday abroad for their sanity, or need more than 3 children, you'll see its never going to happen. People like their freedom too much.

MumUndone · 08/08/2021 07:50

@Carboholic

xkcd.com/1732/

Take one look at this graph and then please blush at ever having said “natural phenomena”.

OP:
Have fewer children
Fly less
Drive less
Vote!
Don’t buy shit just because an ad tells you you should or because the Joneses have it
Eat less meat

The big ones are probably flying less, voting better and having fewer children (though this is a hard one and very personal). Just because other people are doing something pr not doing something doesn’t mean you have to. Eg, if China and the US are pissing in the swimming pool doesn’t mean we should, and if MN tells you never to date a man who doesn’t drive doesn’t mean you need to own 3 SUVs. Doing something lessens anxiety. But there is a good reason to take this very, very seriously.

Agree that taking individual action can lessen anxiety and that everything on your list is important, but the most important action any individual can take it to put pressure on the government - sign petitions, write to your MP, attend demonstrations. If enough of us mobilise, significant and lasting change can and will happen.
HasaDigaEebowai · 08/08/2021 07:42

For anyone interested in solar, it is still a money saving move even though the government payments have stopped.

We are about to have panels installed. The predicted savings over their life are 3.5 times their cost (this is for a system with a battery store so that we can maximise our own personal use from what we generate.)

We need to be in a position where all new builds have solar panels, are super insulated, have triple glazing, have external shutters and have good rainwater harvesting systems.

Monkeymilkshake · 08/08/2021 07:40

It’s really bad! And stressful. And we do male changes to our day to day life.
But it’s so depressing seeing goverment do nothing and then people around us using their big cars to go to the shop down the road or putting the heating on in august coz they’re a bit chilly or buy new clothes every day or eating meat at every dinner…
Sorry i ramble but i find it terrifying!
What can we do?

GreatAuntEmily · 08/08/2021 07:38

what I don't understand is how is the system to work - if you stop everyone using cars etc and you tell everyone to grow their own food - what is going to happen in the interim - how will people feed themselves if they have no income (because they can't travel to work), if no one gets oil out of the ground, that's good, but how are all the oilworkers to feed their families with no money. Overnight we need to make people stop travelling, and stop heating their homes, and get food sustainably - but what will they live on whilst that happens. Cutting back on oil and gas (good) means no heating or cooking fuel much of the time- what happens in places with temperatures below freezing?
Basically we need to go back to life around 1920s? After that we used coal for heating etc. But we also used wood before that. Which isn't good.
We are well and truly stuffed.

HasaDigaEebowai · 08/08/2021 07:37

Electric cars are a massive step forward but the ideal is to either sell on your old car or to run it until it dies first. But that is the same with everything. No point at all in throwing away plastic straws and buying bamboo straws. All you’ve done is made the problem worse. Just rinse and reuse your old ones over and over again until they die

HasaDigaEebowai · 08/08/2021 07:35

This is down to capitalism. Corporations and the powerful are the only ones who can actually mitigate this because they are responsible. That means pressuring them. Educate yourselves.

But the only thing that puts pressure on them is their customers. If people stop buying plastic straws they make paper ones (actually also really bad and the answer is don’t use a bloody straw. Apart from people with disabilities they are one of the worlds most pointless things). We ALL need to make changes that then add up to business change.

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 08/08/2021 07:33

pollyglot, thank you for your post.

AtticusHoysAnus · 08/08/2021 06:51

Whatever happens the planet will be fine.

We might not be.