Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If it’s that bad, why aren’t we panicking more??

911 replies

Nightgardenisodd · 07/08/2021 20:59

Climate change.
I keep reading posts about it and it’s scaring the crap out of me for my DD’s future.
How bad is it? Anyone have any positivity about it?

OP posts:
seasonalremarks · 08/08/2021 10:16

@DGRossetti you got in before before me. I totally agree.

GreatAuntEmily · 08/08/2021 10:03

I'm going to email my MP and the environment minister to say I hope for big changes and results from Cop26 - it's the least we can do and takes minutes.

DGRossetti · 08/08/2021 09:57

[quote Simpleisntit]@dgrossetti unfortunately it doesn’t work like that. The government only acts when they realise the public want change. Otherwise they only worry about the next election. Not the next 100 years.[/quote]
It does for me. I do what the priest does, not what they say. After all, why should there be a difference ?

Walkaround · 08/08/2021 09:57

Hmm. I think burning billions of years’ worth of fossil fuels derived from the accumulation of billions of years worth of organic life on this planet in just a few hundred years is enough for humans to have had a colossal and catastrophic effect on the planet. Seems weird that anyone would think it wouldn’t or couldn’t cause rapid changes unrelated to changes that would occur with or without human stupidity.

Simpleisntit · 08/08/2021 09:56

@dgrossetti unfortunately it doesn’t work like that. The government only acts when they realise the public want change. Otherwise they only worry about the next election. Not the next 100 years.

Simpleisntit · 08/08/2021 09:55

@buccanarab thank you. I find it extremely worrying that so many people are so ignorant about basic climate science.

DGRossetti · 08/08/2021 09:50

When the government acts like it matters, then I will.

sotiredofthislonelylife · 08/08/2021 09:48

@NCwhatsmynameagain

It is that bad. Why are the world’s governments doing next to nothing is the bit I don’t understand.
Oh, but they are. I am sure I read that once again, world leaders and their huge entourages will be flying all over the place for yet another Climate Change Conference……….. Which, no doubt, will achieve very little (but will make them look virtuous).

The hypocrisy from the rich and famous, not forgetting politicians, is astounding.

If this pandemic has taught us anything, it’s that a huge amount of business meetings, conferences etc can quite easily be accomplished without the need to be face to face. A massive reduction in business travel is certainly bad news for the airlines, but tremendously good news for the planet.

DGRossetti · 08/08/2021 09:41

Nicked from elsewhere ...

I think that the effect of humans on this planet is vastly overimagined, when you consider how long the planet has been here.

Age of planet: 4,500,000,000 years ago.

Life on earth: 3,800,000,000 years ago (apprx).

Mankinds industrial age: 300 years ago.

So you are asking me to believe that one species, can lay waste to a planet in 3,800,000,000 / 300 years ? I certainly believe that one species can lay waste to itself in that time, but that's not "climate change".

The climate changes all the time. 2,000 years ago the Romans grew white grapes in Yorkshire. Try doing that now. 300 years ago the Thames froze over every winter. 10,000 years ago you could walk from Spain to Scotland - and we know people did. Try that now.

Even the experts admit climate change is truly chaotic. Which means you can't factor in or out anything mankind does.

Incidentally, there is NOTHING wrong with wanting to live in a more sustainable way. It's something we should be putting all our effort into. Not because of climate change though. Just because it's more sensible in the long run.

One day, someone will write a book, or make a film. It will start with the idealism and hope after the second world war. It will chart how well meaning, sincere folk started to realise that we can't just rape the planet and not pay. These evolved into the counterculture of the 60s, which were derided, mocked and ridiculed by mainstream society.

Then, somewhere between the 60s, and the 90s, a sort of critical mass was reached - maybe the 1984/5 Band-Aid/Live-Aid phenomenon ? Either way, somehow, people in suits with wire-rimmed glasses and red braces had an epiphany. They realised you could actually SELL being green. You could slap the word "organic" on a food and double the price. So they did.

What was brilliant about this, was that it was the environmentalists that were effectively paying for the marketing. Every Greenpeace ad about the environment would see a jump in sales of "Eco" this, and "Green" that.

And our lords and masters looked upon this, and they saw it was good.

And thus it came to pass that the 1980s misbred young executives that were heavily advertised became the advisers and policy consultants of the 90s.

And lo verily, did the notion of "Green taxes" be dreamt up. For they did see, that whilst Joe Public might be narked about an extra penny on income tax, the same Joe Public would queue up to "save the planet".

I'm sorry, but personally I think the worlds public have been hoodwinked on a massive scale. "Green energy" is a good example. It's doing fuck all for the planet (in fact it's a net carbon contributor) but it's doing wonders for the firms that build the kit, and wonders for the upper-middle classes who actually get paid up to 40p/unit for the electricity that they put into the grid which is charged at 10p/unit.

Everyday I see many small things that could save a shed load of energy. Very simple things. But guess what ? There's no money in it for anyone, so it's ignored. Which leads me to my view of life. "If it really mattered ..."

If reducing emissions really mattered, you'd have a planning and tax system which encouraged work from home, and staggered working hours. That would cost very little, but - guess what ? No money in it. In fact you'll find behind the scenes the road and rail lobby would HATE any idea like that. So it's left alone.

When the government acts like it matters, then I will.

What I find particularly depressing, is people who are a victim of bad science in one area, appear to be willing to fall for it in another.

I manage to avoid long debates on climate change now, by just saying: "Define climate. Define change".

FWIW I have a more Gaian view of things. We live in a symbiosis with everything on earth, including the Earth. And just like a body with an infection, if we start to make the Earth poorly, then it's immune system will start to kick in to eradicate us. Or, alternatively, like a cell about to divide, we somehow manage to become 2 cells. But that requires interplanetary travel on a scale way beyond out capabilities. Especially if our offspring are more content to watch Celebrity Big Brother rather than design a better mousetrap.

Here endeth the rant for today :)

MumUndone · 08/08/2021 09:40

@whenwillthemadnessend

We have the tools and brains to do this

Essentially it's up to governments to enforce the change

1.Amazon and the rainforest destruction needs to stop NOW

  1. We need to step away from fast fashion
  2. We need to step away from overseas food
  3. We need to grow Sea grass to absorb co2
  4. We need to build wind farms. Huge ones. Fuck the look of them. They need to happen
  5. We need to use more solar power
  6. Electric cars and bicycles
  7. State funded cheap and reliable public transport
  8. Other countries will have there own free energy. Sea wind solar. 3rd world countries need to be encouraged and supported to use it.
10. I would go as far as a one child family but no more than two. 11. We need to accept some uncomfortable changes until We get used to it we did it for covid. This is the hardest part

Ultimately the earth will
Move on and be fine if we do or if we don't

It's up to the government to enforce the change but it's up to us to put pressure on them to do so.

Yes, the planet will be fine. Mother Nature will regain her strength in one form of another.

Which means this is a human emergency, not a planet one.

We're fighting for the survival of our species here, but more immediately, a life for our children that is actually worth living.

BigGreen · 08/08/2021 09:39

It is extremely bad unfortunately. In several cases the climate is changing even sooner than scientists predicted. Things you can do are eat less meat, fly less, see if you can switch to green energy, switch to local, organic foods. Think about whether you need to buy new stuff. But ultimately these are relatively small impacts. The most useful thing is to pressure your MP.

nancydroo · 08/08/2021 09:38

Life gets in the way sometimes. There is so much going on in life that Climate change is something that I never think about. I have so many other things to worry about. I recycle because we have recycle bins. I don't do anything else. Reading everyone's concern is actually quite surprising to me.

Hemingwaycat · 08/08/2021 09:38

I do quite a lot to minimise my personal carbon footprint and that of my family. We’ve recently been out litter picking to try help further. I’ve read a lot of literature and watched more than enough documentaries to know this is an emergency, it has been for years. People aren’t panicking because they’re apathetic about it, they just think it won’t happen to them. If the floods and wildfires are in a different country or even a different county it’s someone else’s problem. They’ll only be arsed when it’s directly affecting them.

MushMonster · 08/08/2021 09:35

Personal responsibility is extremely important, but the big change needs to come from goverment action.
Flights, the industry has just shrunk to freight at the moment, due to covid. So they could just leave it so, and forget about flying to the other end of the world for just one week holiday. But.... so many will not like this. They even want to do so in the middle of the pandemic! Actually, there are some private companies working on sending people to space for a tour! That is
a hell of a lot of pollution, just for a trip.

For any change to happen, we need strong goverments (we have no options for this!) that would be prepared to take unpopular actions like this.
Then subsidise renewable energy sources. And electric cars. And improve public transport, with electric options.
And a simpler way of life.

Biodegradable strong plastics are available. But we know that is not a solution for it all. Burgers do not degrade for years and years in a landfill. So the same will happen to the bag. No more landfilling domestic waste. We need to use it in energy production (it will release CO2, but if this does not come from fossil fuels, and deforestation stops and reverse, then it will be locked back, and the balance maintained. That is the trick). At least now the bags that make it to rivers and forest will degrade.
I love windmills, I think they look really pretty.
I would love to change my car by an electric one. It is the price, at present. Also, apparently we need to improve our grid to cope with it.
I do use my clothes till they are trully and well done. Eat less meat, almost none at present.
I try to keep plants in my house, and garden. No fake grass! That is something we all can do.
I need a kick on the ass to remember my life bag when going shopping every time. I tend to forget!.
I am ok with using local produce. I think UK could use greenhouses to produce quite a bit of veg and fruits here. I have spotted quite a few going up lately, which filled my heart with happiness.

RedCouch · 08/08/2021 09:31

The race for the super Rich to get up to Mars etc. Rats fleeing a sinking ship Grin

EvilPea · 08/08/2021 09:27

But whilst they are growing sea grass giving themselves a pat on the back. Governments are also chopping down ancient woodlands for shit like hs2. I drove past a site they are developing recently. Took 20 minutes to get through, that’s 20 minutes extra of traffic jams. They’ve decimated the site and have to pump water away in tankers due to no grass and trees soaking it up.

But back to the ancient forests only now are we beginning to look at what makes up soil and the fungus and bacteria that help sustain life, those forests hold a lot of answers to questions we don’t know we need to ask.

Buccanarab · 08/08/2021 09:26

I have said multiple times climate change exists. It has always existed. It cannot be stopped. Look at the geology of the planet. Seas move. Continents move. Weather changes. The planet was warmer during the fucking Bronze Age than it is now. You are all panicking over a completely natural phenomenon and are brainwashed into thinking humans have caused climate change. We haven’t. We’ve only barely nudged it. Not enough to kill us or all life as the doomsayers and fear mongers would have you believe.

Wow, please stop commenting on subjects you clearly have absolutely no understanding on.

The natural process of climate change is measured over geological time periods. Anthropogenic climate change is being measured over decades, maybe centuries.

There's no doubting atmospheric co2 and global mean surface temperatures have been higher previously. The problem is the speed in which we are changing things. Previously a rise in atmospheric co2 from 400ppm (currently) to 1200ppm (late cretaceous high) took anywhere between 5 and 20 million years to occur. At current rates we will do it in 400 years or so. We've absolutely no idea how such a rapid change will impact on the planet, but it's not going to be sunshine and roses for those of us living here.

The difference between natural climate change and anthropogenic climate change on the planet is the same difference as drinking a bottle of vodka over a year and downing one in 30 seconds would have on an average person.

Atmospheric Co2 is rising faster than it has done in over 66 million years. Guess what the cause of that spike 66 million years ago was? That's right the asteroid that helped wipe out the fucking dinosaurs.
Over the last 100 years or so we've released more than 5 times the volume of stored co2 than that asteroid impact did and people have the fucking idiocy to say "oh it's all completely normal, natural and fine". Fucking wombats the lot.

georgarina · 08/08/2021 09:26

I feel extremely panicky about it. It's to the point more than one of my friends has said they're not having kids because the planet will be in such a bad state by then.

But what can we do. I feel like all the billionaires and corporations won't change, they'll escape the effects and leave the rest of us to suffer.

But yes. It's really bad.

whenwillthemadnessend · 08/08/2021 09:20

www.wwf.org.uk/what-we-do/planting-hope-how-seagrass-can-tackle-climate-change

These the are sort of initiatives that give me hope

Amima · 08/08/2021 09:17

@Pollyglot that sounds idyllic but simply isn’t possible any more. Small shops have been replaced with big supermarkets so we can’t cycle to them. That’s also why we need tamper proof plastic packaging - because selling food in brown paper requires it to be kept behind the counter under someone’s supervision. Houses are so expensive, few people could afford one with a garden big enough to grow food. Not that they’d have time to grow food, or cycle to the shop, or knit sweaters - because high house prices mean that both parents have to work full time. And local industries have gone so people need cars to travel to work far away.

Accommodating all of these things requires massive social change and a return to small local shops and businesses, more gardens and allotments without a 10 year waiting list to get one, more leisure time and shorter working hours. Can you see the government telling the big supermarkets to sling their hook and switching us all to a 4 day work week? I can’t.

MsTSwift · 08/08/2021 09:10

Absolutely agree whenwill. Our expectations need to change as they did with Covid.

Theworldisfullofgs · 08/08/2021 09:08

What we need is to make it clear to the government there is significant support for drastic action

Someone needs to tell Steve Baker MP. The euro sceptics have turned into climate sceptics. Only happy when they are destroying things.

whenwillthemadnessend · 08/08/2021 09:07

We have the tools and brains to do this

Essentially it's up to governments to enforce the change

1.Amazon and the rainforest destruction needs to stop NOW

  1. We need to step away from fast fashion
  2. We need to step away from overseas food
  3. We need to grow Sea grass to absorb co2
  4. We need to build wind farms. Huge ones. Fuck the look of them. They need to happen
  5. We need to use more solar power
  6. Electric cars and bicycles
  7. State funded cheap and reliable public transport
  8. Other countries will have there own free energy. Sea wind solar. 3rd world countries need to be encouraged and supported to use it.
10. I would go as far as a one child family but no more than two. 11. We need to accept some uncomfortable changes until We get used to it we did it for covid. This is the hardest part

Ultimately the earth will
Move on and be fine if we do or if we don't

MsTSwift · 08/08/2021 09:06

We need a “we’re all in this together” war time mindset like we had with Covid. You get one flight a year. No business travel use zoom. Utterly rethink supermarkets so it’s all refillables. The whole economy would need to adjust so it’s not based on acquisition. Humans are smart we need to do this. Our old life (1960s-to 2019) was amazing but we can’t have whole populations living like Roman emperors. Planet can’t sustain that.

EvilPea · 08/08/2021 09:06

What pisses me off. Is that we knew about this when I was a child 40 pdd years ago. We could have made small changes.
But no.
Just look at the ridiculous new developments and concreting over everything and complete denial that it is playing a huge part in the flooding.