Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If it’s that bad, why aren’t we panicking more??

911 replies

Nightgardenisodd · 07/08/2021 20:59

Climate change.
I keep reading posts about it and it’s scaring the crap out of me for my DD’s future.
How bad is it? Anyone have any positivity about it?

OP posts:
SaharaFlower · 08/08/2021 12:14

For the 20 week fetus: I don't know, but may be unfair to deny a life down to disability. People with disability still live good lives.

SaharaFlower · 08/08/2021 12:12

"To put it bluntly we are a victim of our own success. We keep completely useless people alive when we should be looking at quality not how old you can get to. Is it really humane to keep a 20 week old fetus alive because we can even though that child will have life long crippling problems, not all but a lot do. If everyone today has two kids who have two kids etc the world will fill up. Who do you decide not to feed? There is only so much land to grow food on. Even that's disappearing with rising sea levels."

If the point of life is restricting life, then ask what is life? Confused

SlipperyDippery · 08/08/2021 12:11

@TableFlowerss

If world leaders made as much effort in to tackling climate change as they have trying to deal with covid etc… we’d maybe have half a chance.
Thank you. Totally agree and the damage we are doing to our planet with some of these infection controls is utterly immoral.
chocolateorangeinhaler · 08/08/2021 12:06

@SaharaFlower

People really do panic over anything. I can't believe people tell their children to not reproduce. Shock
The problem is that 100 years ago people died very easily women died in childbirth, infant mortality was high men died in wars and industrial accidents. In the mid 20th century the NHS I the uk was born. Infant mortality dropped. People lived longer. NHS is driven in reducing mortality generally.

To put it bluntly we are a victim of our own success. We keep completely useless people alive when we should be looking at quality not how old you can get to. Is it really humane to keep a 20 week old fetus alive because we can even though that child will have life long crippling problems, not all but a lot do. If everyone today has two kids who have two kids etc the world will fill up. Who do you decide not to feed? There is only so much land to grow food on. Even that's disappearing with rising sea levels.

sotiredofthislonelylife · 08/08/2021 12:06

Artificial grass, laid properly on a sand and aggregate base is more free draining than heavily impacted clay underneath the average lawn.
It reduces maintenance - fertiliser, weed killer, mowing (using electric/petrol lawnmowers, and replacing machinery when broken) - and is far easier for less able people to manage. It allows year round use too. I love mine!
I have plenty of flowers and trees in my garden, so plenty of birds, bees and butterflies are catered for.

PickUpAPepper · 08/08/2021 12:05

Best and quickest short answer - who’s “we”? Do you really think a London stockbroker-turned-politician with a few million hidden away in an overseas tax haven, and / or family with landed estates in the Home Counties, is facing the same level of threat as a normal working person from a northern English dump estate with “nothing but themselves to recommend them”? “There is no such thing as society”, remember? Especially when you realise that the former depends on the latter continuing to be an unaware cog in their machine. They care no more about us than the small farmer gradually losing land in Bangladesh - possibly less give today’s uncertain and complex ties and loyalties.

Lapsidasicle · 08/08/2021 11:56

This is a great talk about how to get everyone to care about the green economy....

m.youtube.com/watch?v=slbfAfEvnQ0

lannistunut · 08/08/2021 11:53

@DGRossetti

When the government acts like it matters, then I will.
Quite weird to defer to the government in this way, I prefer to use my own brain.
derxa · 08/08/2021 11:51

[quote MareofBeasttown]@Sarahlou63 The ultra rich will survive anyway, just as they have survived covid. I can;t really stomach this sort of eco-fascism.[/quote]
Agreed

burritofan · 08/08/2021 11:49

Also wonder why artificial grass is allowed in gardens - caused even more flooding issues when there were heavy rains recently, not to mention the impact on birds etc.
Agreed; it’s bloody awful. The trouble is so much relies on legislation: a ban wouldn’t be popular with the manufacturers, the installers, suppliers, etc, also the general public who’ll say, “But I like a clean garden/easier for my dog/whatever selfish reason”, and would vote against any measures. Also where does the old existing stuff go – landfill?

And you can’t rely on educational campaigns and people stopping choosing it so it gets killed off by market forces: look at when we were encouraged to wear masks rather than obliged to, there were threads here with people going, “But I like to see people’s smiles!” as an argument against it. On this thread alone we’ve got “I won’t give up cotton buds because I don’t like wet ears”, as though towels don’t exist; the other day someone started a thread on here blaming the government “because my recycling bin is full of Pepsi bottles” (?!).

Only draconian, sweeping legislation and measures akin to the rationing years will work, and there would be mass revolt. Some of which I think would be fair: easy for me with equity in my house and money in the bank to go and hide out the apocalypse somewhere with a big garden, keep chickens, grow my own, be anti-astroturf, but expensive bamboo toothbrushes/paste capsules/whatever. Harder if your life is different.

turbonerd · 08/08/2021 11:39

Thank you Buccanarab. It needs saying a million times: it is the speed of the changes!
Adjusting takes a while, mass extinction and lots of trouble is what one would hope to avoid,

But panicking is not helpful. A calm rational response would be much better!
And yes, it has to come from the top. But of course, the top can be heavily influenced from the bottom.
Do the majority of people want to, though? It seems not.
I am learning to fish, Hunt and grow my own food just to feel a tad more in control of the future.
The tipping point was a few years back, I am afraid, but as the systems are malleable I do not see any reason to sit back and watch Rome burn (or Greece, Australia, Siberia and North West America as is the RL scenario happening right now!)

Lapsidasicle · 08/08/2021 11:34

*lift households out of poverty

Lapsidasicle · 08/08/2021 11:32

I think that those posting on this thread are a self selecting group. You are right, humans are a great risk of extinction over the next centuries.

But in the real world, most people barely give climate change a passing thought. The vast majority are driven to make consumption choices on price versus utility basis.

The only way to achieve behaviour change is to incentivise it economically.

This is what government needs to do (and strategy is already published on it).... They need to create green jobs, well distributed around the whole country at all SES levels. Demonstrate a green economy is going to pay and life households out of poverty/ hand to mouth living.

You lot are just preaching to the converted middle classes, which is the whole problem with climate change activism. You’ve hit peak critical mass now and you’d be better off putting your energy into something else.

There’s no point writing to my MP. The environment is all he ever talks about anyway. Which in itself is alienating to a lot of people who have far more pressing concerns than climate change effects in future.

SaharaFlower · 08/08/2021 11:27

People really do panic over anything. I can't believe people tell their children to not reproduce. Shock

Laserbird16 · 08/08/2021 11:14

It's terrifying and depressing. I worry so much for my much wanted and loved children who will grow up in a world that will be poorer, sicker, with more conflict ...and it could have been prevented or at least not as bad.

I blame our stupid politics. I look at the braying idiots in power who are so busy point scoring and using bread and circus to shore up their 'popularity. Nobody likes them it's just who is the least odious for the next few years. We're in no way close to the mindset that is needed for meaningful action and international cooperation.

It's bad now. But we carry on. I can hardly claim to be doing all I could. Sometimes I do what I can and others it's just easier to take a 20 min drive to childcare than it is to take a bus for 50 mins or cycle a not particularly safe route. Or I can't justify thousands of dollars to upgrade my house from fossil fuels to a battery etc.

I honestly can't enjoy thinking about the future anymore. It's like watching someone take a knife to the mona lisa. But to talk to anyone in real life they'd think you were the one who was insane and not the situation we're in.

JacquelineCarlyle · 08/08/2021 11:13

@EvilPea

I don’t know why building regulations don’t include more things like this, for all developments, large, small even extensions. Plug points for cars, green roofs or solar panels only, hedges not fences, better landscaping to help slow the flow of water. Rainwater tanks for toilets (using clean water to flush toilets is mental).
I've often wondered this too! Also wonder why artificial grass is allowed in gardens - caused even more flooding issues when there were heavy rains recently, not to mention the impact on birds etc.
EvilPea · 08/08/2021 11:06

I don’t know why building regulations don’t include more things like this, for all developments, large, small even extensions.
Plug points for cars, green roofs or solar panels only, hedges not fences, better landscaping to help slow the flow of water. Rainwater tanks for toilets (using clean water to flush toilets is mental).

HasaDigaEebowai · 08/08/2021 10:52

We certainly need to prepare for far more temperature variation. I was worried by the number of people a few weeks ago talking about installing air con. That will quickly add to the problem. Better solution is external window shutter and brise soleils.

HasaDigaEebowai · 08/08/2021 10:48

There are hundreds of things we can all do. Some cheap and easy, some more expensive and time consuming. For those with gardens, growing food is a massive help.

RubyGoat · 08/08/2021 10:46

Organic is important. Non organic foods require the use of fertilizers. Fertilizer runoff flows into the sea & contributes to biodiversity loss. The sea produces approximately 50% (at least) of the earth's oxygen.

Hope your houses are decently insulated. Much of Scotland & northern England is on the same latitude as the southern tip of Alaska & the Aleutian Islands. We are only as warm as we are because of the Gulf Stream. It appears to be weakening. The last time the Gulf stream turned off, due to ice melt, there was an ice age that geologists believe only took about 10 years to get going.

AlaskaThunderfuckHiiiiiiiii · 08/08/2021 10:35

We try our best, recycle, haven’t been abroad on holidays as I don’t like flying, have meat free nights and the farm in our village is setting up a milk vending machine so will be getting our milk from there once it’s up and running.

Unfortunately I do rely on my car a lot with being rural the school, shops, doctors etc is not nearby. I also work in community nursing covering that wide rural area so it’s not a case of cutting working days/working from home/using public transport or a bike etc. I have a new 1.2 car so not a big gas guzzler. I won’t be changing to electric at the moment as I don’t have a drive and have to park out on the street which is set far off my house so would only be able to charge by running cables out on to the pavement which is a hazard, in my opinion I also think electric cars will be the next diesel

seasonalremarks · 08/08/2021 10:32

So we may not be able to control the outcome now... not saying we shouldn't try.

Sarahlou63 · 08/08/2021 10:29

if we start to make the Earth poorly, then it's immune system will start to kick in to eradicate us.

We have, and it is.

HasaDigaEebowai · 08/08/2021 10:29

switch to local, organic foods.

Definitely switch to local and certainly British but not organic. Its a completely different issue but organic food production is far less efficient and worse from a climate change CO2e point of view

TableFlowerss · 08/08/2021 10:19

If world leaders made as much effort in to tackling climate change as they have trying to deal with covid etc… we’d maybe have half a chance.

Swipe left for the next trending thread