Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If it’s that bad, why aren’t we panicking more??

911 replies

Nightgardenisodd · 07/08/2021 20:59

Climate change.
I keep reading posts about it and it’s scaring the crap out of me for my DD’s future.
How bad is it? Anyone have any positivity about it?

OP posts:
Daftasabroom · 15/08/2021 11:50

@iseeu you're building a bit of straw man there. Of course I don't think any of those are okay, but they are not the big hitters.

The biggest single contribution any individual or organisation can make is to reduce energy consumption. The first step on that ladder is to measure your energy use.

iseeu · 15/08/2021 11:46

@ArielBlue

Re comments about poorer families

I think you’re misunderstanding what I’m saying. I know lots of working class folk who are just starting to wake up to the climate crisis. They want to do something. But the environmental charities are not reaching out to them. Don’t talk their language.

Oh I see - yes I agree, WC doesn't mean poor. I also see what you mean about environmental groups in the UK being more MC. I live in France at the moment and our environmental groups sound very different where I am!! Sorry I misunderstood you

In relation to reaching out more, I think it is really difficult generally as you have to look for info from decent sources. I think having more clear objective info about what damage has been done and what has caused it would help? Posters with photos? But I do also think, personally, that the more info is put out there, the more people will realise that it needs to change from above as the top priority.

iseeu · 15/08/2021 11:40

@PickUpAPepper when you say Perhaps it is something to do with the way established middle class people who haven’t really known what it is to live worrying about where their next meal is coming from persisting in blaming poorer people for the damage? I have just realised that you might have thought I was blaming - in fact I was saying that poorer families do not have choices, they end up buying the cheap with short life span as it is all they can afford in the moment. In relation to poor communities with tvs and mobiles I meant that because of overproduction of goods the goods eventually get sold for very little. I wasn't talking about the uk though.

ArielBlue · 15/08/2021 11:36

Working class is not necessarily poor btw.

ArielBlue · 15/08/2021 11:35

Re comments about poorer families

I think you’re misunderstanding what I’m saying. I know lots of working class folk who are just starting to wake up to the climate crisis. They want to do something. But the environmental charities are not reaching out to them. Don’t talk their language.

iseeu · 15/08/2021 11:21

Text in the wrong place - "Yes it is helpful for posters to be passing comment on these i" - I thought I had deleted that as I didn't want to get bogged down in it

iseeu · 15/08/2021 11:18

@Daftasabroom I am not sure which demands from environmental groups you are talking about so I cannot comment, I am not a part of an environmental group and as I said I don't support what our local groups say and do. I also said that individuals choosing to do what they can is happening and of course is good so you are sort of misquoting me there. But I think you are very badly misinformed if you think that it is incorrect that certain activites have to cease - for example:

  • massive overproduction of electrical goods and mobiles with short life spans - are you saying that should continue and that it is unrealistic to stop that happening?
  • fishing practices where huge boats catch fish and prepare fish on the boat ready for selling in tins and frozen etc - they currently (still) gather up huge amounts of sea life and plants which they cannot use and chuck it back in the sea dead - this has had a devastating effect on biodiversity, acidification, ultimately climate damage for decades.
You think that this should continue? Yes it is helpful for posters to be passing comment on these i
  • oil practices, transport, refinery - should all continue as they are?

Yes I realise that most of these issues are politically challenging to deal with. But see my quote from the CCC you linked - this does not show the promising progress you refer to I don't think - I would be really interested to hear more specifics which show that I am wrong. What changes have been made in the last 5 years which you refer to?

iseeu · 15/08/2021 11:01

arielblue - I have just seen that pepper said similar things about poorer communities

iseeu · 15/08/2021 10:59

@ArielBlue I think very poor families are spending most of their energy surviving. I was very poor when a child - a lot of time and energy goes on worrying about the next meal and paying bills and having enough money for basics and getting to school etc.

I also think cynically that the poorer families and communities aroudn the world are intentionally targeted. The thing is - it is all very well us all making greener choices in goods but if the goods are still being produced - and they are - that is an awful lot of "stuff" - electrical goods, mobiles, etc - which is already made -and ends up on rubbish piles. Like the example I used above - mobile contracts often include regular free upgrades, and they tell you to just get rid of the phones you are upgrading from - that is a lot of unused phones. Sometimes things get sold on and on to poorer and poorer communities and ultimately end up rubbish tips. Which is why I think it needs to change at the top, regulations about the production of goods. This then conflicts with desires for a free market, and it becomes political.

Daftasabroom · 15/08/2021 10:12

@iseeu there has been a see change across business and government over the last five years and this is accelerating all the time.

Environmental pressure groups notoriously demand the impossible, and your own comment that some industries need to cease are equally unhelpful.

The truth is that planting a few wild flowers or using bar soapis not going to even make a dent in global warming, in our house we do both but we are realistic on impact these have. Shifting ALL responsibility away from the individual or household just won't work.

Daftasabroom · 15/08/2021 10:00

@Tealightsandd many cultures do not value educating girls so many leave school much younger than boys. They are then rarely economically active and have bigger families at a younger age.

PickUpAPepper · 15/08/2021 09:54

Perhaps it is something to do with the way established middle class people who haven’t really known what it is to live worrying about where their next meal is coming from persisting in blaming poorer people for the damage? The stats back up the common sense knowledge that excessive use of resources causes environmental trouble, and that is the preserve of those who have the finances to consume mindlessly. Where the impact of poorest people is high it is directly due to the societal choices preventing them from investing in their lives, for instance in housing, or the examples and influence of the rich pushing conspicuous consumption as the only social value through the media. They hold much more of the power of change, not the poorest. That said, it is well-off middle groups who come out with the excuses about how they shouldn’t be expected to change while others aren’t ime. People need to be much more aware of their wealth. I have centred ecological living on much less wealth than most in Britain. Ecological living and economic living go hand-in-hand.

www.theguardian.com/environment/2020/sep/21/worlds-richest-1-cause-double-co2-emissions-of-poorest-50-says-oxfam

www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2019/sep/19/life-earth-wealth-megarich-spending-power-environmental-damage

ArielBlue · 15/08/2021 08:29

Speak to/ speak for

ArielBlue · 15/08/2021 08:28

@iseeu I agree that lower income households are making choices that are less sustainable even though they have less impact than richer groups. But on mass it has a massive impact.

The environmental groups are however really bad at engaging lower income groups. Does anyone know why? I wonder why they are not using media influencers for example that connect with that group. It seems to me that the environmental movement is elitist. It’s made by and for the well educated people in society, also predominantly white.

The environmental movement has a diversity problem in the UK. Whereas I know in Brazil it’s more grassroots and working class.

Let’s face it, worrying about the environment is for ‘well to do’ people in the U.K. That needs to change.

It’s a missed opportunity. My CM and Aunt- both working class - have started talking about the environment for the first time I can remember because it was reported in the daily mail and they’re scared about their grandchildren’s future. The environmental movement needs to capitalise on this and help them make changes. But the movement doesn’t speak for/ speak for them.

iseeu · 14/08/2021 22:29

pickupapepper I understand what you mean but in relation to what you say about poverty, really cheap household items which are built to last a year are the sort of things poorer households buy - eg the example I gave upthread about vacuums - there are many more examples. You find flat screen tvs and latest tech phones in really poor areas because of various ways to access. This is all contributing to piles of rubbish. Also cheap fashion obviously. And it is the young, new in jobs, new to a wage, who is targeted by advertising, isn't it? So people from both rich and poor backgrounds? I take your point about the very rich, obviously - but given that many are the children of the people who profited from the poor practices of industries causing most damage to the environmentin the first place maybe not shocking

PickUpAPepper · 14/08/2021 22:14

there is only so much individuals can do if they have realistic renewable options. Putting a lot of pressure on individuals has in reality, also, turned man on man in many areas - eg the environmental groups near us are aggressive and threaten violence to mothers in cars with small children - that is what happens when you push the burden onto individuals without thought about consequences - it does not help. Obviously individuals who are aware and care will be making changes.

and "individuals must take responsibility" without acknowledging how unrealistic this is is as a policy to bring about climate change in the face of sophisticated marketing and advertising

I kind of get what you are saying, but households are the source of a lot of polluting energy use. That is undeniable.
I posted on another thread about how impoverishing the lower classes in favour of enabling the wealth of the rich, specifically with respect to housing, really hasn't helped, and I have made comments on here in a similar vein. It is the richest groups who consume the most, simply because they have the means to do so. Inequality is bad for us all: the need for conspicuous consumption to protect the status of richer groups is what's driving a lot of issues. I can barely begin to express my frustrations, as someone from a poorer background, with the inability of those better off groups to cope with "sophisticated marketing and advertising" in the face of climate change.

I haven't heard of the kind of violence you describe, but incidentally it sounds like "man on woman" violence, not "man on man".

HasaDigaEebowai · 14/08/2021 21:55

Are you a farmer?

No - and I know you are. I’m a lawyer. I just know quite a lot about the impact of beef consumption on climate change for various reasons.

Happy to say (as I did up thread) that it’s far better to eat British beef if you must eat beef.

iseeu · 14/08/2021 21:52

@derxa where I am in France most of the fields around me are used to farm maize which is then harvested to be used as animal feed

as an aside, the tap water here cannot be used for drinking or cooking for vulnerable people including pregnant women and young children because the nitrates are far, far higher than safe levels, people have to use bottled water for some things - high levels presumed to do with farming practices

iseeu · 14/08/2021 21:47

@Bluebellsinparadise - this is just one short extract from the most recent CCC technical report which illustrates my concerns:

"None of the current and future risks to business from climate change identified in the second Climate Change Risk Assessment (CCRA2) have decreased in magnitude. This partly reflects an improved ability to assess and report these risks, but it also reflects that business decisions continue to create additional risk by locking in increased exposure and vulnerability.
● Confidence in risk assessments is growing with better quality analysis and more sophisticated analytical approaches emerging, but limitations still exist. For example, it is often unclear if and how risks with low likelihood and high impact indirect risks and interdependencies are being considered by businesses. There is a lack of focus in particular on quantifying indirect losses, despite these potentially having significant implications for different business functions (in particular for B1, B2). [...]
● A further concern are lock-ins that occur when business decisions ‘lock in’ future climate risk that may be irreversible or costly to revert later. There is evidence of lock-in through riskinsensitive behaviour. This can occur through businesses’ decisions on operating models, site locations, infrastructure, supply chains, technologies, policies, or pre-existing adaptation actions, which may increase exposure to long-term risks. Lock-ins are concerning when they result in higher magnitude of risk due to slow adaptation or mal-adaptive response (B1, B2, B3, B6)
● The focus in this chapter is on domestic (from climate change in the UK) risks. However, a key source of risk for many UK businesses is the result of climate change outside the UK which affects UK businesses through investments, supply chains, distribution networks and other business relationships. Climate change outside the UK may further affect UK

derxa · 14/08/2021 21:38

@HasaDigaEebowai

Funnily enough the beef animals around here eat grass

If you’re in the UK then yes some will (about 70%).

In much of the rest of the world, particularly the big beef producers such as the US and South America, they are mainly kept indoors and eat animal feed. So if you’re buying beef then but British beef.

Are you a farmer?
iseeu · 14/08/2021 21:33

@Bluebellsinparadise I think your analysis is wrong here: Government is much more than Boris Johnson and his cabinet. I think a lot of people on here need to go back to basics and understand how the policy process in the modern state actually works. I also get frustrated by blaming govt and business - the picture is complex and there is lots of investment being pumped into this - much more than people here realise Yes I do understand how policy process in the UK works - and also how UK policy fits with other jurisdictions and global policy. UK policy can react to emergencies. CCC is bumbling along and there are some positive things - but what we have is a global emergency and policy making should be reacting - with other jurisdictions - as such.

Yes it is extremely complex and what is happening, what you describe, is not sufficient - not competent to deal with contributing to negotiations about how the global emergency is being dealt with.

I understand your frustration, but I personally find it incredibly frustrating that the people you refer to as professionals in this area post things like "there are some positives" - it is clear looking back at what has been happening for decades and this is not enough - and "individuals must take responsibility" without acknowledging how unrealistic this is is as a policy to bring about climate change in the face of sophisticated marketing and advertising

HasaDigaEebowai · 14/08/2021 21:32

Funnily enough the beef animals around here eat grass

If you’re in the UK then yes some will (about 70%).

In much of the rest of the world, particularly the big beef producers such as the US and South America, they are mainly kept indoors and eat animal feed. So if you’re buying beef then but British beef.

derxa · 14/08/2021 21:21

@HasaDigaEebowai

Should I be concerned about where the soy comes from? Is there a reputable way to trace its origin?

Soy is far better than beef, you'll be responsible for around 20 times less CO2e for the same amount of protein if you eat the soy rather than feeding it to the cow to create beef.

Funnily enough the beef animals around here eat grass.
Tealightsandd · 14/08/2021 20:15

@GreatAuntEmily

Although actually in the UK life expectancy has already stagnated. I expect it will go down soon. Poverty - and particularly lack of access to secure affordable housing - is the main reason.

Nothing to do with all the obesity, junk food, booze, lack of exercise then.

You just highlighted several of the key consequences of a life of poverty, misery - and a reactive rather than proactive preventative physical and mental healthcare system. (As an aside, nicotine is an appetite suppressant.)
GreatAuntEmily · 14/08/2021 19:44

Although actually in the UK life expectancy has already stagnated. I expect it will go down soon. Poverty - and particularly lack of access to secure affordable housing - is the main reason.

Nothing to do with all the obesity, junk food, booze, lack of exercise then.