Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If it’s that bad, why aren’t we panicking more??

911 replies

Nightgardenisodd · 07/08/2021 20:59

Climate change.
I keep reading posts about it and it’s scaring the crap out of me for my DD’s future.
How bad is it? Anyone have any positivity about it?

OP posts:
Darlingx · 09/08/2021 08:08

TwigTheWonderKid

Another major problem is that people have become so conditioned into believing that they need to buy things to solve problems that they probably can't get their heads around a situation that they can't buy themselves out of..

This makes me laugh because it’s so true. It’s sell the solution to the problem we are creating….Confused

forinborin · 09/08/2021 08:07

@lannistunut

A demonstration of rational humanism here, in my opinion, would be to invest directly into local mitigating measures for the developing nations affected. All technology is already there. The Dutch live below the sea level. Israel has space age yields in kibbutzes in what was effectively proper desert under extreme water stress already. Mitigate the downside, harvest the upside.

If you apply health economics approach, how are you valuing the land/people of e.g. Bangladesh vs the land/people of USA? That is my point, if you use a 'rational' (your word, not accepted by me) approach, the investment needed to mitigate will not be justified.

We need an ethical approach (although I have little hope of this) if we are to avoid the disgusting spectacle of millions of people simply being collateral damage.

The NHS uses health economics but also has underlying ethical principles. We fund hugely expensive individual treatment plans for this reason (rightly imo). It is not pure rationalism driving NHS decision-making.

I said rational humanism, not just "rational" as in coldly calculating how much Banglandeshi population are worth to me / the US / whoever personally. Ethics is all good in theory, but quite toothless unless armed with some rationality behind it. And yes, medical ethics does have an economic dimension to it - resources spent on a hugely expensive treatment for Peter today are resources not spent on Paul tomorrow.

Otherwise we will see what we see on this thread, people thinking that switching to paper cotton buds will suddenly save Bangladesh and frothing at the mouth about why not everyone grows organic tomatoes on their windowsill.

Impier · 09/08/2021 08:06

What a load of doom mongers. Throughout my life, environmental problems have been identified and fixed.

Lead in petrol, fixed
Holes in the ozone layer, fixed
Rivers, dead due to industrial and municipal discharges, fixed

In this country, our CO2 emissions, both total and per capita have been falling consistently since the 1980s and are now back where they were in the Victorian period.

Scotland regularly generates all of its electricity from zero carbon sources.

There is still more in be done, but what had been done already showed that governments, companies and individuals are all willing and able to solve these problems.

lannistunut · 09/08/2021 07:48

A demonstration of rational humanism here, in my opinion, would be to invest directly into local mitigating measures for the developing nations affected. All technology is already there. The Dutch live below the sea level. Israel has space age yields in kibbutzes in what was effectively proper desert under extreme water stress already.
Mitigate the downside, harvest the upside.

If you apply health economics approach, how are you valuing the land/people of e.g. Bangladesh vs the land/people of USA? That is my point, if you use a 'rational' (your word, not accepted by me) approach, the investment needed to mitigate will not be justified.

We need an ethical approach (although I have little hope of this) if we are to avoid the disgusting spectacle of millions of people simply being collateral damage.

The NHS uses health economics but also has underlying ethical principles. We fund hugely expensive individual treatment plans for this reason (rightly imo). It is not pure rationalism driving NHS decision-making.

Darlingx · 09/08/2021 07:46

Iusedtobesoooomuchfun

I completely agree industrialisation of food is what has produced mass over production and food waste. That model only works with waste plus it has changed our diets to become processed foods packaged to look more animated than fresh food.

GreatAuntEmily · 09/08/2021 07:45

Bitcoin production is a huge electrical demand
'Electricity needed to mine bitcoin is more than used by 'entire countries'
www.theguardian.com/technology/2021/feb/27/bitcoin-mining-electricity-use-environmental-impact

The manufacturers offset it but the offset could be used on something more vital

DGRossetti · 09/08/2021 07:43

This thread is a paradigm of why things are fucked.

Pages and pages of discussing this car vs. that car, with no one stopping to think "you know what ? Maybe we should do without cars altogether ?"

I now predict a slew of posts explaining to me - in painful detail - why this poster absolutely has to have a car.

The biggest obstacle to change is the (mistaken) belief by the many that "it's all about me". Because it isn't. It really isn't. If Covid has taught you anything, it should have taught you that. But some people are - let's be honest - a tad dim.

Darlingx · 09/08/2021 07:42

Food waste we are overfishing, over culling. We are literally filling the aisles with surplus supplies of perishable goods that get thrown away. The animals that gave their lives are already not being given dignity but to then also just bin it is insane I feel. We need to look at oversupply and foodwaste as much as consumer dietary trends.

Elephantsparade · 09/08/2021 07:40

@Lapsidasicle - those are interesting examples. Its good to hear all this is going on. It is reassuring. Thank you

The reason i was left with the impression nothing was happening is the new housing developments around here. I dont mind new housing but one is literally called Water Meadows! The developers build the same houses in the same way. I dont get why it isnt compulsory to orietate the site around maximum solar panels, make sure there are communal areas designed to flood, things to stop it becoming extra hot like not masses of concrete parking but a different surface, planting trees to shade the roads. Im sure there is loads of things i havent thought of.

Darlingx · 09/08/2021 07:37

How do you lobby powerful corps or govs who only have a short term view easy vote with your spend. Do your research as the wolf in sheep’s clothing can be multi layered. But our power as a mass is our consumerist habits in spending or active change because if we didn’t support them they would be forced to fail for not moving with the current consumer trend. So don’t buy into gimmicks or greenwash but do make your choices educated ones and use common sense. Buy from a greengrocer , walk , cycle etc it actually saves your environment, your budget and your health.

forinborin · 09/08/2021 07:36

@lannistunut

I think the benefits will not be felt by the displaced.

One you reduce living humans to a cost/benefit spreadsheet, you're in dangerous territory ethically. The costs will fall on people living today. It is only possible to discuss cost/benefit like this because you yourself are not in the group going to be displaced.

Many things in this world are decided according to a cost-benefit spreadsheet. Even when the NHS decides whether to give a life saving treatment to a sick child. Otherwise it makes it impossible to implement in practice, emotional decisions rarely work. A demonstration of rational humanism here, in my opinion, would be to invest directly into local mitigating measures for the developing nations affected. All technology is already there. The Dutch live below the sea level. Israel has space age yields in kibbutzes in what was effectively proper desert under extreme water stress already. Mitigate the downside, harvest the upside.
Iusedtobesoooomuchfun · 09/08/2021 07:34

We should have stayed as hunter gatherers. The agricultural revolution ruined humans. Idiots!

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 09/08/2021 07:33

Humans are, for the most part, selfish, shortsighted and unwilling to give up things for the benefit of future generations.

Simpleisntit · 09/08/2021 07:33

People are already moving being displaced by drought and flooding, especially in subsaharan Africa.

Iusedtobesoooomuchfun · 09/08/2021 07:32

People just don't want to give things up. Foreign holidays, theme parks, swimming pools, gyms, mobile phones, tablets, supermarkets, cars, flying, downsizing houses, new clothes, make up, perfume, new shoes, meat, dairy products.

All of it is unnecessary but who cares, you have your new nikes and you can upload the picture to instragram where very one can tell you how amazing you are.

The amount of energy wasted for Internet servers is alarming. But its OK. Because we can chat about it on Mumsnet.

Big business don't want to give things up either.

So nothing will change

Upinflames · 09/08/2021 07:31

We are.

I have been in the middle of a bushfire, one of the ones you might have seen on the news from Australia last year. That's what's coming down the line.

But stopping climate change lies less with individual actions than with systemic change. We could all stop flying and emissions might go down slightly, but not enough. What is needed is for governments and big companies to make the huge-scale changes - switching entire national electricity grids to renewables, phasing out coal burning power stations and petrol cars within the next five years, incentivising manufacturers and households to electrify so they don't need to use gas. Taxing the living shit out of companies that run high-emitting operations.

The bad news is that the scale of change required is vast. The good news is that it has already started.

Simpleisntit · 09/08/2021 07:29

Not sure if anyone has mentioned the small matter of soil. Because of the way we farm, and the effects of climate change, the UN predicts we have only 40 harvests left at the current rate of soil degradation.

That’s 40 years of food.

On a planet that’s population is due to be 9 billion in 2050.

There are different opinions about the amount of years but the point is that we are not using the earth in a way that is sustainable.

Binnaggy · 09/08/2021 07:28

This reply has been deleted

Withdrawn at the user's request

lannistunut · 09/08/2021 07:25

I think the benefits will not be felt by the displaced.

One you reduce living humans to a cost/benefit spreadsheet, you're in dangerous territory ethically. The costs will fall on people living today. It is only possible to discuss cost/benefit like this because you yourself are not in the group going to be displaced.

forinborin · 09/08/2021 07:20

@burritofan

I think that post means that the benefits are in the adaptation?

But I suspect a lot of benefits are only from a privileged perspective, e.g. climbing off the work treadmill, buying some land and becoming self-sustainable (while doing some white-collar WFH to sustain the instagram chickens).

Yes, that is exactly what I meant, you are very perceptive!
forinborin · 09/08/2021 07:15

Millions of people will be displaced, with widespread famine and drought. Wars over water.
Read the original studies, not the media representation of them. Many of them present a much balanced picture. Some areas will have increased water stress, but some will have reduced water stress - it is not like water will suddenly evaporate to the outer space. Vegetation is expected to flourish in presence of extra CO2, leading to increased agricultural yields and a reduction in droughts and hunger levels is expected in many regions currently suffering from it. Displacement can be prevented by technology - the Dutch were doing it for centuries, before any climate change. It would be wise to invest into that rather than into the paper straws and cotton buds PR campaign. We are allowed different opinions on the matter, no?

burritofan · 09/08/2021 07:08

I think that post means that the benefits are in the adaptation?

But I suspect a lot of benefits are only from a privileged perspective, e.g. climbing off the work treadmill, buying some land and becoming self-sustainable (while doing some white-collar WFH to sustain the instagram chickens).

lannistunut · 09/08/2021 07:04

@forinborin

I'd say adapting to the climate change is a better option than fighting. There are some benefits that come with it too, not only downsides.
What benefits? Confused

Millions of people will be displaced, with widespread famine and drought. Wars over water.

forinborin · 09/08/2021 07:02

I'd say adapting to the climate change is a better option than fighting. There are some benefits that come with it too, not only downsides.

HasaDigaEebowai · 09/08/2021 06:48

I’m not saying that meat and fish shouldn’t also be consumed far less. But it’s a difficult change to get people to accept.