Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If it’s that bad, why aren’t we panicking more??

911 replies

Nightgardenisodd · 07/08/2021 20:59

Climate change.
I keep reading posts about it and it’s scaring the crap out of me for my DD’s future.
How bad is it? Anyone have any positivity about it?

OP posts:
malificent7 · 09/08/2021 10:04

25 years ago i didn't want to learn to drive because of the climate and I was vegan...people thought I was mad and I got so much grief. I even wanted to move to an eco villiage.
I try to teach dd about recycling and cosumption...she rolls her eyes and thinks im mad.

Impier · 09/08/2021 10:01

"so ban polluting lorries, how many of use have followed a vehicle pouring out smoke?"

But that addresses a local pollution problem - particulates. A substantial part of the carbon cost of road transport is in the manufacturing of the vehicles. Scraping them before the end of their life adds to the overall CO2 production, rather than reducing it. There is balance to be stuck between local and global pollution. Local pollution is easy to see so people get fixated on that to the detriment of global warming.

Valeriekat · 09/08/2021 10:00

No-one actually knows anything because the data is corrupted.
Have your winter heating bills gone down yet?

Soberanne · 09/08/2021 09:57

@jasjas1973 of course we need more education. We need to educate our children from a young age so they can make informed choices. Education leads to action. Already on here there are people learnjng about the risks and how we an change. How can we vote in a government that can made a difference if we are not educated in what needs to change and why. Its our youth of today who will soon be the bigger voters, its their future, howmany people on here have already stated that they will be dead by the time i happens so they struggle to relate.

jasjas1973 · 09/08/2021 09:53

@Soberanne

I think we need more education overall. Young people are talking more and more about this but where is the real education. Not the scaremongering, not the focus on the disaster heading our way but rather how do try to stop it happening or limit the damage. Its easy to blame society and everyone else including governments etc but we need to start looking at and building a future. No one signed up for this, we cant blame people who were brought into a world based on consumerism etc, we need to change the thinking.
We certainly don't need more education! we need action, so ban polluting lorries, how many of use have followed a vehicle pouring out smoke? build houses out of recycled plastic - look at Nudura? uk housing is the worse in europe for energy use.

On shore manufacturing, so we have more control on pollution and reduce shipping, more localised manufacturing, again less shipping.

More transport by rail.

But what is desperately missing is leadership, looking at the UK, we have (at heart) a climate denier as our PM and the USA may well vote in Trump or similar in 3 years time.

It maybe that China provides the world leadership on Climate change?

Thingaling · 09/08/2021 09:52

It is really bad but then it never seems to stop any of my friends (and probably a good proportion of the people on this thread) booking foreign holidays left right and and buying second homes - both of which are bad environment wise.

Psychologically, people are unwilling to make sacrifices now for future benefit. Hence boomers and their environmentally disastrous cruises.

Soberanne · 09/08/2021 09:51

Things keep changing. We were all advised to get diesel cars, cheaper and cleaner, now its proven they are not but getting a new car is unaffordable for most.
Wehrn my child was little our nursery was encouraged to buy plastic, long lasting, saving the trees etc etc not its stop the plastic as its killing the environment yet the government still provide thousands of free plastic toothbrushes every year within its schools.
So we cant blame the very people who were born into this society that we live in that technically we never made. Had humans all those years ago realised the damage that was going to cause many just like today would have stood up and forced change. Thats what we need now.

Soberanne · 09/08/2021 09:47

I think we need more education overall. Young people are talking more and more about this but where is the real education. Not the scaremongering, not the focus on the disaster heading our way but rather how do try to stop it happening or limit the damage. Its easy to blame society and everyone else including governments etc but we need to start looking at and building a future. No one signed up for this, we cant blame people who were brought into a world based on consumerism etc, we need to change the thinking.

forinborin · 09/08/2021 09:46

You could start with that article I posted and check theirs out. There was some material coming out of KU Leuven and Utrecht University that I stumbled across. Shouldn’t be hard to find.
But the article you posted actually says that they are expecting to cope - in some scenarios with some abandonment, in some scenarios with actually reclaiming additional land, with the decision to be finely balanced based on the multitude of factors. As literally any other decision of that magnitude. Nowhere does it say that the Netherlands are going to "vanish under the waves" in the next 50 years as you put it. Confused

Look at what’s actually out there, actually learn something about how society and the environment has changed. Do your own research instead of subtly trying to undermine those who have.
Ah, great, so you're an actual climate researcher?

Amima · 09/08/2021 09:44

My car costs way more than a bus but it’s more convenient. The bus takes 4-5 times as long. That’s not realistic when you have to get to work on time and get home to pick up your kids. How am I supposed to drop off DC at 8am and get to work by 9am when the bus would take 2hrs from school to work? But it’s perfectly doable in a car because it’s a 30 minute drive.

The problem is that our lives have become too dispersed. Local businesses have closed down. Local shops have closed down. Now to access work and shopping we need to travel perhaps 20 miles, and realistically the only way to do that is in a car.

PickUpAPepper · 09/08/2021 09:29

I would be interested in looking at some sources for that. I genuinely mean it, I am trying to discipline myself into reading original studies and evidence-based predictions, and prepared to changed my mind.

So seriously interested that you haven’t bothered to look?

You could start with that article I posted and check theirs out. There was some material coming out of KU Leuven and Utrecht University that I stumbled across. Shouldn’t be hard to find.

Throughout my life I’ve watched consumerism ramp up and the ideological emphasis on individual solutions over collective ones, for instance, destroy any chances for individuals of poorer background, here and elsewhere. Always the same triviality from those who really had the power to choose something different, always the same excuses. I’m through. Look at what’s actually out there, actually learn something about how society and the environment has changed. Do your own research instead of subtly trying to undermine those who have.

Soberanne · 09/08/2021 09:15

There are solutions but they are expensive
Free Or really cheap public transport. When its cheaPer to drive your car than jump on a bus then thats exactly what people will do
Again grants for poorer people to buy electric cars or solar panels, community crofting, farming and growing.
Communal living.
Going back to the basics.
But nothing will ever change while we are so consumed by consumerism.
And people saying oh these small changes wont make any difference then oh well we might as well just give up.

Cukku · 09/08/2021 09:01

Global Warming is worse than any of those.

Caspianberg · 09/08/2021 09:01

I think growing more food at home, if you can is definitely the way forward. Even if each household with outdoor space grew some fruit or salad/ herbs, it would make a huge difference to having to move those items across the country or world.

My mother is a terrible gardener. She lives in a typical terrace house with small garden. She accidentally planted 5 courgette plants this year for the first time 🤣, and is now supplying half the street with surplus. Yes I’m aware this is only for maybe 2 months of the year. But it’s a small start. She said neighbours are already talking about trying to grow a few different things each and then swapping between each other excess.

forinborin · 09/08/2021 09:00

I really couldn’t imagine a worse set of cultural, social and economic trends coming together.
Fascism and the Second World War?
Slavery?
The Black Death?

50% child mortality?

Maybe let's keep a sense of proportion of how bad things actually are for the humanity these days.

forinborin · 09/08/2021 08:56

@PickUpAPepper

A ‘profitable export sector’ will mean nothing when they have no land left.
I would be interested in looking at some sources for that. I genuinely mean it, I am trying to discipline myself into reading original studies and evidence-based predictions, and prepared to changed my mind. So far I could find that the Dutch are provisionally planning for up to 2.5m future increase in the sea levels. And yes, there will be areas that would be abandoned in a controlled way under most extreme scenarios.
wherearemychickens · 09/08/2021 08:53

And we might have managed to clean up our rivers but they have been getting worse again over the last 10 years - see the chicken shit pollution of the River Wye this year.

wherearemychickens · 09/08/2021 08:52

Going back to biodiversity, we are one of the most nature depleted countries in the world, LemonSwan - look up the State of Nature reports from 2016 and 2019. We've seen really bad falls (c.30 - 40%) in abundance and range of wildlife since the 1970s. Insect decline is really really scary.

PickUpAPepper · 09/08/2021 08:49

A ‘profitable export sector’ will mean nothing when they have no land left.

PickUpAPepper · 09/08/2021 08:48

To really bring the masses with you requires an understanding of people’s circumstances- put yourself in the average family’s shoes and they only care about getting by until the end of the week, not the next decade. They are not selfish, rather many of the people on this thread exist in middle class bubbles with the luxury to make eco decisions.

I totally agree this is a big factor. Impoverishing working families has definitely all fed into this - starting with their finances, going on to demolish their opportunities as social contacts and hereditary nepotism becomes more important, but also treating their minds with contempt and feeding a daily diet of inadequate entertainment “news” and reality TV, telling them how shit they are whenever they point out the realities of life at the bottom in modern Britain and how little room they have for ‘choices’ and ‘flexibility’.

It makes it more important than ever that all the middle income groups become aware of their wealth and relative power and become responsible for their actions and choices, but they have, under the same cultural trends, become more selfish, complacent and arrogant than ever.

I really couldn’t imagine a worse set of cultural, social and economic trends coming together.

forinborin · 09/08/2021 08:41

Since a couple of posters have (predictably) mentioned the Dutch as an example of the technological marvels that could be done, please realise that the Dutch are seriously worried. With a long history of reclaiming land from the sea and protecting themselves by sheer will, they know that there are practical limits beyond which they cannot go.
As far as I understand, quite the opposite - engineering expertise in flood defence becomes a very profitable export sector. I think Big-U in Manhattan was projected by a Dutch team (but may be incorrect about this, was a few years ago that I read it).

PickUpAPepper · 09/08/2021 08:33

Since a couple of posters have (predictably) mentioned the Dutch as an example of the technological marvels that could be done, please realise that the Dutch are seriously worried. With a long history of reclaiming land from the sea and protecting themselves by sheer will, they know that there are practical limits beyond which they cannot go. The Netherlands is on course to vanish beneath the waves in the next 50 years.

As I said upthread, that might - might - wake people up in Britain. I will believe it when I see it. Too much belief in large scale centralisation, large scale energy production, to feed large scale profiteering, instead of looking after the bread-and-butter.

www.politico.eu/article/when-will-the-netherlands-disappear-climate-change/

jasjas1973 · 09/08/2021 08:18

@Impier

Your optimistic post shows why nothing will change.

Our rivers are polluted as are our seas, sewage and industrial waste.
Lead in petrol replaced by particulates, Ozone issues still alive and kicking!

UKs CO2 output is lower only by ignoring the manufacturing emissions incurred by other countries and not counting the cost of the raw materials used or the waste when no longer needed.

I think most people can appreciate that a govt that is dead keen on airport expansion, isn't really serious on climate change.

Simpleisntit · 09/08/2021 08:18

I’m waiting for the ippc report with baited breath today. I don’t think it will be pretty.

Zilla1 · 09/08/2021 08:17

@impier if this country is the UK then might those reductions have been achieved by exporting our CO2 by de-industrialising and importing manufactured goods?

Swipe left for the next trending thread