Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If it’s that bad, why aren’t we panicking more??

911 replies

Nightgardenisodd · 07/08/2021 20:59

Climate change.
I keep reading posts about it and it’s scaring the crap out of me for my DD’s future.
How bad is it? Anyone have any positivity about it?

OP posts:
Marimaur · 09/08/2021 12:44

It’s really interesting when people complain about China and India.. they make almost all the products we consume in the West.
We are responsible for their pollution.

Maggiejardine · 09/08/2021 12:37

Having read this thread and agree with many of the views, I now worry that we risk feeling so depressed, helpless and fatalistic - ‘we’re all doomed’ - that people will feel there is no point in doing anything as it will make no difference.

VickyEadieofThigh · 09/08/2021 12:22

@lannistunut

It is really, really bad.

We are not panicking more because humans are not always good at processing extreme risk, or dealing with our utter lack of control.

The fact the government is opening up more fossil fuel projects is making me feel both furious and completely powerless.

This - AND we've been 'boiled frog' on it by the media and the many deniers, some very high profile.
Impier · 09/08/2021 12:19

Again, global warming is a global issue not a local issue. It doesn't matter where in the world the migrant is. What does happen is when people move from a high fertility rate country to a low fertility, within a couple of generations they revert to the low fertility norm of the country they are living in so, from a global warming perspective, this migration is a good thing.

jasjas1973 · 09/08/2021 12:17

We are not panicking because we are doing sensible things like closing coal fired power stations. We are using less plastic

I thought we were opening up a new coal field and more licenses for oil exploration? only putting them on hold pre COP26.
Germany has more CO2 emissions because it has not off shored so much manufacturing to Asia/China as the UK has.

Are we using less plastics? not noticed any such thing, almost everything is encased in the stuff.

The UK is a past master at lying about its pollution, not least what we allow in our rivers, every single one is polluted with sewage, as our many beaches.

markmichelle · 09/08/2021 12:03

We are not panicking because we are doing sensible things like closing coal fired power stations. We are using less plastic.
Unfortunately we cannot convince other countries like Germany to give up coal power. Some countries like Poland or Botswana cannot afford to make the changes quickly, but they are starting.
It is progressing.
Can we afford to equip our homes with Charging points for cars?
Where will the money come from for re supplying the local electricity grid?
In the war against cars that many councils are waging against families they have forgotten that for most of us the first task of the day is to get 4 people to 4 different destinations between 7.30 and 9.00am.
Schools are not planned on easy to reach sites and Public Transport is a joke in most small towns.

MidnightMeltdown · 09/08/2021 11:55

I think it's really bad, but try not to think about it as I feel quite helpless about the situation. I think that my carbon footprint is probably smaller than most as I don't drive, and fly rarely. I also avoid fast fashion.

I know people who are very preachy and vocal about climate change, and yet they own a car and drive everywhere, have more than two kids, own cats and dogs, go on foreign holidays at least once a year etc etc. All very well for them to criticise others, as long as they aren't inconvenienced themselves.

LemonSwan · 09/08/2021 11:44

@wherearemychickens

LemonSwan - look up the State of Nature reports from 2016 and 2019. We've seen really bad falls (c.30 - 40%) in abundance and range of wildlife since the 1970s. Insect decline is really really scary.

Its true we lost a lot of fauna. But if you look at the history we lost most of our fauna a long long way before that. Its only due to anthropogenic maintenance that we retained such good insect diversity (from a very small original diversity) for so long. Ie. Wildflower meadows management.

So we might look like we have done badly compared to other countries. Statistically it might look like that, but its simply not true in reality if you understand the context which predated 1970, and the context now. That sounds like I am dismissing. Its not there isn't damage. But to say its worse than Europe is just not true.

Many european countries have fragile systems. They have declining indigenous flora as well as fauna and they do not have the conditions to remedy this without wiping out their natural species.

Say if you look at Spain, Italy, France and the general med countries. Xyella is one step away from wiping most of their indigenous flora and by extension their insect communities and then their general wildlife. So when we look at the big picture - on paper they might look like they are doing OK. But they are really not, its very concerning.

woodhill · 09/08/2021 11:43

@Empressofthemundane

Perhaps it’s really overpopulation that is the problem?
Yet the governments encouraged immigration for the past 30 years' hence having to keep building houses and leading to more cars on the road.
SixesAndEights · 09/08/2021 11:37

@Empressofthemundane

Perhaps it’s really overpopulation that is the problem?
Haven't there been studies done to show that's not the case?

Veggie or vegan diets and dialling back on over consumption seem to be some of the main solutions.

SixesAndEights · 09/08/2021 11:34

Every single new home should have photovoltaics, an underground rainwater tank for toilet flushing and the latest eco boiler.

These need to also be massively discounted for every other house and the aim needs to be to have as many buildings as possible converted to as many green alternatives as possible.

There would have to be a phenomenal increase in buses to cater for commuters. I worked out that to get to my old place of work I'd have to leave home at 6am, walk 2 miles into town, get two buses with a 30 minute wait between them, and at the other end walk 2 miles along a road with no pavement, to arrive at work by 10am. It's a 20 minute drive!

Empressofthemundane · 09/08/2021 11:16

Perhaps it’s really overpopulation that is the problem?

MsTSwift · 09/08/2021 11:12

It’s insane that flights are so cheap but the train is so expensive 🙄

jasjas1973 · 09/08/2021 10:52

@burritofan

Therefore we are all fucked. Yup. And even if individual action did help, this thread shows it ain’t going to happen en masse – from “but my wet ears!” to “but my car!” via “who cares about future generations lol not me”, this thread alone is basically a microcosm of selfish society
Societal change only happens at the national/international level.

People need leadership, if politicians acted and led, then we would all fall into step.

Individuals cannot and will not make the changes required and unless there are alternatives, people living in rural areas cannot make the changes.
42% of our (uk) energy, right now, is from burning fossil fuels, this idea we are some sort of Green leading nation is bullshit.

The money wasted on HS2 could be used to open up 100s of branch lines... housing estates nr me were only granted permission if a new rail line was opened, the developer was allowed to go back on that promise, so 1000s more cars on congested roads... its madness.

woodhill · 09/08/2021 10:48

@GreatAuntEmily

On the radio 4 news just now - the gov make 20 billion pounds a year in tax from fuel, petrol etc, what do you replace that with if everyone has electric cars. Something else will need to be taxed to raise that amount.
They'll tax the road use instead.

Also what happens to all the old cars

woodhill · 09/08/2021 10:42

@malificent7

25 years ago i didn't want to learn to drive because of the climate and I was vegan...people thought I was mad and I got so much grief. I even wanted to move to an eco villiage. I try to teach dd about recycling and cosumption...she rolls her eyes and thinks im mad.
I find it difficult where I work as some people are so cynical about where the recycling goes there and still go through bottled water even though there is a cooler and buy take away coffees - there are clear recycling bins etc. Covid has made it worse with disposable masks.

It's also the buying of fast food and packaging that is not helping

I know it's a drop in the ocean

Ooh if no one bought from the fast food & coffee shops etc then less jobs

Sarels · 09/08/2021 10:40

I meant globally selfish. I perfectly understand of income brackets myself am single parent working all hours just to keep up with cost of living , all the countries in the world need to be in this altogether and they are not ... and until that happens then personally I think it's just going to get worse . It just so so sad 😞

burritofan · 09/08/2021 10:30

Therefore we are all fucked.
Yup. And even if individual action did help, this thread shows it ain’t going to happen en masse – from “but my wet ears!” to “but my car!” via “who cares about future generations lol not me”, this thread alone is basically a microcosm of selfish society

Buccanarab · 09/08/2021 10:29

The IPCC have released their latest report this morning.

Full report, summaries, faqs, and other material can be found on link below.

www.ipcc.ch/report/ar6/wg1/?cf_chl_jschl_tk=pmd_53a162a45e1171a47986505fe85e47aab66b9d57-1628500943-0-gqNtZGzNAeKjcnBszQji

And in the interest of fairness a couple of articles from papers on the opposite end of the political spectrum.

The Guardian's take
www.theguardian.com/science/2021/aug/09/humans-have-caused-unprecedented-and-irreversible-change-to-climate-scientists-warn?CMP=Share_AndroidApp_Other

The Daily Mail's take
mol.im/a/9875079

diddlediddle · 09/08/2021 10:20

The only way anything will happen on a large enough scale to make a difference is if multiple governments worldwide take huge decisions about banning certain energy sources/activities etc and make various things illegal.

There is no way of individuals making enough of a difference on their own. Governments won't take this kind of drastic action because there would be huge economic and social consequences eg poverty, protests to name a few. Right wing leaders would then get elected and reverse everything so it would be futile.

Therefore we are all fucked.

ChainJane · 09/08/2021 10:19

@Thingaling

It is really bad but then it never seems to stop any of my friends (and probably a good proportion of the people on this thread) booking foreign holidays left right and and buying second homes - both of which are bad environment wise. Psychologically, people are unwilling to make sacrifices now for future benefit. Hence boomers and their environmentally disastrous cruises.
Exactly, nobody has come up with a convincing argument as to why I should make my already shit life even worse in order to benefit people who aren't even born yet.

Give me a well-insulated new home that is 100% green, powered by renewable energy, and I'll live in it. Give me an electric car and I'll drive it. But don't expect me to agree to struggle even more because that way things will be better in 50 or 100 years than they otherwise would be.

I would also add that I think a lot of the justification for flying (for example) that otherwise "green" people make is that on an individual level nothing we do will make a difference. It doesn't matter if I take a cruise or not (btw - I'm not, they sound horrific), it doesn't matter if I fly or not (btw - one return flight in past 10 years, six return flights in my life), it doesn't matter that I use as much single use plastic as possible (btw - I do Grin) - all my actions are statistically irrelevant.

All that matters is what everyone else does. If they care, they can make the changes. If they don't, fair enough.

burritofan · 09/08/2021 10:17

I’m waiting for the ippc report with baited breath today. I don’t think it will be pretty.
It’s definitely not pretty. www.theguardian.com/science/2021/aug/09/humans-have-caused-unprecedented-and-irreversible-change-to-climate-scientists-warn

jasjas1973 · 09/08/2021 10:16

[quote Thingaling]@jasjas1973

it maybe that China provides the world leadership on climate change

ha, China. China that is still building brand new coal fired power stations and is projected to keep increasing coal use over the next ten years. Coal is one of THE biggest causes of greenhouse gas emissions. China is also one of the world’s biggest users of cement which is also environmentally egregious.[/quote]
Yet still per person, China trails the US on GH gasses! and China is very much effected by climate change as it relies on imports of foods, raw materials and has seen earthquakes and floods.

My point is that the US cannot be guaranteed to be so keen on tackling climate so who will step up?

Caspianberg · 09/08/2021 10:10

Flights v trains is still a cost and time thing. We live a 2hr flight away. With Ryanair, no frill flights as low as £9 each way.
Train takes 16-20 hrs, requires 3-4 train changes, costs £180 min each way.
We have taken the train in the past, but its definitely not as convenient.

Also car v bus. Where we live buses run hourly 6am-10am, nothing again until 2pm, then last bus at 8pm. Last bus 2pm Saturday and no buses at all Sunday. It’s just not convenient. Everyone choices to walk, cycle or car over taking the bus.

Thingaling · 09/08/2021 10:06

@jasjas1973

it maybe that China provides the world leadership on climate change

ha, China. China that is still building brand new coal fired power stations and is projected to keep increasing coal use over the next ten years. Coal is one of THE biggest causes of greenhouse gas emissions. China is also one of the world’s biggest users of cement which is also environmentally egregious.