Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

If it’s that bad, why aren’t we panicking more??

911 replies

Nightgardenisodd · 07/08/2021 20:59

Climate change.
I keep reading posts about it and it’s scaring the crap out of me for my DD’s future.
How bad is it? Anyone have any positivity about it?

OP posts:
derxa · 11/08/2021 10:55

I and millions of others have become accustomed to a life full of luxury fuelled by consumerism. Nobody really wants to say goodbye to that.
In a nutshell. I was a sixties child and our lifestyle was far greener than most people's now..

User135644 · 11/08/2021 10:38

man won't be satisfied until everything has gone,,& then he still won't be satisfied

Capitalism won't be satisfied until everything has gone,,& then it still won't be satisfied

Walkaround · 11/08/2021 10:32

@MsTSwift - there is inconsistency in the messaging over children and families, though - China already has a massive population, but has had to reverse its one-child policy, because an ageing, shrinking society is not sustainable. So, after reducing births, you are then looking at ways of reducing numbers of elderly, infirm or otherwise vulnerable for the notion of population reduction to be viable, which makes the idea seem somewhat less appealing.

MsTSwift · 11/08/2021 10:16

There are threads where people are asking if they should have the 3rd or 4th child 🙄 which I find extraordinary this week. We stopped at 2 don’t expect me to endorse some randomers decision to add to over population because sorry (not sorry) I’m in no mood this week to gush how marvellous large families are 🙄.

malificent7 · 11/08/2021 10:13

Quite why people want large families is beyond me for different reasons but that is for another thread!

malificent7 · 11/08/2021 10:11

It's not a bad thing though if we don't last as a species...it serves us right. We have the knowledge and capability to form a great sustainable civilisation on earth and we have royally spaffed our opportunity up the wall. Lets hope we can change before it's too late.

iseeu · 11/08/2021 10:11

individual consumerism has been driven and manipulated by businesses, for over a century, getting increasingly worse. And for about a century there has been a practice of intentional limited life spans of goods - hence huge piles of rubbish - for the benefit of increasing profits. It isn't individuals driving consumerism. It is consumers being manipulated and also forced to buy things with limited lifespans as nothing else available.

Biodiversity in the sea has dramatically reduced and we are on track to have a sea full of nothing but jellyfish in about 80 years... Acidification from pollution from oil, plastic, piles of junk and fishing practices which involve huge numbers of ocean life not suitable for eating being caught and thrown back into the sea dead.

Some governments are acting in other parts of the world, but not enough - to turn things back would mean to get rid of entire huge industries which have basically dominated politics. There is also probably a lack of awareness of how bad it is - cabinet ministers will not necessarily have much more understanding than your average person because you have to really look to find the info - we just get the stark warnings, no specifics about what needs to be done about industries and consumerism - and there is no incentive for industries to spread the word.

Trying to push responsibility onto individuals is going to do very little other than cause tension between the individuals who want to live differently and those who don't

mogsrus · 11/08/2021 09:54

man won't be satisfied until everything has gone,,& then he still won't be satisfied

lovesthosebeeps · 11/08/2021 09:50

It can't be that bad though. No government seems to care so much as to put any serious messages across.

I and millions of others have become accustomed to a life full of luxury fuelled by consumerism. Nobody really wants to say goodbye to that.

I think there should definitely be a strong message to stuck to a max of 2 DC though, for so many reasons

Mreggsworth · 11/08/2021 09:44

I agree I dont think its fair necessarily to tell people they should only have 1 child or no children but I think 2 is reasonable. But its just advice, it's not making people do anything.

Something needs to be done around awareness of having too many children in this climate, theres a thread right now about wanting a 3rd child and the ones encouraging the 3rd child arent even considering the environmental impact.

I don't see any limit on children in this country being enforced as it couldn't be done ethically, so I think the best anyone can do is strongly advise people to consider the environment and make people aware that a decision to have a 3rd/4th/5th child is contributing to the potential threat to humanity.

Walkaround · 11/08/2021 09:39

I fear that if the problem is not taken seriously internationally, by governments, that the general attitude is likely to be that it either can’t be as serious as they say, or, if it is, then best to enjoy life as much as you can before you die in the inferno or flood. It really is farcical to tie people’s ability to survive to their ability to earn money, and then tell individual people they have the power to fix things and make big business change its polluting ways. Like hell they do in a global, capitalist economy. Who deliberately trashes the industry which provides them with the income they live on when they will effectively just be punished for it by becoming unemployed/losing their retirement income/going bust? That’s like expecting everyone to isolate without furlough pay.

Dreamstate · 11/08/2021 09:29

Well we have peolle here telling other people that they shouldn't have children whilst they have had multiple children themselves

Don't you see how utterly disgusting that is. So you want other people to stop doing the very thing you've done.

Deny other people the experience of having children because all of a sudden your concerned about the environment

And if as some others say there are too many people on the planet then wasn't covid the right time to depopulate then? Instead people didn't want anyone to die.

So you eveb listen to yourselves when you spiut utter tripe like that

MsTSwift · 11/08/2021 09:16

So what’s your solution? Just give up?

diddlediddle · 11/08/2021 09:10

@MsTSwift if the majority of us did a few things it would help yes, but it's a drop in the ocean. It won't make any meaningful difference in the timescale needed. What is needed is global cooperation from governments and corporations to eliminate entire industries and imposing aggressive laws on individual freedoms. Which ain't gonna happen.

Hatethisplacetho · 11/08/2021 08:44

What good does panicking do? Why are we all still buying food in disposable plastic when the supermarkets and food producers could make a huge difference by insisting we all reuse our glass containers, I have hundreds of glass jars, Pyrex etc and I would much prefer to refill those than buy a new one each time. The big industries need to step up and make changes that we the little people can support.

User135644 · 11/08/2021 08:29

@Globaluser

The people on this planet are selfish, unkind, and just absolutely awful; therefore the world is broken! My heart weeps for it and the children that live on it!
Humans are the worst. Awful race.
ThirdElephant · 11/08/2021 08:26

@Dreamstate

So how many of you saying w ended to do this do that are actually doing it yourself? Have you stopped shopping at places that use too much plastic? Have you given up your car? Stopped travelling abroad? Only had one child Quit meat entirely Buy less stuff

Lets see if your practicing what your preaching

Yeah, this attitude is part of the problem. 'Unless everyone else is perfection personified, I can feel morally justified in living my life in the easiest and most fun way possible. They shouldn't pass judgement on me because they're not perfect either,' while you take your five kids on long haul holidays every year, run the hot tub at 40 degrees constantly all year so it's always the perfect temperature etc.

No one is going to be perfect. Everyone can do better. Doesn't mean no one should bother trying.

MsTSwift · 11/08/2021 08:25

The childish aggressive “if you don’t live under a hedge yourself stfu” approach needs to stop. If the majority of us did a few things it would help. I’m not perfect by any means but am trying - reducing meat stopped at two dc refillables etc. We bloody love travel and not flying is what hurts me.

LadyLaSnack · 11/08/2021 07:50

*Have you stopped shopping at places that use too much plastic? (trying but could do better)

Have you given up your car? (no - I have trouble doing this as I live rurally - e.g nursery is 5 miles away)

Stopped travelling abroad? (yes)

Only had one child (no)

Quit meat entirely (yes)

Buy less stuff (yes)*

So I'm trying but I could do better.

I would be happy to use public transport if there was any, but local buses are extremely few and far between and don't go anywhere directly. I did try quite hard to make an electric car work last time we needed to change cars, but in the end, with the 2nd hand ones we could afford, the batteries didn't last long enough to fulfil our daily trips.

jasjas1973 · 11/08/2021 07:42

@Dreamstate

So how many of you saying w ended to do this do that are actually doing it yourself? Have you stopped shopping at places that use too much plastic? Have you given up your car? Stopped travelling abroad? Only had one child Quit meat entirely Buy less stuff

Lets see if your practicing what your preaching

3 of those 5, working on the meat.

We are missing leadership and focus, since the 'report, climate change has been removed from the news :(

Dreamstate · 10/08/2021 22:28

So how many of you saying w ended to do this do that are actually doing it yourself?
Have you stopped shopping at places that use too much plastic?
Have you given up your car?
Stopped travelling abroad?
Only had one child
Quit meat entirely
Buy less stuff

Lets see if your practicing what your preaching

pheebumbalatti · 10/08/2021 21:23

The main underlying cause is that there are simply too many people now, and more being created.

Newgirls · 10/08/2021 20:59

Climate activists have been taking about population controls, eating less meat, not buying single use items for years. It’s all obvious but we need to do it.

Yes government should be leading this and dealing with dire companies. But as we have these clowns we need to do our bit now and vote for better MPs ASAP.

Business for too long has been ignoring climate issues. It’s all about profit. Companies who use packaging should pay for it to be collected and reused. From coffee cups to cars. They produce what they like and let councils eg us pay for getting rid of it down the line. Germany has a much better approach where packaging companies have to fund recycling plants. We don’t do that in the Uk.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 10/08/2021 20:28

The thing is that cheap mass production brought us here. When you produce cheap the only way to make money is to mass manufacture and that wastes resources and energy.

Restricting the number of flights a person can take will lead to fewer air movements and higher prices.

Whoever put that quiz together has either no idea how things work or wants to mislead the public.

There is no choice.

DGRossetti · 10/08/2021 19:30

@ChardonnaysPetDragon

Interesting polling info - people not keen on higher costs, more keen on restrictions on e.g. number of flights.

The interesting thing is that people are under the illusion that there is a choice to be made.

I suspect an awful lot of answers were given in the assumption that "somebody else" will be affected ....