Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

GP Surgeries are NEGLIGENT if they're not doing face to face appointments

342 replies

AmIEmptyOrNumB · 07/08/2021 18:23

My GP surgery never stopped. They just triaged so 90% by phone and those essential face to face appointments carried on but with masks etc. Why is the government not doing more about this? These Surgeries denying all face to face appointments are failing the hippocratic oath.

OP posts:
annie335 · 08/08/2021 18:30

@igelkott2021

It's not just GPs actually. I have a private dentist and they still haven't opened their doors to people walking in from outside (it is in the town centre so I used to pop in to make appointments), and you can't make an online appointment either.

I assume you have to phone up and beg to see someone.

Dental practices have been open since June last year but you can't just pop in like before as there is a locked door policy. You should be able to get an appointment though especially if you are private.
inpixiehollow · 08/08/2021 18:24

My doctors surgery are still only doing telephone appointments although they are now doing smears, vaccinations etc with the nurse Confused to be honest I think my particular surgery have taken it as an excuse to do as little as possible, getting an appointment was always an ordeal before covid so i think they are secretly delighted with the new system.

igelkott2021 · 08/08/2021 17:08

It's not just GPs actually. I have a private dentist and they still haven't opened their doors to people walking in from outside (it is in the town centre so I used to pop in to make appointments), and you can't make an online appointment either.

I assume you have to phone up and beg to see someone.

Tistheseason17 · 08/08/2021 17:06

All I have is hugs for you as it is indeed a shitshow for those who are actually living it @MissLucyEyelesbarrow - I'm a PM and 99% of pts are fab but that 1% who are not are particularly vile and present daily to GPs, reception/admin and nurses. Your team, although smaller is with you!

Stillgoings · 08/08/2021 16:59

Its so stressful. Firstly the battle to get through at 8.30am. Redial after redial until you finally get through to the telephone queue.. Then having to explain it all to the receptionist. Then the wait for the phone call which can be absolutely any time. They don't give a shiny shit about our work or other commitments. You answer it or you miss it and if you ring back because you've missed it, it's tough shit, 'they're too busy, try ringing back tomorrow'. If you do get the call you just have to answer it wherever you are and explain your bowel issues or whatever in front of whatever audience..I hate it. I don't ring unless I absolutely have to. I can feel my blood pressure rising, like boiling, at just the thought of the music on their phone. There's no wonder things are getting missed, it's too hard to get seen. And I don't blame it on the receptionists at all. I feel really sorry for them. That's one job I could never do. The system is broken.

Menora · 08/08/2021 16:36

@thereisonlyoneofme

I have been with my GP surgery for since 1970! It has changed from seeing the same GP each time to not being able to get an appointment or phone consultation, even before COVID, apparently we now have one part time GP surgery owner and one locum. Our town has experienced massive house building and all these people need a GP. I came out of hospital after having a radical hysterectomy plus, and despite informing that I lived alone with no support, received no back up or any contact with my GP. I am desperate to change surgeries but most of them in our town are the same. I expect if I went private I would see the doctor fairly quickly.
I also had a hysterectomy recently what is it that you were expecting from your GP can I ask?
Menora · 08/08/2021 16:21

If you are calling and told to call at 8am it is likely any advance appointments have already been taken
There isn’t an infinite number of them
Most GP’s work a 4 hour session with either 10 or 7 minute consultation per session so could see 24 people in the AM or PM. If you have 5 GP’s working all day that’s still only 240 appointments. And some have to be double appointments because they are more complex. Out of that 240 some of them will already have been filled with reviews (mental health and medication for instance).
If they have 10,000 patients that is only 2.4% of their list of people a day

Sunshinealligator · 08/08/2021 15:44

I agree.
My husband required a Dr's appt.
When he got a telephone appointment he was told he was absolutely fine.
His right arm was 2.5 inches bigger than his left, it was red, painful and hot to the touch. He almost begged for a face to face appointment.

No, no, Mr sunshine alligator, it doesn't sound infected at all. You don't NEED to be seen in person.

2 days later he was in hospital with a severe case of cellulitis, he stayed for 5 days whilst they tried to get the infection under control, re-opened his arm, had to remove some of the infection.

He has had cellulitis 3 times since then, and they have refused to see him face to face at every request. He has started to just bother 111 and they get him OOH appts because our GP are negligent.

thereisonlyoneofme · 08/08/2021 15:33

I have been with my GP surgery for since 1970! It has changed from seeing the same GP each time to not being able to get an appointment or phone consultation, even before COVID, apparently we now have one part time GP surgery owner and one locum. Our town has experienced massive house building and all these people need a GP.
I came out of hospital after having a radical hysterectomy plus, and despite informing that I lived alone with no support, received no back up or any contact with my GP. I am desperate to change surgeries but most of them in our town are the same. I expect if I went private I would see the doctor fairly quickly.

MissLucyEyelesbarrow · 08/08/2021 14:33

I'm not a GP but given the choice of 12hrs of verbal abuse versus a hospital consultant position with 20 min appointments and fixed breaks you can see which is more attractive to a trainee doctor exc ED as this is also hard

Exactly. In fact, I'm an ED (A&E) doctor as well as a GP, and being a GP is considerably harder. A&E is intense, but there is a camaraderie and you have way more support than a GP because you're in a hospital, with access to imaging, pathology, colleagues for advice etc. As a GP, it's you, by yourself, in a room 12 hours a day, being shouted at by patients,, with fuck-all support and no resource.

LjSebs · 08/08/2021 14:17

When I asked the receptionist for an approximate time for a telephone consultation, I was told they could not provide that and it would be sometime that day. I queried this as I had to work and was told my problem couldn’t be that bad if I still went to work and couldn’t sit and wait (all day) for the call.

Made me feel like I was inconveniencing them so much. I never got called.

Tistheseason17 · 08/08/2021 13:43

@Congressdingo

then we'll have to pay £99 to speak to a GP. Then people will use the NHS more appropriately or the poor will become more ill. This makes me desperately sad

Last time I read about charges for appts a fiver was mooted. I know it's a few years ago but bloody hell from five quid to £99 is a leap.

I'm totally against charging anyway for many reasons but I'm not particularly poor and I'd have a hard time finding this much on a regularish basis.
If I look back at the last month if this was in place I would need to find 3 fees for me, 2 fees for DP and 1 or 2 for a child. So 6/700 pounds in a month. Add on prescription fees and I'd be broke.

To see a GP privately in UK now is £99 - go online and check it out. I understand that in Ireland over 18s pay 50-70 Euros already as they have no NHS. Even a £5 is too much if you are in poverty and unwell IMHO.

Government needs to invest in training GPs.

I'm not a GP but given the choice of 12hrs of verbal abuse versus a hospital consultant position with 20 min appointments and fixed breaks you can see which is more attractive to a trainee doctor (exc ED as this is also hard)

Puzzledandpissedoff · 08/08/2021 13:04

Financial resources for the NHS have plummeted and been used for vanity projects. How much did those ridiculous Nightingales cost? How much was diverted to friends of cabinet ministers through dodgy contracts? ...

And that's exactly why the cries about "funding" aren't the answer, or at least not all of it. We could give every penny the UK has to the NHS and what's to say it would make the least difference without thorough reform?

TheWernethWife · 08/08/2021 12:56

I had a missed call from my GPs surgery, on ringing them back, I had to listen to a recording asking to more or less be patient, don't abuse staff as they are all trying their best in these "difficult times".

Almost everyone I've spoken to has had difficulty accessing their GP whichever surgery they are registered at.

Most people have been jabbed, doctors and staff have been doubled jabbed. People are frustrated especially as dentist round here have been opened for routine visits for at least six months. The really are up close and personal with clients.

NightOwl19 · 08/08/2021 12:44

My gp has refused to see anyone since this began.

I had a c section that got infected they refused to see me and said as I work in a medical field I know the signs of sepsis do take myself to hospital it I become unwell.

Refused to see my poorly newborn and said go to a&e who were pissed off that the GP refused to see us.

Over 6 months later and I still haven't see. Signed off post Natalie because my GP won't see anyone

lavenderandwisteria · 08/08/2021 12:34

I think it’s possible to have the utmost respect for GPs as individuals and to recognise the current system fails them as well as us.

LakieLady · 08/08/2021 12:32

I am so fucking fed up of this never ending stream of utter shit against GPs. The vast majority are on their fucking knees they are so overloaded, but because you can’t “see” it it isn’t happening

The number of GPs in the town where I live is the same as it was when I moved here in 1991. The population of the town has grown by around 25% in that time. In addition, the surgeries serve a number of rural parishes, all of which have had significant population growth because of all the extra housing that has been built.

It's no bloody wonder the GPs are stretched, they've got loads more people to look after, even disregarding the impact of Covid and the demands of an aging population.

Whyo · 08/08/2021 12:30

@AmIEmptyOrNumB

The GP'S that are too lazy to do face to face should be DEEPLY ASHAMED
No GP isn’t doing f2f for laziness - they’re able to book more patients over the phone so are busier.

No it’s not negligence not to give you a f2f if not required.

No doctor in the U.K. takes the Hippocratic oath you’ve pulled that from American hospital dramas.

If you mean breaching code of ethics, then still no they’re not.

If you feel you’re being gatekept by reception I sympathise I really do, complain to your practice manager it’ll be more constructive to your issues than this.

lavieengris · 08/08/2021 12:23

It seems common. I’ve had it in each of the three surgeries for same day appointments. It is very stressful as I’d only call if felt really rough- not usually up for being on hold and then the triage!

This is one of my biggest issues - the people who are sickest are often not able to compete in the phone scramble.

However, they did/ do also have a ring after 2 option for routine appointments and, usually, an online booking option.

Sensible. Routine appointments can be planned and spread across the year to better manage capacity. I don't know why some practices fail to grasp this. You know how many of your patients have conditions that require regular care. You can schedule those patients. If you schedule them, they are far less likely to need urgent care, because their conditions will be under control. It means you have more certainty over how much time you can free up to deal with unexpected, urgent matters, typically other patients.

Why admin/IT staff can't come up with logistics that are fit for purpose to leave doctors to get on with practising medicine, I just don't know...

If my NHS GP can manage it, so should everyone else's!

ResIpsaLoquiturInterAlia · 08/08/2021 12:18

Original poster I have a different viewpoint regarding disagree your statement about GP surgeries. In my experience I telephoned my NHS doctor practice a few days ago and spoke to the receptionist to enquire if they were currently conducting in person appointments. As they were, I was offered an appointment later that afternoon. Job done and no biggie but business as usual although obviously masked with strict no nonsense Covid protocols and questioning with few people permitted simultaneously in the building. This is a large practice in central London connected to one of London’s major teaching hospitals. I rarely make use of my NHS GP practice as I normally use private healthcare or just ask a sibling who is a senior head of practice GP or father in law who is a retired hospital surgeon so two family doctors on speed dial if absolutely necessary. I normally use my GP practice for travel clinic vaccinations and keep myself and family trim and healthy to fight against Covid. We are not regular ill patients and so light fair usage of limited NHS resources. Doctors have been under undue pressure since the pandemic and have done an amazing job! It is the Covidiots that have themselves to blame for ill health. The doctors are doing their best to fix the mess.

Birminghambloke · 08/08/2021 12:16

[quote lavieengris]@Birminghambloke My previous practice didn't let you book routine problems, which was a big part of the problem. Every appointment - urgent or non-urgent - was dealt with via the 8am same-day phone scramble.

No one has yet managed to convince me that the 8am phone scramble is a justifiable way of operating. And yet, it's so common...[/quote]
It seems common. I’ve had it in each of the three surgeries for same day appointments. It is very stressful as I’d only call if felt really rough- not usually up for being on hold and then the triage!

However, they did/ do also have a ring after 2 option for routine appointments and, usually, an online booking option. I did online for my routine appointments when undergoing lots of tests/ consultant appointments. One surgery had the online routine appointments available for after 4 pm. Perfect for my work and leaving a bit early. The best surgery offered 7.30 / 7.40: 7.50 a.m appointments via online booking. These seemed to always be available! You’d be there with an empty carpark too!

The system I liked best was in one city where you could turn up from 8 and by 9 and wait and be seen by 10.30! All GPs just saw patients. It meant a waiting room full but you knew you’d be waiting for a definite face to face consultation as opposed to waiting in a phone queue.

lavenderandwisteria · 08/08/2021 12:05

I think that there is a middle ground between free at the point of service but not very good and the system they have in America, to be honest.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 08/08/2021 11:44

@LemonRoses,

I don’t care whether it is ‘free at the point of access’.

We need some kind of system which works, regardless of whether copayments are required.

Everyone looks at the U.S as an unfair system but we are pretty much there here, just conning the average person that they have a marvellous ‘free at the point of access’ service. We don’t.

Want to see a GP, next appointment a month away. If I pay £75 (and an annual membership fee), I see a GP same day, pretty much at the time of my choosing. In pain and need a hip replacement, waiting list now 2 years (?). If I have insurance or have 10-20k, I can go in in a couple of weeks and have state-of-the-art surgery.

The NHS might have had its moment in the sun but, especially post COVID, and with a few exceptional pockets of excellence, it is a second class service.

Why do we keep kidding ourselves it is somehow wonderful?

lavieengris · 08/08/2021 11:30

@Birminghambloke My previous practice didn't let you book routine problems, which was a big part of the problem. Every appointment - urgent or non-urgent - was dealt with via the 8am same-day phone scramble.

No one has yet managed to convince me that the 8am phone scramble is a justifiable way of operating. And yet, it's so common...

Birminghambloke · 08/08/2021 11:27

@sheepisheep

"Phone appointments are a great idea BUT need to be more thought out. I work in a school. I cannot have my phone on me. I don’t get “leave” to be taken as and when I want it. So how do I get to speak to my doctor unless it’s the school holidays (which was how I got my recent appointment)."

How did you get time for doctors appointments before covid? This sounds like your employer's issue tbh. Also, mostly when I've spoken to teachers they've asked for calls after 4pm and usually it's not an issue to accommodate that.

The issue with all of this is that demand outstrips supply every single day. We have moved to a triage situation, which is fundamentally different to the old set up. For that reason we can't give exact times for appointments. Patients can request a time, but the reality is that if there is something more urgent that needs dealing with you cannot justifiably leave it for the convenience of the patient who wants to be called before work. E.g. patient who wants to discuss peri menopause symptoms (lots of those just now after the davina documentary) - understandably doesn't want to discuss around work colleagues so asks for an 8:30am call.

However - also on the list are:

  1. Man with chest pain - reception have suggested he call 999 but he doesn't think he's having a heart attack and just wants to talk to the gp.
  1. Woman with copd thinks she has a chest infection. May need to have f2f arranged, you think. Also, hasn't told reception but is struggling with mental health since her husband was diagnosed with cancer last year, and they're still trying to isolate to protect themselves from covid. Call ends up taking over 20 minutes when she becomes emotional and start to cry.
  1. 8 month old child who isn't well, not feeding as much as normal. Mum is worried.

And so on....

How is it possible to predict who else ends up on the list, and how long their (serious, justifiably in need of a consult problems) will take? The reality is that healthcare is unpredictable. You HAVE to attend to urgent situations first. That's how triage works. You often can't predict what other serious issues will crop up during a consultation. This is the reason that we don't make promises about timings for appointments. There is an expectation that if patients were previously able to take time off for a doctor's appointment, they should still be able to take that time for a phone appointment. I realise that is harder without a clear time (although as I said, certainly at our surgery we do our best to accommodate requests and they are usually easier to manage if they are after a certain time rather than before). Unfortunately, as we can't even speak to everyone who wants to speak to us each day, the convenience of the patient does fall down the priority scale. Sorry, but that's literally all the system can accommodate at the moment. There are plenty of posts on here demonstrating the enormous strain GPs are under, nobody is slacking off here.

Really good post. No one knows the wider picture of what surgeries deal with. Plus we all know in our jobs that you can take or make a call, predicting its duration and then be on it longer. That’s then without the workload actions after it and/ or record keeping of content which needs to occur.

Staff in school can take a call. You just mention it to your wider team so that it can occur. In the same way that occurred prior to covid to release for appointments. Routine appointments are booked for the school holidays.