Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

GP Surgeries are NEGLIGENT if they're not doing face to face appointments

342 replies

AmIEmptyOrNumB · 07/08/2021 18:23

My GP surgery never stopped. They just triaged so 90% by phone and those essential face to face appointments carried on but with masks etc. Why is the government not doing more about this? These Surgeries denying all face to face appointments are failing the hippocratic oath.

OP posts:
Mrs08 · 07/08/2021 19:13

Maybe our surgery is the only bad apple...

This surgery also refused to go to a house and certify a death and insisted a warden video the deceased...

I don't even know if that's legal tbh...

Mrs08 · 07/08/2021 19:12

@girlmom21

I don't think doctors have stopped face to face consultations.

Some surgeries have grouped together when they have staff shortages so people may have had to travel an extra 0.2 miles.

I think most complaints have come from people who really haven't needed to see GP's or aren't willing to go through the triage process because they think they know best.

I'm not medically trained but I know that oxygen sats of 90, inability to walk and pain need intervention.
TheLovleyChebbyMcGee · 07/08/2021 19:12

Our GP has been fine, it takes a while to get through, but that's standard. We had to send pictures of DS eczema flare up, and were then referred to dermatology and given new creams, which was the outcome we wanted.

Mrs08 · 07/08/2021 19:09

My 75 year old mum (who has several health conditions including a bladder prolapse) has just spent a 5 days in hospital with nephritis on IV fluids, IV antibiotics, IV pain relief and Supplemental oxygen.
Why??
Because when I filled in an e consult form for her (as the surgery now demand....) a Dr called her back that afternoon, dx a UTI over the phone (how do you dip urine over the phone!!??) And gave her 3 days of Nitrofurantoin.
By midnight that night she was systemically ill and needed all the above interventions.
Formal complaint in.
Nothing will happen.
No other option where we live.
They don't have to improve.

godmum56 · 07/08/2021 19:07

@TheUndoingProject

GP practices introduced telephone screening etc. to keep the most vulnerable safe during a pandemic. GP practices have remained open throughout the pandemic and face to face appointments have always been available where clinically necessary.

You seem very het up about this given your GP practice has apparently been perfectly accessible to you.

this^ but as a matter of fact, although the Hippocratic Oath is said to have been written by Hippocrates, no doctor is required to take it or abide by it. patient.info/doctor/ideals-and-the-hippocratic-oath
lannistunut · 07/08/2021 19:06

I think the move to phone calls is quite positive in lots of cases, the GP gets through more cases, the waiting rooms are not full of people sharing germs and I can have the call without having to disrupt the day.
Agree there should be f2f when needed, but I have not needed one so far.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 07/08/2021 19:04

@iboogy,

Totally agree. GPs are fast becoming for those who cannot afford private GPs, whose practices are thriving.

It is sad that a two tier system is being created.

TheReluctantPhoenix · 07/08/2021 19:02

I have been flabbergasted by how negligent some GPs have become in the last 18 months or so.

Receptionists just don’t have the skills to triage and many doctors have written that you just cannot replace a physical examination with a telephone consult, as you miss all the non verbal cues, as well as not being able to physically listen and percuss.

There has been a massive difference between some heroic practices and some who have used COVID as an excuse to not see patients.

GPs reading this should look at the vote and reflect carefully, not just assume that the general public is ignorant.

lboogy · 07/08/2021 19:02

I agree. I don't mind the screening but it feels like it's an excuse not to see anyone

My daughter has had a runny nose - not COVID for nearly 8 weeks. I tried to get an appointment and they refused to see her first - a child needs the routine ear nose and throat check.

Then when I went in to the gp to wait for a walk in appointment I was told I'd have to wait outside for an hour. If I went to A&E I wouldn't wait outside would I to why in the go surgery? I pointed out to the receptionist I'm 8 months pregnant and can't stand outside for an hour when there were plenty of seats inside. She didn't give a shit.

Anyway lucky for me I have private gp access and was immediately referred to a paediatrician.

It's sad that money is creating a two tier system

Theunamedcat · 07/08/2021 19:02

It takes so long though you have

The long wait in the morning to talk to the receptionist
If you pass that test

A day in waiting for a call from the doctor/nurse and on one memorable occasion there in house pharmacist (we had already seen one in person and he reccomended a doctor)

An in person appointment

Before it was phonecall make appointment attend appointment

NotMyCat · 07/08/2021 18:59

The problem for me is I can't answer the phone!
And they're only doing on the day appointments
So say I need antibiotics for a UTI, but I'm well enough to work
Rather than ringing at 8am (time off work) and getting an appointment (time off work) it goes
Ring at 8am (time off work), wait for call back and answer (time off work), take urine sample in (time off work), get call back (time off work), maybe get appointment (time off work!)

My boss is perfectly happy with me taking time to ring the GP and make an appointment but not to have to mess about ringing, taking samples in, waiting for call backs etc when they can't give a time. I can't answer my phone when I'm working

Ratched · 07/08/2021 18:56

@TidyOmlette

I don’t know any GP practice that has refused appointments and I work very closely with a lot in my area. As PP’s have said, people see a telephone consultation as a refusal when it was put in place to keep people safe and reduce the need to people to travel especially on public transport during covid.

People are always complaining about not being able to access GP surgeries but people tend to forget how many patients each surgery actually has. My one for example has 6 GP’s and 2 practice nurses but there are almost 1200 patients registered.

I would have loved a telephone consultation, I know the surgery has a lot of patients, but having spent several hours over six separate days trying to access said service, I do find it a bit galling to be almost blamed for needing to see a health professional ( give not a toss whether that be a doctor, nurse or receptionist with a magic potion).

Also wonder what the issue is with phone lines. obviously a provider issue on the lines. When I walked into my surgery, completely against the rules, the phone did not disturb the peace for the 3 or 4 minutes I was there.

As a lifelong supporter and defender of the NHS, my disappointment in them now is palpable.

iklboo · 07/08/2021 18:55

These Surgeries denying all face to face appointments are failing the hippocratic oath.

The surgeries themselves have nothing to do with the Hippocratic oath. And it's not a legally binding thing in any case.

lavieengris · 07/08/2021 18:55

My GP (even before Covid) has always done telephone or video appointments (patient's choice) at a set time in the first instance, with follow up in-person appointments if necessary (including with a specialist). When making the appointment, I make notes explaining why I need the appointment (so I don't forget during the appointment) and attach a photo, if relevant. I love this system. I can slot appointments into the working day, no bother.

I don't know why other practices don't follow the same system. It feels massively efficient for both the patient, and I assume, the doctor.

doodledoodledooby · 07/08/2021 18:54

DD did an online consultation- and got a reply asking her to make a telephone appointment.

She rang for a telephone appointment and was told they don't have any. She was told they would release 4 more telephone appointments the following week for a call back mid September!

So, assuming she was successful at getting one of the four appointments, she'll be back at college by mid September so would have to keep her phone on in class, then hope for permission to leave, to speak to them Confused

TheWayTheLightFalls · 07/08/2021 18:54

I rather like the phone consultation system and I don’t think we need HCPs or vulnerable people exposed to others / hanging around waiting rooms mid-pandemic more than necessary. But a) there needs to be good triage so that the right patients get the right appointments - I can’t be the only person who’s had to try describe a rash to a GP over the phone and b) this “we’ll call you at some point between 8am and noon” approach would be much improved with an hour slot / text 15 minutes before / anything to avoid discussing genital warts in the middle of Tesco.

threecee · 07/08/2021 18:54

Why are G P's still not routinely seeing all patients face to face as before Covid ? surely there are still the same numbers of GP's employed, it strikes me that they are using covid to bring phone consultations in without discussion with the patients, government etc.

girlmom21 · 07/08/2021 18:53

I don't think doctors have stopped face to face consultations.

Some surgeries have grouped together when they have staff shortages so people may have had to travel an extra 0.2 miles.

I think most complaints have come from people who really haven't needed to see GP's or aren't willing to go through the triage process because they think they know best.

Chloemol · 07/08/2021 18:50

Ours see face to face if necessary. But to be fair lots aren’t necessary

I have had telephone consultations, no issues and refereed on as required.

Orf1abc · 07/08/2021 18:49

My one for example has 6 GP’s and 2 practice nurses but there are almost 1200 patients registered.

Is that a typo? My surgery has ten times that number of patients and half the doctors.

Or is this part of the problem? Inequality across different areas.

Becca19962014 · 07/08/2021 18:45

*insisted

Becca19962014 · 07/08/2021 18:44

@ssd

Ive found the problem to be the telephone consultation. Its not private, like seeing the gp is. My house is small and full of people who can hear me.
There was a woman in the pharmacy the other day who was rung by their GP who initiated they spoken then or it was recorded as DNA. I felt really sorry for her. She clearly needed mental health help but was too ashamed to speak in front of everyone. The GP kept asking her about self harm and suicide. It was horrible. The result? You're fine, look on the health board website for mindfullness exercises. That was it. Try didn't care she was in public, and it was a video call so could even see that.
weakpanda · 07/08/2021 18:44

The only issue I have with the telephone appointments given by my surgery is they never state a time, just "Dr will call you during afternoon surgery anytime 12-6pm". So I'm expected to stay home all afternoon and wait for a call? Or discuss my suicidal thoughts while doing the Tesco shop where everyone can hear???

ssd · 07/08/2021 18:43

Also, when rhe gp calls back it registers on my phone from an 0800 number...and for some reason my phone blocks 0800 numbers, so even getting the call is difficult.

Hekatestorch · 07/08/2021 18:42

Our go has been great and we are getting a better service

I called last year because I found d a lump on my breast, someone called me back in 10 mins. Spoke to me for a few minutes and asked me to go straight down. They referred me to the hospital and I was seen in less than 2 weeks.

When I have called regarding some pain my son had, they got him in. And when he had what we think was a post viral rash, they asked for photos then saw him the same day as they couldn't decide from the photos.

But the telephone appointments do suit us as well. I had problems after I had covid for quite a while. I felt mentally and physically drained, if it had have been a face to face appointment, I wouldn't have it. I couldn't face driving myself.

Dp has had 2 appointments and it being over the phone suited. Also meant he didn't have to take time off work, unpaid, to go.

For telephone appointments we are getting appointments either the same day or next day. And when it needs to be face to face, it's always the same day. Rather than a week or 2.

They aren't denying face to face. My parents GPs aren't denying face to face. But they are dealing with more via the telephone.

Maybe they need to make it more clear, if you want face to face you can have it.

I had no clue doctors were refusing face to face completely.