Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

WIBU not to wish him happy birthday?

56 replies

Wobblelmyheadplease · 07/08/2021 16:52

First off I will say that I know I am being a but UR and petty but I'm asking this question as I'm wondering if it might help save me more pain to do this.

Long story short, my Dad has always been emotionally distant and is now georgraphically so (200 miles away) he remarried after my mother and had stepchildren who are also now grown and live about 100 miles away.

It is a milestone birthday for him on Tuesday. I became aware (through facebook) that he has a party planned to which the stepkids are invited, but he has made no mention of this to me.

I guess I felt hurt, but then there are more of them, they are nearer and there will be no room for me to stay with him if they do. He lives in a holiday destination so I could have gone with the DC for a holiday and attended the party, but wasn't invited so I've said nothing about it.

Anyway, I sent him a card and present last week which arrived today (his birthday not til Tuesday). He sent me a one line whatsapp thanks for the gift and a comment on the picture on the card so he has obviously opened them.

It is also my birthday today so I replied no problem and look what the DC got me for my birthday. He replied happy birthday, when was it? I said today and replied with something chatty. He's read it but not responded at all.

Despite being left out of the party and him not knowing when my birthday (despite being days before his) the thing I am most hurt about is him opening my present and card today - three days before the big day when I know everyone else will be sitting with him to open cards and presents.

I feel completely sidelined and like I'm not part of this day, he didn't even want to be looking at the card and present on the day in front of I guess the people he considers his 'real' family.

WIBU to not bother messaging him or calling him on the day now? I feel I've sent my felicitations, he's deliberately chosen to keep them separate from the day and doesn't want me involved at all, so just ignpore him until....well, I doubt I'll hear from him again if I don't get in touch, that's usually how it goes.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Feedingthebirds1 · 08/08/2021 20:17

I know he doesn't give that much of a shit about me but I'm not certain some of it isn't forgetfulness.

OP you're trying to minimise his behaviour, and the resultant hurt he's caused you. Please try to accept some of your new found recognition that he's written you out of his life. That may (I stress may) be because it doesn't sound like he and your mum had a great relationship and perhaps he's decided to write that part of his life out of his memory. But that's not you fault. His new family obviously don't try to include you, and they've picked that up from somewhere.

Please don't feel humiliated - don't give him that power over you. Leave him to it and build your own life, without him in it. I know it hurts, he's your dad, but he isn't going to change no matter what you do. All the cards and presents in the world aren't going to turn him into the dad you want him to be. Talking to a professional counsellor would help you resolve your feelings around him and be able to let go, or at least reduce the intensity of those feelings.

Wishingwell75 · 08/08/2021 19:06

Oh it's so hard isn't it! I hope you make peace with whatever you decide, if you keep contacting your Dad or not. Xx

ItzANoFromMe · 07/08/2021 23:32

Happy Birthday, OP. 🎉🎉🎉

I can empathise. My birthday is a few days before my father's. He forgot my 21st. I knew he was crap but that just sealed the deal. His loss.
My mother is also out of my life. So I'm in a similar boat to you. Seems fairly common, on here.

Focus on your children and the family you've made.

Hope it didn't mar your day too much.

MushMonster · 07/08/2021 23:02

You are not alone OP, sadly.
Happy birthday to you! Enjoy your cards, presents and prosecco.
They did exclude you, and your brother. Easy enough to send an invitation. It is your decision if you can make it or not.
It wiuld be forgetfulness if it was only the once, but had to take your DOB written in a paper? And not active on contacting his own children? Rubbish. Actually, the DOB on paper is shocking! Who would not know their own children DOB!
I would not make any effort for him.

MzHz · 07/08/2021 22:38

My dad arranged a big slap up hotel away stay for his wife and her kids

We got offered a chain Italian for a crappy lunch

He insisted on her being invited too

Told him on the day that I wouldn’t make it

Didn’t speak to him for a few years

Gave him another chance, he blew it.
He’s not interested

I have no family, DM was already NC for her own cruelty towards me and ds

Sis too.

Cut them off love, it’s sad, but it’s a lot better than expecting and hoping for them to ever change and give a shit about you, cos they don’t.

I found a really good therapist helped me loads

milcal · 07/08/2021 22:36

I'm so sorry this is happening to you.

When was the last time you saw him? Would it be possible for you to see him soon? Then you would know if there was a deterioration in his health

Shehasadiamondinthesky · 07/08/2021 22:09

PLEASE don't ever send him a card or gift or wish him a happy birthday again because it is plainly obvious he does not give a shit about you.
I learnt this with my only family years ago and have now stopped trying. none of them have even noticed.

ddl1 · 07/08/2021 22:05

I know this is a bit of a cliche; but is it possible that he is developing some degree of dementia? You say that he is getting very forgetful, and that he seems to have forgotten your birth date between last year and this year. (Though he does seem to have had some forgetgulness on this issue in the past.) Maybe his children being 'unable to include you' means that they are trying to hide his deterioration from people who don't see him regularly?

Of course, even if this is the case, it doesn't alter the fact that he has never really been there for you, or given you much thought. I am sorry that you have to deal with this.

Wobblelmyheadplease · 07/08/2021 21:19

@Wishingwell75

It sounds like your Dad and my Dad should get together, see what else they have in common apart from the ability to be completely emotionally unavailable to their daughters and in my case to completely dictate the relationship he has with me. That's over 40 years of having everything on his own terms. For me a lifetime of rejection, of being told he doesn't want to spend time with me for coffee, to see his DGS or even speak on the phone. But if he is in the mood, I have to play my part and be delighted to meet him. How ridiculous does that look in black and white? Is there another single living person you would have in your life on those terms? Because I know I wouldn't tolerate that from anyone else. For myself, it's actually at the point where I can see that I only have myself to blame now, he's not going to change. What would be the difference if I decide not to contact him again? What is the actual cost of wanting this man to give me something that he is incapable of and has no interest in? These are the questions I am asking myself and I would be very interested to know how you would answer them from your point of view. Finally, I don't think it matters if others open presents on the actual day or beforehand; the only important thing is that it bothers you, it hurt your feelings. I think you hit the nail on the head when you identified that it's painful because you imagine him opening the rest at his party. But you don't know if that's the case. The step kids may be encouraged by their mum to participate (if she's still in the picture) because I doubt if he's been father of the year to them over the years.Flowers x
Wishingwell I'm sorry it's taken me some time to respond to this, I found it so difficult to read. I'm sorry for you, too. I remember when I was early teens my Dad going to work one day with a bit of paper my mother theatrically shoved in front of him to NOT FORGET.

Which obviously caught my and my brother's curiosity (that was her intention). It was our birth dates, he was taking them with him for some legal document or other but had obviously had to get my mother to write down our DOB because he had no idea of either of them. And my mother couldn't let the opportunity pass to make us both aware :(

Families are shit. Thank you for your message x

OP posts:
EKGEMS · 07/08/2021 21:15

You can send him a letter and tell him how you feel-forgotten,excluded and abandoned and your mother and him were both abusive and you already are a far better parent than either of them could ever wish to be. Let it all out. Then say this will be your last bit of contact. And fuck off or drop dead or whatever.

youdoyoutoday · 07/08/2021 21:07

WTF??? Your own father asked when your birthday was on your birthday?? Fuck him!!

SummerWhisper · 07/08/2021 20:52

Hopefully your children have 2 parents who think the world of them and will always cherish them. Seek the love from your immediate family. Let your so-called parents fade into their own self-importance.

Wobblelmyheadplease · 07/08/2021 20:26

And yet as soon as I've said that I'm thinking about the fact that he seems so forgetful these days.

Last year he texted me and gave me a card for my birthday. This year he didn't seem to know that my birthday was anywhere near his.

There are other things. He IS dismissive, definitely. But he repeats himself a lot. Forgets things. Even in a conversation direct with him. I was speaking to him about my new job (am a teacher) recently and he somehow got it into his head that it was a boy's school. I corrected him a couple of times, no it's mixed sex and he still came out of the conversation thinking I teach at an all boy's school.

I know he doesn't give that much of a shit about me but I'm not certain some of it isn't forgetfulness.

OP posts:
Wobblelmyheadplease · 07/08/2021 20:23

Ok, thank you everyone.

I'm going to let it fizzle out, because without my input there is nothing. Which tells me everything.

OP posts:
Furrydogmum · 07/08/2021 19:52

Buy yourself a present every year and totally sack his birthday off, he doesn't deserve your gifts and you don't deserve to feel so crap each year!! Flowers

Retrievemysanity · 07/08/2021 19:36

Op, your dad is 70 and acting like this, he’s not going to change. As hard as it is, I think you need to accept that you’re not going to have the relationship with him you want. So you need to decide if you can handle things the way they are, or if you let things fizzle out. Personally, I’d take the massive hint that he and the whole family are giving you and leave them to it. Don’t mean to sound harsh, you sound a lovely, thoughtful person but this doesn’t sound like it’s good for you. Happy birthday FlowersWine

Wobblelmyheadplease · 07/08/2021 19:30

@Theunamedcat

If you want to send him a card for his 70th carry on but personally I wouod make sure it was a 29p one and leave the price ticket on
I've already sent the card and it was a really nice one :(
OP posts:
Theunamedcat · 07/08/2021 19:11

If you want to send him a card for his 70th carry on but personally I wouod make sure it was a 29p one and leave the price ticket on

TreadSoftlyOnMyDreams · 07/08/2021 19:05

I would neither send further wishes on the day of his actual birthday or remotely bother my arse with him going forward.

I'm sorry your parents are so utterly shit but for the sake of your own self esteem you do need to simply say "fuck it" and go and enjoy your birthday with your own family.

Summerbubbles · 07/08/2021 19:00

And don't feel humiliated, being a good person, a thoughtful, caring, generous daughter is something to be proud of, it's his loss if he doesn't appreciate you

Summerbubbles · 07/08/2021 18:57

You sound like a caring person who has made enough effort already, I wouldn't bother to call on the day but I would continue to send a birthday card etc and the occasional text, even if the thought is not reciprocated at least you know you've done all you can.

It's hurtful when it feels like a family member doesn't care.

bigvig · 07/08/2021 18:57

It hurts when family let you down. It will always hurt but you can train yourself to care less and give them less emotional energy. Send him a card each birthday so he can't accuse you of being the one responsible for the lack of any relationship but make no more effort than that. If he contacts you that's another matter - but unfortunate I doubt he will.

Sonofabiscuit · 07/08/2021 18:56

Op I totally understand ,I've been ignored and left out of things for years by my so called parents ,sister and nephews and their partners .
I only found out I was a great aunt as my dn rang me .not to tell me but to ask me to contact my parents and say he'd be over soon to take them to see the baby .he's done this as well with his 2nd child .
Was 6 months before met 1st child and have never met his 2nd child .
Tried to explain to my "family" how it hurt and nothing changed so now I don't bother and make no effort for birthdays /Xmas.

Wobblelmyheadplease · 07/08/2021 18:46

@eveoha

I’d be inclined to pity them and pray for them acting in that manner - it is they who are not decent loving people - as you seem to be
Thank you.

I actually feel really humiliated now about going out and buying a lovely card and really thoughtful gift while all the time he, his wife and stepchildren were deliberately going out of their way to exclude me. And my DC as well, his only grandchildren! What have my kids done wrong to be treated like that?

It's embarassing. I have barely any relationship with my mother because of all the evil things she'd done, he's actually the better of my parents. And he and his other family have gone out of their way to exclude me. I feel so humiliated.

OP posts:
eveoha · 07/08/2021 18:43

I’d be inclined to pity them and pray for them acting in that manner - it is they who are not decent loving people - as you seem to be

Swipe left for the next trending thread