Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

PIL running commentary on everything I do

63 replies

philadelphiafreedom · 07/08/2021 16:10

PIL live in the same village as my DM, and about 10 mins drive from us.

MIL makes a point of calling/texting/mentioning every time she sees my DM walking in the village, and telling me that I should worry about a ‘woman of her age’ walking alone and stop her doing this. For reference, DM is very fit, healthy and in her early 60s. MIL makes a lot of comments about DM’s age and that she is single. I feel protective of DM and eventually got fed up and shut this down by saying ‘MIL, you are only a year younger than DM - do you think we should be worrying about you?’ This stopped the age comments but not the alerts that my mother had been spotted outside the house. MIL seems to have a fixation with DM and what she wears/drives/cooks/does with her life in general. MIL has also spotted DM and I in town and texted to say that we should both be wearing coats 🙄

We don’t have them round very much as MIL in particular can be critical. PIL no longer have a key to the house as they were letting themselves in unannounced - that’s another story. She can be interfering and unkind in general, with a particular habit of providing a running commentary on everything I do. Small example: last time she was here I was in the midst of fairly severe hyperemesis and made a slice of toast (one of the things I could periodically get down) and she started saying ‘oooh you’re having toast, mind you don’t burn it’ and ‘someone’s burnt the toast!’ ‘Oh PF’s just enjoying her burnt toast’ tinkly laugh - it went on. I was bemused more than anything as it’s such a non issue (like the time I accidentally killed a house plant and she told me thank god I didn’t have children if I can’t even look after a plant) but it’s just part of a wider pattern of anything and everything DP and I do being up for debate/comment. Recently we have been doing work in the garden and MIL been quite unpleasant to DP over the phone for not sending her pictures quickly enough.

So, the plan for now (mid pregnancy and having some pregnancy complications) is to ease back on the contact and for DP to work on ability/willingness to put in healthy boundaries. He says he understands but that this is the way she’s always been and that covid has given her ‘cabin fever’, making the behaviour worse. Since becoming pregnant her behaviour has had a greater effect on me, I’m not sure why.

DP has mentioned in passing today that FIL texted him to say that he has driven past and seen me walking the dogs in our village. An older person had fallen further down the road; when I passed there was a large group of people offering assistance with first responders attending to the injured person. FIL wanted to know from DP whether I stopped, what happened, what I did I do about it. I know this is irrational but for some reason the idea of FIL rushing home to report back to MIL has really irked me? Normally I wouldn’t care but on top of everything else the idea of yet more comments when I wasn’t expecting them, makes me want to tell them to go away and get a life? AIB completely U over such a small thing?

OP posts:
OnTheBrink1 · 07/08/2021 17:21

Oh god OP I can so imagine all of those things you have said and yes they would really annoy me.
Sadly though when the baby comes it’s much worse because you are battling to be a mum your way and she will probably think she knows best because ‘that what she did 40 years ago and all her children survived’ etc. In my experience everything to do with care of the baby is met with disapproval or a funny look and offers of help really arent that helpful. My MIL though breastfeeding and slingwearing was bizarre and disgusting and got cross because it meant she couldn’t take the baby. You become mega protective and you may not even want your MIL around you.
Try to not respond as much to texts and phone calls, delay the response, start to distance a bit if possible. Stand your ground when the baby is here. Don’t worry about offending. Your baby, your birth your choice.

30degreesandmeltinghere · 07/08/2021 17:13

My ils never had my mobile number. Made for a much easier life. And tell your dh he needs to stop reporting back to her anything about you. Or you will look at him and see his df... Not your dh... And that isn't in your opinion a man you deem attractive...

Howshouldibehave · 07/08/2021 17:11

The running commentary alone would piss me off! DH’s grandma had form for his. She was quite deaf as well so it was commentaries based on stuff she’d seen/heard incorrectly which was even worse!

AngryWhompingWillow · 07/08/2021 17:10

That is super super SUPER annoying @philadelphiafreedom I feel your pain.

I live about 30 miles north of my extended family now - cousins and aunts etc. I am in a different county, and I go to a town 5 miles north of where I live to do my shopping. So the town I used to go to (and that THEY still go to,) is 35 miles south of the town I go to now... SO I never see them! And they never see me! (Only maybe 3 or 4 times a year for 'family events...')

I am so glad, because like with you, every single little thing I did, was monitored and reported back to my parents. Not only when I was a teenager, but also when I was in my 20s and 30s, and married with my own home, and with children.

EG... My one cousin 'Jane' (just 9 months older than me, but who acted like I was a child,) once told my mother that she had seen me giving the V sign to a van driver. He had pipped his horn and shouted 'nice tits' out of window at me, and as he drove off I stuck my 2 fingers up.

When I saw my mum, she said, 'honestly Willow, they're all talking about you being so rude to a man driving a van!' I said 'FFS, he shouted nice tits out of the window at me.' But it had gone all round the family what a cheeky, impudent individual I was. My mum said I should be bigger than that, and not show myself up! Hmm I was 30, and had my own home, and I was a mother. Yet they were acting like I was a naughty child.

A couple of neighbours were gossipy too, (my parents neighbours) and reported back if they saw me coming out of the pub. Confused Even when I was in my mid 20s, had my own flat, and was virtually still sober. I got scolded for 'looking like an alkie - being seen coming out of the pub twice in the same week!'

I also had a male cousin of mine, who worked at the same place I did when I was 20, tell my parents that I had sworn at work. SO I got a scolding for saying the word 'shit' in the factory I worked at. When I was 20!

I was still being gossiped about and judged in my early 30s, (and as I said, had my own home, and was a mother.) I believe it was because I was the youngest of 9 cousins, and was quiet and timid as a child, and they thought I should behave in a certain way... subservient, and 'ladylike' and well-behaved!

Once my parents passed away, (mid noughties,) I moved away. One of the best decisions I made was moving 30 miles away. No more judgy extended family or neighbours.

I would move too if I were you philadelphiafreedom

Wobblelmyheadplease · 07/08/2021 17:09

I felt really irritated just reading this. The bunt toast thing gave me the rage.

I don't have great parents (distant Dad) and rather a narcissistic mother. My mother has a lot of form for this no-boundaries kind of stuff and, I'm afraid to say it did escalate when DC arrived.

She was always trying to grab control, we'd go to the shopping centre when DS was tiny and she'd literally wait for me to look at something then run off with the pram around Debenhams. DS needed constant feeding at that age and we'd had a really traumatic birth and it used to really upset me her just disappearing off with my tiny newborn while my back was turned.

Your DH needs to nip this in the bud now, it's intrusive and weird and shoes she doesn't respect you as autonomous human beings.

TakeYourFinalPosition · 07/08/2021 17:03

No advice, @philadelphiafreedom, but sympathies - if DH had a brother; I’d be sure our MILs were the same person.

Does your MIL not have a life? She is going to be a nightmare when the baby arrives

This scares the living daylights out of me. I’m due at the end of the year and I’m so nervous about it.

stairgates · 07/08/2021 17:03

Have you considered moving, this would drive me insane and will only get worse when baby is here. At least get some brochures from estate agents and leave a bundle laying around, and tell your mum to go into all the estate agents in town regularly so it looks like you and your mum are both moving on and tell your mum to wear odd fluorescent colored socks to make sure shes noticedGrin

PersonaNonGarter · 07/08/2021 16:58

Ignore the stupid texts. Yes annoying but what can you do.

The stuff in your home though - that’s a different story. You need to have DH on board though. If he isn’t on board then there is a problem.

clickychicky · 07/08/2021 16:55

That is so weird, like you are under surveillance!

DoTheNextRightThing · 07/08/2021 16:53

[quote philadelphiafreedom]@Debetswell I am chuckling heartily at the idea of telling PIL that I am up for a Pride of Britain! Not sure what I am going to wear to the ceremony due to my hair issue though[/quote]
Well obviously you need to wear a coat else MIL will text you while you're on stage to tell you!!

LanaDelBoy · 07/08/2021 16:53

Tell her that your mum is in witness protection and your PILs are potentially at risk of being bugged by a criminal gang from London so they need to stop mentioning when they've seen her or the gang will get the tip-off...

eightyfourandahalf · 07/08/2021 16:47

Your PIL have no life, and are bored out of their head, not much you can do!

I know friends who physically moved away to get some peace, one of them even cross country literally because of suffocating IL like that (think Cornwall from Scotland!)

Unless your mother and you all move away, you just need to smile and bear it, they won't change. I would limit contact to an absolute minimum.

‘oooh you’re having toast, mind you don’t burn it’ and ‘someone’s burnt the toast!’ ‘Oh PF’s just enjoying her burnt toast’ tinkly laugh - it went on.
I am sorry.. your MIL is just stupid. Likely doesn't mean bad, but is thick as a plank. Try to find it more charming than annoying, or use whatever skills she must have in something for your own benefit (like ask her to bake or darn your socks or something).

Bythemillpond · 07/08/2021 16:46

I grew up in a place like this where relatives and friends of dm would report back to her where I had been or what I was wearing.

I moved to the other end of the country.

This sounds like mil is stalking your dm.

alexdgr8 · 07/08/2021 16:45

send them some adverts for undercover enquiry agents, the sort who spy on people claiming disability benefits while teaching kick-boxing.

NammeChannge · 07/08/2021 16:44

I would move but not so far that they can't get to you and back in a day or they'll have to stay.

eightyfourandahalf · 07/08/2021 16:44

eventually got fed up and shut this down by saying ‘MIL, you are only a year younger than DM - do you think we should be worrying about you?’

brilliant Grin

LanisHouseLot · 07/08/2021 16:43

How tedious. Does your mum know about the reporting back on her? You could make a pretend game of it to highlight the utter ridiculousness to MIL - which one can ring you fastest to say they've seen the other. Let MIL know about the game next time she calls "that was pretty quick, but I'm afraid mum got it just before you this time - she saw you on the corner of Cobb Street 10 ten mins ago. But don't worry you're still 2 sightings ahead after last week!". I bet she'll stop.

When she commentates on you, pretend you're enjoying it and commentate back with a big smile on your face "MiL chuckles to congratulate herself on the amusing quip about Philadelphia's toast. Tragically she's the only one laughing". Again, i bet she'll stop!

Chibbles · 07/08/2021 16:39

They sound really fucking irritating.

Maintain your distance.

philadelphiafreedom · 07/08/2021 16:38

Thank you for the replies, I feel heard! Also, to the PPs who have mentioned her being a nightmare with the baby - I totally agree and think the anticipation of this is what’s sending me over the edge!

@ineedaholidaynow DM absolutely loves DP and therefore doesn’t like to say anything too critical about PIL, mostly just rolls her eyes. At one point she started to feel really ‘watched’ and it did upset her as they would bring her movements up with her and ask what she or I had been doing. However, her approach now is that they absolutely do not have enough going on in their own lives and just lets them be.

OP posts:
BluebellsGreenbells · 07/08/2021 16:38

Wow how wearing. Unfortunately it only ramps up when the baby arrives.

You need to repeat what she says to you back to her

‘DM was in the village alone?’
‘Who’s burnt the toast?’

That way she has to answer her own questions, which she’ll realize is a very sill and b quite annoying!!

Try it, it takes practice?
‘

LivingLaVidaBabyShower · 07/08/2021 16:36

MIL has also spotted DM and I in town and texted to say that we should both be wearing coats 🙄

The only thing i could say in response to this is "MIL what is wrong with you?"

And I would be openly challenge all their idiocy - they sound horrendous

Allthelights · 07/08/2021 16:36

It’s a shame you all live so close to each other. Is there anything you can do about that?

Parker231 · 07/08/2021 16:36

Limit the number of times you answer the phone to them. Don’t respond to texts. If they don’t have information about your lives they will have less to comment on.

Sssloou · 07/08/2021 16:36

They are ridiculous and highly irritating.

You have done really well with boundaries to date (taking back the key, calling her on the age comments) - these have been effective.

You have 2 choices here.

  1. Continue to call out EVERYTHING in a calm consistent way. Same phrase every time.

“Please stop doing / saying x, y, z - it’s rude/irritating/inappropriate.”

If she continues / repeats the behaviour give a warning and consequence just say:

“I will leave / ask you to leave if you continue to do x,y,z which is rude/irritating/inappropriate”

And then DO it.

Basically you are trying to put manners on her - like training a toddler.

Boring, hard, tedious and draining.

  1. If you can’t be arsed just withdraw more from the relationship. Don’t respond to inane texts. Don’t have them in your home.

Your DH needs to step up. Who cares if she has always been like this and cabin fever has intensified it - the dynamic isn’t working and needs attention and adapting.

Is this your first child and their first grand child? Because if this isn’t tackled now you have one miserable journey ahead. Don’t let her nonsense behaviours pollute your experience of motherhood.

ElizaDoolots · 07/08/2021 16:31

Gosh, it’s all very suffocating isn’t it. Hope your DP works on setting some boundaries with them for when the baby arrives, they’ll drive you nuts if they want to know every detail.