Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

PIL running commentary on everything I do

63 replies

philadelphiafreedom · 07/08/2021 16:10

PIL live in the same village as my DM, and about 10 mins drive from us.

MIL makes a point of calling/texting/mentioning every time she sees my DM walking in the village, and telling me that I should worry about a ‘woman of her age’ walking alone and stop her doing this. For reference, DM is very fit, healthy and in her early 60s. MIL makes a lot of comments about DM’s age and that she is single. I feel protective of DM and eventually got fed up and shut this down by saying ‘MIL, you are only a year younger than DM - do you think we should be worrying about you?’ This stopped the age comments but not the alerts that my mother had been spotted outside the house. MIL seems to have a fixation with DM and what she wears/drives/cooks/does with her life in general. MIL has also spotted DM and I in town and texted to say that we should both be wearing coats 🙄

We don’t have them round very much as MIL in particular can be critical. PIL no longer have a key to the house as they were letting themselves in unannounced - that’s another story. She can be interfering and unkind in general, with a particular habit of providing a running commentary on everything I do. Small example: last time she was here I was in the midst of fairly severe hyperemesis and made a slice of toast (one of the things I could periodically get down) and she started saying ‘oooh you’re having toast, mind you don’t burn it’ and ‘someone’s burnt the toast!’ ‘Oh PF’s just enjoying her burnt toast’ tinkly laugh - it went on. I was bemused more than anything as it’s such a non issue (like the time I accidentally killed a house plant and she told me thank god I didn’t have children if I can’t even look after a plant) but it’s just part of a wider pattern of anything and everything DP and I do being up for debate/comment. Recently we have been doing work in the garden and MIL been quite unpleasant to DP over the phone for not sending her pictures quickly enough.

So, the plan for now (mid pregnancy and having some pregnancy complications) is to ease back on the contact and for DP to work on ability/willingness to put in healthy boundaries. He says he understands but that this is the way she’s always been and that covid has given her ‘cabin fever’, making the behaviour worse. Since becoming pregnant her behaviour has had a greater effect on me, I’m not sure why.

DP has mentioned in passing today that FIL texted him to say that he has driven past and seen me walking the dogs in our village. An older person had fallen further down the road; when I passed there was a large group of people offering assistance with first responders attending to the injured person. FIL wanted to know from DP whether I stopped, what happened, what I did I do about it. I know this is irrational but for some reason the idea of FIL rushing home to report back to MIL has really irked me? Normally I wouldn’t care but on top of everything else the idea of yet more comments when I wasn’t expecting them, makes me want to tell them to go away and get a life? AIB completely U over such a small thing?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
LivingLaVidaBabyShower · 08/08/2021 11:26

@Skiptheheartsandflowers

The threads about these people after the baby's arrival are going to be epic. I echo the advice about not telling them you've gone into labour.
Yes yes

These two will fully jump the shark once offspring arrives.

Skiptheheartsandflowers · 07/08/2021 23:44

The threads about these people after the baby's arrival are going to be epic. I echo the advice about not telling them you've gone into labour.

BunnyRuddington · 07/08/2021 23:35

I’ve got an idea - send them on a nice holiday to the States
🎶Welcome to the Hotel California🎶**
🎶You can check out any time you like - but you can NEVER LEAVE.�
�Just a thought GrinGrin

LittleMowf · 07/08/2021 23:23

I couldn’t be arsed with all that, how weird of her. Worrying about your DM like that - plenty of people in their 60s and beyond work, live independently, walk round by themselves….my DM is 75 and still works nights! She lives alone and is 2 hours from me, her only child - although she drives up to see us once or twice a month. I’d quite like to reply to her with the 👍 emoji when she sends her spy messages - it’s got a slightly passive aggressive energy which I enjoy

lazylump72 · 07/08/2021 23:16

This is all so unhealthy,its like being stalked, You must do something Op what a dreadful way to live having all this shite, Stop being so nice would be my advice,be less understanding and back right off,Tell dp you have no wish to be involved anymore,He can deal with them totally on his own and you do not wish to be a party to anything,He must tell them zero about you and your life and you do not wish to know anything more about them, Cannot see any other way of you getting any peace, I would hate my privacy to be scrutinized like this its awful,By all means dp have any kind of relationship you want with them, I will put up no barriers with regard to that but leave me out of it....

Branleuse · 07/08/2021 22:35

Id emigrate

DreamTheMoors · 07/08/2021 22:32

@philadelphiafreedom
I see a lot of recommendations telling you to take your DP & DM & move away from your PIL.
I’ve got an idea - send them on a nice holiday to the States!
🎶Welcome to the Hotel California🎶
🎶You can check out any time you like - but you can NEVER LEAVE.🎶
Just a thought.

dustofneptune · 07/08/2021 21:44

You're not being unreasonable.
The way I see it, you have three options.

  1. Move. Seriously, just get away from them.
  2. Stay and insist DP has a strong word. Hope that this changes things.
  3. Stay and have a strong word, yourself. Or otherwise, choose to have fun with the situation / ignore it / try not to let it bother you.

If you keep going the way you're going (not saying anything, accepting DP not saying anything, staying where you are), you're going to drive yourself mental. You have to take some kind of action. Easier said than done, I know!

LadyTiredWinterBottom2 · 07/08/2021 20:03

Please try not to get too wound up about what happens when the baby arrives. Enjoy this time and all the prep. Otherwise she might make your blood boil and that won't do you any good Smile

Honestly sarcasm works wonders. My mil asked if our new sofa was on credit- l told her l found it in someone's front garden

I still laugh at the look on her face now

Svalberg · 07/08/2021 19:54

If your MIL is concerned about "a woman of her age" walking alone, when your DM is in her early 60s, how does she cope with the fact that women of that age still work? Pension age is 66-67! Does she expect them to have a bodyguard to take them too & from work?

MiloAndEddie · 07/08/2021 19:22

God this sounds infuriating. I would honestly hate this. If she texts about your mum I would just reply ‘ok’ or the coat thing ‘thanks.’ Literally one word answers.

Either that or just block her or mute her and never reply. Never answer the phone, anything

adreamofspring · 07/08/2021 19:15

Move, get your mil a hobby, get her to volunteer or do something more useful than this verbal water torture. DP needs to call her out on it too. Ugh, this would give me daily migraines. I feel for you OP.

tobedtoMNandfart · 07/08/2021 19:12

This is batshit behaviour and they need telling so. By your DH.
Block them on your phone.
Insert boundaries.
If DH won't enforce boundaries you have a DH problem.

tempester28 · 07/08/2021 18:37

the only real solution is to move

Cherrysoup · 07/08/2021 18:30

You need serious boundaries before the baby arrives. They would drive me mad.

MagpieCastle · 07/08/2021 18:17

Looking at it from another angle, it’s potentially useful in giving you an opportunity to consider what boundaries you want to put in place for when dc was born. Like you I found certain PiL behaviours more challenging than before whilst pregnant. In the early days of dc arrival you’re going to need dh to have your back and be on the same page so do talk it through together beforehand and make it clear what will/will not be acceptable. These are his dp and so he needs to stop enabling or normalising things that are stressful or cross boundaries.

After a while, I found parenthood made it a lot easier to be direct about what was acceptable and also to totally ignore stuff when needed (so you get to choose when you send pics of your garden/children and any other damn thing in your life - you only need to share/respond as and when you choose, not as demanded). Their commentary sounds really irritating and your dm sounds great but, lordy, this isn’t fair to her either. Depending on what you feel comfortable with, either the breezy ‘you don’t have to concern yourself about dm/me/dc, it’s all good’ or something more direct will mean that by the time dc arrive you’ll be able to shut down their nonsense quickly and crisply. They do it because, at the moment, they feel entitled to and are currently allowed to - but you and dh have the power to re-draw boundaries so that it’s clear that this isn’t ok.

FlyingPandas · 07/08/2021 18:11

Following on from what a pp said about hobbies - I would be sorely tempted to respond to the next intrusive stalking comment with something along the lines of “PIL, we’re worried that you must be so bored and unfulfilled in your lives because all you ever seem to do is obsess about what people are doing and where they’ve been. It’s really not healthy. We think you would both benefit from taking up a new hobby and wondered if you’d be interested in x y z” and then present them with brochures or links to any courses for retired people you think they’d be vaguely interested in.

Any further ridiculous comments about yours or your DM’s daily lives, say “Did you think about those hobbies we suggested? It’s not normal or healthy to be so obsessive about what other people are up to all the time”

And repeat, and repeat, and repeat.

And if that doesn’t work, move.

1forAll74 · 07/08/2021 18:08

I think I would make a joke about all the things they say and do,in fact I know I would, as I tend to joke and make fun of peoples foibles. I think that a certain amount of people, do spend their lives noticing, and making comments about all and sundry. Maybe they are just that way inclined, or that their lives are just a bit boring at home. and what others are doing, gives them plenty to talk about, and some of this talk can be very critical of others., so best ignored really.

Flamglimglubberty · 07/08/2021 18:05

This is so annoying, but I'd be so tempted to have some fun with it... Every time she texts to say she/someone saw you I'd reply with increasingly ridiculous scenarios as to why it couldn't have been you (even if it was!)

MIL: Doris saw you in the high street today
YOU: Oh it couldn't have possibly been me, I was over in X town having a bikini wax

MIL: Ethel saw you outside the post office on Friday not wearing a coat
YOU: Nope not me, I was busy getting my anus bleached on Friday

Eventually you could drop a "MIL do we need to get your eyes tested, you seem to be seeing everywhere in places that I wasn't" Grin

BunnyRuddington · 07/08/2021 18:02

Agree that you've been great with your boundaries so far. Now it's time for your DP to step up. Saying that "she's always been like this" and it "cabin fever" is ignoring the problem and the fact that you're upset.

If MIL truly has got Cabin Fever I'd start giving her suggestions of things to do like becoming a befriender for Age Concern, joining the U3A or doing the 30 miles in September for Alzheimer's.

SchadenfreudePersonified · 07/08/2021 18:00

@girlywhirly

How fit and active are your PIL’S, and do they actually have any hobbies and interests apart from nosiness? I’d be inclined to tell them that unfit older people with no hobbies and interests are at a significantly higher risk of developing dementia. Do you know if they have many friends? If they don’t that will tell you that others are also fed up with them! Look up lots of clubs/societies/classes for seniors for them to join.

Texts are easy to ignore, they don’t always need a response. You don’t have to answer calls.

But the in-laws DO have hobbies and interests - spying constantly on OP and her DM, criticising them and making their lives a misery.
scrappydappydoo · 07/08/2021 17:50

Oh this would drive me nuts - I’d get a new phone and give your new number to everyone except PILs then just keep your old phone as the bat-shit phone for PILs then you can choose when to look at messages and not feel as harassed.

girlywhirly · 07/08/2021 17:43

How fit and active are your PIL’S, and do they actually have any hobbies and interests apart from nosiness? I’d be inclined to tell them that unfit older people with no hobbies and interests are at a significantly higher risk of developing dementia. Do you know if they have many friends? If they don’t that will tell you that others are also fed up with them! Look up lots of clubs/societies/classes for seniors for them to join.

Texts are easy to ignore, they don’t always need a response. You don’t have to answer calls.

Mrs08 · 07/08/2021 17:27

...and you dh needs to step in tbh.

What your pils are doing is ridiculous.

Mrs08 · 07/08/2021 17:26

I no longer reply to my mils wittering unsolicited texts
(She is prejudiced bigot too which informs my behaviour somewhat...)
Blank looks also work 👍