Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be annoyed at these comments from DH’s family?

106 replies

nonwor · 07/08/2021 10:53

DH has a low sperm count, so we used a sperm donor and DD is now 8 months old.

Our families didn't meet her until she was 3/4 months. Since she's gotten older, they've been making comments about DD not looking like DH, and asking him if he's sure he's her father etc.

They also ask if we're having another child, we always tell them we don't know and they say that we have to as it'll be unfair on DD being the only child etc.

Aibu to be annoyed at these comments?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Dishwashersaurous · 08/08/2021 15:11

Wow. Everyone makes comments about who a baby looks like. That's just what people do.

However, you used a sperm donor.

You are going to need to tell your child that one day.

It would be much easier if you also told very close family.

nanbread · 08/08/2021 14:12

I think YABU about the comments on who your DD looks like. So many people comment on this sort of thing (and they would know if you had adopted etc so aren't in their minds being insensitive).

I think YANBU however over them telling you DD HAS to have a sibling though. Only children and their parents are typically happier, so how is that unfair?

Plumtree391 · 08/08/2021 13:55

[quote PotteringAlong]@Plumtree391 it’s not always as dramatic as transplants. It’s doing genetics at school and realising that your ability to roll your tongue / not roll your tongue compared to your parents means that you’re not biologically related…

It’s something happening to their children, so the OP’s grandchildren and realising that the medical history they have is inaccurate so the OP has to tell them.

It’s sending a DNA sample to something like ancestry.com without the OP knowing, turfing up half siblings and opening a can of worms.

I think “no one needs to know” is naive at best and downright harmful at worst.[/quote]
They are good points and I hadn't thought of Ancestry.com. However surely nobody except the child needs to know.

Speaking of Ancestry.com, I did think of it at one time because I am an adopted child but I did meet my biological mother who told me about my bio father, and that was sufficient for me. They are both dead now anyway.

I do get that a child has the right to know where he or she comes from but I don't think I would want to know I was conceived with a sperm donor (now I expect someone who was conceived that way will come on here and say it makes no difference to them), and would a child benefit from knowing their father was, say, a serial killer? It is certainly a difficult one which is why, I suppose, donor insemination is so controversial.

Moancup · 08/08/2021 10:57

I don’t know why the OP has bothered posting if she’s not going to engage with the far bigger question of how and if they’re telling their child about the donor.

There is a reason you’ll have been advised to tell your daughter about this. Doing it early and naturally will help her process it and that’s much easier if family are already in the loop. I do hope you’re not ignoring the advice you will have received and planning to keep this a secret.

FuckingFlumps · 07/08/2021 22:04

I think “no one needs to know” is naive at best and downright harmful at worst

I absolutely agree. This child deserves to know her story from the beginning. These days I honestly thought we were more aware of how important it is to know about your identity and for something so integral to never be a secret that the child risks discovering.

There is no shame in using a sperm donor but pretending that it didn't happen will only lead to heartache and confusion later in this child's life.

PotteringAlong · 07/08/2021 21:29

@Plumtree391 it’s not always as dramatic as transplants. It’s doing genetics at school and realising that your ability to roll your tongue / not roll your tongue compared to your parents means that you’re not biologically related…

It’s something happening to their children, so the OP’s grandchildren and realising that the medical history they have is inaccurate so the OP has to tell them.

It’s sending a DNA sample to something like ancestry.com without the OP knowing, turfing up half siblings and opening a can of worms.

I think “no one needs to know” is naive at best and downright harmful at worst.

Namechangeforthis88 · 07/08/2021 21:24

On the only child front, DS is an only and markedly more sociable, thoughtful and confident than a couple of cousins that have a couple of siblings. He is pretty relentlessly happy.

Biancadelrioisback · 07/08/2021 21:18

I think everyone has a right to know how they came to be. If it's talked about from an early age, there is probably less chance of the child having identity issues when they inevitably do find out.

Biancadelrioisback · 07/08/2021 21:15

This is literally something that happens to everyone when a baby is born...people try and figure out who the baby looks like.
Seems strange you haven't told them unless you're very LC

Tubbs99 · 07/08/2021 21:01

Are you suggesting that she shouldn’t tell her own DD about her own background/about her biological father? Her DD has a right to know. Genetic testing is getting more popular and even more so as her DD ages. Nothing to do with transplants.

Plumtree391 · 07/08/2021 20:57

'have' needed a transplant, not 'has'.

Plumtree391 · 07/08/2021 20:56

@Tubbs99

Are you planning on telling your DD? You do realise that this secret will come out eventually.
I don't see why it should. In television dramas, people always need transplants of some kind which means it is revealed but, honestly, how many people do you know who has needed a transplant?

There's more chance of it coming out if people are told. There is no need to tell anyone.

Premier12 · 07/08/2021 20:48

@nonwor

No, they don't know we used a sperm donor, I did think I made that clear in my OP
No, it's not mentioned
Kite22 · 07/08/2021 20:40

It often happens in families that siblings don't look like one another, or both look like one parent and not the other or they look like one each, or like neither.
I've got friends with 3 gorgeous little boys with really ginger hair - neither parent has ginger hair. I've got other friends where one parent has African heritage and really really dark skin, the other parent is the palest of pale. The child is white, but with a blonde afro.
Genetics are really weird.
Growing up, people used to say two of my siblings looked like my Dad, one sibling looks like my Mum and they'd turn to me and go "hmmmm" Grin. It was never an issue. It was quite funny in fact. When I hit about 16, everyone started saying I looked like my Dad's sister (no-one had seen that before). We change as we grow.

So, what I am trying to say is that there is no guarantee any child will look like their Dad, at any point in their lives, let alone when they are still a baby.

Tubbs99 · 07/08/2021 20:23

Are you planning on telling your DD? You do realise that this secret will come out eventually.

Feedingthebirds1 · 07/08/2021 20:18

My brother didn't look like either of our parents. I don't remember it being a big thing. Some years later Mum found a bag of old photos clearing out her great aunt's house, and there was one of a great uncle as a child - the spitting image of my brother.

Feedingthebirds1 · 07/08/2021 20:15

I thought the question from them 'Are you sure you're the father' was clear enough to mean that they didn't know. If they knew, they wouldn't be asking.

LIZS · 07/08/2021 20:05

If you have made a decision not to tell anyone, as is your right, you do need a few comments to respond with. While dc is a baby it should be easy as babies tend not to instantly resemble either parent. The expectation of a sibling is slightly different and enquiries plain nosy but a "we're grateful for the one we have" "let's just enjoy having her" should close it down. There are limited circumstances where others might need to know or find out but do consider if you may plan to tell her later.

HauteGirlSummer · 07/08/2021 19:52

To be fair both situations can be avoided if they knew you used a sperm donor.

They wouldn't mention the baby not looking like their dad as that would be obvious and insensitive. They also wouldn't question if you were having a second child either since it'd be clear you have fertility issues.

Maybe let them know so they stop making these jokes?

Heronwatcher · 07/08/2021 19:35

We are always talking about who looks like who in my family. 2 of my kids look just like me, the others not. My niece looks like the image of my gran. It’s just something we say, and I find it nice to compare. That’s not to say that I wouldn’t fully welcome a child which I wasn’t genetically related but when kids do, or don’t, look like parents it’s just something that people comment on. If this is going to bug you then you need to tell them the truth. I think it might also be better for your child otherwise, as others have said, they will find out anyway and it will look like it was a dirty secret. Your DH does realise that having a low sperm count is nothing to be ashamed of?

arethereanyleftatall · 07/08/2021 19:33

If you're not going to tell anyone, then you'd best learn to get used to this.

PearlFriday · 07/08/2021 19:32

I think you should just say ''lucky girl looks like me!''

Looubylou · 07/08/2021 19:29

It wasn't clear. As they don't know, I don't think they are meaning to be rude, these are very common comments to make. YANBU to find it upsetting, but YABU to seem angry towards them. I would hope they would be far more sensitive if they did know. Moving forward, you could tell them, or if nor, learn to let these innocent comments go over your heads. Congratulations on your DC.

saraclara · 07/08/2021 19:28

The comments about her not looking like her dad are touching a nerve with you because of the situation but they’re not unusual or unkindly meant.

That. So being snippy about it as others have suggested, is only going to raise questions. And they won't be about sperm donors.
So do what the rest of us do and laugh off the comments with "yep, he's definitely more my side of the family " or "I know, that nose is definitely all his own rather than either of ours!"

twinningatlife · 07/08/2021 19:15

I agree that your immediate family should have known from the start - now you've just invited speculation and gossip behind your backs which is worse to be honest