Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I tell her?

289 replies

Pollypocket89 · 07/08/2021 08:22

I probably am being unreasonable but I'm exhausted and angry

My lovely friend found out she was the other woman last night after being very much in love for 13 months. Obviously that's over and she's devastated. She's promised him she won't tell his girlfriend as he threatened to harm himself

I've been cheated on and I'm furious on both their behalf. I don't want to cause trouble and I'll probably be told its not my business but I would want to know myself
Do I tell her?

OP posts:
Blossomtoes · 08/08/2021 17:25

@DrSbaitso

Honestly, if you did this to me - unilaterally decided to change my life for the worst without having any connection to it - and told me it was fine because YOU were satisfied with it, I wouldn't thank you and I wouldn't think it was altruistic or noble.
Nor me. In fact if anyone did this to me my fury would hit them with such force they’d never even think of doing it again. It’s such a presumptuous thing to do.
5128gap · 08/08/2021 17:01

@WallaceinAnderland

People who wouldn't want to know are essentially agreeing to an open relationship, which is fine of course if that's what they want. The message is be discreet, be careful re pregnancy and sti and don't tell me, I don't want to know.
No, they're not. That is another example of projecting your own views onto someone else. Maybe if the person said that to their partner it would be taken that way, but just thinking that way is a far cry from being happy with an affair. There's also a huge difference between wanting to know what's going on in your relationship, and wanting some busy body you've never met giving you some half story, often based on gossip, hearsay and presumption. They don't know 'the facts' from their position behind the net curtains, usually they know just enough to cause severe distress and embarrassment. There may be a time to involve yourself in other people's relationships, if it's your daughter, sister, best friend for example, but this is not one of them.
WhatAShilohPitt · 08/08/2021 16:55

Somebody anonymously told my friend her husband was having an affair and it was the best thing they could have done. It meant she could make an informed choice, take control of her life and get rid of him.

DrSbaitso · 08/08/2021 16:52

Honestly, if you did this to me - unilaterally decided to change my life for the worst without having any connection to it - and told me it was fine because YOU were satisfied with it, I wouldn't thank you and I wouldn't think it was altruistic or noble.

DrSbaitso · 08/08/2021 16:42

I would do it because I think she has a right to know...My view is that it's better they have all the information in order to make a good, informed choice...I am personally satisfied that the responsibility lies entirely with the cheating partner...

You think, you would, you personally are satisfied.

But also...

I would want to know, others wouldn't. None of us know what is in another person's mind

Your response to this is to to with what you decide, you think, you are satisfied with. But if you understand that you don't know what others want, and that some people wouldn't want you telling them, your personal view isn't enough to make such a massive unilateral decision for them just because YOU would be happy with doing it. It's actually quite a myopic and self serving view.

If you're actually involved in the situation, that's one thing. If you know the person very well and you really are very sure this is the best thing for them, and you aren't going to skip away from the flak, that's also one thing.

But unilateral decisions that change someone else's life when you have no connection and don't know what they'd want? Because you personally feel OK with it? No. First, do no harm. It is not your job to go around correcting people's lives as you see fit.

Oh, and...

I understand that not everyone would want to do that because they don't want the responsibility

No, it's not because we are shirking a responsibility, thank you. It's because we think the responsibility here is not to drop bombs in people's lives when we aren't involved or sticking around afterwards. Part of responsibility is knowing when it's not your place.

WallaceinAnderland · 08/08/2021 16:33

You don't know if she wants to know, and if you're a stranger or near enough, you'll merely drop the bomb and then skip away from the devastation. There's absolutely nothing noble in that.

I would not do it because I wanted to be noble. I would do it because I think she has a right to know.

The more important issue is that you don't have a right to try to correct strangers' lives for them. If you're not directly involved and can't make a very good, informed guess about the outcome, stay out. First, do no harm.

My view is that it's better they have all the information in order to make a good, informed choice about what they want, so I would give them the information I had in a neutral, factual manner and let them decide.

I understand that not everyone would want to do that because they don't want the responsibility but I am personally satisfied that the responsibility lies entirely with the cheating partner who weighed up the risks in the first place and decided it was a risk worth taking.

I would want to know, others wouldn't. None of us know what is in another person's mind so we can only be guided by our own personal view and my view is that she has a right to know and a right to decide what, if anything, she wants to do about it.

3scape · 08/08/2021 15:58

Only cheats cover for each other. There are a lot.

DrSbaitso · 08/08/2021 15:49

@WallaceinAnderland

She can make her own decisions based on the fact that she wrongly thinks she is in a committed relationship. Her decisions may very well be entirely different once she knows that he is not as committed as she thought. Or they might be entirely the same, it's completely up to her. That's why I think she has a right to know.
You don't know if she wants to know, and if you're a stranger or near enough, you'll merely drop the bomb and then skip away from the devastation. There's absolutely nothing noble in that.

The more important issue is that you don't have a right to try to correct strangers' lives for them. If you're not directly involved and can't make a very good, informed guess about the outcome, stay out. First, do no harm.

WallaceinAnderland · 08/08/2021 15:39

She can make her own decisions based on the fact that she wrongly thinks she is in a committed relationship. Her decisions may very well be entirely different once she knows that he is not as committed as she thought. Or they might be entirely the same, it's completely up to her. That's why I think she has a right to know.

DrSbaitso · 08/08/2021 15:17

@WallaceinAnderland

She could make any one of those decisions without the input of a meddlesome stranger who takes it upon themselves to launch a bomb into her life.

Not really. She can't make informed decisions without the information needed to be informed.

She can make her own decisions without total strangers appointing themselves her informational aides. Especially if they're just going to drop the bomb and disappear.

It's not our business to go around inserting ourselves into the lives of strangers to try to make them do what we think they should do or "inform" them of things we want them to know. If you think she is going to stay anyway, it makes even less sense that you should tell her. You've changed nothing except her happiness levels with her situation.

Some people don't want to know. Unless you're closely involved in some way, and are absolutely sure of what you're doing, you stay out of strangers' lives.

Some cheaters justify it by saying they aren't causing any pain. I don't think that makes it right, but it's not a justification that a meddler could use.

Blueskytoday06 · 08/08/2021 15:04

Yep tell her. Or tip her off anonymously.

Blossomtoes · 08/08/2021 15:00

She could make any one of those decisions without the input of a meddlesome stranger who takes it upon themselves to launch a bomb into her life

This.

WallaceinAnderland · 08/08/2021 14:58

She could make any one of those decisions without the input of a meddlesome stranger who takes it upon themselves to launch a bomb into her life.

Not really. She can't make informed decisions without the information needed to be informed.

DrSbaitso · 08/08/2021 14:39

@WallaceinAnderland

I guarantee they'd be furious if they told her "so she can make an informed decision" and her decision was to stay.

Tbh I would expect her to stay. At least at first. If she didn't already have suspicions it would be a lot to take in. And of course he would put his spin on it so she would not know the full story or who to believe.

But it would be out in the open for her to think about, discuss and make informed decisions. They could stay together, they could go for counselling, there could be a big shift in their relationship, she could focus on her career to maximise her potential if not already doing so, she could decide not to have another child with him or not to invest in property with him. She could make all sorts of decisions that ensure she is protected and covered should it all go tits up. And if she decides to stay, fine, that is absolutely her choice. Not telling does not give her any choice and that's why I think it's wrong.

She could make any one of those decisions without the input of a meddlesome stranger who takes it upon themselves to launch a bomb into her life.
TeaDrinker98 · 08/08/2021 14:21

Try to detach your feeling of anger and focus on the love you feel for your friend.

You wanting to tell about of anger isn't going to help matters, it'll only make them worse as your friend will feel that she can't trust you. She confided in you and if she decides that she wants you to tell, then that's when you should tell the girlfriend. Under no other circumstances should you tell.

This woman means nothing to you, so you have no reason to help her when it means hurting your friend and breaking trust. She's already having a hard enough time trusting people right now, why add to that?

I will say though, you sound like a very loyal friend. Your friend is so lucky to have you.

WallaceinAnderland · 08/08/2021 14:12

I guarantee they'd be furious if they told her "so she can make an informed decision" and her decision was to stay.

Tbh I would expect her to stay. At least at first. If she didn't already have suspicions it would be a lot to take in. And of course he would put his spin on it so she would not know the full story or who to believe.

But it would be out in the open for her to think about, discuss and make informed decisions. They could stay together, they could go for counselling, there could be a big shift in their relationship, she could focus on her career to maximise her potential if not already doing so, she could decide not to have another child with him or not to invest in property with him. She could make all sorts of decisions that ensure she is protected and covered should it all go tits up. And if she decides to stay, fine, that is absolutely her choice. Not telling does not give her any choice and that's why I think it's wrong.

WallaceinAnderland · 08/08/2021 14:07

People who wouldn't want to know are essentially agreeing to an open relationship, which is fine of course if that's what they want. The message is be discreet, be careful re pregnancy and sti and don't tell me, I don't want to know.

ByWayOf · 08/08/2021 10:22

Blossomtoes I'm sorry, I can see how it could come across that way. It's because it really does seem to me like that's what it amounts to and personally I do find that stance (which some people - including some of my family members - are very open about!) quite baffling.

I completely understand wanting to avoid hurt for yourself if you wouldn't leave someone for cheating on you anyway (lots of legitimate reasons people don't, don't get me wrong) but "I wouldn't want to know" does seem like a green light to discretely cheat to me and I wondered whether you are indeed of that school of thought that says it's not really the most important thing whether of not someone is faithful to you. If that's not your attitude, I was wondering what you think the difference is.

It seems to me it's either that attitude (and fair enough), or actually you would leave someone if you knew they'd cheated on you (whether for personal feelings or social reasons) but you'd rather someone treat you in that way you find unacceptable but successfully deceived by them to avoid having to leave them.

I didn't express it very tactfully because that stance is very alien to me so I apologise. And you certainly don't owe me any further explanations.

DrSbaitso · 08/08/2021 10:21

Just as some cheaters don't care who they hurt to get their gratification, some "tell, he deserves it" people don't care who they hurt to get their own.

I guarantee they'd be furious if they told her "so she can make an informed decision" and her decision was to stay.

Hekatestorch · 08/08/2021 09:45

I have to be honest, I would definitely want to know.

But why are people being shitty to @Blossomtoes because she feels differently.

Once you know, you know. There's no going back and people often say they wished they hadn't found out.

And I do agree with Blossoms 'polishing their halo' statement. Most people don't tell the other woman, for her benefit. They do it because they have another motive.

I believe in ops cases, ots so she can feel she exacted revenge on a cheater, because she was cheated on by someone else. Its not an altruistic deed.

When the OW wants to the girlfriend or wife, it's usually because they want to cause the most amount of pain. Which is why you get alot of OW refusing to give details, then giving them later, but not all, then giving some more and dragging it out. They don't care about how the wife/GF feels. They care about causing him the most pain and the wife/gf is just collateral damage.

Or the hope the wife/gf dumps them to the cheater will run back to them.

Again, it's not an altruistic deed. The person telling usually gets one gain out of it and just see the wofe/gf as a pawn to get whatever they want.

In all honesty, if dp cheated and the OW knew about me and then was pissing me about. I wouldn't leave him. I would spend time getting everything ready. Make sure he makes sure she absolutely knows she means nothing to him. And then when he least expects its, I would make sure he knows he means nothing nothing to me and get rid then.

But then I can be really spiteful.

Blossomtoes · 08/08/2021 09:35

@ByWayOf

Blossomtoes Genuine question: are you saying you're basically happy for someone to cheat on you as long as they're clever enough to keep it a secret from you?

Presumably you'd be unhappy of they gave you an STI or it impacted you practically, like them spending a chunk of family money on an affair partner, or they started treating you badly because they resented you, but am I right in thinking that - outside of those things - you'd rather share your partner with (an)other women/woman in blissful ignorance (even if everyone around you knows) than have to confront the truth and lose the perks of a relationship?

It’s not a genuine question. It’s a goady loaded question. I’ve said all I’m going to. Why does it piss people off so much when others hold different views?
belle40 · 08/08/2021 06:50

I was in this situation but on the other side. I simply had no idea my partner had started another relationship behind my back. He ran both for almost a year before I found out. I made several huge decisions based on his lies and I would have been so grateful if someone had told me. Buying a house with someone can be unpicked but I guess the next step would be marriage and children which is much harder to manage if built on lies. I would tell her so she can make an informed decision. No one can make good choices on bad information.

ByWayOf · 08/08/2021 06:34

Blossomtoes Genuine question: are you saying you're basically happy for someone to cheat on you as long as they're clever enough to keep it a secret from you?

Presumably you'd be unhappy of they gave you an STI or it impacted you practically, like them spending a chunk of family money on an affair partner, or they started treating you badly because they resented you, but am I right in thinking that - outside of those things - you'd rather share your partner with (an)other women/woman in blissful ignorance (even if everyone around you knows) than have to confront the truth and lose the perks of a relationship?

OhWhyNot · 07/08/2021 21:51

Girl code Hmm

Do we inform on women who cheat too or just men

It’s about feeling better about yourself are you also going to be there to pick up the pieces or just drop off your letter/post on Facebook/make the phone call

stevalnamechanger · 07/08/2021 21:48

Tell her

Swipe left for the next trending thread