Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I tell her?

289 replies

Pollypocket89 · 07/08/2021 08:22

I probably am being unreasonable but I'm exhausted and angry

My lovely friend found out she was the other woman last night after being very much in love for 13 months. Obviously that's over and she's devastated. She's promised him she won't tell his girlfriend as he threatened to harm himself

I've been cheated on and I'm furious on both their behalf. I don't want to cause trouble and I'll probably be told its not my business but I would want to know myself
Do I tell her?

OP posts:
ByWayOf · 08/08/2021 21:53

Alternative it was not to illustrate that a cheater should be treated the same way as a paedophile. It was to illustrate that your, "but what if he did?" is, by itself, a poor argument that speaks more to your view of the seriousness of the underlying offence than an serious consideration in its own right (as well as, in my opinion, a misconceived shouldering of responsibility for someone else's potential actions).

And you've all gone on to illustrate my point perfectly.

Because you don't think cheating on a partner is that big a deal in the scheme of things, you are perfectly willing to be manipulated by any cheater who trots out the threat that he will kill himself if you simply tell the truth.

Because to you the consequence of a cheated on spouse being lied to for a chunk of their life and making important and sometimes irreversible life decisions on the back of less and deceit by the person who is supposed to love them most in the world doesn't really rank.

Because you would (erroneously, I feel) feel personally guilty if someone caught in this particular lie decided to actually follow through with their threat as though exposing long-term, self-serving deceit to the victim therefore becomes a morally bad thing for you to have done in retrospect.

I disagree.

Incidentally, I also think such reasoning opens the door to giving many known liars and manipulators, in many given scenarios (including this one), the ultimate power over your moral choices on the strength of their very dubious word (threat). Anything immoral ranking less than a human life should be covered up on behalf of the perpetrator as soon as they threaten to kill themselves? Frankly, I think that's nuts.

Alternative Fortunately I have no particular desire to be taken seriously by someone whose level of engagement is to call someone who disagrees with them, and has explained why in considerable detail, a "thick twat". It doesn't really matter.

Blossom I am perfectly willing to understand other points of view and indeed have expressed as much in previous posts. Respecting and understanding your position doesn't mean I have to agree with it and I've already said that I don't expect we're changing any minds, here.

I think I'm entitled in the course of discussion to point out and question what I think are flaws in people's reasoning, though I appreciate it's a very personal subject which can bit very close to home.

You act according to your conscience and I'll act according to mine, and sleep well.

5128gap · 08/08/2021 21:26

Theres also the concept of least harm. Most people would agree that an action that may result in a peadophile taking his own life should be taken regardless of the risk to the paedophile, in order to prevent a child being abused, as in this case the action is less harmful than inaction.
In the case of disclosing cheating this is not necessarily so.

AlternativePerspective · 08/08/2021 21:26

But let’s look at your comparison here in the way you seem to think we should all understand.

The crimes of a paedophile are worse than his killing himself.

A man cheating on his partner is not.

I care about whether a paedophile abuses children more than I would care if he killed himself if found out.

By comparison, if a cheating partner were to kill themselves, then I actually don’t care if he’s cheating on his partner if the alternative is that he ends his life.

Blossomtoes · 08/08/2021 21:17

it's very silly and speaks to you having no sensible response to the points actually made

You’ve had responses which you disagree with. Your arrogance and complete inability to even consider that there’s any merit in any view that doesn’t correspond with yours shines out of every post.

AlternativePerspective · 08/08/2021 21:16

Yes, you absolutely are making a comparison between cheating and paedophilia.

You asked if a paedophile threatened to kill himself would it be ok to withhold information about his crimes in order to illustrate how a man cheating on his wife should be treated the same.

Reality is that very few people would care if a paedophile killed himself. In fact if I knew who he was I’d want to kill the fucker myself.

So you absolutely cannot use this as an illustration. If you want to be taken seriously here you’re going to have to come up with something more intelligent than that I’m afraid, because right now you’re looking like a thick twat.

ByWayOf · 08/08/2021 21:10

"Clearly, I am not making this comparison to put it on a par with cheating"

Just repeating that one for you, Blossom.

By all means if you feel the need to pretend I've suggested that non-disclosure of cheating is on the same level as standing by and watching someone drown or concealing paedophilia, go right ahead, but I think it's very silly and speaks to you having no sensible response to the points actually made.

Blossomtoes · 08/08/2021 21:05

That was an absolutely ridiculous comparison

It was, as was the drowning person analogy. All those posts are just full of excuses to play God with other people’s lives through sheer arrogance.

ByWayOf · 08/08/2021 21:01

It's not a complicated point, but it is of course much easier to respond to with, "oh my god, you're comparing cheating to paedophilia!" than to engage with what was actually said.

ByWayOf · 08/08/2021 20:58

You'll notice that I prefaced it with "purely for the sake of illustrating the point". I was explicitly not comparing cheating to paedophilia.

I was examining and testing Alternative's premise as to whether or not the threat to kill oneself in response to someone suggesting they may make your immoral actions known is the relevant consideration in making a decision as to whether or not one speaks up, and whether one bears any moral culpability if that threat is carried through. I don't agree that it is or that you do.

I think whether or not you act actually all comes back again to what you think of the underlying action and consequences for the victim of saying nothing.

I don't think that speaking the truth about a lie you believe will harm someone else makes you responsible for the deceiver's subsequent actions.

In an extremely immoral situation, nor do you. So again, we come back to whether or not you're particularly bothered by the underlying action and deceit.

saraclara · 08/08/2021 20:45

@AlternativePerspective

You lose any credibility as soon as you start comparing a cheating partner to a paedophile.
Beat me to it.

That was an absolutely ridiculous comparison.

AlternativePerspective · 08/08/2021 20:41

You lose any credibility as soon as you start comparing a cheating partner to a paedophile.

ByWayOf · 08/08/2021 20:25

I disagree and have explained why in my response to Blossom below.

5128gap · 08/08/2021 20:21

@ByWayOf

5128gap Certainly not. Doing nothing (as a concept) is often very far from a neutral act and it certainly does have consequences.

Clearly, I am not making this comparison to put it on a par with cheating, but to illustrate the point: If you see someone drowning in a body of water and there is a lifebelt at the side, you can choose to throw it to them and call emergency services with the potential consequence of saving their life, or you can take the "neutral" position of doing nothing. That is up to you. But choosing the "neutral" position of absence of action has certainly increased the risk they will die.

I agree that the cheater's actions are their own, but by the same token it cannot be right to have a person who merely informed you of the truth share in the blame either.

I agree entirely there are situations where doing nothing is not a neutral act. I am referring to the specific situation in this post. If OP does nothing it will have no impact on the people concerned.
ByWayOf · 08/08/2021 20:20

"What if he did?" and misplaced sense of guilt and responsibility are exactly what allows abusive manipulators to use the, "if you do X, I will kill myself and it will be all your fault," with such success.

Again, purely for the sake of illustration of a point, if a paedophile said that to you that they would kill themselves if you revealed their disgusting behaviour, would you think, "oo, what if he did? Better not say anything"?

I take the liberty of answering for you that of course you wouldn't, because you would recognise a much higher moral duty to protect that child, and children in general, and consider that any consequences of his horrendous actions and your bringing them into the light - including any further decision by him to harm himself - would be his own doing. Perhaps if you are a particularly nice person, you would think that particular consequential action would be unfortunate, but I doubt you'd second-guess whether your actions in exposing his actions in the shadows were justified.

So it's a bit of a red herring and we're back to what you think of the underlying deed, whether you think you owe any moral obligation owed to the injured party and weighing those two things up.

AlternativePerspective · 08/08/2021 20:07

It is ridiculous to suggest that the OP owes any stranger anything.

The responsibility is all on the boyfriend, and perhaps the friend as I don’t believe for a second she didn’t at least suspect she was the OW

And while I agree entirely that the man is being manipulative in saying he would kill himself, what if he did? It’s all very well to say that that would be his responsibility when you’re sitting behind a keyboard, when you’re actually the person who did what you were told not to and the threat was carried out, it really isn’t as easy as just saying “well that was his decision.”

It’s entirely possible the friend doesn’t want to tell his GF because she was knowingly the OW and is hoping that he will come back to her. That’s not likely to happen if she tells the GF now is it?

ByWayOf · 08/08/2021 19:57

Blossomtoes

Leaving aside the fact there is every possibility of your finding out or being told or left by your partner at some point anyway, way down the track when you've already made decisions in ignorance which will lead to significant chaos in your life (and that is a very big 'leaving aside'!), it is also perfectly possible that you are already suffering for his infidelity, unbeknownst to you.

Other pregnancies and consequent resources, STIs, family money being spent elsewhere, unexplained absences, gaslighting and consequent mental health issues, a totally different dynamic in your relationship because one partner knows what's going on and feels whatever they feel about what they're doing to you and views you however they view you for not cottoning on.

So sorry, I don't agree there's no chaos without the truth.

As I say, I'm not expecting to "convert" you but I'm afraid you're fighting a losing battle with me too

To me the truth, however painful, is almost always preferable to deceit.

Blossomtoes · 08/08/2021 19:39

@ByWayOf

Blossomtoes Once again, you could say exactly the same for someone who chose not to tell you and let you suffer all the consequences of hitching your wagon to a cheat unknowingly.

You'd be left with all that chaos and they could pay themselves on the back at having "kept out of it".

If I didn’t know there wouldn’t be any chaos, would there?
ByWayOf · 08/08/2021 19:38

5128gap Certainly not. Doing nothing (as a concept) is often very far from a neutral act and it certainly does have consequences.

Clearly, I am not making this comparison to put it on a par with cheating, but to illustrate the point: If you see someone drowning in a body of water and there is a lifebelt at the side, you can choose to throw it to them and call emergency services with the potential consequence of saving their life, or you can take the "neutral" position of doing nothing. That is up to you. But choosing the "neutral" position of absence of action has certainly increased the risk they will die.

I agree that the cheater's actions are their own, but by the same token it cannot be right to have a person who merely informed you of the truth share in the blame either.

ByWayOf · 08/08/2021 19:31

Blossomtoes Once again, you could say exactly the same for someone who chose not to tell you and let you suffer all the consequences of hitching your wagon to a cheat unknowingly.

You'd be left with all that chaos and they could pay themselves on the back at having "kept out of it".

5128gap · 08/08/2021 19:28

Having the information and not sharing it is not a choice with consequences. It is a neutral action. The cheating partner's choices are the ones with consequences and the blame should never be shared by a person who believes it best to mind their own business.

Blossomtoes · 08/08/2021 19:18

Blossom You could say the same for someone who told you

Except I’d be left with all the chaos they’d wreaked. All so they could pat themselves on the back.

ByWayOf · 08/08/2021 19:12

My point, basically!

ByWayOf · 08/08/2021 19:11

Blossom You could say the same for someone who told you.

Blossomtoes · 08/08/2021 19:08

I would judge you for not telling me

How would you judge a stranger? And why would they care if you did?

ByWayOf · 08/08/2021 19:04

I should say that the position would shift somewhat for me if my accidental OW friend were against me telling the "official" girlfriend purely because I would have a greater sense of loyalty to that friend than a stranger, but that doesn't necessarily make it a hugely moral choice - it would just be based on partiality in favour of my friend, and probably a self-interested desire not to lose her.

It doesn't sound like that's the case here, though. If she's happy for the OP to tell the girlfriend but just doesn't want to personally risk cheater's wrath (or dubious claims of consequent self-harm) by doing it herself, then I'd feel free to act in accordance with conscience.

Swipe left for the next trending thread