Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I tell her?

289 replies

Pollypocket89 · 07/08/2021 08:22

I probably am being unreasonable but I'm exhausted and angry

My lovely friend found out she was the other woman last night after being very much in love for 13 months. Obviously that's over and she's devastated. She's promised him she won't tell his girlfriend as he threatened to harm himself

I've been cheated on and I'm furious on both their behalf. I don't want to cause trouble and I'll probably be told its not my business but I would want to know myself
Do I tell her?

OP posts:
ByWayOf · 09/08/2021 11:30

Incidentally, DrS, and in case I've been misunderstood, if I knew someone like you who absolutely wouldn't want to be told even if the consequences were being deceived forevermore, I certainly would never go against their wishes and inform them.

The difficulty is that the OP had no idea which camp the girlfriend falls into.

ByWayOf · 09/08/2021 11:28

Hello again, DrS. I wasn't asking you - I know your feelings perfectly well.

I was interested to know U2's thoughts about whether they would rather know from a stranger (such as the OP is to the girlfriend) or no-one at all.

U2 lives in hope that they would figure it out themselves but doesn't actually answer the question, which is fair enough. It's an uncomfortable and difficult proposition if you're adverse to bring told by a stranger but also wouldn't want to be cheated on behind your back. Unfortunately, in reality, many people do live in ignorance for many years without cottoning on so I do think it is a relevant question.

DrSbaitso · 09/08/2021 08:55

@ByWayOf

U2 Of course that would be ideal. But in a situation where noone you love either knows our is willing to tell you, what is your preference between continuing to live in ignorance and your DH continuing to chat behind your back vs being told by a stranger?

As I think that's the situation the OP is in.

No, it's not the situation OP is in. OP isn't the wife or the OW and she's got no connection to the situation. Being the unwitting OW's friend isn't enough. She is a stranger to these people and it is absolutely not her business to insert herself. She should support her friend, and nothing more.

People have told you and others over and over again that they want to hear it from a close friend or relative, or nobody at all. If you really are motivated by what's best for the wife, you'll accept that rather than constantly trying to question them until they give the answer you clearly want. As it is, you're just proving that it's your own personal feelings that you're prioritising here, not the wellbeing of strangers. Once you know that many people don't want your involvement and do not consent to it, why wouldn't you just butt out unless you really are involved enough to know what they'd want, and to be a support after you've told them?

Wives and families are not collateral damage for the revenge wish fulfilment of strangers. It's horrible.

U2HasTheEdge · 09/08/2021 08:29

@ByWayOf

U2 Of course that would be ideal. But in a situation where noone you love either knows our is willing to tell you, what is your preference between continuing to live in ignorance and your DH continuing to chat behind your back vs being told by a stranger?

As I think that's the situation the OP is in.

OP isn't in that situation as it is not her relationship. She is not the OW. She is seeing her friend hurting and wanting the man who hurt her to suffer consequences. That is understandable, but she isn't really caring about his girlfriend.

Id like to think that if my husband was having a 13 month affair I would have some inkling. There would be a lot of changes in his behaviour for a start (like suddenly going out more when he previously didn't socialise much at all). I don't think I would be living in ignorance for too long and I would rather figure it out myself then have some stranger I don't know if I can trust insert themselves into my life.

ByWayOf · 09/08/2021 07:54

U2 Of course that would be ideal. But in a situation where noone you love either knows our is willing to tell you, what is your preference between continuing to live in ignorance and your DH continuing to chat behind your back vs being told by a stranger?

As I think that's the situation the OP is in.

U2HasTheEdge · 09/08/2021 07:44

[quote farmhouseloving]@saraclara would you want to be told the truth about your husband?[/quote]
I'm not Saraclara, but I wouldn't want to be told the truth about my husband by a total stranger.

It would turn my life upside down, and that of my children's. If I was to hear that news I would want to hear it from someone who genuinely loves and cares for me and understands what that news would actually mean for me and our family.

I would not want to hear it from someone I do not know and have no idea about their motives and what is or isn't true.

DrSbaitso · 09/08/2021 06:21

[quote farmhouseloving]@saraclara so if the only person who would have told you was a stranger you would rather have it been kept as a secret?? So he can carry on doing it behind your back??[/quote]
She wouldn't want an unconnected stranger getting involved. Neither would I. Or many other people.

You don't have to like that or understand it. But knowing it's how many people feel, it takes some arrogance to assume you know better and should do it anyway.

And all this arguing with people who feel that way, trying to make them feel "wrong", is just further proof that it's nothing to do with helping the wife or what she wants. It's purely about trying to get her to do what you want, when you don't even know her. Purely about your own gratification because you don't like cheaters.

Hell, one of the loudest advocates for telling admits she doesn't understand the consequences or why it matters, but she sure knows she's right because she personally feels totally justified!

Hydrate · 09/08/2021 04:56

@Pollypocket89

Oh I wouldn't do it without telling or talking to my friend first

She wants to tell her but said she couldn't as if he did hurt himself because of her she couldn't cope

Threatening suicide is a manipulation. Let him face the music, your close friend was hurt badly by him plus his unsuspecting partner should know that he has been doing this.
strivingtosucceed · 09/08/2021 02:36

I think the problem with not being close enough to the situation but still poking your nose in is, if the woman wants questions answered or needs information, you don’t have it firsthand. And you can’t give it to her without involving other people who may not want to be involved.

So you’ve dropped her into a world of pain and deception, but she doesn’t even have the full picture to make proper decisions with. I agree, if you do this you don’t really care about her, you just want to hurt him and she’s just collateral damage.

My ex told me when he cheated, or I found out on his phone. It was hard enough knowing, but if the OW had told me or a concerned friend I would have felt so much more humiliated and pressured to make certain decisions. I’m glad that ultimately all discussions were solely between the both of us.

farmhouseloving · 09/08/2021 01:06

@saraclara so if the only person who would have told you was a stranger you would rather have it been kept as a secret?? So he can carry on doing it behind your back??

saraclara · 09/08/2021 01:04

[quote farmhouseloving]@saraclara would you want to be told the truth about your husband?[/quote]
I don't have one. He died.

But if such a situation had occurred back when he was here (which it never would have), I absolutely wouldn't want some stranger to come out of the blue, drop this bomb and then disappear.

If a friend who cared for me plucked up the courage to tell me, or even if the OW did, it would be a different matter. Both could either support me or at least answer my questions. A random busy body who thinks she's 'doing her duty' could fuck right off.

farmhouseloving · 09/08/2021 00:59

@saraclara would you want to be told the truth about your husband?

saraclara · 09/08/2021 00:55

@farmhouseloving

Would you want to be told? Whatever that answer is, is what you should do. Follow your gut, don't follow other peoples advice who isn't in this situation
What an astonishingly strange view. You know that everyone isn't the same, right? What you want might not be what someone else wants?

Yours is an incredibly egotistical way to think.

farmhouseloving · 09/08/2021 00:49

Would you want to be told? Whatever that answer is, is what you should do. Follow your gut, don't follow other peoples advice who isn't in this situation

saraclara · 09/08/2021 00:11

It is so, so, so arrogant, self serving, dangerous and presumptuous to assume that you know better than a total stranger what is best for them, and to make irreversible, life changing decisions for them when you aren't in any way a part of their lives and will suffer no consequence. If you don't know them, if you aren't connected, if you don't know the situation, butt out.

Amen.

DrSbaitso · 08/08/2021 23:59

@saraclara

People always come onto these threads and talk about the sisterhood, how they would be saving someone from a life of deceit etc. In reality it is more about their need to see someone pay for their actions.

It is very rarely due to genuinely caring about a woman they have never met or know nothing about. No one owns up to that though. They wrap it up in a pretty bow and claim that they are being caring and responsible individuals.

If I was going to tell someone that news it would be because I know the person and will be there to help them deal with the fall out, and answer any questions they may have. Dropping a bombshell on someone then being able to walk away from it is not a caring action

I couldn't agree more. Perfectly put. And that last bit is crucial.

Quite.

And that's why in some ways, it can be worse than an affair. A person who decides to tell when they have no connection to the situation is gratifying their own desires every bit as much as a cheater.

But cheaters at least don't usually intend to cause pain (if they want to, they'll out themselves to their partner)...sometimes they even don't cause any. And they are at least vulnerable to consequences. Tellers who are strangers know full well they're going to cause pain and usually even intend it; they just think it's worth it to satisfy their misplaced vengeance. And they know there will be no impact on them.

It is so, so, so arrogant, self serving, dangerous and presumptuous to assume that you know better than a total stranger what is best for them, and to make irreversible, life changing decisions for them when you aren't in any way a part of their lives and will suffer no consequence. If you don't know them, if you aren't connected, if you don't know the situation, butt out.

saraclara · 08/08/2021 23:36

People always come onto these threads and talk about the sisterhood, how they would be saving someone from a life of deceit etc. In reality it is more about their need to see someone pay for their actions.

It is very rarely due to genuinely caring about a woman they have never met or know nothing about. No one owns up to that though. They wrap it up in a pretty bow and claim that they are being caring and responsible individuals.

If I was going to tell someone that news it would be because I know the person and will be there to help them deal with the fall out, and answer any questions they may have. Dropping a bombshell on someone then being able to walk away from it is not a caring action

I couldn't agree more. Perfectly put. And that last bit is crucial.

Blossomtoes · 08/08/2021 23:28

@pinkflamingo21

YES, be the better person
The better person than whom?
U2HasTheEdge · 08/08/2021 23:17

@pinkflamingo21

YES, be the better person
I don't think it would make the OP a better person.

You don't go sticking your nose into people's relationships when you don't really know the couple and you aren't even the one who was the accidental 'OW'.

People always come onto these threads and talk about the sisterhood, how they would be saving someone from a life of deceit etc. In reality it is more about their need to see someone pay for their actions.

It is very rarely due to genuinely caring about a woman they have never met or know nothing about. No one owns up to that though. They wrap it up in a pretty bow and claim that they are being caring and responsible individuals.

If I was going to tell someone that news it would be because I know the person and will be there to help them deal with the fall out, and answer any questions they may have. Dropping a bombshell on someone then being able to walk away from it is not a caring action.

pinkflamingo21 · 08/08/2021 22:46

YES, be the better person

clpsmum · 08/08/2021 22:31

I would tell her and I would want to know. Follow your gut op

ByWayOf · 08/08/2021 22:29

Wallace yes, you're right! Apologies, I got sucked into an interesting side discussion. Back to the OP.

Hope you're ok, whatever you've decided, OP.

ByWayOf · 08/08/2021 22:28

Ah yes, there's the other point in which we disagree - "nobody owes anything to the girlfriend".

It's another moral chasm between us, I'm afraid. I don't subscribe to the, "fuck her, let her take her chances, she's nothing to me" school of thought.

I'm sure that plenty of people would feel guilty if someone who said, "if you tell the truth / leave me, I'll kill myself" actually followed through. I truly sympathise but think it's utterly misconceived (though very conditioned into women in particular) to take this upon yourself and to think that the morally correct course of action is to cover up for a liar to the detriment of the wronged party, or not to leave a relationship (as you acknowledge), because the perpetrator threatens this.

I don't say that you must tell the wronged party even if you think it would seriously affect you if the cheater killed themselves afterwards, but if you feel it's the morally correct thing to do and could live with it if the cheater took it upon themselves to kill themselves after being exposed, taking the view that it isn't your responsibility to collude with them to prevent it (like me), it's absolutely not an action to be condemned in my book.

Whether the perpetrator follows through or not, it's a manipulative tactic to try to cover up their own wrongdoing or get their own way at other people's expense. No thanks.

WallaceinAnderland · 08/08/2021 22:27

Things have gone way off tangent on this thread.

AlternativePerspective · 08/08/2021 22:13

And you seriously think that someone wouldn’t be affected by someone committing suicide off the back of something they’d done? Get real.

It’s very easy to sit here and say that the person isn’t responsible, but when someone has threatened that, and then follows through, of course they’re going to feel responsible, even if they aren’t.

years ago I knew someone whose boyfriend threatened suicide when she wanted to end the relationship. She went along with the notion that it wasn’t her responsibility and ended the relationship anyway. She was right to do that for herself. However, he then went on to commit suicide, and she lived with the guilt of that for several years worth of therapy.

You might act in a way which benefits you if the threat was there. But in truth nobody owes anything to the girlfriend. The friend was the OW anyway, so telling her could well just come across as spite because she didn’t get her man, and it’s none of the OP’s business.

And in the scheme of things, no, cheating isn’t that big a deal when compared with child abuse.

Swipe left for the next trending thread