Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I tell her?

289 replies

Pollypocket89 · 07/08/2021 08:22

I probably am being unreasonable but I'm exhausted and angry

My lovely friend found out she was the other woman last night after being very much in love for 13 months. Obviously that's over and she's devastated. She's promised him she won't tell his girlfriend as he threatened to harm himself

I've been cheated on and I'm furious on both their behalf. I don't want to cause trouble and I'll probably be told its not my business but I would want to know myself
Do I tell her?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DrSbaitso · 09/08/2021 19:06

@ByWayOf

Thanks, U2, interesting to know.

DrS, any answer I give you will only serve to prolong this now tedious conversation with you either telling me why I'm wrong and assigning particular motives to me if I say yes, or telling me I'm morally inconsistent if I say no. I therefore decline to answer.

Perhaps you could agree to disagree, given that we are never going to concur rather than flogging a dead horse. If simply having the last word is your aim, please go ahead and take it. I'm sure you will.

You can agree to disagree and leave the discussion any time you like if it bores you so much.

But yes, the fact that you clearly want to keep talking but won't answer this is very telling. You think everyone in the world would be morally wrong not to do as you do, so why won't you tell us what you'd do?

If your morals don't lend themselves to answering a very simple question about how they operate in practice - because the situation I put to you is a very common one - you may wish to reconsider them.

Awwlookatmybabyspider · 09/08/2021 18:37

How are you going to tell her.
Do you even know who she is.

Why do you want to rock the boat even further.
I agree she probably does have the right to know.

However that’s not your place.
Your loyalty is to your friend.

I don’t think she’ll appreciate you going to find his wife and telling her they’ve been shagging behind her back.

ByWayOf · 09/08/2021 18:14

Thanks, U2, interesting to know.

DrS, any answer I give you will only serve to prolong this now tedious conversation with you either telling me why I'm wrong and assigning particular motives to me if I say yes, or telling me I'm morally inconsistent if I say no. I therefore decline to answer.

Perhaps you could agree to disagree, given that we are never going to concur rather than flogging a dead horse. If simply having the last word is your aim, please go ahead and take it. I'm sure you will.

U2HasTheEdge · 09/08/2021 17:54

@ByWayOf

Hello again, DrS. I wasn't asking you - I know your feelings perfectly well.

I was interested to know U2's thoughts about whether they would rather know from a stranger (such as the OP is to the girlfriend) or no-one at all.

U2 lives in hope that they would figure it out themselves but doesn't actually answer the question, which is fair enough. It's an uncomfortable and difficult proposition if you're adverse to bring told by a stranger but also wouldn't want to be cheated on behind your back. Unfortunately, in reality, many people do live in ignorance for many years without cottoning on so I do think it is a relevant question.

It's not uncomfortable to answer. I was just posting when I should have been going to work Grin

I agree that many people are blindsided by their partner's affair for a long time, or may never find out. In my husband's situation, due to illness, I am pretty confident it wouldn't take me too long to figure it out that his dramatic change in social life could be down to an affair.

To answer your question- no, I do not want to be told my a stranger about my husband's infidelity. Id prefer to take the small risk of never finding out.

Tiana4 · 09/08/2021 17:40

On Saturday OP said she was going to leave the thread. As she felt the further responses were unhelpful.

MNers, I know this is a public forum and you can post and comment what you like. And have a view.

But those saying she ought tell bc you would want to know - and have a strong moral compass that overrides friendships- this should really all be about OP's friend. Who doesn't want to say anything at the moment. It should be within her control and her call entirely.

OP ought be focused on supporting her friend not considering going behind her back to damage friend's trust in her and blow up her life. We all need a good confidant, not a wild firecracker .

It will not work out well if OP goes behind her back to throw in that firework no matter if the man deserves it . It will bounce back on OP's friend.

DrSbaitso · 09/08/2021 17:37

ByWayOf, I know your views.

But I'm asking: would you have tracked down this man's wife and told her? A man you hardly knew, and a woman whose face, name and voice you don't know from Adam?

ByWayOf · 09/08/2021 17:31

DrS If you'd like to know my views, I suggest you read over my many, many comments on this thread and absorb their meaning. I'll repeat the fundamentals one more time.

If you were in possession of knowledge about my cheating DH you wouldn't tell me and I would be just as unhappy with and judgemental about your choice to collude in my deception as you would be about my choice to tell you the truth. I would consider that your unwelcome choice was just as self-serving and immoral as you would apparently consider mine to be. So there.

You never know whether the person you tell will take your view of the situation or mine so you can only go by doing to others as you would be done by. There is no neutral. Absolving yourself of all responsibility to tell the truth to someone you know if being lied to doesn't wash with me, just as much as taking it upon myself to tell you the truth doesn't wash with you. We're at an impasse.

I'm willing to accept that and agree to disagree. Perhaps you would kindly do the same and this thread can turn back to the OP specifically.

WallaceinAnderland · 09/08/2021 17:22

We know. You’ve told us about a billion times Grin

That's the trouble with circular arguments isn't it. I think those of us with opposing views will have to agree to disagree on this thread as knowing/not knowing is obviously equally important to each of us

DrSbaitso · 09/08/2021 17:11

@ByWayOf

Thanks, DrS. As you know, I disagree.

Have a lovely day.

Yes, you keep saying. Unfortunately, when you're making decisions about other people's lives, what they might think should really trump what you think.

So I know you would barge into my life and feel good about it even if I told you it was ruinous, unwelcome and not your place. OK.

What would you have done with my old work colleague who was having an affair, to whom I spoke maybe three times in five years and whose wife I had never met? I chose not to look his address and phone number up on the work records and contact his wife to tell her (would have been tricky, I didn't know her name). What would you have done?

ByWayOf · 09/08/2021 17:04

Thanks, DrS. As you know, I disagree.

Have a lovely day.

DrSbaitso · 09/08/2021 16:50

@ByWayOf

I won't. I would tell you. In your case that would be the wrong decision for you because you would rather not have known, but that defies the odds.

Again, the same question applies the other way round. But you surely know that by now and it's getting very boring repeating myself that what you think are "gotchas" apply equally in reverse and that that is precisely why it is such an invidious position to be put in as a third party with never a clear right answer.

Have a lovely day.

They're not "gotchas", they are fair points. You have no answer to them so you try to invalidate them.

I do indeed not want you, a perfect stranger, to blunder into my life and possibly ruin it. You do not have my consent. And you know many other people like me are out there. And you have decided that you know better, and your beliefs for my life trump mine, and that you have the right to enter my life unbidden and change it for me. When you don't know me or anything about me.

The "odds" are another thing you don't know and have made up, on the myopic logic that your wants are the default ones. And those of us who feel are worth risking. But it's ok, because YOU feel happy with it.

You may feel comfortable ruining my life and making decisions for me without my consent, as a total stranger, but at the very least do not flatter yourself that it was a noble act. It is presumptuous and self serving.

Blossomtoes · 09/08/2021 16:46

@WallaceinAnderland

I would definitely want to be told and I wouldn't care who told me or why. I would just want that information.
We know. You’ve told us about a billion times.
WallaceinAnderland · 09/08/2021 16:45

I would definitely want to be told and I wouldn't care who told me or why. I would just want that information.

ByWayOf · 09/08/2021 16:16

I won't. I would tell you. In your case that would be the wrong decision for you because you would rather not have known, but that defies the odds.

Again, the same question applies the other way round. But you surely know that by now and it's getting very boring repeating myself that what you think are "gotchas" apply equally in reverse and that that is precisely why it is such an invidious position to be put in as a third party with never a clear right answer.

Have a lovely day.

DrSbaitso · 09/08/2021 14:13

@ByWayOf

Right-o, DrS. I disagree with the vast majority of what you're saying and always will.

Thanks for the chat.

Wait, one last question. You've given me permission to tell tell if I see your husband kissing someone else. Given that I don't give you permission to tell me the same, and you have no idea who I am, how will you know not to do it if you see him?
ByWayOf · 09/08/2021 14:00

Right-o, DrS. I disagree with the vast majority of what you're saying and always will.

Thanks for the chat.

DrSbaitso · 09/08/2021 13:56

"We're going round in circles" immediately followed by a lengthy post. Either accept that you're at least as invested in your view as I am in mine or jump off the roundabout.

I'll lose my trust not only in my partner but in all those around me who knew

A stranger would not be around you. That's the entire point. That's the huge difference between learning that someone you don't know is having an affair, and learning that your sister or best friend's husband is.

But given both perspectives exist, there is no real neutral or "no harm" option here.

Withholding your active and unsolicited input into a stranger's life is certainly closer to it. At the very least, you have not made things worse for anyone.

you don't accept that people who would want to tell or be told are not necessarily acting out of a desire to punish the cheater or frustration at the deceived partner not leaving. That isnotmy motive...If the deceived partner knew and decided to take no further action at all, and the cheating partner suffered nothing for their actions I would be absolutely content with that.

Who cares what you're contented with regarding someone else's life? The fact that you're saying things like this and asking emotive leading questions of other people who feel differently betrays the personal investment you've got in what other people do. Like the woman who said she would be OK if I hated her for it, as if HER feeling fine with it is the deciding factor!

Besides, won't they feel stressed and pressured knowing you're out there and presumably continuing to watch their life to see what they do?

I and they have been given proper agency and clear-eyed choice over their own lives.

Their own lives, nothing to do with you. You have no way of knowing that they don't already have this clear eyed agency or that they consent for you to appoint yourself their informational aid. You do not know anything. You are making unilateral decisions for people people do not know.

Like the woman who invented the girlfriend "torturing herself". She doesn't know what the girlfriend thinks!

I cannot agree that it's right to participate in a serious deception of someone else..I won't participate in lying

You're not participating! You have no connection to it! You would participate if you blundered in!

I knew a man at my old office was having an affair with a co worker (co worker saw the emails). I think I spoke to him maybe three times, brief work conversations, nothing more. I could have looked up his home contact details on the system (I didn't even know what city he lived in or if he had any kids) and somehow informed his wife, whose name and face I didn’t know, who had no idea I existed. I didn't. Should I have? Was I "participating"?

They divorced soon after anyway.

We disagree. That's fine.

Why, thank you.

Brainwave89 · 09/08/2021 13:46

sorry should be no.

Brainwave89 · 09/08/2021 13:46

To the women who post that if their partner was having an affair they would know. Sometimes yes, and sometimes know. if a partner works away a lot anyway, or works unsociable hours which do not align with your own, it is quite possible that you can be wholly deceived. Throw in that you trust your partner and think they have the best motives you do not get suspicious perhaps for quite some time... and then the walls come tumbling down. It feels like everything you have ever done is a lie and has been a waste of time. It is the most horrid of feelings.

OhWhyNot · 09/08/2021 13:44

I wouldn’t be informing on any strangers

I have no idea what is going on in their lives, I’m not there to help pick up the pieces. There could be other issues, illness, loss of job, family illness or death, miscarriage (or pregnancy), concerns over child’s health

Are you going to be there to help the person you feel you have apparently allowed to make an informed decision (and that’s assuming they have not worked if out for themselves)

It’s nothing to do with allowing another to make an informed decision if they are a stranger to you you are not aware if they do know s about you feeling you are doing the right thing 😇

ByWayOf · 09/08/2021 13:33

DrS I think we're going round in circles here, but I'll just say two things:

  1. The first is that we disagree about what constitutes "doing no harm". If someone knew and didn't tell me in order to give me proper agency over my own life, I would consider them to be doing harm to me. Not least because as and when I do find out, I'll lose my trust not only in my partner but in all those around me who knew and did nothing to help me protect myself. As much harm as the person who cheated on the first place? Certainly not. But doing me harm by their silence when they could make another choice? Yes. You have a different view. But given both perspectives exist, there is no real neutral or "no harm" option here.
  1. I say this because for some reason you don't accept that people who would want to tell or be told are not necessarily acting out of a desire to punish the cheater or frustration at the deceived partner not leaving. That is not my motive. If the deceived partner knew and decided to take no further action at all, and the cheating partner suffered nothing for their actions I would be absolutely content with that. That would be the absolute choice and right of the person deceived and no judgement or frustration from my end. Similarly, I might choose not to leave for very valid reasons of my own. But I and they have been given proper agency and clear-eyed choice over their own lives. I cannot agree that it's right to participate in a serious deception of someone else on the basis that "they might be happier not knowing" unless you actually know they are ok being lied to by action or omission (which I would say is unusual).

As I said, if I found out your husband was cheating on you, I absolutely wouldn't tell you or get involved in any way because I know that you are someone who wouldn't want to know. I find that unusual but I respect your wishes and would leave you to find out on your own, or not, as fate dictates.

As a rule, though, I won't participate in lying to someone about the fundamental foundations of their life because I think it's wrong, morally dubious and ultimately damaging.

We disagree. That's fine.

If you see my husband snogging someone else, give me a heads up, though, please! Grin

Thevoiceofreason2021 · 09/08/2021 12:25

It’s not your business and tbh she probably knows already. He sounds like an absolute dreamboat and your friend is well out of it. Help your friend get over it /,take her out , encourage her to join a dating site , book a weekend away hiking …what ever it takes her to get over that sociopath. Walk away from the situation…. What do you hope achieve by getting involved? He’s a waste of skin - just move on.

DrSbaitso · 09/08/2021 12:11

@ByWayOf

Incidentally, DrS, and in case I've been misunderstood, if I knew someone like you who absolutely wouldn't want to be told even if the consequences were being deceived forevermore, I certainly would never go against their wishes and inform them.

The difficulty is that the OP had no idea which camp the girlfriend falls into.

Which is why the saying "first, do no harm" applies so much here. You say "Not wanting to be told isn't the default just because it's how you feel", but it's not because that's how I feel. It's because your first move should be to do no harm. And if you're not close enough to know if you will or not, then don't!

I know you weren't asking me, but a) it's an open and public discussion and b) it's another example of people asking extremely leading questions designed to get the other person to say that actually they do want you to tell them.

I do appreciate how frustrating it is when a woman appears to you to be allowing a POS man to get away with it. But things are often more complicated than they seem to an outsider, especially a stranger, and these are very personal and life changing decisions. If you're not in any way connected to the situation or the people, it's just not up to you to do it.

Brainwave89 · 09/08/2021 12:03

Difficult one. I see why people would say nothing to do with you and move on, but I have had too many friends who have had their lives badly damaged by such a cheating fuckwit as this. He is buying a house with his girlfriend?... what a shit. I would be curious as to why your friend agreed not to tell his partner. I suspect he begged and emotionally blackmailed her not to do this... something like it was a blip it will never happen again, you will really hurt her etc? I would have this discussion with her and strongly encourage her to speak to his partner, or allow you to. I would back it up with evidence if you have any.

ByWayOf · 09/08/2021 11:42

And to be clear, what many people (including me) want or would want is to be told. By anyone. To stop them wasting any more of their lives. I actually wouldn't care what the motivation of the person telling me was (though it may affect how profusely I thank them!), because I'd just want to know.

Not wanting to be told isn't the default just because it's how you feel.

Again, I say that this is why it's such an invidious position to be put in, because you can't do right for doing wrong.

I would, however, venture to say that yours is the more unusual position and so the odds of doing the right thing in the mind of the wronged partner are likely to fall on the side of telling her.

So equally you could say, why wouldn't you tell someone unless you're close enough to know that they wouldn't want that?

Swipe left for the next trending thread