Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Climate change - is this a wakeup call?

192 replies

Tulipomania · 07/08/2021 07:58

Seeing the wildfires in Greece and Turkey.

The extreme heatwave we had here in the UK. Floods in central London.

Flooding in China. More extreme heatwaves in the US.

Is anyone else as worried as I am for the future of our kids, or are we just going to carry on ignoring the warning signs until it is too late?

OP posts:
Elys3 · 07/08/2021 16:19

And I can’t get too worked up about politicians flying to tackle the most pressing global emergency when there are 39 millions flights per day.

Elys3 · 07/08/2021 16:17

Have you seen what people in parts of Greece and the US are facing right now?

twitter.com/socalfirephoto/status/1423104046689177600?s=21

twitter.com/blkahn/status/1423994817642737665?s=21

All places will be impacted and the safer parts of the world will be even more inundated with displaced and desperate people. Every positive action counts and we are not powerless as individuals because there are millions of us…, but we all need to do as much as we can, including not voting in political parties that talk climate action whilst supporting the status quo.

beforesunsetorsunrise · 07/08/2021 16:11

Yes I am worried about it recently. Admittedly for the first time ever. I'd (selfishly) thought before now that it's not going to happen for a long time..

I don't think the climate emergency should be used to further control us minions though, when huge corporations are mostly to blame.

HasaDigaEebowai · 07/08/2021 15:54

Worrying about the future is a waste of the time that we have left. Enjoy life, live for the moment, use whatever resources we have available to us. Ultimately it's better for us to have a few decades of pleasure than for humans to suffer for centuries

What a sad and utterly selfish view.

Howtotameyourtoddler · 07/08/2021 15:54

@ChainJane well, aren't you a breath of fresh air. Mass culls? Sterilisation? Do you take this chat to dinner parties?

OP, I hope the current (and, now, constant) displays of the impacts of climate change will help to sharpen minds and efforts. And I hope that the global response to covid has demonstrated that governments can act quickly, decisively and in a united way when forced to. But on the latter point, it frightens me to think how far down the line we'll have to get with the climate crisis before government takes that sort of action, and at what cost. The sacrifices we could have made 20 years ago to avoid catastrophic global warming were significantly less than what is required now, but god only knows what will need to happen in another 10, 15 years time.

I work in a climate change related field and yes, it scares and depresses me. The comfort I take it that viable solutions do exist. We aren't bumbling around in the dark here, we do know how to avoid and survive the worst effects of global warming. What we lack, right now, is the collective public and political willpower to take that action. But the political landscape is already changing. The most meaningful thing we can do as individuals is to exert pressure on those in power.

I have to have some hope - I have one child and another on the way and, without hope for their futures, I don't think I could get out of bed in the morning.

ChainJane · 07/08/2021 15:38

I've know this was happening since I was about 10. The difference is, a few decades on, I really couldn't care less! Humans are just doing what our species has always done, exploit the available resources to try to live the best lives we can.

Who cares what things are like in fifty or a hundred years time? Most of us will be dead by then. If you are worried about the future for you children, the answer is simple - don't have them! I have no sympathy for those who've had kids in the last thirty years or so, it's been clear since the 1980s that we'd be in a lot of trouble by 2100.

The important thing to understand is that all species die out at some point and humans will be no exception, and we shouldn't try to delude ourselves that we are somehow "special" and will exist forever.

Little changes won't change the course we are heading in. We would need radical action - not "PC" radicalness like supergluing yourself to a train, sitting in a road blocking traffic, only flying twice per year or going vegan, but actually radical policies like a massive population cull or sterilisation programme - the world is overpopulated by at least four billion people.

Worrying about the future is a waste of the time that we have left. Enjoy life, live for the moment, use whatever resources we have available to us. Ultimately it's better for us to have a few decades of pleasure than for humans to suffer for centuries.

YouWereGr8InLittleMenstruators · 07/08/2021 14:49

You're not U.
This conversation is so important. Normalising talking about the choices you make to decrease your carbon footprint in your family and social circle:
"Love the sofa I got from Freecycle / these shoes from Oxfam / camping in Norfolk / the zero-waste shop laundry liquid refill!"
"This year? Nah, we stopped flying."
"It was so easy to change my energy supplier / insurance company / current account etc for one that's divested of investment in fossil fuels, I'm kicking myself for not doing it ages ago!"
And so on.
Of course corporations and governments play a huge part, but we can and should be indicating our concern for the climate and environment by making solid consumer choices and telling others about it.
My DC (11 and 8) know that every time we buy something "new" we are participating in a process of creating demand for production which requires both natural resources and energy, both of which take their toll on the planet. They advocate buying second hand or going without every time.

Orangemochafrappacino · 07/08/2021 13:35

@ComtesseDeSpair

we need countries like China, India, Saudi Arabia and Brazil on board, all of which have showed a reluctance to make change.

And why should they change? In the West we’ve enjoyed the luxuries and spoils which have arisen from cheap fossil energy, corporate irresponsibility and industrial farming for several generations - and yet now, just as people in the developing world are beginning to get a taste for and enough money to enjoy those things too, we want to tell them how irresponsible they’re being and they need to think of the planet and cut back on their consumption. I don’t think it’s at all surprising that we’re getting pushback from other governments and their populations on this.

That's a pretty narrow minded stance to take considering its the developing world that are likely to feel the extreme effects of climate change, and sooner.
Womaninthemirror1 · 07/08/2021 13:31

*not a

Womaninthemirror1 · 07/08/2021 13:31

Yabu but only because this is my a wakeup call, this is the new reality. Wakeup call was 25 years ago.

SmokeyDevil · 07/08/2021 13:26

@MoreRainThanAnyYet

If flying people round the world and buttering them up with posh hotels is what it takes to get climate agreements, that’s a worthwhile flight and hotel bill.
They've been doing these for quite a while now, and have accomplished fuck all. How many meetings is it going to take them? Hmm
workwoes123 · 07/08/2021 13:06

Really? All I see is double standards

… and while we are distracted by criticising these “double standards” (which are really just the consequences of living and operating in the society we currently have) the oil and gas companies carry on doing their thing, safe in the knowledge that our attention is not focused on them. Ditto if we’re busy calculating our personal carbon footprints (popularised by British Petroleum - more distraction and individual shouldering of blame) and trying to reduce it (pointless and doesn’t make any difference, but makes us feel like we are a. culpable and b. doing something significant).

Micheal Mann’s book The New Climate War is eye opening on this.

PopcornMuncher · 07/08/2021 12:54

If flying people round the world and buttering them up with posh hotels is what it takes to get climate agreements, that’s a worthwhile flight and hotel bill.

Really? All I see is double standards

workwoes123 · 07/08/2021 10:40

I think it’s quite well established that small, individual actions have virtually no impact. At best they might raise awareness: at worse they are a total distraction from the actions of the oil and gas companies (and are in fact a tool they actively use to divert attention from their actions and to divide us). You can do every green thing in the book - and you still have no impact on climate warming.

Voting and campaigning are the actions that will have an impact. But who’s going to vote for the party that promises to reduce their quality of life, to restrict choice and limit our ambitions ?

TeamRick · 07/08/2021 10:34

And yet the outrage from people who have been asked not to go abroad on holiday for one year in the middle of a global pandemic! 🤷‍♀️

We're screwed!

ComtesseDeSpair · 07/08/2021 10:30

we need countries like China, India, Saudi Arabia and Brazil on board, all of which have showed a reluctance to make change.

And why should they change? In the West we’ve enjoyed the luxuries and spoils which have arisen from cheap fossil energy, corporate irresponsibility and industrial farming for several generations - and yet now, just as people in the developing world are beginning to get a taste for and enough money to enjoy those things too, we want to tell them how irresponsible they’re being and they need to think of the planet and cut back on their consumption. I don’t think it’s at all surprising that we’re getting pushback from other governments and their populations on this.

Proudboomer · 07/08/2021 10:30

@MoreRainThanAnyYet

If flying people round the world and buttering them up with posh hotels is what it takes to get climate agreements, that’s a worthwhile flight and hotel bill.
They have been doing it for years and not any closer.

Years ago face to face meetings might have been the only way but modern technology means it is no longer necessary. Should our world leaders not be leading by example?
Should they not be showing a commitment to change rather than just saying meaningless words?

MoreRainThanAnyYet · 07/08/2021 10:25

If flying people round the world and buttering them up with posh hotels is what it takes to get climate agreements, that’s a worthwhile flight and hotel bill.

Spudina · 07/08/2021 10:23

It’s hard not to despair. There is a Maya Angelou quote which I am struggling to find, that is something like the best way not to feel helpless is to do something. I do feel helpless on this issue because in reality as well as our individual actions in climate change, to really stop the worst impacts, we need countries like China, India, Saudi Arabia and Brazil on board, all of which have showed a reluctance to make change.
But I have done a couple of things this month which have made me feel like I am “doing something”. (I already power my house from renewables, don’t fly, don’t eat red meat). I have signed up to Kilma an app which carbon neutralises my life for £6 a month. I’m trying to remember to take my own lunch to work to pay for it. I also have downloaded Treeapp which plants a tree everyday I watch a short advert. Next I’m debating meeting with my (Tory) MP during his surgery to discuss the climate talks. Even though I hate the man and everything he stands for. I’m also raising two very environmentally aware children. (Sorry this post was a bit rambling. Hopefully you get my point!)

Proudboomer · 07/08/2021 10:16

We are in a climate emergency and yet we are holding yet another summit where all the heads of government and advisors will get in their planes and fly halfway around the world to attend. They will stay in the best hotels, eat and drink the finest there is to offer, be driven around in large vehicles then fly home again.
Yet you the little person living your ordinary life are being asked no take public transport, recycle every thing possible, scrap your summer holiday on a beach somewhere and buy secondhand and locally produced food.
Maybe someone could tell them about zoom.

SmokeyDevil · 07/08/2021 10:05

This isnt a joke topic. No planet no life. We may not be able to control the people above us but we have a responsibility in our own lives to do something, small or not

You're right, but sitting back at the end when it's all gone tits up feeling smug that you recycled your cans still got you to the same position as the ones who didn't, or did worse.

The little people (us) have little to no effect on changing the current outcome. It's the big corporations and governments that need to take bigger steps now, not by 2030.

There was a point actually in scotland about a decade ago (might still actually be the case, but im not sure), that the government had us using recycling bins etc wanting us to do our part, and THEY threw it all into landfill anyway. They had no recycling plant. So when you have a government who isn't fulfilling it's side of the deal, it makes the whole thing pointless. Bet they still fined people for not recycling. Hmm

You've got big businesses in other countries making all of the plastic that contains our food and drinks, that then ends up in the ocean. Oh and all the tourists leaving rubbish along our roads up here in Scotland, because there are no bins or anyone emptying them. Although that doesn't stop the public putting it back in their cars, but they don't.

Relle1 · 07/08/2021 09:47

These chain of events really has me scared for our future. If its ever more clear our climate is suffering it's now. I'm so so worried for my child and for the planet in general. Its us. We are the ones rapidly increasing the killing of our world. How can money be more important than our world? It's like this whole pandemic, if people die there is no economy, if there is no anet there is no money to worry about. Yet all these corporations and government seem to care about is the things that are meaningless.

I know what we do is most likely a speck in the ocean but if everyone has this mentality of there is no point because I wont make a difference, that means billions of people will do nothing instead of changing. And as a collective our change will matter! We all need to do our part.

This isnt a joke topic. No planet no life. We may not be able to control the people above us but we have a responsibility in our own lives to do something, small or not

ComtesseDeSpair · 07/08/2021 09:43

@MoreRainThanAnyYet

I wonder whether the example set by the COVID emergency might shift our thinking from ‘we can’t possibly do that, how would it work?’ to ‘it’ll be difficult to do that, but the alternative is worse’.
I don’t think so. The main thing about Covid was that, however much many people dressed it up as caring for others and not being selfish, they fell into line with restrictions because they were scared for themselves and those they loved and feared an imminent threat. I don’t think we’re quite there yet with feeling at imminent threat, or being frightened of enormous risk to ourselves. Climate change is still something that’s going to affect other people first.
MoreRainThanAnyYet · 07/08/2021 09:37

I wonder whether the example set by the COVID emergency might shift our thinking from ‘we can’t possibly do that, how would it work?’ to ‘it’ll be difficult to do that, but the alternative is worse’.

SmokeyDevil · 07/08/2021 09:28

It's already too late. As you say, the government's of the world are meeting in a few months time. How are they getting here? Private planes. Hmm Could have done the meeting last year via video calls, but no no, hold a climate meeting after flying in.

Nothing can be done to stop it and by the time everyone stops being selfish and tries to act, it will be really too late. We could manage it now maybe if everyone would agree and act together, and I mean properly act not with our crap deadlines now, but it will never happen. Your kids generation is screwed.