Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Climate change - is this a wakeup call?

192 replies

Tulipomania · 07/08/2021 07:58

Seeing the wildfires in Greece and Turkey.

The extreme heatwave we had here in the UK. Floods in central London.

Flooding in China. More extreme heatwaves in the US.

Is anyone else as worried as I am for the future of our kids, or are we just going to carry on ignoring the warning signs until it is too late?

OP posts:
HasaDigaEebowai · 07/08/2021 18:31

Politicians do whatever they think people want. If we all show we want climate change to be a priority then they will prioritise it. Politicians who are concerned about this will come through but in the meantime we have to do as much as we can ourselves and try to influence those around us as much as possible. When everyone is talking about how much they want to go on holiday it needs to become normal to say that you’re not doing that anymore because of the climate impact. It won’t be popular though.

Elys3 · 07/08/2021 18:30

[quote workwoes123]@Snoogled

A sizeable proportion of the world still lives like that, you know.

No i don’t think that in the west we’ll see living standards go backwards like that. We are not going to un-invent technology that we already have. I think will happen is that we get less and less choice about how we live - but hopefully there will be carrots as well as sticks.

Eg. In France, diesel vehicles are being phased out and the gouvernement is making it harder and harder to own one and use it daily. In a few years you won’t be able to buy one. Already, pollution control schemes mean that on high pollution days, older diesels aren’t allowed to be driven in the cities (and commuters / shoppers have to make alternative arrangements). Over time, the number of no-diesel-allowed days will increase. Until diesel cars simply cannot be used in cities… then the whole country. No choice - you have to buy a non diesel car or not drive. The carrots: grants to trade in diesels, various incentives to buy an electric car (still really expensive though).

And other things - holidays for example - will simply be priced out of the reach of many. Once the externalities (true costs to the environment of such activities) are priced into the cost we pay, they will be out of reach for many people.

But who’s going to vote for that? Maybe in Europe where there is more of a collective approach, but I can’t see the US or U.K. getting behind it.[/quote]
A travel industry expert has said that annual overseas travel will decline. Her prediction is that people will holiday overseas much less frequently but will travel for a longer period when they do.

Snoogled · 07/08/2021 18:18

Workwoes123 yes I realise a lot of the world lives like that. I wasn’t meaning that it was too drastic a change. Just that perhaps that is what we need to do. If it makes a better world for our children I would do it. I would be behind a lot of changes if it was a community wide change for everyone. But I am not going to give up car myself so my children have to walk everywhere while their friends drive around in land rovers.

workwoes123 · 07/08/2021 18:16

@HasaDigaEebowai

No, what you have to do is vote for politicians who will make all of these things obligations that apply to whole populations, not options or lifestyle. You doing all these things makes zero difference. But a government that forces airlines to internalise the environmental costs of their activities? That’s worth doing.

Let me know if you find a politician you’d vote for who’s up for this.

workwoes123 · 07/08/2021 18:11

@Snoogled

A sizeable proportion of the world still lives like that, you know.

No i don’t think that in the west we’ll see living standards go backwards like that. We are not going to un-invent technology that we already have. I think will happen is that we get less and less choice about how we live - but hopefully there will be carrots as well as sticks.

Eg. In France, diesel vehicles are being phased out and the gouvernement is making it harder and harder to own one and use it daily. In a few years you won’t be able to buy one. Already, pollution control schemes mean that on high pollution days, older diesels aren’t allowed to be driven in the cities (and commuters / shoppers have to make alternative arrangements). Over time, the number of no-diesel-allowed days will increase. Until diesel cars simply cannot be used in cities… then the whole country. No choice - you have to buy a non diesel car or not drive. The carrots: grants to trade in diesels, various incentives to buy an electric car (still really expensive though).

And other things - holidays for example - will simply be priced out of the reach of many. Once the externalities (true costs to the environment of such activities) are priced into the cost we pay, they will be out of reach for many people.

But who’s going to vote for that? Maybe in Europe where there is more of a collective approach, but I can’t see the US or U.K. getting behind it.

Snoogled · 07/08/2021 18:11

If stop flying makes such a difference then it is just awful that the government are being pressured by the “travel industry” to allow holidays again. Foreign holidays should be phased out of people’s lives. And this needs to be done on a government level not just asking people nicely.

Tulipomania · 07/08/2021 18:09

Wow, I went to test drive a new EV (yes really, I've had one for 6 years and it's time to get one with a better range) and this thread hasn't fizzled out yet.

Personally I don't begrudge the leaders flying in for COP 26, I think face to face meeting is important for getting an agreement, and it's tiny compared to people flying on holiday.

I also work in a climate-change related industry and have been watching people ignore the signs for 10 years.

On China, they have a net zero goal too - it's just later than ours. And yes, their energy is polluting and their politics is horrible, but they are also world leaders on generating renewable power.

I also think we should be capable of an international response to climate change that involves nearly everyone, just as we did for Covid.

And also that supporting a green economy can actually be a wealth generator too.

We jus need to get on and fucking do it. And stop bitching about wind turbines and solar panels going in the wrong places.

OP posts:
HasaDigaEebowai · 07/08/2021 17:49

There are masses of things we can do. Read “there is no planet b” by Mike Berners Lee.

Some of the biggest things:

Get solar panels - still a money saving move too.

Stop buying stuff you really can live without. If you have to buy try to buy things that are well made and can be repaired when they do break and try to buy second hand if you can.
If you need a car get an electric one but ideally only when your current vehicle is at the end of its life - otherwise the carbon involved in making the vehicle has been wasted since an awful lot of cars are scrapped.
Plant trees. This has a massive impact but interestingly the carbon benefits are mainly whilst the trees are growing and less so when they’re mature
Stop flying - nobody wants to hear it, we all want our foreign holiday and everyone seems to think they can’t “live their best life” without it. But it makes such a massive difference that this alone could slow things down enough to give us time to implement measure that could basically save the planet.
Of course there are then thousands of small things we can do too that really do all add up and we should be trying to influence those around us to make changes too.

Thewinterofdiscontent · 07/08/2021 17:48

@ChainJane
I think you’re right. There’s been 5 major extinction events. Ours will be no different.

No one wants to live like a peasants. People om MN can’t cope withot washing their hair and clothes every single day.
Unless we radically reduce the population and keep it low there’s no point anyway.

ChardonnaysPetDragon · 07/08/2021 17:43

It's a bit late for a wake up call I thing.

We slept through the alarm, we'll be paying for it.

veeeeh · 07/08/2021 17:42

The world is huge. Unless and until everyone does their bit nothing will change.
No point in me doing X or Y if the entire population of China or wherever continues to pollute the planet.
I don't know what the solution is, but it has to be global. Will it though?

Snoogled · 07/08/2021 17:31

Do you think we would literally have to go back to living in basic houses and travelling by horse and cart? Growing our own veg etc. Say back to 1800s style living ?

workwoes123 · 07/08/2021 17:27

I have googled this, and can't find any really good articles that outline this in simple terms - just lots of stuff about the individual recycling/ not flying/ not having children.

I’ve looked too and agree there is very little. My pessimistic view is that this is because the changes that need to happen are so drastic and the impacts on our day to day lifestyles are so huge that no one - not environmental NGOs, not campaigners, and definitely not politicians - are willing to spell it out. Because it will be utterly disruptive of everything we see as “normal”. And people, generally, don’t want that.

Snoogled · 07/08/2021 17:10

People need to be forced to change. I look around at everyone who are spending so much on consumerism . The latest thing for people we know is to get hot tubs. Big plastic things in the garden using completely unecessary energy. Should things like that actually be illegal across the world? Probably in an ideal world.

NameChangeHelpWithBullies · 07/08/2021 17:08

I do not pretend to be an expert in any way but have also been trying to inform myself and believe that on the individual level one of the best things we can do - as touched on upthread - is look at where our money is invested. What are our pensions, ISAs etc supporting?

The other one I discovered is sponsoring small actions with bigger knock-on effects - for example, sponsoring a girl to stay in school in certain parts of Asia/Africa can dramatically reduce the number of children she is likely to bear over a lifetime because it protects her from becoming a child bride. The knock on effects of this single thing is apparently pretty big because population growth is a fundamental cause of climate change and it has to be slowed.

It does feel desperate but current wisdom still seems to dictate that if we take urgent action we can change it. It feels insurmountable but I don't see how we can accept the 'it's too late' idea.

RubyFowler · 07/08/2021 17:05

I work in a climate change related field and yes, it scares and depresses me. The comfort I take it that viable solutions do exist. We aren't bumbling around in the dark here, we do know how to avoid and survive the worst effects of global warming. What we lack, right now, is the collective public and political willpower to take that action. But the political landscape is already changing. The most meaningful thing we can do as individuals is to exert pressure on those in power.

Like @Howtotameyourtoddler I also work in the field, and I agree with their take on it. It is generally the feeling amongst my colleagues too.

The answers are there, we still have time, but only if we act now and with urgency.

Jackgrealishscurtains · 07/08/2021 17:03

@AbsentmindedWoman

What kind of sacrifices do we need to start making on a global level?

What reform would oil and gas companies need to do?

Does anyone know what our lives would look like?

I have googled this, and can't find any really good articles that outline this in simple terms - just lots of stuff about the individual recycling/ not flying/ not having children.

Yes, I'm interested in these questions too - what would it actually look like for us?
AbsentmindedWoman · 07/08/2021 17:03

Sorry for rambling Blush but basically if anyone has read anything they found very good and could link it, I'd be very grateful!

AbsentmindedWoman · 07/08/2021 17:02

Also - of course we are beginning to see awful stuff happening around the world, but again I can't find any good articles on for example when and where the mass migrations are forecast.

I have read pieces about the water wars that will be in our future unless there is a miraculous shift somehow.

AbsentmindedWoman · 07/08/2021 16:59

What kind of sacrifices do we need to start making on a global level?

What reform would oil and gas companies need to do?

Does anyone know what our lives would look like?

I have googled this, and can't find any really good articles that outline this in simple terms - just lots of stuff about the individual recycling/ not flying/ not having children.

StartingAgain33 · 07/08/2021 16:58

I work in climate change and yes it’s terrifying. I’m dreading the ippc report on Monday. Basically we are fucked unless we halve emissions before 2030 globally. Which needs widespread support from governments and drastic measures. I know it is probably hopeless but I would really love if everyone could put as much pressure on their governments as possible. Wholesale radical innovation is needed and they are for the most part burying their heads in the sand. And we,re not safe in the uk - in a 2 degrees scenario the feedback loops mean we will get to 3 or 4 degrees, meaning many major cities including London will be under water. We are looking at mass migration, war over resources including food etc. We will be profoundly affected.

tilder · 07/08/2021 16:41

I feel more positive actually than I did 10 years ago. Because it's now mainstream, accepted and talked about. Climate change denial is now seen as an extreme and unscientific view. 20 years ago, climate change scientists were seen as doom mongers peddling extreme views.

Technology has come on massively. Things that were fringe or for the minority (wind farms and battery cars) are normal. Desirable.

It is all a bit too little too late, but in terms of public opinion and industry drive we're doing much better. Shame the politicians are a bunch of spineless incompetents.

veeeeh · 07/08/2021 16:31

I wouldn't change my way of living until the mass polluting countries do something also and it shows committment and results. Like China, and the US where practically everyone over the age of 16 drives a car and they will not give that up for anyone any time soon! And so on.

There is money behind this clarion call, not sure exactly what it is, but you can be sure of it. There are carbon levies and so on, where is that going?

People live in the moment mostly, and a bit of extreme weather in some foreign land is not going to bother a lot of people, when we look out the window and see buckets of rain day after day in Summer.

If there is no immediate threat on an individual basis (see Covid), I doubt much will change. Some people think it is all a scam anyway, there have been floods, pestilence, famines, fires, flooding going on since Adam was a boy, it is not just now.

It seems to be an issue for the committed tree huggers only, most people are not that worried by it as it affects nothing in their lives right now.

Jackgrealishscurtains · 07/08/2021 16:30

I just don't think people are will I g to make the necessary sacrifices. I know several people who go on about climate change a lot, post stuff on Facebook and make a big thing that they use a reusable coffee cup, metal straws, and they bought a coffee table made of recycled materials, but drive absolutely everywhere, brand new PCP car every couple of years, at least one long haul holiday a year and during the pandemic absolutely hammered Amazon prime.

People are aware, but they are just not willing to do anything like what is needed in terms of changing their own lifestyle.

CandlesBlanketsandTea · 07/08/2021 16:27

Personally I think it's too late to make a real change, people and corporations won't do it until they are forced. Unfortunately, the necessary infrastructure like reliable public transport is nonexistent outside of London, so it makes it difficult to make changes to how you travel, that's one example. I don't have children and knowing what crisis we are facing I'm pleased about that. If we thought Covid was bad we are in for a rude awakening when climate change ramps up a gear.