Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To leave dd to cry?

162 replies

Lavendarsaturation · 06/08/2021 20:18

I’m really struggling with dd, 5, at bedtime.
She doesnt ever want to sleep until really late, her pattern naturally would be 10.30pm - 8.30am and in the holidays she sometimes slips to 11pm to 9am.
I’ve started waking her up at 7am in the hope she will go off earlier. She is really busy in the day but she just never stops.
It’s taking me two to three hours every evening to get her to bed. I’m a single mum and it’s driving me crazy. I don’t have any break ever.
She was up at 7am today and has been out all day. I took her up at 7.30 and she is still wide awake but screams if I leave the room saying she is scared. I am having to take calming breaths because I’m really close to losing it. I have another older dc who spends the evening sat on their own.
It’s making me feel a huge amount of resentment towards dd. I have tried:
Talking to her about it
Special worry eater toy
Special soft light
White noise
Stories
Gentle music
Total silence
Darkness
Lavender spray
Warm bath

NOTHING makes any difference at all. I feel like 2-3 hours a night is crazy and frankly it is ruining my life. I know that sounds over the top but I’m tired! I get to 8pm and I think most children her age would just go to sleep, especially as she is really busy most days. I resent my whole evening being eaten up by sitting next to her waiting for her to go to sleep.
AIBU to now just leave her to cry?

OP posts:
Morechocmorechoc · 06/08/2021 21:34

I would not leave a child who has just lost dad out the house to cry, she will already be going through more than you see from her. It coukd do major damage.

Morechocmorechoc · 06/08/2021 21:34

Well there's a start for you, stories lullabies and chatting do not need to take an hour. Spend half an hour doing all that then stop engaging. Tell her before hand you will chat for say 5 minutes then its rest time.

Maybe go up at 8.30, routine for 30 mons as above then if not engaging she migjt just chat herfelt to sleep in the 30 mins you don't engage. Then it's just an hour upstairs which is a good start. My 3 year old has a long routine, it's just what he needs. We chat then he I say I'm going to sleep and he carries on for a bit not expecting a response as he never gets one!

Lavendarsaturation · 06/08/2021 21:33

She can’t tell the time. The light evenings don’t help though.
She does wind herself up massively.
I started bedtime at 7.45 tonight and I still have no end in sight.
I’m meant to be going to a concert next weekend and I won’t be able to go because of her sleep. I know this sounds selfish but I spent so many years being controlled by DH and now I feel like this is no better! I’m held to ransom by a 5 year old instead!

OP posts:
MorriseysGladioli · 06/08/2021 21:32

Have you thought if having one of her friends for a sleepover?
I wonder if that might break the habit, or at least make you both see bedtimes differently.

MsChatterbox · 06/08/2021 21:31

Sounds tough. You say if you stay with her she chats. Do you reply? My son tries to chat. I just say no talking. You could also tell her you will only stay if she lies down with her eyes closed and no talking.

WetWeekends · 06/08/2021 21:30

I would try to take the stress out of it for a week or so. Would she twig if you changed the clocks? So that she was going to bed at 9.30 but thought it was 7.30? I would sit with her with no talking, anything she says just respond with “shhh, time to go to sleep now”. After a few nights I’d leave the room when she was virtually asleep, then use the gradual retreat method of sitting near we the door very couple of nights. I think as you’ve recently split up from your partner I’d try to do things very gently. You don’t want her feeling stressed about bedtime on top of getting used to Dad not being there. I would also consider melatonin, you can buy supplements for kids, as she’s always been a late sleeper it might help.

Lavendarsaturation · 06/08/2021 21:29

I start work at 7.30am in the holidays so that I can finish earlier and spend time with the dc - there’s just no respite at the moment!

OP posts:
Greenrubber · 06/08/2021 21:29

My 4 year old DD was starting to get to that point! I knew me being in her room was more of a hindrance and it was gradually taking longer and longer for her to fall asleep!
I feel for you! We actually by chance managed to get her to go to bed on her own because we got covid so we literally couldn't stay with her (she ended up getting it anyway)
But we have now had 2 weeks of her going to bed on her own its a little silver lining 😁 and she falls asleep within 5 min

But in your case it seems very extreme I would maybe take a step back and just take the struggle out tell her to go to bed when she is tired see how it pans out or even let her watch some TV in her room until she falls asleep

Devon1987 · 06/08/2021 21:29

Mine has always gone to bed at 7pm but it is up to him when he falls asleep. I would not be sat there with waiting for him as he would just want to chat or play.
I would let her cry it out, you need and deserve an evening too.

lannistunut · 06/08/2021 21:26

I think that only 9 hours of sleep doesn’t seem much for a 5 year old. The sleep predates the split. Some children sleep more, and some less.

I have a child who wakes at 5:30am, always has - nine hours. Like clockwork.

You can not fight a child's nature, you will never win!

Couldn't you have family time at night, and then set your own clock for e.g. 6am and have peace and quiet in the morning?

Lavendarsaturation · 06/08/2021 21:21

Thank you for the suggestions - I’ll look at the Moshi app.
Basically I don’t mind if she isn’t asleep but she needs to not need me to lie by her for hours at a time. She has always tended towards this. So did ds tbh and I had years of it then too.
I just look at other people who have children who go to bed and think - how lovely.

OP posts:
Lavendarsaturation · 06/08/2021 21:18

I don’t expect her to go to sleep at 7pm - but stories, lullaby, chatting etc takes an hour or so. If I don’t start it until 8pm it’s then gone 9 etc.

I think that only 9 hours of sleep doesn’t seem much for a 5 year old. The sleep predates the split.
She doesn’t stop. When at school she’s up about 6.30am and still doesn’t want to go to bed although is usually asleep by 9pm.
Last week we went on a day trip and had to be out the house by 6.30am, she was on the go all day, didn’t sleep in the car, wasn’t home until 8pm and still didn’t sleep until gone 10.30pm.

My other dc is older and will take himself off to his room even if he doesn’t sleep.
Dd isn’t hugely demanding it’s just the space. I just need some space and I’m not getting any.

OP posts:
twinkie100 · 06/08/2021 21:18

We went through this stage with our eldest when he was 3. It could take HOURS (2-3 every night) and he would get so cross and have never ending energy. It was completely exhausting, and you have all my sympathy.

I came to say that we found something that worked for us! It was a super nanny technique (don't judge me, I was willing to try anything).

You say goodnight once with all the love and care, books, songs kisses etc. And then leave the room.

The first time they come out the room, you say super kindly but also firmly 'night night, mummy expects you to go to sleep now' and tuck back in with a kiss etc.

Every single time after that you say NOTHING. Not a word - no bargaining, pleading, no discussion, no 'one last snack/cuddle/story' and just take the child back to bed. They get frustrated that there's no reaction but it was amazing.

The first night or two I honestly must have taken him in 25 times. The next nights less, and by about night 5 we were down to 2/3 and asleep by 8. It was LIFE-CHANGING.

When we embarked on it we made a commitment we would do it for two weeks. I think we explained it to him before hand... and just stuck to it. It was all sorted within a week.

Anyway you might have already tried this but wanted to share as it really helped us. Good luck!

laalaaland · 06/08/2021 21:17

That sounds so tough.

Personally, I'm not sure that the tough love thing would be my choice in your situation. I think you sound really understandably exhausted and stressed out, and hours of screaming and stress is not going to help that. Also, it's likely she genuinely needs that extra reassurance of you being there not only due to her age, but also due to the recent separation.

My son is also always on the go and doesn't need much sleep...normally only 10 hours. He's just turned 6.

I've had to accept his later bedtime. We go upstairs at 8ish and he is now asleep by around 8.45

We talked a lot about bedtimes during the day and agreed on a routine.

I will stay with him and read my book, and he can have his night light on and music (if he wants) but he CAN'T chat, he has to TRY to go to sleep.

When he starts messing I barely engage, just say 'sleep now'. If he gets really bad I say if he's not ready to sleep, I'm going to go and get on with my jobs and he can play by himself til he's ready.

He always wants me to stay so normally settles back down. It's gone from taking 45mins/hour for him to get to sleep to it literally being 5-10mins sometimes now.

You've got lots of different advice on this thread so I really hope things improve for you soon.

Jerima · 06/08/2021 21:11

Stop putting her to bed the struggle probably hypes her up and makes it so she can't relax.

Let her go up the same time as older DC and if she wants to read books in bed or play with something allow that whilst you have your time downstairs to relax .
My DC go up to bed at the same time and do their own thing until they feel like sleeping some nights are later than others but they stay in their room and I know they're safe. I'm either downstairs or in bed myself they have always done it this way and had no problems. They're 16 and 10.

Hercisback · 06/08/2021 21:11

The quiet time idea is a good one. No pressure on her to be in bed but she has to be in her room and quiet.

Confused102 · 06/08/2021 21:10

What if you just lay with her for 30 min, completely ignoring her and no chats at all. Her body just needs a new routine and being consistent is key. So laying down with her, lights off, no talking?

Rizzoli123 · 06/08/2021 21:09

My 6 year old is the same. No matter how much I try he won't sleep till really late. Even it he has been at school all day. I have tired moshi and helps. He finds and excuse to get of bed and run downstairs where he sees daddy and daddy let's him stay up even though I have told him no he should be in bed. I agree most kids his age would be asleep by now.

I have also started to listen to music with him and sing and that helps.

lannistunut · 06/08/2021 21:08

I would probably just put my effort into making the evenings a fun and relaxing family time, maybe watch nice films together, or play games. It could be a time of nice happy bonding rather than a battle.

Sometimes when we get stuck in a battle with our kids we have to think - what precisely am I achieving by doing this? What you are doing, OP, is creating a stressful situation.

In many countries it is routine for children to go to bed at 9pm, 10pm.

Whenwhy · 06/08/2021 21:07

If you are about to lose your shit then it's worth sleep training her. Definitely. At her age you can sit her down and simply tell her the new rules in order to prepare her for them. Then bloody stick to it!!!

I would also try waking her at 6am rather than 7am. You need her to be at a point where even if she isn't ready to sleep, she can stay in her room alone to give you an evening.

Would a reward system work? The problem is that age 5, short of locking her in her room (not ok) you can't force her to stay in bed.

Hercisback · 06/08/2021 21:07

Consistency is key here. It doesn't hugely matter which strategy you choose BUT you have to be consistent with it. Treat the break up as a reset for any strategies you tried before. Decide on your course of action and discuss it in the day with her. Explain why it is important for her to sleep, what she can expect at bedtime, and that you will do XYZ. Repeat the expectations through the day and follow through for at least 2 weeks.

UndertheCedartree · 06/08/2021 21:07

@lannistunut

You have to leave her to cry.

No one has to leave a kid to cry.

Some people choose to do it, some people choose not to do it. I personally chose never to leave my kids to cry, and it worked out very well for me.

Yes, I agree with this. You do not have to leave a child to cry. There are many avenues that OP can try.
UndertheCedartree · 06/08/2021 21:05

The other option is to say she has to have quiet time from 8/9pm whatever suits. So doesn't have to sleep but has to read/colour/play quietly in her room.

Splendo · 06/08/2021 21:03

I see other people have suggested it but I was wondering if you have tried either the moshi app or audio books? I used to have to lie with my son to get him to sleep until we introduced audio books, then I'd just pop downstairs to put laundry on/ unload dishwasher and come back up 10-15 minutes later and he'd be much more settled.
It sounds awful OP and there's no wonder you're struggling. Hope you find a solution that works soon.

lannistunut · 06/08/2021 21:03

You have to leave her to cry.

No one has to leave a kid to cry.

Some people choose to do it, some people choose not to do it. I personally chose never to leave my kids to cry, and it worked out very well for me.