Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To expect my mum to help with her grandchildren?

470 replies

flingaling77 · 06/08/2021 20:12

My mum is 68 years old and quite well. She lives a few minutes down the road. She is retired and on her own since my dad died. During covid she stepped back and refused to be part of our bubble at times. We have a 6yo daughter and a 3 yo son. My son has a speech delay and has behaviour issues. My husband and I found lockdown very tough and argued frequently. We considered splitting up due to the strain of his behaviour and the need for constant supervision. His parents live in Cornwall which is 6 hours away from us. They are older but amazing and so hands on. I feel closer to them than my mum really. We chose to live near my mum to support her but we get little help. She makes us feel guilty and is reluctant. She blames lack of confidence but she has made it clear that she wouldn't like to do a lot of childcare like some of her friends. She has said she would have my son for 1 day a fortnight only while I work. I feel hard done by as most of my friends get more help than us. AIBU to expect my mum to want to help with the kids?

OP posts:
LuxOlente · 07/08/2021 17:39

Your kids, not hers - she doesn't have to spend a minute with them.

Mine doesn't bother. She just said "I've done my time" and sees my kids maybe twice a year for a few minutes and asks a couple of perfunctory, awkward questions. She has a Candy Crush addiction to return to.

But nope, you can't expect anyone to give up their time for your children. In turn, though, I don't have any time for her - she keeps to herself, and I do too.

Lovely13 · 07/08/2021 17:35

My mum died when I was a child. When I had children, it was just me most of the time. My father still worked full time and wasn’t keen on babies! In-laws lived abroad. Husband worked 12 hours a day.
It was very hard, but also sometimes it’s easier knowing you’re in it on your own and you just get on with it. Perhaps you need to change perspective and do what’s best for you, even if that means moving to Cornwall. Good luck!

Proudboomer · 07/08/2021 16:54

When most posters say grandparents what they actually mean is the grandmother. I have never seen a thread complaining that grandfather doesn’t give over his retirement to give pretty much full time childcare. But then it is always the woman who is expected to take on caring responsibilities over the child’s own father and grandfathers.

choli · 07/08/2021 16:42

@speakout

It just doesnt happen sometimes though OP. My mother is the only living grandparent of my children- she has provided no significant childcare- maybe looking after one child for half an hour while I nip to the shops, but no care while I work, no baby sitting,, not once, never looked after both children at the same time. It is just reality. My kids are in their early 20s now and as much as my mother would like to be taken on days out by them there is no great relationship. What goes around comes around.
Newsflash: most grandchildren don't do much taking their grandparents on days out, regardless of the childcare offered in the past.
Obviouslynotallthere · 07/08/2021 16:12

You can't expect anything but equally I would say your mum's behaviour is pretty disappointing when she can see you are struggling at the moment. I would want to help my child.

TheLovelinessOfDemons · 07/08/2021 16:06

Expect? YABU to expect it. She raised you. My DM would like to have my DS nearly 10 for the day, but as she's in her 70s and he has ADHD, I feel like it would be too much for her. DS 30 lives with her but has cystic fibrosis and honestly I think his little brother would be too much for him for a whole day too.

Karmalady · 07/08/2021 16:00

I think, when hitting middle age, people should start making contingency plans to help support them in old age, if they need help or care (I’m here now). Put money away, so that you can get proper help without your kids or social services having to get involved.

Mommabear20 · 07/08/2021 15:52

YABU!!! You chose to have kids, why is it up to other people to look after them?? Yes it's nice if they want to but certainly shouldn't just expect it! You sound very entitled to me

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 07/08/2021 15:44

UnamiMammy that's what I'd expect to if I were a grandparent, to be able to have the grandchildren if needed for appointments for the parents and so on - and to have some proper scheduled time to take them out - but NOT as part of regular childcare. That's the difference.

What you describe in your family sounds mutually supportive and beneficial for all of you.

UmamiMammy · 07/08/2021 15:37

We moved close to my parents 10 years ago.............my father was in poor health and one of my dc has special needs. It has been a mutually beneficial move.............we live 10 doors away and I am on hand to support them, mum and dad have both had falls / broken bones over the years and I can drop the kids there if I have an appointment.
I would feel very hurt if they expected support from me without offering any in return.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 07/08/2021 15:22

Why does grandparenting = childcare to so many posters here? Can there not be just, you know, being a grandparent without them having to 'clock in' for parenting?

Is it of less value if a grandparent cannot do childcare but loves and wants to spend time with their grandchild(ren), just not on a scheduled basis?

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 07/08/2021 15:19

I really loath this MN-centric trope of 'no childcare, no help for older parents', it's pathetic. Being a grandparent doesn't mean that you want to relive your parenting days again and that's what childcare is... you're looking after children again.

Grandparents should be able to do things with their grandchildren in that capacity, not make up shortfalls in childcare. I will (hopefully) be a doting grandparent if and when that happens but I won't be 'drafted in' in a quasi-parental role.

OP... you mention that your parents in law are hands-on, but you really don't know how they would be as a more regular requirement - or even if they'd be up for that. You and your husband really need to start focusing on your relationship and re-building it. That's what your children need, TWO parents, backing each other up.

Also - and I'm sorry to say this - but if you don't and you become an 'ex', those PIL may not be so obliging. I've seen this before and understand it - why would they be? You and your husband are a unit and a priority for attention.

SmashingBlouson · 07/08/2021 15:13

@beachcitygirl

I've just had a wee look & what is absolutely fascinating is that loads of people saying YABU and that the op should be parenting her own kids & the DG is not obliged to help are exactly the same posters that gave a woman a really hard time on here recently for considering emigrating as she would be leaving elderly parents. Such hypocrisy!!
That's a really interesting observation. It does go both ways doesn't it? You shouldn't have kids for the purpose of expecting them to care for you in old age either, especially when you have not shown any interesting their lives or their grandchildren.
SmashingBlouson · 07/08/2021 15:04

Unfortunately you can't expect anything, but out of the four gp's my children have, only one helps me on a regular basis and the others have never really helped, so when it is their turn to depend on us, it will be my mother who is prioritised. Not just because of childcare (to be fair as I WFH I still change the nappies and make the tea!)but I just think through her whole life she has been great to us and the kids, and our other parents less so.

Funnily enough, she is the most busy out of all of them, she still works, runs her own house and has to help her own mother. The others don't have parents and never really cared much for them, don't really take full responsibility for themselves, so in general I feel my mother is more deserving.

If you shouldn't expect childcare from your mother, then it does go both ways, and I don't think you owe your mother anything if you want to move away. You can't let it keep you living somewhere that isn't right for you and your family. You said she made you feel guilty and was reluctant? Living near more involved grandparents would be much better for your kids, than one who isn't really interested in them and acts like they are a burden.

Kite22 · 07/08/2021 15:02

In fairness. Many mothers didn't work at the time. My mum is retired.

What time ?
I'm in my mid 50s and expect the dp is closer to the age of my dc. I've always worked OTH.
If my Mum were still with us, she would be 90 and she always WOTH.

Yes, this is anecdotal, but so is your claim. People (all of us) tend to know 'people like us'. So, growing up, it was very common / normal for my friends' parents to work, and my parents' friends to work. This idea that it is only the current generation that work outside the home, is poppycock.

Am also not sure where some posters are getting the idea that Grandparents "don't want to spend time with their dgc" or won't babysit or won't help out their dc. There are about two posters who might have said that - and that is a shame. Overwhelmingly posters have been saying they don't want to take up a new career as childminders in their retirement. I think that is a completely different matter from 'not being around / involved / willing to help their dc. That is absolutely right and reasonable.

sueelleker · 07/08/2021 14:54

You chose to move nearer to her-I don't get the impression she asked you to.

Karmalady · 07/08/2021 14:39

I love my grandkids dearly but I didn’t want to be lumbered with a lot of childcare. I’ve done my bit, with my own kids, and it’s “me” time now.

DH (their step grandfather) and I have our own hobbies and interests.

Thankfully, they are all teenagers now and don’t require a babysitter.

beachcitygirl · 07/08/2021 13:56

I've just had a wee look & what is absolutely fascinating is that loads of people saying YABU and that the op should be parenting her own kids & the DG is not obliged to help are exactly the same posters that gave a woman a really hard time on here recently for considering emigrating as she would be leaving elderly parents.
Such hypocrisy!!

MiaRoma · 07/08/2021 13:55

@bargelights

If I were 68 years old and widowed, I think I might be reluctant to provide regular childcare for a 3-year-old with behavioural issues. Taking care of a child with additional needs is exhausting for two parents, as you know. Imagine how much more difficult it could be for an older person on her own.

Your mother has offered to care for your son once a fortnight. That sounds very generous of her IMO. I would be grateful for that help, rather than expecting more.

This is absolutely correct

You are being VERY unreasonable and entitled, OP.

I also think you're projecting. You've chosen to be near your mum to help her. You expect the same in return. Did she ask you to move near to her , to help her?

If you want parental help above everything , move to Cornwall. Don't mess around telling everyone you feel too guilty to move. Thats just manipulation

EezyOozy · 07/08/2021 13:44

So just like the OP had children then so should be doing the caring herself…..

Yes , the MN logic works both ways

riromay · 07/08/2021 13:33

No expectations for child care and no expectations for help in her old age 🤷‍♀️

beachcitygirl · 07/08/2021 13:08

I think it depends if your mum gives support to you in other ways, ie comes around and helps, comes on days out to help.
It depends on what type of support you give her. If she's not the picture of health then yabu if she takes from you and doesn't help then yanbu

If you want help & support & an hour here and there to have a coffee to help your marriage or an extra pair of hands. Then she should be helping
But if you want regular childcare and babysitting then that's just not on.

comingintomyown · 07/08/2021 13:06

I find it amazing how judged GP are on here unless they are offering up considerable amounts of their time to look after their GC. I also disagree with those saying how “sad” it is when they aren’t as involved as people think they should be.
The fact you are a GP doesn’t alter the fact you are a person in your own right with responsibilities, hobbies and basically your own life to live after having brought up your own children and likely have worked as well. Why is there this idea that you then owe your DC and that it is so sad if you would rather be living your life and having involvement but not a week in week out commitment.
Personally I think once a fortnight is a fair and perfectly acceptable amount of time to expect your DM to be looking after your young DC.

saraclara · 07/08/2021 12:53

Ugh. "NOT their 60s..."

saraclara · 07/08/2021 12:52

I spent a lot of time with my GP s too. But like most women in the 50s, my mum had me on her early 20s, as had her mother. Grandparents were in their 40s, but their 60s as many are now.

I'm 65, healthy, independent, I backpack around the world in normal times, and I'm probably more fit and agile than many. But looking after a toddler all day is still more exhausting than I expected, and I'm glad I only do the odd day here and there.

Lots of new mums will say that being a FT mum is harder than going to work. So why are people saying that providing childcare for GCs should be a doddle for us in our mid 60s? And that's without factoring in additional needs and behaviour issues.

Swipe left for the next trending thread