Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be irrationally sad about my dd's nose piercing?

185 replies

AlexaShutUp · 06/08/2021 10:39

DD is 16. She wants her nose pierced, and she is getting it done tomorrow. I have agreed to this, but I'm really, stupidly sad about it. I need some help unpicking what this is really about and why it's bothering me so much, and frankly, I think I probably need to be told to get over myself.

I really hate the way nose piercings look, always have done. My lovely best friend had one done when we were teenagers, and I hated it then. Still hate it now, even though I know some fabulous people who have them. I know it's just a tiny hole and a bit of jewelry, and ultimately, it's dd's nose and I totally respect her right to choose, but I feel inexplicably upset about it nonetheless.

She is a really good kid. Incredibly hardworking, sensible, respectful, considerate etc. I genuinely have nothing to complain about as she defies most of the stereotypes about teenagers. She is old enough now to get the piercing done without my consent but I know she wouldn't ever have done that - she'd prefer to have my blessing. She knows I don't like them but equally, she knows that I am not so controlling as to stop her from doing it without a valid reason. And I haven't got a reason, other than the fact that I really don't like it. Not sure if it's relevant, but in dd's mind, the piercing isn't just about the aesthetics, but it's also about connecting with half of her cultural heritage in which nose piercing is the norm. I know that this aspect is really important to her and I totally support her in wanting to connect with that. I just can't get past my visceral dislike of how they look.

So she has my consent (even though she doesn't actually need it), she has researched options carefully and will get it done in a reputable place but I am still struggling to process how I feel about it. I know it's totally my problem and I'm being fucking ridiculous. I don't want to show any negativity to dd once it has been done, so please help me to get past this!

OP posts:
NCNCNow · 06/08/2021 12:08

I never told my mum I just went and got my nose pierced same with my tattoos.

AlexaShutUp · 06/08/2021 12:07

@ExConstance

I'm wondering if, because she has been such a wonderful daughter and you are very close that it is not the piercing itself you are unhappy about but because it is a manifestation that there is a significant issue you disagree on? I tend to find with my sons that we get on very well, share values and tastes in any things and then wham! you get an oddball point of view about something expressed that you are not expecting that makes you feel a bit discombobulated.
Yes, I think this is probably what it's about. That, and acknowledging the fact that she is growing up. Sad

Naturally, I want her to grow up, to be independent and to have her own mind. It's what we spend all those years helping them to achieve. But it's hard to let them go...

OP posts:
Lellochip · 06/08/2021 12:06

[quote AlexaShutUp]@steppemum, yes, I have always taken the same approach with my dd. For the most part, I really like her style, although it's quite different to anything I wear. She looks great.

As you say, I guess a nose piercing will be reasonably discreet. Hopefully I will just get used to it![/quote]
If it helps, obviously you'll see it, but a lot of people I've known for years haven't even realised I have mine done so you might find once you get used to it you stop noticing

Todaytomorrowyesterday · 06/08/2021 12:06

I’m not over keen on nose piercing. My daughter had hers done this time last year - the only thing I said I didn’t want her to get a septum one but never said anything else against them. In the hope she’s get bored of it or hate it…it’s still in a year later.
It’s not my choice and she turned 18 recently and now has two tattoos (designs very personal to her and she can cover them or show them) she still a lovely beautiful young lady :)

Bouledeneige · 06/08/2021 12:05

I like nose piercings and didn't mind when my DD got hers done.

Wait till she starts the tattoos! Brace yourself.

AlexaShutUp · 06/08/2021 12:03

@IdblowJonSnow, yes, she is planning on a small stud. She doesn't like the nose rings, apparently.

@wtfisgoingonhere21, yes, you're probably right about needing to develop a thicker skin. Haven't had much practice so far, evidently. I will try!

OP posts:
godmum56 · 06/08/2021 12:03

@ChainJane

I've never understood why there isn't an age limit for piercings in the same way there is for tattoos. OK they're not necessarily so permanent because small holes can heal over if someone decides not to wear jewellery any more but it's still a body modification. In my view a small tattoo on the arm is less of a big deal than having your ears disked.
tatts are way less reversible
BumbleMug · 06/08/2021 12:01

@AlexaShutUp if it helps I’d be the same OP. Facial piercings just ‘go through me’. They’re a bit like a visual nails down a blackboard to me. Or chewing wool (shudder!). No reason other than that.

Culturally and aesthetically I think they look beautiful, but I spend my time wincing at the thought of them getting pulled or caught on something. Can’t help it.

So I’d be the same as you OP. If DD ever gets a facial piercing, which is her right if she chooses, I’m gonna have to fight like mad to get over my heebie jeebies.

AlexaShutUp · 06/08/2021 12:01

@eightyfourandahalf, sorry if I seem defensive. I'm happy to be told I'm unreasonable, I just didn't understand where the thing about not being able to talk to dd had come from. That isn't really the issue here.

OP posts:
icedcoffees · 06/08/2021 11:59

@pelosi

The hole will close really quickly if she loses interest (which she inevitably). Be glad it's not a tattoo.
Why do you assume she'll inevitably lose interest?

I've got my nose pierced - I got it done at university and I'm in my thirties now with zero intention to ever take it out.

Minfilia · 06/08/2021 11:58

I get it. My DD16 just had her septum pierced and I bloody hate it!

I’ve never told her that though.

I just console myself with the fact that she can hide it quite easily by pushing it up inside her nostrils as it’s a half ring, and it looks like she has no piercing… but honestly, I think she looks like some kind of farmyard animal and it’s ruined her pretty face Blush

AlexaShutUp · 06/08/2021 11:57

@steppemum, yes, I have always taken the same approach with my dd. For the most part, I really like her style, although it's quite different to anything I wear. She looks great.

As you say, I guess a nose piercing will be reasonably discreet. Hopefully I will just get used to it!

OP posts:
ExConstance · 06/08/2021 11:57

I'm wondering if, because she has been such a wonderful daughter and you are very close that it is not the piercing itself you are unhappy about but because it is a manifestation that there is a significant issue you disagree on?
I tend to find with my sons that we get on very well, share values and tastes in any things and then wham! you get an oddball point of view about something expressed that you are not expecting that makes you feel a bit discombobulated.

wtfisgoingonhere21 · 06/08/2021 11:57

Op as in your original post you describe a lovely natures level headed mature 16 year old.

I have one of them too and we took her for a nose piercing at 14 as she really wanted to try it and as other posters have said it closes over really quickly if they choose to take the piercing out.

Your going to have to grow a thicker skin if a nose piercing at 16 is bothering you.

Once they start doing other things and exploring other things as they grow up it gets trickier

Fernando072020 · 06/08/2021 11:55

You sound like a great mum, op.
You're allowed to feel sad about it, sometimes there's no explanation for how we feel but the fact you putting those feelings aside for your daughter is amazing and selfless

LST · 06/08/2021 11:55

@steppemum

I have always siad to my kids - you can wear whatever clothes and hair styels you like, but be very careful before doing anything permanent, and I have encouraged them to wait to 18 at least.

dd is now 16 and wants to get a bar at the top of her ear. I think it will look awful, but it is her choice, and my line is the same as it has always been - when it is permanent, you can't change your mind, so think carefully.
Interestingly she hasn't done it yet. I thought she would over the summer, but she hasn't.

As parents we really need to let go of our own opinions on style etc. In fact if our kids only dressed/wore/did things that we liked, that would make them mini me, which would be awful. I try and get interested in their style and work with them.
I think a nose peircing is pretty discreet. Imagine if it was one of those discs in the ear to make your earhole huge - horrible ugly things, and very permanent!

I'd be wary about the bar. It's one piercing I have never had as everyone I have ever known to have it had a right nightmare trying to get it to heal correctly
IdblowJonSnow · 06/08/2021 11:53

I've had it done twice. Turned out to be a pain in the ass. Both times I just let it heal up, no visible marks.

Is she going to have a really tiny stud? They look quite pretty I think.

Yanbu to feel the way you do. You're doing the right thing keeping it to yourself. You'll probably get used to it very quickly once it's done.

Sounds like you have a lovely relationship! Smile

PheasantsNest · 06/08/2021 11:51

My DD has recently got hers done. I hate it but as she's old enough I can't do anything about it. It spoils her face.

eightyfourandahalf · 06/08/2021 11:47

What makes you think I can't talk to her?

This wasn't a personal attack, it was a reply to people who think they should never say anything to their children.

All I said was that it's not unreasonable to be "sad" about something. You asked!

Now you are weirdly defensive and justify yourself, it's weird.

AlexaShutUp · 06/08/2021 11:44

@eightyfourandahalf

Mine are not even allowed to have their ear pierced until they are independent anyway Grin

Yours is allowed, of course YANBU to have feelings about it or even give her your opinion. If you can't even talk to your own daughter, it's not a good relationship is it.

What makes you think I can't talk to her?

She knows how I feel about it as we have talked about it quite a lot. However, she also knows that I have no wish to control what she does to her own body without any valid reason. Our relationship is based on open communication and mutual respect. On this occasion, her very strong desire to get the piercing done overrides my objections to it, because it's her body and her right to choose. Not because I haven't told her how I feel.

Now that the decision has been made and she's getting it done, though, I see no point in me continuing to bang on about not liking it. The time for that has passed. I guess that is why I came on here to work through my feelings instead.

OP posts:
steppemum · 06/08/2021 11:42

I have always siad to my kids - you can wear whatever clothes and hair styels you like, but be very careful before doing anything permanent, and I have encouraged them to wait to 18 at least.

dd is now 16 and wants to get a bar at the top of her ear. I think it will look awful, but it is her choice, and my line is the same as it has always been - when it is permanent, you can't change your mind, so think carefully.
Interestingly she hasn't done it yet. I thought she would over the summer, but she hasn't.

As parents we really need to let go of our own opinions on style etc. In fact if our kids only dressed/wore/did things that we liked, that would make them mini me, which would be awful. I try and get interested in their style and work with them.
I think a nose peircing is pretty discreet. Imagine if it was one of those discs in the ear to make your earhole huge - horrible ugly things, and very permanent!

LST · 06/08/2021 11:40

@Pigeonpocket

Lots of tattoo hate on here Hmm

I think you have to remember that it's her body and she will likely do lots of things to it that you don't like. My sister used to pluck her eyebrows to nothing when she was a teenager and my mum wasn't a fan and told her she'd ruin her eyebrows, which she did, but it had nothing to do with my mum. A nose piercing probably feels more visceral than eyebrow plucking but it's basically the same thing - your child is changing how they look and it's not to your taste, when you've spent most of their life being more in control of their appearance. At some point you just have to let go.

There is always lots of hate towards piercings, tattoos or anyone that doesn't mould into the MN aesthetic
eightyfourandahalf · 06/08/2021 11:38

Mine are not even allowed to have their ear pierced until they are independent anyway Grin

Yours is allowed, of course YANBU to have feelings about it or even give her your opinion. If you can't even talk to your own daughter, it's not a good relationship is it.

LST · 06/08/2021 11:36

I've had my facial piercings since I was around 14. I'm 31 now and still like them

AlexaShutUp · 06/08/2021 11:35

Thanks @Pigeonpocket, I think you're right that it's probably about accepting that she is a separate and independent person. In theory, I have always known and accepted that, but in practice, I haven't really been challenged by it in any meaningful way, because dd is always so sensible and because we generally agree on stuff anyway.

On the one hand, I'm glad that she has handled this issue in such a mature way. She hasn't just gone off and got the piercing done, like some of her friends have done. She knows that I don't like it but she is assertive enough to be able to say that she respects how I feel but she wants to get it done anyway. I want her to assert that autonomy over her own body and one bit of me is glad that she feels able to do it. I do just need to let go, don't I?Grin

Maybe I'll surprise myself and actually like it when I see it. Will try to keep an open mind!

OP posts: