Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

AIbu to feel this way or am I allowed to be slightly sad

91 replies

Birthdaybits · 06/08/2021 07:05

It was my birthday yesterday I’ve never had good birthdays my family never made a fuss of them we would wake up open a gift go to school and that would be it. My ex also used to like to ruin every one of my birthdays. Last year I just started going out with my boyfriend so we had a nice meal and he got me some flowers was all really lovely. It was his birthday in January and I cooked him a 3 course meal made him a cake decorated the room with balloons brought him 3 really lovely gifts. This year for my birthday I saw a cheap bag while out with him and he asked if I wanted it for my birthday from him I said yes and he said I’ll get you some other bits too and then didn’t wrap the bag either said I could have it before my birthday in the plastic bag. So all week I’ve got myself really excited thinking what else could he of got me this is going to be the first birthday where I feel special he’d previously promised me some balloons and a cake so I assumed I would get that. I got a card and dinner out which I had booked and organised. I just feel a little let down.

OP posts:
starrynight87 · 06/08/2021 09:23

@ivykaty44

communication is key

I don't want my birthday present a week before in a plastic bag, birthdays to me are special and a gift wrapped and given on the day is how it works. put some effort in in making the day special

explain, ive had shit birthdays in the past and im not making compromises any more

I agree 100% with this
Iusedtobesoooomuchfun · 06/08/2021 09:17

@JonahofArk

And I really don't understand some of the posters who are saying that they don't do birthdays and don't understand the fuss. That's great for you, but the OP does want the fuss. The focus here is on the OP's needs and expectations not being met, so going on about how adults shouldn't have cake/flowers etc. is not helpful.

On a side note, I hate the idea that we stop needing to have fun/being treated when we reach adulthood. What's wrong with having a fun day and a bit of cake once a year? It's one day!

Then OP lays it on the line with Boyfriend then.

Either he buys more presents and gives more compliments on her birthday or they split up. Or she decided that what he already does is enough.

2Hot2Handle · 06/08/2021 09:13

Have you told him that you were disappointed and does he know about your lack of birthday celebrations growing up?
Definitely let him know how you feel. He may well have meant to plan a bunch of things, but didn’t get round to it and didn’t know how much it meant to you.

Thewinterofdiscontent · 06/08/2021 09:13

Have you told him how important this is to you?

Why did you organise the dinner?

Cryalot2 · 06/08/2021 09:13

Sorry Whatashilopitt, you are right. It is not about us I will try and delete my previous post.
Op just needs to chat with her bf . It is possible he has no idea this upset her.

JonahofArk · 06/08/2021 09:13

And I really don't understand some of the posters who are saying that they don't do birthdays and don't understand the fuss. That's great for you, but the OP does want the fuss. The focus here is on the OP's needs and expectations not being met, so going on about how adults shouldn't have cake/flowers etc. is not helpful.

On a side note, I hate the idea that we stop needing to have fun/being treated when we reach adulthood. What's wrong with having a fun day and a bit of cake once a year? It's one day!

MauveMagnolia · 06/08/2021 09:11

Is the lack of balloons on environmental concerns?
I wouldn’t do balloons

Crayfishforyou · 06/08/2021 09:11

@starfishmummy

kept reminding him in a low key way about my birthday

You sound like hard work!

No she doesn’t. Some people are not bothered about birthdays. Fine, but the OP WOULD like a nice birthday as she’s never had one. And it’s not about the stuff. A card, a gift and a meal out is perfect for a birthday. But it’s not pleasant if he’s written the card in the car on the way there, bought the gift in front of the person and then not bothered to wrap it, plus not booking the meal out. It stinks one year into a relationship. He could have booked somewhere he’d think you’d like, he could have bought/made a cake, he could have written a card the day before. He could have woken you up with breakfast and flowers. He didn’t He is a bit shit.
SmallChairs · 06/08/2021 09:11

@Funnylittlefloozie

The birthday miseries are out in force as usual. Yes, some adults might not know that in conventional society birthdays are celebrated. I can only assume those people don't watch TV or read books.

BUT, if your partner has seen you push the boat out for his birthday, unless heis really stupid, he should have realised that this is how you like birthdays to be celebrated. So, he should have understood that it would be nice to do something similar for yours. Hes either clueless or selfish. Neither is a good thing in a partner.

People just have very different ideas about birthdays, or what would constitute celebrating a birthday. Cake and balloons are a child’s thing for me, for instance, and the OP needs to communicate clearly what she expects to her boyfriend — if she wants him to book a restaurant, if she expects a card (which for me is something I get only from people at a distance) etc. I confess to not entirely understanding how emotive birthdays are for some people.
WhatAShilohPitt · 06/08/2021 09:10

You got an unwrapped gift, a meal you organised and a card in the car. He said he’d get other gifts, balloons and a cake but didn’t so quite clearly has gone back on his word and done nothing extra at all. So I’d speak to him about that. Just say that you had gone to a lot of effort for his birthday and you’d been told to expect several surprises yourself so were disappointed that the only thing he gave you that you didn’t know about was a card. This isn’t about what other posters do for birthdays - that’s totally irrelevant. The other posters weren’t told by your boyfriend to expect balloons, a cake and little surprise gifts!

Cryalot2 · 06/08/2021 09:10

This reply has been deleted

Message withdrawn at poster's request.

IceCreamAndCandyfloss · 06/08/2021 09:09

Not sure how a card, gift and meal out translates to him not caring.

I’m not sure I’d have gone overboard either with balloons and cake if someone kept reminding me it was their birthday either. Small children yes, adults no.

DiscoDown21 · 06/08/2021 09:09

It’s mumsnet so some think you aren’t allowed to celebrate birthdays as an adult but I’m with you OP. It’s only us two and I like to make a fuss on birthdays and Christmas etc. I’m lucky that my partner likes it too his family always do cake and champagne too. We do presents, cards and usually a meal/night out that I organise. We do sometimes go away for mine and we did balloons only for our special birthday.

I always organise catch ups with my mates for my birthday. I want to celebrate it and so I do the organising.

Maybe you need to explain your thoughts to your boyfriend on why you feel like you do about it. Lots aren’t fussed on birthdays so maybe he doesn’t realise how important it is to you?

JonahofArk · 06/08/2021 09:06

This is a new boyfriend and it's the perfect time for you to lay down your expectations. Do not downplay how important your birthday is to you, and make it clear to him that you expect to be treated and fussed over on your birthday. Also do the same if Christmas, Valentines Day etc. are important to you too.

Make your expectations absolutely clear now so that he cannot pretend he wasn't aware later.

And you need to value yourself more. A cheap bag is not an adequate birthday present in my opinion. And you should have said that at the time.

Don't quietly wait to be treated well, demand it.

MiddleParking · 06/08/2021 09:05

I wouldn’t be at all happy to be in a relationship where my birthday wasn’t celebrated. Stuff like that is what makes relationships fun and worthwhile in my opinion.

gannett · 06/08/2021 09:05

@Birthdaybits

Also what I don’t get is he’s the most romantic person every day of the year so I don’t no why on my birthday he wasn’t
If him putting in low effort for your birthday was part of a pattern where he doesn't seem to put much effort into treating you generally, I could understand feeling put out. But if he's romantic all the time I really don't get why you'd stamp your foot about this one day.

A bag and dinner out seems pretty decent to me though I don't know why you booked the dinner. DP and I usually just take each other out to a fancy restaurant, we don't bother with presents any more. Even when we did I don't think I ever bothered wrapping them, seemed really pointless.

Maggiesfarm · 06/08/2021 09:03

@diddl

"All this “we don’t do birthdays” is a load of bollocks. Anyone who says that is just being lazy."

I would say that we don't do birthdays.

We always get each other a card, sometimes a gift & go out for a meal.

Minimal effort, suits us both.

Happy to be lazy!

That sounds about normal to me.
lynsey91 · 06/08/2021 09:03

@DinosaurDiana

We don’t do balloons, just presents and a cake. Maybe tea out if the person wants it. As my family has got older, we don’t get excited by birthdays anymore. It’s just another day. It’s like Christmas, a lot of hard work for some presents and a roast that needs cooking/washing up.
Birthdays and Christmas may be "just another day" to you but to many people they are special days.

Me and DH always go out somewhere for the day for each of our birthdays. DH takes the day off work (I no longer work but did always take time off). We have lunch out and then usually a nice meal in the evening or we cook a nice meal for the other.

We always give each other a card and presents.

We have done this for the 40 years we have been married.

Maggiesfarm · 06/08/2021 09:02

Second para - should be 'anyway' not 'anyone'.

Zealois · 06/08/2021 09:01

Tell him! Let him know your expectations and tell him why you felt let down. I definitely don't think it's reason to be questioning the relationship just yet...

My first birthday after I got together with DP was a bit crap. He did buy me something but had left it so late to order that it didn't arrive, and he hadn't gotten a cake because he was with me all week and "didn't know how to sneak away to get it". I wasn't seeing any family that day so it didn't even feel like my birthday.

Anyway, I was a bit upset and told him the next day and every occasion since has been lovely. He hadn't done it out of malice, he just wasn't great at organising himself.

Maggiesfarm · 06/08/2021 09:01

@Birthdaybits

Well he did a few months ago and I kept reminding him in a low key way about my birthday I just feel like I gave him lots of effort for his and got nothing back I mean I love the bag but he could of wrapped it or something I mean I revived my card in the car while driving to the restaurant
Presumably he paid for your meal in the restaurant.

I think a card, a bag and a meal out is just as good as you cooking for his birthday. He could have wrapped the bag but you knew what it was anyone, you chose it, so not a surprise.

What you had for your birthday would suit most people. Many would be glad of just a card and a bunch of flowers.

I'm glad you revived your card - did it faint :-)?

I'm sorry no fuss was made for your birthday when you were young but that's nothing to do with your boyfriend.

Move on Birthdaybits, it's over for another year.

Iusedtobesoooomuchfun · 06/08/2021 09:01

It was my birthday yesterday too!! Happy Birthday. August birthdays are the worst.
DH forgot.
I didn't receive a single card or present.
Or a single happy birthday message.
My mum eventually phoned me at 8pm.
I hate birthdays too!

LittleMissBoss · 06/08/2021 08:58

Not lazy in any way, just see the value in other things,different things are important to them, can show they care in other ways, dont need to give/receive fuss and stuff to show this. Not lazy just different.

godmum56 · 06/08/2021 08:57

@pinkcircustop

YANBU. It’s not hard to make some effort by wrapping the bag and getting you some other gifts.

All this “we don’t do birthdays” is a load of bollocks. Anyone who says that is just being lazy.

wow judgy much?
godmum56 · 06/08/2021 08:56

its fairly simple really...One question. Is this a dealbreaker?
If it is then tell him so and leave. If it isn't then what are you going to do about it?