Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was this cf behaviour?

69 replies

OaxacaChihuahua · 06/08/2021 04:39

I recently went to a wedding which took place in a hotel. There was no gift list and the invitation said ‘no gifts necessary’. However, like many people, we gave a gift voucher in a card which we put in a cardboard postbox on a table covered in sweets and the guestbook etc,

In a horrible turn of events, the contents of the postbox have been stolen. Possibly / most likely by an employee of the hotel. The hotel is investigating but there’s no cctv, so they’re making no promises.

The bride and groom sent out an update from their wedding website to explain this, because they wanted people to know why they weren’t sending personalised thank you letters. No issue with that at all, it was thoughtful. However, in that update they said ‘should you wish to replace your stolen gift, please consider donating to our honeymoon fund’ and a link to s gofundme set up for this purpose.

AIBU or is this a bit cheeky? As it happens I would have given them a replacement voucher anyway, but this feels like a bit of pressure put on people to do so when some may not be able to afford it. It’s obviously terrible for the bride and groom that their gifts were stolen and not their fault at all, but it’s hardly the guests’ fault either.

So:

YABU - it’s a horrible thing to have happened and most people would want to replace their gifts anyway. It’s fine for the bride and groom to give directives on how that should be done.

YANBU - it’s cheeky to ask people to stump up again for presents, they should have said nothing and left it as a matter of individual choice.

OP posts:
OaxacaChihuahua · 06/08/2021 08:40

I definitely don’t think the couple has masterminded this themselves!

I can’t answer a lot of questions because I don’t know a lot of the details. My husband spoke to the groom fairly briefly this week and was told there is no cctv covering the part of the room the postbox was in (the table was set in a little alcove behind the double doors into the room). The box itself wasn’t stolen. It was made of cardboard and cut open at the seam, and the contents taken.

Good point about cheques being cancelled. I don’t use cheques and don’t know many people who do, but hopefully if any guests did give them they can be cancelled. I hadn’t thought of cancelling my own voucher, so that’s an excellent idea - I’ll try and do that today.

Don’t know what the police have said, or if there is insurance. I imagine it’s tricky as they don’t know how much was actually given. The hotel has said they are investigating so something may come of it yet.

I do really feel for the couple because it’s a horrible end to their wedding. As I said, I would have happily replaced my own voucher anyway. It was just the wording of the request and the direction into a gofundme that felt cheeky to me. Had it been expressed as some PPs suggested with something like ‘a few people have kindly asked us about replacing their gifts. There is absolutely no obligation on you to do so, but should you wish to, please post to X or, alternatively, we have set up a gofundme account if this is easier for guests’ I wouldn’t have had an issue I don’t think.

OP posts:
bigbaggyeyes · 06/08/2021 08:30

Yes I do think it's cheeky. It's awful that the letterbox was stolen, however the shouldn't have asked, or even insinuated that people replace or give money towards a honeymoon, you've already spent once. They abvu

WhatAShilohPitt · 06/08/2021 08:23

I think they should have said nothing and spoken to individuals who contacted them directly about replacing their gifts. To send a blanket message about being bought a second gift - even presented as an option - is not good manners.

comebacksunshines · 06/08/2021 08:11

Starting to feel like i must be very naive after reading some of these responses, my initial thought was that they must have been asked by a lot of people and so they have set up a website.
The original invite stated no gifts necessary. What are they criminal masterminds double bluffing their guests, you don’t have to buy us anything, but if you do we’ll pretend they’re stolen so we can ask for money towards honeymoon.
Maybe it’s badly worded and they could have added SOME guests have asked if they can replace to the notice, but don’t think it’s an elaborate plot to get more out of their guests .

Icecreamsoda99 · 06/08/2021 07:57

Really shitty thing to happen to them and mar their wedding. I really couldn’t blame them for the link, it's up to you if you donate, they had their big day spoilt by a thief, regardless of the money aspect all the cards have gone as well.

Maybe practice some compassion instead of getting worked up about a request.

drpet49 · 06/08/2021 07:31

@TwoAndAnOnion are you the bride/ groom?

I don’t know anyone who uses cheques.

unidentifed · 06/08/2021 07:30

YANBU.

yikesanotherbooboo · 06/08/2021 07:27

I think they handled it well up to the request which as someone above said is 'crass'. You all know that your gifts were stolen . It soesn't need to be hammered home. Some will cancel cheques some will not. Are they asking that people who have given cash or gift tokens should give more money? I think that is cheeky. A few might generously choose to give again but prompting people to give more for a holiday really is a bit much imo.

Hekatestorch · 06/08/2021 07:18

They actually should, it's down to the hotel. it happened to a wedding I went too, the hotel paid compensation to make up for the loss. It doesn't come down to people replacing what they gave. The couple need to take it up with the hotel.

Them choosing to accept responsibility is an entirely different thing though.

This venue, is clearly not accepting responsibility.

anon12345678901 · 06/08/2021 07:16

@Hekatestorch

A hotel isn't going to claim on its insurance. For all the bride and groom know, there could have just been cards and a couple of vouchers in there. There's no way of knowing how much there was.

There's also no proof, that the hotel or staff are at fault and most make it clear, securing the gifts are the responsibility of the bride and groom.

I don't think many wedding insurances would cover this either.

They actually should, it's down to the hotel. it happened to a wedding I went too, the hotel paid compensation to make up for the loss. It doesn't come down to people replacing what they gave. The couple need to take it up with the hotel.
ThinWomansBrain · 06/08/2021 07:15

it seems a particularly odd thing to do when they specified "no gift required" at the outset.
Anyone that heeded that advice must have mixed feelings.

AngelDelightUk · 06/08/2021 07:13

Something doesn’t sit right here, if it was a postbox for cards who would steal it. It just doesn’t make sense. And wouldn’t someone have seen it being taken

I wouldn’t be donating again that’s for sure

gurglebelly · 06/08/2021 07:11

Perhaps various people have asked if they can replace their gift and the B&G put something out because of it.

itsgettingwierd · 06/08/2021 07:11

On the face of it it does seem like a really cheeky request.

However I'm wondering if it's a response to loads of guests already asking about replacing their vouchers and so they've sent out a information email rather than keep replying to loads of people individually?

BritWifeInUSA · 06/08/2021 07:09

They didn’t even expect or ask for gifts so if no one had bought them anything they would be in the same boat. I don’t know why they need replacements for things that were an unexpected bonus,

Hekatestorch · 06/08/2021 07:08

Surely if people have issued a cheque that can be cancelled and a similar donation made to the fund? Ditto vouchers can be cancelled. I mean, who actually uses cash in the 21st century?

Lots of people have used cash in the last 20 years. I don't know anyone who uses cheques though.

Serious question, do people still have cheque books? Do you need to to request one, because I haven't been offered one in at least 10 years and they are a good idea for this sort of thing.

MaggieFS · 06/08/2021 07:08

Yes that's very cheeky.

What did the police say?

And I would have thought that somewhere between wedding insurance, the hotel's insurance, their home contents away from home insurance, ditto for guests' insurance plus people being able to cancel cheques and having receipts for vouchers, a fair bit could be recouped?

Hekatestorch · 06/08/2021 07:06

A hotel isn't going to claim on its insurance. For all the bride and groom know, there could have just been cards and a couple of vouchers in there. There's no way of knowing how much there was.

There's also no proof, that the hotel or staff are at fault and most make it clear, securing the gifts are the responsibility of the bride and groom.

I don't think many wedding insurances would cover this either.

TwoAndAnOnion · 06/08/2021 07:02

@OaxacaChihuahua

I recently went to a wedding which took place in a hotel. There was no gift list and the invitation said ‘no gifts necessary’. However, like many people, we gave a gift voucher in a card which we put in a cardboard postbox on a table covered in sweets and the guestbook etc,

In a horrible turn of events, the contents of the postbox have been stolen. Possibly / most likely by an employee of the hotel. The hotel is investigating but there’s no cctv, so they’re making no promises.

The bride and groom sent out an update from their wedding website to explain this, because they wanted people to know why they weren’t sending personalised thank you letters. No issue with that at all, it was thoughtful. However, in that update they said ‘should you wish to replace your stolen gift, please consider donating to our honeymoon fund’ and a link to s gofundme set up for this purpose.

AIBU or is this a bit cheeky? As it happens I would have given them a replacement voucher anyway, but this feels like a bit of pressure put on people to do so when some may not be able to afford it. It’s obviously terrible for the bride and groom that their gifts were stolen and not their fault at all, but it’s hardly the guests’ fault either.

So:

YABU - it’s a horrible thing to have happened and most people would want to replace their gifts anyway. It’s fine for the bride and groom to give directives on how that should be done.

YANBU - it’s cheeky to ask people to stump up again for presents, they should have said nothing and left it as a matter of individual choice.

Surely if people have issued a cheque that can be cancelled and a similar donation made to the fund? Ditto vouchers can be cancelled. I mean, who actually uses cash in the 21st century?

Not really seeing the issue actually.

custardbear · 06/08/2021 06:59

Hotel or wedding insurance should cover it, can you check if it's possible to cancel the voucher card abs get a replacement?

HarebrightCedarmoon · 06/08/2021 06:59

It would be quite easy to find the thieves if gift cards or vouchers were bought online, as soon as they try and spend them.

ohthatbloodycat · 06/08/2021 06:55

Wouldn't the hotel's insurance cover this?

Jengnr · 06/08/2021 06:53

I bet they’ve been asked so many times they put it out there.

nancydroo · 06/08/2021 06:48

YANBU to suggest this to people who may have written a cheque as it is simply cancelled and rewritten but they would not have known who had done that and who would have given vouchers.

YABU to suggest this to the people who have enclosed cash or gift vouchers.

Miserable end to their wedding

LongTimeMammaBear · 06/08/2021 06:35

I agree with @AnneTwacky. If they were interested in gifts or honeymoon fund, they would have asked from the start particularly as it’s it an unusual thing these days to ask for donations to honeymoon rather than gifts. They didn’t do that.

Out of curiosity, did anyone try to stop the gift vouchers? Most companies would do so if you notify them before they’re spent.