Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Was this cf behaviour?

69 replies

OaxacaChihuahua · 06/08/2021 04:39

I recently went to a wedding which took place in a hotel. There was no gift list and the invitation said ‘no gifts necessary’. However, like many people, we gave a gift voucher in a card which we put in a cardboard postbox on a table covered in sweets and the guestbook etc,

In a horrible turn of events, the contents of the postbox have been stolen. Possibly / most likely by an employee of the hotel. The hotel is investigating but there’s no cctv, so they’re making no promises.

The bride and groom sent out an update from their wedding website to explain this, because they wanted people to know why they weren’t sending personalised thank you letters. No issue with that at all, it was thoughtful. However, in that update they said ‘should you wish to replace your stolen gift, please consider donating to our honeymoon fund’ and a link to s gofundme set up for this purpose.

AIBU or is this a bit cheeky? As it happens I would have given them a replacement voucher anyway, but this feels like a bit of pressure put on people to do so when some may not be able to afford it. It’s obviously terrible for the bride and groom that their gifts were stolen and not their fault at all, but it’s hardly the guests’ fault either.

So:

YABU - it’s a horrible thing to have happened and most people would want to replace their gifts anyway. It’s fine for the bride and groom to give directives on how that should be done.

YANBU - it’s cheeky to ask people to stump up again for presents, they should have said nothing and left it as a matter of individual choice.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Hopdathelf · 06/08/2021 16:58

YANBU at all. Very cheeky request or at best horribly worded.

Are you sure they’re not trying it on? I feel very mean asking but surely it’s covered by wedding insurance or the venue will want to make some sort of no admissions settlement payment to avoid a terrible review?

Chloemol · 06/08/2021 16:40

YANBU. They should have insurance, or claim from the hotel insurance

WomanStanleyWoman · 06/08/2021 16:02

@Fernando072020

It's totally up to the hotel to resolve this. They have been ridiculously cheeky asking people to replace their gifts.

I had two vouchers for game for my brothers for helping on my wedding day. They were in the hotel room and suddenly had vanished. It was clear they had been stolen by someone who worked there.

I had to give my brothers money instead as it was the day before the wedding. The hotel replaced the vouchers and sent me an apology (and I didn't even complain, I was asking if anyone had handed them on because at the time I thought with all the chaos of the day before prep that I had misplaced them or dropped them somewhere even though I can remember putting them on the table in the room).

But as you say yourself, they were left in your room. A private, lockable space that only you and hotel staff with pass keys could access. This present box was left in an open, unattended area. There were potentially hundreds of people - staff and guests - with access to it.

If I managed that hotel, I’d take a chunk off the bill as a ‘gesture’ (NOT an admission of liability) to avoid bad publicity. But they’re no more legally responsible than a nightclub is if your handbag is stolen from a table when you could have put it in the cloakroom.

EL8888 · 06/08/2021 12:13

Wow that’s cheeky and definitely CF!

Fernando072020 · 06/08/2021 12:11

It's totally up to the hotel to resolve this. They have been ridiculously cheeky asking people to replace their gifts.

I had two vouchers for game for my brothers for helping on my wedding day. They were in the hotel room and suddenly had vanished. It was clear they had been stolen by someone who worked there.

I had to give my brothers money instead as it was the day before the wedding. The hotel replaced the vouchers and sent me an apology (and I didn't even complain, I was asking if anyone had handed them on because at the time I thought with all the chaos of the day before prep that I had misplaced them or dropped them somewhere even though I can remember putting them on the table in the room).

MaggieFS · 06/08/2021 12:06

Egg on my face! I read the word cheque for gift card. I'm on here too much. I've been brainwashed. Sorry!

MaggieFS · 06/08/2021 12:05

@quizqueen

I didn't know you could cancel gift cards. If true, that's very useful information in the event of them being stolen and a reminder that receipts should always be kept for everything. I keep all mine for a year,.
You clearly haven't been on mn long if you didn't know you could cancel a cheque Grin
quizqueen · 06/08/2021 11:30

I didn't know you could cancel gift cards. If true, that's very useful information in the event of them being stolen and a reminder that receipts should always be kept for everything. I keep all mine for a year,.

starfishmummy · 06/08/2021 11:12

I think it just sounds very cheeky. Letting people know their envelopes have been stolen so they can cancel cheques and gift cards is one thing. Most friends would then do that and replace anyway, but the go fund me is just cheeky.

girlmom21 · 06/08/2021 11:12

@aalidfeie

To my previous message, what annoys me is that they didnt pay for their honeymoon before they got married, is that normal? I dont know about these things?

I cant help but think this is all a bit fishy! Maybe I am a cynical old hag though!

I'd say that's fairly normal given the Covid situation but it's more likely they'll use it towards spending money
aalidfeie · 06/08/2021 10:59

To my previous message, what annoys me is that they didnt pay for their honeymoon before they got married, is that normal? I dont know about these things?

I cant help but think this is all a bit fishy! Maybe I am a cynical old hag though!

aalidfeie · 06/08/2021 10:49

My lord, cheeky as F behaviour! I get fed up with the whole wedding process as it is, massively expensive to even attend one without having to add in another present when you already gave one. Yep bad luck for them but they should not have even floated the idea of asking people to donate to their honeymoon and also a go fund me for their honeymoon, seriously Get Fkd. Pay for your own honeymoon, you are big enough to get married you should be big enough to pay for your honeymoon too! jesus the chutzpah....

Maybe I am a grinch but I can say I would never do any of the above!

Crockof · 06/08/2021 10:38

They probably don't have wedding insurance, considering the amount of people that don't have house insurance.

Thehop · 06/08/2021 10:31

“So sorry to hear about this. How awful. If your wedding insurance company want receipts for the gift vouchers we posted in order for you to make a claim please do let us know”

ThanksIGotItInMorrisons · 06/08/2021 10:26

Depends really. Perhaps those that knew the gifts were stolen asked about replacing them, so they put it in their message.
Horrible business all round. The hotel should check if they can claim insurance or if the bride/groom have provision in their own household insurance to cover money outside the household.

Balgoresboy · 06/08/2021 09:58

''The hotel should be giving them something in compensation.''

I am pretty sure businesses disassociate themselves with stolen or missing possessions from customers in the same way you are told if you use a car park any damage/theft is not their responsibility. Otherwise where would it end?
It does seem bizarre though it was stolen and this thread is pretty revealing as surely this can't be a common occurrence.

SaltySheepdog · 06/08/2021 09:32

The hotel should organise something not the guests

Hekatestorch · 06/08/2021 09:20

how can you secure a gift table at a reception? Its not an uncommon thing to do.....as i said, if the hotel knew and allowed it and did not warn the couple that their insurance would not cover it then they are acceting at least some of the responsibility.

You can't, which is why the vast majority of contracts with wedding venues, state that the hotel doesn't recommend doing then and/or takes no responsibility. Also usually, that gifts should be removed to a secure room.

As for the "what was there" I did say that I would have expected the couple to ask people for any proof of what they had put in the box.

But if there was cash, as expected then you can't prove it. Nowhere near. Vouchers will have a receipt but can often be cancelled and reissued, so they wouldn't be a cash equivalent for the hotel to pay, unless it can't refunded

And yes, hotels will be reluctant to claim but that doesn't mean that they aren't insured and couldn't claim.

Yes, I know. As I said, it's not as simple as the 'the hotel needs to claim'

It was part of the conference setup and the users were explicitly told that they could leave possessions there.

So the hotels, took responsibility before hand for unattended items, before the event aim the planning stage? That's quite usual. If that's the case here then the hotel I am sure they will pay out. But then them saying there's wasn't anything they can do doesn't make sense.

godmum56 · 06/08/2021 09:13

[quote Hekatestorch]@godmum56 I get what you are saying but that's different again.

At conferences and this sort of thing a secure room would be supplied. If that secure room was accessed, that would be the hotels responsibility. Because they offer that security. Usually one or 2 people will be given access to those rooms. This is why key cards have been popular for about 20 years as you can track which card was used likely, a staff card was used to access this area.

I worked weddings and conferences for many years, in hotels.

Also, in a briefcase they can do an estimate of cost of contents.

This box, seems to have been left in a common area, that could have been stolen by anyone.

Unless the hotel agreed to secure it or it was left in the bride and grooms private room.

The hotel, may have insurance for this sort of thing, but will be reluctant to claim. And even if they do, they will stipulate they aren't responsible for things left unattended in common areas.

There could have been just the ops gift in there or 10k, in theory.

Its really not as simple as the hotel needs to claim. And paying the couple out, could also Imply they take responsibility and are admitting that their staff stole it

That was my point 'the hotel has to claim on their insurance' isn't quite as simple as people are making out.[/quote]
how can you secure a gift table at a reception? Its not an uncommon thing to do.....as i said, if the hotel knew and allowed it and did not warn the couple that their insurance would not cover it then they are acceting at least some of the responsibility.
As for the "what was there" I did say that I would have expected the couple to ask people for any proof of what they had put in the box.
And yes, hotels will be reluctant to claim but that doesn't mean that they aren't insured and couldn't claim.
Oh btw in both cases of briefcase theft, the possessions were not left in a secure room. All the attenders were able to access the room freely during the day and it was where hot drinks were left for the conference attenders. It was part of the conference setup and the users were explicitly told that they could leave possessions there.

Hekatestorch · 06/08/2021 09:03

@godmum56 I get what you are saying but that's different again.

At conferences and this sort of thing a secure room would be supplied. If that secure room was accessed, that would be the hotels responsibility. Because they offer that security. Usually one or 2 people will be given access to those rooms. This is why key cards have been popular for about 20 years as you can track which card was used likely, a staff card was used to access this area.

I worked weddings and conferences for many years, in hotels.

Also, in a briefcase they can do an estimate of cost of contents.

This box, seems to have been left in a common area, that could have been stolen by anyone.

Unless the hotel agreed to secure it or it was left in the bride and grooms private room.

The hotel, may have insurance for this sort of thing, but will be reluctant to claim. And even if they do, they will stipulate they aren't responsible for things left unattended in common areas.

There could have been just the ops gift in there or 10k, in theory.

Its really not as simple as the hotel needs to claim. And paying the couple out, could also Imply they take responsibility and are admitting that their staff stole it

That was my point 'the hotel has to claim on their insurance' isn't quite as simple as people are making out.

OaxacaChihuahua · 06/08/2021 08:56

@Claredemoon

Yes perhaps it was clumsily worded but perhaps they were upset having to tell people they had been victims of a crime on their wedding day to think if their message was going to offend sensitive guests. I really hope the bride or groom or one of their guests don't see this and tell them, as unless they have a history of being actual being CFs this would be really upsetting on top of what has happened.
That’s a fair point, hadn’t really thought of that Sad that’s the problem - sometimes you just want a sense check and mumsnet is way for that, but you don’t actually want to broadcast it that someone has been a cf.

They don’t have kids, so hopefully aren’t on here. I know not every MNer has children but I’d imagine the majority do.

OP posts:
OaxacaChihuahua · 06/08/2021 08:54

Perhaps - he’s 33 and she’s 29 so not that young, but they are both a little bit ditzy tbh. The groom is a former work colleague of my husband so he’s really the one who knows them best - I’ll suggest he mentions that to them in case they haven’t chased it up.

It does seem a bit odd that they didn’t ask for confirmation of what people gave for insurance purposes, but maybe that would have seemed even ruder. If I hadn’t given anything I wouldn’t want to put on the spot about it!

OP posts:
Claredemoon · 06/08/2021 08:53

Yes perhaps it was clumsily worded but perhaps they were upset having to tell people they had been victims of a crime on their wedding day to think if their message was going to offend sensitive guests. I really hope the bride or groom or one of their guests don't see this and tell them, as unless they have a history of being actual being CFs this would be really upsetting on top of what has happened.

godmum56 · 06/08/2021 08:49

are they a youngish couple? Would they perhaps not have given the hotel a good push about it being covered by insurance?

godmum56 · 06/08/2021 08:42

@Hekatestorch

They actually should, it's down to the hotel. it happened to a wedding I went too, the hotel paid compensation to make up for the loss. It doesn't come down to people replacing what they gave. The couple need to take it up with the hotel.

Them choosing to accept responsibility is an entirely different thing though.

This venue, is clearly not accepting responsibility.

I don't think they have a choice. Either they carry insurance for such occurences (which I would expect) or they don't and they would have told whoever organised the wedding, and the gift table was set up against the hotel's advice. My late husband used to stay in hotels for work confernces on a regular basis. Twice over the years groups of folk had their briefcases stolen and both times the hotel asked for contents lists and just paid up on the basis that the possessions had been left in a room set aside by the hotel and therefore it was their responsibility. No choice. I am surprised that the first email to guests mentions replacement...I'd have thought the first one would have been asking who had any proff of what their gift had been for insurance purposes and then maybe a second one saying that people had been asking about replacement....even then I think that to say anything other than how kind the offer is but guests shouldn't think of it would be the more usual and politer option......so yes CF-ery especially having said "no gifts necessary" which of itself is weird wording.