Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Ex MIL charity shop gifts

68 replies

OrganicAvocado · 05/08/2021 20:09

Ex MIL sends my kids charity shop junk all the time and I’m fed up with it. I have asked her to stop. We don’t need any of it and have no space for it. Not only inappropriate books (Uni level biology “colouring” books to help students memorise internal body parts), shoes that fit none of us, clothes that fit none of us (she send me a crop top and I have a massive mum tum), just endless stream of junk. At Christmas she sent some “pottery” which were some sort of child’s “decorate your own” animals that had already been decorated by someone else.
I could just take it to the nearest charity shop but I just want her to stop sending it all. She sees everything as a bargain and things we’ll appreciate her bargain as much as she does. We’re not struggling financially and my kids have loads of clothes. She, on the other hand, has no money, because she has a spending addiction. She has literally no bags full of charity shop junk in her living room waiting for an occasion to send to us.
Am I unreasonable not to want it? Am I ungrateful? I’m quite happy to shop in charity shops, but for things I want or need. I would never send second hand (well used) clothes to anyone as a gift.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
DistrustfulDinosaur · 09/08/2021 09:35

Tell her you're running out of space at home and hate to think of her spending so much on posting items to you. Perhaps she could keep the stuff at her house or send it to her son to use when they visit. It's tricky if she's posting things to you rather than trying to give them to you in person.

Could you suggest she saves her money for say six months then takes your kids shopping for something they actually want/will use? Perhaps if she sees them get excited about buying a particular toy and how much they enjoy playing with it, she'll think twice about buying so much crap.

AgentJohnson · 09/08/2021 05:16

Refuse the posted items, don’t take stuff with you when you visit and refuse items that she brings. She called you rude to guilt trip you into feeding her habit.

IveGotASongThatllGetOnYNerves · 09/08/2021 04:51

Hand absolutely everything she sends straight over to your ex, without opening it.
His mum - his problem.

MiddleParking · 09/08/2021 04:41

Being called rude for refusing strangers’ cast off shite that she indulges herself in hoarding (but not to the extent she’s going to store it herself) would give me the utter rage. And she’s not even your mother in law. I’d give her a helpful demonstration of what rudeness actually looks like.

househousehousefox · 09/08/2021 04:24

My DM was like this. What you need to do is go with her! Show her what size clothes your kids are and what books or toys they are interested in.
Worked wonders for me. Now she knows what to get and I am grateful for it.

Better yet get her a hobby. My dm has recently gotten into knitting so she's making bits and bobs. Spending her time on that rather than filing through charity shops. Wool is cheap and in abundance in charity shops near me so if I were you I would push knitting or some similar time consuming hobby on her. Sorted my own mum out this way.

FictionalCharacter · 08/08/2021 03:13

She has a real problem and you’ll have to be very firm in refusing to take any more. Yes, she’ll say you’re rude, but she isn’t able to face the reality- she’s indulging her obsession and it doesn’t benefit you or the children. Would it matter that much if she was less friendly with you because you won’t let her use you like this?

UrbanRambler · 08/08/2021 01:17

@Jerima

DH mum used to work in a charity shop and shop in them. One time he was haunted by a pair of his own shoes. No matter where he donated then his mum brought them back saying she's seen shoes he might like. He had to take them up the road and put them in the bin in the end
This made me laugh out loud - the word "haunted" made the shoes seem like something out of an old horror film, and conjured up visions of the shoes walking themselves back into your home in the dead of night! Grin

I am doing my best to declutter our home, and I feel good about each bag I drop off at the charity shop. It would do my head in if my MIL kept buying us unwanted items that we don't need. You will need to be very firm about refusing these unwanted gifts, even though your MIL may have good intentions.

NowEvenBetter · 08/08/2021 01:08

It’s for your ex to deal with. Opt out entirely. Tat can stay at ex house or his mothers house. Nothing to do with you.

ZingDramaQueenOfSheeba · 08/08/2021 00:48

🤣
I'd be tempted to send it all back

messybun101 · 07/08/2021 23:55

@Jerima

DH mum used to work in a charity shop and shop in them. One time he was haunted by a pair of his own shoes. No matter where he donated then his mum brought them back saying she's seen shoes he might like. He had to take them up the road and put them in the bin in the end
Grinwoke DP up laughing at this. The boomerang boots
OoglyMoogly · 06/08/2021 14:50

@WhatAShilohPitt
I use a local freecycle page and there’s one lady in there who asks for pretty much everything that’s being given away ‘for my grandkids’

It's not for her grandkids. She's selling the stuff.

OoglyMoogly · 06/08/2021 14:48

@Jerima

DH mum used to work in a charity shop and shop in them. One time he was haunted by a pair of his own shoes. No matter where he donated then his mum brought them back saying she's seen shoes he might like. He had to take them up the road and put them in the bin in the end
Sorry but this made me laugh! @Jerima Grin
Dogscanteatonions · 06/08/2021 14:28

My ex mil is like this! Sackful each for my teenage kids at Xmas - shit old toiletries sets and endless awful clothing - I mean it's hard enough to buy clothes for teenagers as it is but random charity shop clothes and an assortment of sizes too. So basically out of the massive sackful most of the clothes they don't even try on and the odd thing they might like is invariably too small or big!

So Xmas means a load of stuff for me to post on to the charity shop and the kids basically get nothing from her in the end.

JustLoveYourselfALittle · 06/08/2021 13:18

Hi mil. Please send stuff for dcs to your ds for when they're there

OrganicAvocado · 06/08/2021 13:11

Hemingwaycat

We’ve received broken and/or dirty stuff too. Some quite large items. One was an enormous (almost 6ft tall) stuffed animal. She still has it at her house because we (thankfully) couldn’t fit it in our car! She was so pleased with herself for having “only paid £6” for it!

OP posts:
Hemingwaycat · 06/08/2021 10:53

My MIL does this too. Every Christmas she turns up dressed as Mrs Claus (shit you not) with a big sack over her shoulder. Sounds adorable I’m sure except for the fact the sack is filled with charity shop tat. Almost all of it completely misses the mark and never gets used, some ends up in the bin and the rest goes back to the charity shop… We’ve definitely had shoes that didn’t fit before as well as books none of us would ever be interested in reading, dirty old keyrings, board games with bits missing. Just totally pointless.

PandemicAtTheDisco · 06/08/2021 10:50

My ex MIL did this slightly and I was more concerned about her wasting her money - she wanted to feel she was being a good grandparent but wasn't discerning enough for me. I tried to redirect her attention to specific items and focus on only buying good quality stuff. I asked for denim pinafore dresses with embroidery from Next or Marks & Spencers and waterproof all in ones - things that were expensive to buy new yet were generally good secondhand. I made a huge fuss when she got it right. I got her to return stuff we didn't need or if I didn't like it or have space. I made her store things at her house or mend broken items herself before I accepted them.

PidgeInAPud · 06/08/2021 10:22

This is my mother. She has a spending/hoarding problem. It's a bit of a family joke but actually it's really annoying so I sympathise. Years ago we bought a little place in France and she went into overdrive buying tat for us to fill it with. It really was a hobby for her. I just quietly disposed of everything.

RubyGoat · 06/08/2021 10:20

I have exactly the same issue. If my BIL were married I'd wonder if you were his wife. It's literally impossible to get her to understand. They actually bankrupted themselves & had to sell the house due to her spending. And she still does it. FIL just stands by & does nothing.

Howshouldibehave · 06/08/2021 10:17

If he refuses to deal with it, can you tell the postman to return the parcels to the sender?

If she was my ex MIL, I don’t see why I’d have to put up with it

OrganicAvocado · 06/08/2021 10:17

but I believe it's more about her not being able to enjoy buying her unwanted bargains.

Yes, exactly this.

OP posts:
OrganicAvocado · 06/08/2021 10:12

The ex just tells me that he’s given up telling her to stop. Not helpful. He knows she has mh issues so just let’s her crack on. He says it’s better than arguing with her about it. Confused

OP posts:
PandemicAtTheDisco · 06/08/2021 10:06

My friend (with not much spare money)annoys her family by buying them broken, stained and/or unwanted second hand stuff then sometimes expecting them to pay for them or for the postage costs.

After they fell out with her over the issue - she then decided I was too ill to buy my friend's and family's Christmas gifts and presented me with several bags of items that she wanted paying for. It was hard to initially say no to her and ask her to return everything. She ended up using some of those purchases for my subsequent birthday and Christmas presents. I had to be very blunt about why I didn't want to give people gifts I hadn't chosen myself or weren't new. Not everybody appreciates new toiletry sets - nevermind ones 10 years old.

It's an addiction. She needed to be buying her bargains for someone and it transferred from her family to me. She sees it as helping others and making her money go further. I see it as her fulfilling her addictive needs.

She will spent £20 on each of her grandchildren but she'd rather give a huge pile of unsuitable secondhand goods than one new specific item. After a huge argument about unsuitable, used presents she bought £20 of new unwanted poundland like items instead. They've now told her to gift money only or just not bother. She's really upset and says she thinks it's impersonal but I believe it's more about her not being able to enjoy buying her unwanted bargains.

LadyDanburysHat · 06/08/2021 09:38

@Jerima

DH mum used to work in a charity shop and shop in them. One time he was haunted by a pair of his own shoes. No matter where he donated then his mum brought them back saying she's seen shoes he might like. He had to take them up the road and put them in the bin in the end
This made me laugh so much! Imagining your DH trying to get rid of his shoes. Grin
kwiksavenofrillsusername · 06/08/2021 09:24

You need to put your foot down and give her a firm no. Don’t accept stuff and then give it to the charity shop, or pick through it to find the ‘good stuff’ as this will just encourage her. Sorry OP, I know it’s a tough situation to be in. I’ve had a hoarder family member and the crap they used to bring us was just unbelievable. If you accept stuff, they’ll start escalating and giving you stuff from the hoard and it gets worse.

Swipe left for the next trending thread