Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should dogs be allowed in more places?

538 replies

Patchworkknitter · 05/08/2021 17:44

I'm a bit hurt today but I don't know if I'm being completely unreasonable.

A friend and I were trying to arrange to meet up. We had sorted what we were doing and then she changed her mind and wanted to change where we did something which would have added another 90 minutes onto the day.

I couldn't do that as my dog would already have been left all day (with 2 dog walks from a dog walker). Even with the dog walker, he couldn't do another 90 minutes. My friend got a bit cross and said I should just get my parents to look after him but they're already looking after him the day before so it wouldn't be fair. I don't like to ask them too often, a bit like people don't like to look after their children too often.

It just seems we always do child friendly places (I'm not a Mum but I try my best to be understanding of her childcare needs). She says she can't afford any additional childcare to that which she already needs for work but I can't afford additional dog care either (I pay £400 a month and don't have a partner to share any costs).

It got me thinking how restrictive it can be having a dog as a single person. I wouldn't change him for the world but it's incredibly difficult. If it was childcare I feel people would be much more understanding.

If I was a mum I could take my children pretty much everywhere.
As a dog owner, I can no longer go to the cinema, to most pubs, to restaurants, to the theatre, shopping, etc without paying out for extra dog care.

I feel dogs should be allowed in more places, more shops, more cafes, more pubs etc. Aibu?

OP posts:
ichundich · 06/08/2021 13:02

@AudacityBaby

I'm not sure about allowing dogs into more places but I'm with a couple of other posters - I'd like more places to be adult-only! Lots of posters talking here about how disruptive, noisy, uncontrolled and (sometimes) smelly dogs are; same applies to a fair amount of kids. I realise that y'all had them just to support me in my old age and everything, so sorry that I'm uncharitably suggesting they also be banned from Starbucks.
Everyone should be banned from StarSucks; why anyone would prefer them to an independent coffee shop serving freshly baked goods and coffee / tea that doesn't taste like dishwasher is beyond me.
EffOrf · 06/08/2021 12:09

I'm another that would like places to be adult only

AudacityBaby · 06/08/2021 12:04

I'm not sure about allowing dogs into more places but I'm with a couple of other posters - I'd like more places to be adult-only! Lots of posters talking here about how disruptive, noisy, uncontrolled and (sometimes) smelly dogs are; same applies to a fair amount of kids. I realise that y'all had them just to support me in my old age and everything, so sorry that I'm uncharitably suggesting they also be banned from Starbucks.

liveforsummer · 06/08/2021 09:43

I also don't think the friend was unreasonable as the day was already planned to not include the dog and the Walker already arranged. If the original arrangement had been dog friendly I'd think differently An extra 90 minutes (I assume 45 minutes either side) really won't hurt if the dog is walked in the morning, visited twice by the dog walker then has their human home all evening for walks and company that's not very long in between visits and walks to be alone especially as they will sleep after the walks. Sounds like OP does ok anyway with 2 days out in a row one with parents looking after dog and one with dog walker (something I as a dog owner could never afford but was aware of this when I got her)

liveforsummer · 06/08/2021 09:32

For what it's worth, I didn't say I wanted to take my dog to the cinema or theatre. There were examples of places I could no longer go

Where is it you do want them to be able to go then? We can already take dogs to many pubs and cafes, some restaurants, holiday cottages, b&b's, campsites,shops, even many posh 5* hotels allow them. They are allowed on public transport. There are loads of dog and kid friendly outdoor places to go such as country parks. These things are all suitable for dogs in that they are an environment that most dogs will enjoy being with their humans. The things that there aren't dog friendly versions of such as indoor swimming pools, cinemas, theatres etc aren't pleasant or suitable environments for dogs therefore is no demand and no reason to provide. Zoos and animal parks aren't suitable as the dogs could scare or hurt the animals. They are however accessible to service dogs who have been trained and desensitised specifically to do the job. I say the same here as I did on an anti dog post a while ago. Lots of people were disgusted dogs were allowed in pubs and I strongly disagreed with them. There is a balance and it's important that there is one. There are both dog friendly and non dog friendly places. Everyone is provided for. I'm glad I can take my dog lots of places as she prefers to be with us, she'd rather be sitting quietly at our feet in the pub than home alone but equally she's fine for a few hours if I want to go to the cinema every now and then. She'd rather be home alone than be at the cinema even if it was an option to take her. I'm also glad there are non dog friendly places for those who dislike, fear or are allergic to dogs.

Hopeisallineed · 06/08/2021 09:15

@vivainsomnia that’s not the point, dogs do not have the same rights as children whether you think they are just as important or not. They are not comparable because they are not on the same level, people trump dogs I’m afraid whether you think it’s a fur baby or not and should be allowed everywhere doesn’t matter. It’s laughable to even compare. One is a pet, another is a person, not sure why some folk don’t get that. 😂

Deedoubleyou · 06/08/2021 09:10

Yabu, as a dog owner there are already loads of places dogs are allowed in, especially in beer garden season (although you may need to sit under a brolly)

However I also think your friend is being unreasonable, as she shouldn't expect you to cater only to her needs. Just tell her you need to meet somewhere dog friendly, take a coffee to a park or something even?

bettyboodecia · 06/08/2021 09:06

@Patchworkknitter

I'm guessing I'm not going to get any understanding here.

Thank you.

You're not going to get understanding many cases because it's a stupid argument. No we shouldn't allow shitting, barking, smelly (i.e. all) dogs everywhere just because you choose to live hours for any entertainment!
purplesequins · 06/08/2021 08:56

I think some dog owners are incredibly selfish when it comes to their pets.
I don't think most people mind dogs in general, but dogs being present everywhere is a bit much, especially if it's the fur baby badly trained type like the running up to people jumping and licking type.

I can admire dogs from afar, but am severely allergic. I cannot spend more than a few seconds in a closed room with one without medication (which I would happily take for an assistance dog). a dog licking my hand could lend me in hospital.

Sloth66 · 06/08/2021 08:55

Your choice to get a dog?
For people with allergies, they are getting harder to avoid as it is.

liveforsummer · 06/08/2021 08:50

There isn’t. If you have a dog allergy or phobia it doesn’t magically disappear if the dog is an assistance animal. A dog is a dog.

The difference is the human owner of the dog requires it's presence to be able to be there. Disability is a protected characteristic and disabled people have the same right to enjoy public spaces as you do. Your allergy or fear does not trump the owners right as a person to be there.

SelkieQualia · 06/08/2021 08:49

I think you are being a bit precious about how long you leave your dog. Going out to the movies is fine! Also, you can't take young kids to the theatre / nice restaurants.

UntilYourNextHairBrainedScheme · 06/08/2021 08:38

Dog ownership is a more serious undertaking in Germany as dogs legally have to be registered with the town hall and have to be insured for damage they might do to third parties. Dogs tend to be on leads unless impeccably trained. I've never had a dog jump all over me or my kids in Germany, they are always called to heel if off lead when we walk in the forest which is also where dogs are walked - but it happens every time we try to go to the beach in England.

Perhaps if there were the same legal responsibilities put on UK dog owners, there would be the same privileges, because the responsibility to register your dog and be insured for any damage it might cause might well be linked to better average standard of training and behaviour...

MangosteenSoda · 06/08/2021 08:29

I lived in Germany for a while and people seemed to take dogs almost everywhere. It was nice and they didn’t randomly soil themselves. They were incredibly well trained though. My South African dog wouldn’t have been able to manage sitting under the table in a fancy restaurant all evening, so stayed at home.

liveforsummer · 06/08/2021 08:23

It depends on the dog. Animal welfare organisations recommend dogs aren’t left alone for longer than 4 hours and are properly acclimatised to it. Thanks to lockdown, my dog has regressed to a couple of hours max and will have to be worked back up to longer periods.

The 4 hours is a rough guide and applies mostly to day times. Dogs don't have watches and won't know if you've been gone 4,5 hours instead - especially in the evening where they'd ordinarily be fast asleep and go 10 hours without going out for the toilet

Twokitstwokats · 06/08/2021 08:22

Yes, in a pub garden. I visited the pub twice and it happened twice. The dogs were free to run around the garden.

liveforsummer · 06/08/2021 08:19

How can I? My dog walker doesn't walk evenings and my nearest cinema is 40 minutes away, nearest theatre 45 minutes away. That's nearly 2 hours travelling plus the show. A dog can't be left alone for that time.

Most adult dogs can be left for 3.5 hours every now and again. Especially in the evening when they'd be asleep anyway. Even my little Velcro pup can manage that just fine

liveforsummer · 06/08/2021 08:16

I think the balance as it is is fine. There are plenty dog friendly places. I say that as someone single with a dog. I have dc too. Ddog does occasionally limit us but tbh I could go to the cinema, it's not that long and I don't have a dog walker. I'm sure your dog is fine for the day with a walk before you go, 2 visits from a dog Walker then a walk and company all afternoon/evening once you get back. Maybe look on to some ad hoc doggy day care? We have some locally, one is attached to the local shopping centre that has cinema etc, although I don't use it as Ddog hates strangers.

Confiscatedpopit · 06/08/2021 08:12

Your friend was being unreasonable changing your plans then complaining.

But please do not compare your dog and your responsibilities to those with her having children. Particularly to her if you want to keep the friendship.

I once had a friend say she knew how I felt being a parent as she had a cat. It’s not the main reason but we are no longer friends!

cleocleo16 · 06/08/2021 08:01

I don't understand why you would need to pay for dog care just to go to the pub or cinema. Surely it's ok to be left for a few hours so you can go out?

ufucoffee · 06/08/2021 08:00

@TheFoundations no, I was just wondering why dog care was so different now

FatAnkles · 06/08/2021 07:56

NRFT.

But in-laws' dog is a pampered pooch, a fat little barrel spoiled by his owners. I feel sorry for him. (I've tried to tell them they need to treat him more like a dog than a baby but it falls on deaf ears).

When I (used to) go abroad, dogs were kept outside and had a purpose, either as security or to assist humans. They aren't taken shopping! They are treated like dogs. They are not equivalent to human babies. Very different.

TheFoundations · 06/08/2021 07:55

@ufucoffee

This all seems to be a fairly recent thing. In years gone by people used to leave their dogs in the house all day while they were at work, and in alone when they had a night out. Why is it so different now? And no I don't think they should be allowed in any more places than they already are.
But do you think that generally things should just stay the same because new ways have been invented/discovered? I mean, giving up smoking for health was a new thing a few years back. Do you think we should have just carried on smoking to clear our lungs like we used to do?

It's different now because it allows more customers to use your business, and this by far outweighs the customers that you lose from it.

vivainsomnia · 06/08/2021 07:54

A dog is not and will never be the same as a child
This statement really annoys me. A dog might not be the same to you, but it is to many dog owners. I have children and I have a dog. Of course my children needs would come first if I was ever in a situation to have to pick, but that scenario is very unlikely, in real life, I aim to meet the needs of all and I care to ensure my dog is as happy as I can make her as I do for my children. I don't go about making decisions on the basis that my dog will never be the same as my kids. It's irrelevant. What is is that I tailor my days, weekends, holidays to ensure my dog' needs are met and more.

Saying all that, i do think there are many options to meet with friends and your dog, although of course, it depends where you are. I don't think there is a need for anything more. There is a limit to what is reasonable and what isn't.

BungleandGeorge · 06/08/2021 07:51

Many dogs react to each other so having a venue full of dogs would be chaos. I don’t understand how you can’t leave your dog for long enough to go to a film or for a day with 2 visits. It’s your choice but that is very restrictive. Could you work with a behaviourist?

Swipe left for the next trending thread